HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jnky

358 karma · joined July 23, 2011

submissionscomments
jnky··on VMware GPL Enforcement Suit in Germany Continues
> It exports many symbols for drivers (proprietary or otherwise) to use internally.

I fail to see how those symbols being exported makes the relevant functionality public vs. internal to the kernel [1]

> Some symbols are exported GPL_ONLY, which means that only GPL drivers may call those symbols.

I don't think that is accurate. Drivers are necessarily derivative works of the kernel and have to be licensed under the GPL anyway. In practice closed source driver modules seem to be tolerated, even if they are not strictly compliant with the kernel's license.[2] The purpose behind the GPL_ONLY symbols is that a driver has to declare itself compliant with the license to use the symbols. If a proprietary driver would declare itself GPL compliant to gain access to GPL_only symbols, its author would be in even muddier waters than before.

[1] https://www.kernel.org/doc/Documentation/stable_api_nonsense... [2] http://archive.linuxgizmos.com/are-non-gpl-loadable-linux-dr...

jnky··on VMware GPL Enforcement Suit in Germany Continues
The Linux Kernel does not have a public API/ABI apart from the userspace syscall interface.
jnky··on A native hypervisor is coming to OpenBSD
Yeah, but on the other hand one might argue that there is no reason to believe Intel's hardware implementation of such features is more correct and less prone to errors than Xen's implementation in software.
jnky··on Windows Symbolic Link Mitigations
You can still run 16 bit applications on Windows 7|8|10, as long as you use the x86 (i.e. 32 bit) flavor of the OS. I'm fairly certain that there are still enterprises large and small that depend on running 16 bit code, because replacing it costs money.
jnky··on The Ashley Madison Database Was Leaked
> [...] but I wonder about people who follow this line of reasoning for this release but not for the Manning/Snowden releases.

I think it would be easy to argue that the leaks of Manning and Snowden are justified because they exposed illegal and reprehensible activity from the government; an entity that should be held to the highest moral standard.

Users of this site generally did nothing illegal and they wronged at most one other person each.

jnky··on Amazon Web Services revenue rises 81% year over year
Maybe taxes on profits were created so that companies invest their profit instead of hoarding it or giving it to shareholders, creating jobs and infrastructure in the process. As far as I'm concerned, Amazon is using its profits (or lack thereof) exactly as intended.
jnky··on Introducing s2n, a New Open-Source TLS Implementation
> "Yeh, we're not vulnerable, because we've been using the swan library"

Yeah, who would name a crypto implementation something stupid like "swan". Oh wait... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Openswan

jnky··on Liblfds, a portable, license-free, lock-free data structure library written in C
> Is this an aspirational stance?

Obviously.

> Because at the moment that's not what the law says (in any country I know of) [...]

True. But that's also why I'm unwilling to play along and express my views on the matter within a framework that I perceive to be immoral and wrong.

jnky··on Liblfds, a portable, license-free, lock-free data structure library written in C
I don't see why it should be possible to own code.

I think the ownership of physical items is an intuitive concept that comes naturally from the scarcity of such items.

Code, algorithms or ideas on the other hand are not scarce and I think that the legal framework that makes it possible to own such immaterial things is immoral.

jnky··on Liblfds, a portable, license-free, lock-free data structure library written in C
I understand that there are practical problems with this approach, but I disagree with your conclusion: Adding a free license would express my principles within a framework that I fundamentally disagree with.

Your comparison with the freeman on the land / sovereign citizen line of thinking made me reflect on my own views on the subject, as these people are obviously nutjobs. However, I view my approach as a valid act of civil disobedience with no ill effects for anyone involved.

jnky··on Liblfds, a portable, license-free, lock-free data structure library written in C
> So, you accept potential legal hassle for you and the users of your software in order to "protest against the current copyright laws"?

Yes.

> Exactly. So why not just add a brief MIT license [1] to your code, painlessly clarifying your legal stance?

Because that does not clarify my legal stance at all. My legal stance is that code does/can/should not have a license and that no license is necessary to use any code. I feel like adding a license (even a permissive one) undermines this very idea.

The only people who insist on a license are exactly the people that this form of protest is meant to oppose.

jnky··on Liblfds, a portable, license-free, lock-free data structure library written in C
I don't know about the specific intentions of the author, but I also refuse to put an explicit license on my code, because I firmly believe that code cannot be owned, sold or licensed anymore than the Pythagorean theorem can. In that sense, I consider the refusal to put a bunch of legalese nonsense on/near my code a form of protest against the current copyright laws. I'm here to write code and I don't want to put a license on my work just to appease some lawyers, as it lends credibility to a system that I reject on principle. Doing it this way only presents a problem for people and companies who subscribe to the view that copyright is indeed a real thing.
jnky··on CNNIC's response to Google
The $59.90 account only buys you identity verification so that you can get a cert for your own personal domains. When you want to get certs for a company's domains, you also have to pay for organisation verification for another $59.50. In neither case are you allowed to request certificates for domains owned by other entities, even if you are authorized to do so by the owner (e.g. as a service provider). See here: https://www.startssl.com/policy.pdf
jnky··on Introducing Pseudo IPv4
I think you are missing a lot. For instance, I have IPv6 set up at home, at work and at some homes of friends and family. I have firewall rules setup such that traffic from subnets I know is generally allowed instead of allowing access to a single port for the general internet. I also have DNS set up with names like computername.sitename.mydomain.tld

That allows me and the people I know to connect to each other's machines in a way that wouldn't be possible with IPv4 and NAT. I can be at my brothers and type \\[fqdn] in explorer and it will just work. To me, that is the way the internet was meant to function from the beginning.

jnky··on Introducing Pseudo IPv4
You setting up firewall rules at your gateway has no influence on whether an address is routable or not.
jnky··on How Munich switched 15,000 PCs from Windows to Linux
When you consider how long it is taking organizations to move away from XP, a decade for a Linux migration doesn't seem so bad.
jnky··on Apple Products and EU-wide Consumer Laws
The problem is that the free market and freedom of choice aren't appropriate solutions to all problems, one of them is standardization.

For the EU, the whole Micro USB thing isn't just about defining a connector that is somehow superior to all existing solutions. It is about standardization and about reducing waste from old phone chargers.

And I think Apple, with their shift to the Lightning Connector proofed this point for the EU better than anyone else could have. Just think about the enormous amount of chargers and other products with a dock connector that will hit the landfills sooner rather than later for no good reason at all, except Apples vanity and some marginal improvements.

jnky··on Apple Products and EU-wide Consumer Laws
Yet in practice, I never had any trouble getting products repaired for free after 23 months or something along those lines. It may be that the burden of proof is on the buyer after six months, but in reality no company (except maybe Apple) really makes a fuss about it. Burden of proof is one thing, but as an EU citizen I expect my electronic devices to work at least two years. If a company were to argue that I have to proof a defect is really their fault after just a year, I would definitely never buy from them again.
jnky··on Recover MySQL root password
I hate it when I google how to recover some password only to find hints on how to reset it.

Yes I know that not all passwords can be recovered because of hashing etc, but please don't talk about recovering when all this really does is reset the password.

jnky··on Nexus 4 oversold, Google places many on back order
Yeah, I meant the time. Sorry I wasn't clear about that.
jnky··on Nexus 4 oversold, Google places many on back order
What irks me the most about this whole ordeal is the utter lack of communication from a company that prides itself on being open and transparent.

There was no release time, no numbers on the amount of phones after they sold out way too soon, no excuse for the Play Store and Wallet glitches, and now, finally, no statement on how they somehow managed to miscount their inventory. I cannot even fathom how something like this can happen to a company like Google to begin with.

I'm really disappointed in Google, to say the least.

jnky··on Wikileaks Expenses: 2011 and 2012 (pdf)
I think the income listed is only for donations made to Wikileaks via the Wau Holland Foundation in Germany, while Wikileaks itself may also receive money from other sources.
← PreviousPage 3 of 3