HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jnmandal

925 karma · joined December 23, 2014

Software developer and forest enthusiast hailing from the Great Lakes
submissionscomments
jnmandal··on Launch HN: Uplift (YC S25) – Voice models for under-served languages
Looks really cool, exciting to see. I have two questions around this:

1. Given that you are concerned with providing access a class of folks that are traditionally ignored by technologists, do you plan to make these models usable for offline purposes? For example an illiterate person I know from Uttarkhand: his home village is not connected to road. Interestingly he does speak Hindi, but his native language I believe is something more obscure. To get home, he walks five hours from the terminus of a road. Connectivity is obviously both limited and intermittent. A usable device might want the voice interface embedded on it. Any plans for this?

2. I have minimal understanding of this but as someone who has learned Hindi/Urdu as a foreign language but in the US, I am often in mixed conversation w/ both Indians and Pakistanis. There never seems to be any issues with communication. I have heard that certain terms (like for example "khub suraat", "shukria", "kitaab") are more Urdu than Hindi. I also studied Arabic, Farsi, and Swahili so I am familiar with these as loanwords Arabic and/or Persian, but in practice I hear Hindi speakers using these terms often. Is the primary value add here political? Is it an accent thing? Thanks in advance for any explanation. This is still very much a mystery to me.

jnmandal··on Show HN: Whispering – Open-source, local-first dictation you can trust
Looks like a really cool project. Do you have any opinions on which transcription models are the best, from a quality perspective? I have heard a lot of mixed opinions on this. Curious what you've found in your development process?
jnmandal··on UI vs. API. vs. UAI
This is true but also your API needs to actually implement all the use cases (often its only for a subset) and it needs to work well (often there are many nuances or inconsistencies). But I agree there are lots of overlap. No need to completwly reinvent the wheel here. Actually CQRS systems work incredibly well with LLMs already.
jnmandal··on UI vs. API. vs. UAI
Yeah, this is so true. Well designed APIs are also already almost good enough for AI. There really was always a ton of value in good API design before LLMs. Yet a lot of people still said, for varying reasons, let's just ship slop and focus elsewhere.
jnmandal··on OpenAI's new open-source model is basically Phi-5
I think its likely that soon the "AI" aspect of the "models" get worse and worse with each iteration. This is because:

1. data pollution/dilution -- with each subsequent generation more and more LLM-produced content will make up the bulk of the web this means it either gets into get into the data set, which makes the model "spikey" or reduces the relevant knowledge available which dumbs the model down 2. LLMs were sort of a freak breakthrough in deep learning and while its remarkable, tuning them only makes them marginally better. Diminishing returns apply here. Its a new LLM but its still an LLM -- years old technology now

However, despite these two realities, the total utility/productivity/societal gain from a product (note I didn't say model) like ChatGPT can still increase by orders of magnitude. That is because companies like OpenAI, and many, many, other technology corporations and startups are figuring out how to leverage LLMs to do stuff much more powerful than just answer questions from the corpus (ie: perform quality research, reevaluate itself, computer controls, etc, etc).

Consider for example, flat screen displays were pioneered in like the 50's and arguably, they didn't become disruptively useful until the advent of smart phones. So yeah, the model may get sort of worse or maybe more brittle, but it almost doesn't matter if they are figuring out what to do with the model and making the model more useful for actual tasks. Sure its cute to talk to an AI persona and ask it questions but that is probably the least important aspect of these type of models. Microsoft word had Clippy, and yeah that was cool. But productivity gain came from word processing, the '.doc' filetype, filesharing, editing, etc. Clippy is just a meme now and that's a likely future scenario for the "chat" features in LLM products IMHO.

jnmandal··on Ollama Turbo
Sure but if my some of the development team is using ollama locally b/c it was super easy to install, maybe I don't want to worry about maintaining a separate build chain for my prod env. Many startups are just wrapping or enabling LLMs and just need a running server. Who are we to say what is right use of their time and effort?
jnmandal··on LLM Inflation
LLM Inflation is an interesting choice of terminology. Like with many things in our contemporary society there is a temptation to assign absolute, quantitative value to everyday concepts but realistically we should know this to be a fallacy. Many concepts actually have no "on paper" value but still manifest significant social value. Marketing is the typical example, and yet we don't refer to advertising as inflation (though maybe we should).

This concept probably applies to lots of work in the "AI" space right now. The idea of using huge amounts of compute to generate lifelike voices for LLMs comes to mind as being recently maligned (something many users may not want). Or people upset about getting AI summaries in search that they didn't ask for. And yet, swaths of capital has been invested in these ideas and perhaps its a worthwhile use of resources. I am not sure personally. Time will tell. But I suspect its more complicated than the author is implying here.

jnmandal··on Ollama Turbo
Honestly, I think it just depends. A few hours ago I wrote I would never want it for a production setting but actually if I was standing something up myself and I could just download headless ollama and know it would work. Hey, that would also be fine most likely. Maybe later on I'd revisit it from a devops perspective, and refactor deployment methodology/stack, etc. Maybe I'd benchmark it and realize its fine actually. Sometimes you just need to make your whole system work.

We can obviously disagree with their priorities, their roadmap, the fact that the client isn't FOSS (I wish it was!), etc but no one can say that ollama doesn't work. It works. And like mchiang said above: its dead simple, on purpose.

jnmandal··on Ollama Turbo
I see a lot of hate for ollama doing this kind of thing but also they remain one of the easiest to use solutions for developing and testing against a model locally.

Sure, llama.cpp is the real thing, ollama is a wrapper... I would never want to use something like ollama in a production setting. But if I want to quickly get someone less technical up to speed to develop an LLM-enabled system and run qwen or w/e locally, well then its pretty nice that they have a GUI and a .dmg to install.

jnmandal··on AI capex is so big that it's affecting economic statistics
> Just because we invest these ressources in AI does not mean we could mobilize the same capital for other pursuits.

No offense but you sound naive here. This is exactly how dry powder manifests in PE/VC and is even predictable under cash rich corporate regines via M&A.

Trends like this are ripe for acceleration under favorable environmental conditions like high interest rates. Not to mention, a lot of it develops out of peer pressure.

Sometimes when your job is to deploy capital, you just deploy it. Of course you try to put it in the best possible places. But when those are few, well yeah... This happens.

jnmandal··on First ammonia-fueled ship hits a snag
I get that but isn't it like 100x more efficient to be storing that energy to offset intermittency/base power or selling that ammonium as fertilizer to offset hydrocarbon-based haber bosch ferts?
jnmandal··on First ammonia-fueled ship hits a snag
Isn't the energy return on investment for this extremely low and/or negative? Am I missing something here?
jnmandal··on Botched Alerts Turned This L.A. Neighborhood into a Fiery Death Trap
Cannot overstate how important investigations like this are as the polycrisis continues to accelerate. This is great work
jnmandal··on Eggs US – Price – Chart
Meanwhile, my chickens cost exactly the same as they did 12 months ago. :)
jnmandal··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (February 2025)
You guys have a map bug in your careers page which is causing a point to show at 0,0 (the center of the world!)-- just off the coast of Nigeria in the gulf of guinea. Well at least, I'm assuming its a bug since that's a common result of something like null values being mishandled. But maybe you have an underwater office there?
jnmandal··on I'm Peter Roberts, immigration attorney, who does work for YC and startups. AMA
Peter -- many thanks for your continued presence and accessible approach. My wife and I reached out to you several years ago and your response was immensely helpful and comforting. Thanks for what you do.
jnmandal··on Xylella Fastidiosa: A crisis brewing in Europe's olive groves
Seems like you are working on a lot of cool projects. You keeping a blog or socials or anything like that ? Would be cool to follow along.

I am doing some similar projects. I've got some acreage planted with chestnuts and a few other select trees. Going on three years now of planting. I haven't done a good job documenting things but putting together a talk about agriculture so maybe that will change.

> Their minimum order's a little high for a cultivar of pistachio I need for rootstock, doesn't seem to be any other option.

Sounds like you need some friends/neighbors/comrades to throw in with you on a group order. I have been in a similar place myself; I've roped a lot of friends into these schemes now. Last month I had 7 lbs of chestnuts sent to my buddy while I was out of the country haha.

jnmandal··on Xylella Fastidiosa: A crisis brewing in Europe's olive groves
Nice. Good luck. It sounds like we are up to similar things. Its nice to see that. I wish there were more forums for this specific type of discussion.

> We have a list of "things we can't live without if the rest of you monkeys shit the bed and and can't sell it to us anymore".

Not trying to be obtuse about this because I get it... but if we end up in this situation, I think olives and pineapples will be one of our least concerns. Both are great plants to grow and experiment with. I also grow olives, fruits, all kinds of berries, etc. But due to the rather interconnected nature of both the global economy and the global climate system, it may be that if we ever begin to see items like that in widespread failure we could simultaneously be overwhelmed w/ larger problems. Lets say massive food price inflation, isolated famines/shortages, and ultimately total base calories for our diet.

So while I don't disagree with your sentiment at all I would just say that I hope you have things like grains and staples on that list. Sweet potatoes are a relatively nutrient-rich and calorie dense food that are technically perennial and can be grown in similar format to how you describe your olives and pineapples (take them indoors in winter, use some greenhouses to extend season, etc). Bananas are similarly useful if you are in the right climate. In the biosphere 2 experiment, sweet potatoes constituted the bulk of their diet (source: https://ecotechnics.edu/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/Advances-...). In a worst case scenario we might even end up in victory garden type situation and need to plant corn, beans, etc wherever we have space to do so.

> anybody at Foundation Plant Services at UCB

As for this, I'm not in your region so I have no connections there but I highly recommend just finding a few names and emailing them about your project. I've done similar with people all over the and I normally do get a reply. Most recently an Israeli horticulturalist I had read about on HN responded and gave me germination tips for some trees I am growing after I emailed her.

Happy gardening mate. :)

jnmandal··on Xylella Fastidiosa: A crisis brewing in Europe's olive groves
Nailed it. Indoor farming doesn't work at scale for tree crops. The soviets had quasi indoor "pineapple pit" style plantations of citruses in far north of their effective ranges. Imagine something like a subterranean greenhouse in trench format -- yet even in a planned economy that was hardly a viable project.

But the Spanish monks who gave gave California olive trees were on to something. If you plant enough new olives from seed then you can eventually find and develop a variety that grows well in your particular climate. This obviates the need for sheltering the tree much or at all.

No offense mate but I bet if we accounted for the cost of your grow light setup your eventual harvest might could be some of the most expensive olives in the world. No hate though, I've got an olive tree indoors too (though just in a window).

jnmandal··on Xylella Fastidiosa: A crisis brewing in Europe's olive groves
No offense but that is bunk.

To grow thousands of olive trees indoors would be nearly impossible. Perennial crops like this need huge amounts of soil for their root systems, and to replace the amount of olives with indoor plantation would require a massive square footage of greenhouses.

Not to mention that diseases like this can just as easily transmit indoors. Look into the American chestnut blight if you don't believe me. There almost no way to grow a tree isolated from the blight.

The only viable solution in cases like these is a genetic one. In this case, we can actually top the olive and graft a disease resistant variety onto the rootstock. In some cases you may have to actually develop an entirely new tree from scratch and replant.

That is why continuous research into plant genetics and breeding is so extremely important for the continuation of human society.

jnmandal··on Trump wins presidency for second time
Ultimately I'm not giving up, and I would say being aware of this fact is the opposite of ignorance.

The very first step here is to phase out extraction of fossil fuels. Kamala Harris was not going to even stop fracking, which is by far the most environmentally damaging extraction, let alone phase out drilling.

Basically no state/country nor any politician is going to save us. Currently it's up to regular people to work on building a better world, restoring the biosphere, coming up with ways to adjust our manner of living towards a sustainable course and one that will be resilient to catastrophic climate events and even social upheaval.

Instead it seems a lot of people want to just cast a ballot and then forget about it, but this will be a fundamental lifestyle change, and it's going to involve sacrifice.

jnmandal··on Trump wins presidency for second time
Everything you say is true. However it's bizarre for me to read you lamenting as if this election somehow had any bearing on that trajectory.

Under a continued Biden regime or a renovated Harris regime the climatic trajectory was similarly in overshoot. Like if you pay attention to what scientists, or even just general NGO representatives are saying... You should know that we are far off the rails.

Id encourage you to read the world meteorological organization's report from just last week; we are no where near what is manageable for a stable and prosperous future for our descendants. The climate has absolutely destabilized and we now have left a dismal future laced with intermittent catastrophe. Our generations greed and myopia means we have also left a momentous task to our descendants who might seek to try and restore the planet to equilibrium. Trump or Harris at the helm --it makes no difference-- the ship is going down.

Future generations will inherit a ruined biosphere, food insecurity, resource wars, etc. Humand can obviously mitigate tha somewhat but there's not a single political entity in the US or perhaps even the West as a whole that is currently engaged in doing so.

jnmandal··on Trump wins presidency for second time
Quite the opposite really, but I think it's naive to pretend that was on the ballot here.

Both the candidates were in favor of a continuation of the petroleum based industrial society that will inevitably collapse in on itself.

In fact an argument can be made that this election and it's result are a symptom of that.

jnmandal··on Trump wins presidency for second time
That was going to be the case either way. In fact we have pretty much already blown through that
jnmandal··on Carbon Sequestration by Recycling Cement, Aggregates, and Concrete
Yes. More fundamentally than housing, this is about demographics. Human population will peak soon and then decline. Wether degrowth is embraced or forced upon actors who whine about it is the main question. Its increasingly looking like that latter, which I personally refer to as angry degrowth
jnmandal··on Carbon Sequestration by Recycling Cement, Aggregates, and Concrete
Its fundamentally not possible to replace NEW cement production with recycled cement without degrowth. The nice thing about degrowth -- and lets be very serious here: degrwoth IS happening in China, and many other demographically unbalanced socitieties wether you like it or not -- is that it enables a completely circular economy whereby most minerals and even things like cement can be 100% sourced from the existing materials with no need for additional raw inputs. That's what this paper is fundamentally about.
jnmandal··on Carbon Sequestration by Recycling Cement, Aggregates, and Concrete
Degrowth economics go brrr
jnmandal··on Elderly dementia patients are unwittingly fueling political campaigns
The state of affairs surrounding this practice as well as the amount of money used up in the election system generally is absolutely ridiculous.
jnmandal··on Biblical plant with medicinal properties resurrected from 1,000-year-old seed
Being frank, I didn't even realize this was available freely. When I searched "Miski silphium" the first place I ran across was asking for a log in (researchgate I believe) so I just copied the DOI since its easier for folks... PTSD from reading a lot of papers I guess. IYKYK

Anyways I first read about this in a book: The Lost Supper by Taras Grescoe. I also recommend checking that book out if you find this topic interesting.

jnmandal··on Biblical plant with medicinal properties resurrected from 1,000-year-old seed
The Romans may have had difficulty cultivating it but based on recent findings, local peasants in the region were capable of doing so. See my other comment above or check out DOI 10.3390/plants10010102 -- its possible it never went extinct at all.
← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →