HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

joelegner

107 karma · joined July 9, 2019

Human, husband, father, musician, former structural engineer. I preach the good news that it is the natural state of humans to be good to each other.

https://x.com/josephlegner/

submissionscomments
joelegner··on Telly Is the First TV Paid for by Brands
Yes, but I have not heard it used for years. It seems to have fallen out of favor like my dad’s favorite: “boob tube.”
joelegner··on NewsNotFound: An open-source, unbiased news company
It sounds to me like you want to rely on quantifiable science in all things. Yes science is founded upon math which is founded upon logic. Both math and logic are axiomatic systems, and axioms are assumed or declared. They are not independent of a person's mind either. You cannot escape it. David Hume sorted it out for us long ago. Rational certainty is a pipe dream. But that need not prevent us from navigating this world and enjoying life.

Back to the topic: we seem to be talking about a human being choosing between competing news sources. As that consumer, you get to define "unbiased" for yourself. Wise people have given it a lot of thought, so you might consider consulting what they said.

And you can draw the line at something being measurable to matter to you. That's your choice. I have found the things that matter most are fictions in my brain: love comes to mind.

It is also not necessary to measure to detect a distance. I love my dog, and I love my child. I cannot measure love, yet I detect a significant distance between my love for my dog and my love for my child.

Like love, "bias" has meaning even if it cannot be measured. Like love, one can detect distances between biases, even if they cannot be measured. Science (measurement), math (quantity), and logic (relations of ideas) are just as ephemeral, because they are founded upon unprovable axioms and norms.

joelegner··on NewsNotFound: An open-source, unbiased news company
Isn’t the aspiration to be unbiased worthy already?

The goal or call it “aspiration” to serve unbiased news is admirable to me, even while my rational mind knows the aspiration is an unattainable ideal. I will give them a try. Then I can judge their sincerity and performance relative to their aspiration.

Edit: added “judge”

joelegner··on Roald Dahl: Rishi Sunak joins criticism of changes to author's books
Yes, there are many! I was shocked to learn this as an adult. Various sources seem to number them in the hundreds of thousands of variants.

This one remarks there are a half-million variants of the New Testament. It does not seem to be in doubt that there are at least tens of thousands.

https://equip.sbts.edu/article/can-really-trust-bible-manusc...

There seems to be an academic field that studies them, how they evolve and split like an evolutionary tree. The way things are going, by the end of my life that field will have to expand to all literature.

joelegner··on How the Colosseum was built and why it was an architectural marvel
Good point. In the United States there are two pozzolanic materials frequently used as "admixtures" in concrete: fly ash and silica fume. Fly ash is far more common. It is a beneficial byproduct of coal combustion. Being a byproduct of another industry, it is less expensive than Portland cement.

There are several reasons for adding it to mix designs. It can replace a portion of the Portland cement without sacrificing long-term strength, so it is added to reduce cost. It adds to the strength by reacting with some hydration products that do not contribute to the strength of the hardened concrete, converting those hydration products to those that do increase strength (calcium-silica hydrate for example). It reduces the permeability of the hardened concrete which improves resistance to corrosion in marine environments. It reduces the heat of hydration (which can be damaging), because it reacts less vigorously than Portland cement. There are probably other benefits, but those are the ones that come to mind.

joelegner··on How the Colosseum was built and why it was an architectural marvel
Structural engineer here. Much of what is said in the other responses is correct, but I will try to explain it as structural engineers do and also use industry-standard terms.

There are many things called concrete. I am going to use the word "concrete" to mean "Portland cement concrete". That's what you are describing in your questions.

Concrete is the stuff sidewalks are made of. Some people use the word "cement" when describing sidewalks. But that is akin to calling bread yeast. Sure, there is cement in concrete like there is yeast in bread but concrete is more than cement as bread is more than yeast. Cement and yeast are the active ingredients only.

Hardened concrete is a composite material made up of aggregates and a binding matrix that holds the aggregates together. Aggregates in concrete include sand (fine aggregate) and gravel or crushed stone (course aggregate). The matrix consists of cement particles and minerals that grow out of those particles as the cement reacts with water: a process we call hydration. These minerals or "hydration products" grow around the aggregates and give the concrete its strength.

What we call cement is rightly called Portland cement. It is added to a concrete mix in the form of a very fine powder. The cement is manufactured from limestone (primarily) that has been fired in a kiln before being ground to that extremely fine powder. The kiln treatment is how it becomes hydraulically reactive.

Material that reacts with water similar to Portland cement also occurs naturally around volcanoes. I believe that is where the Romans got the cement for their concrete. But nowadays we manufacture Portland cement it instead.

Hardened concrete is strong in compression (when squeezed) but weak in tension (when pulled apart). When we need tensile strength, we add steel reinforcement. The resulting composite material is referred to as reinforced concrete. Concrete can also be used without steel reinforcement when it is not subject to tensile loads. This we call either plain concrete or unreinforced concrete.

The word "rock" or "stone" encompasses a wide range of naturally-occurring solid materials made up of various minerals. Limestone, granite, marble, and sandstone are common examples. Most of the solid rock you see around your world is much stronger than concrete. Concrete is an imitation of rock. In fact, the name Portland cement was given to it because the concrete resulting from its use supposedly looks similar to natural stone quarried on the Isle of Portland in the United Kingdom.

I hope this helps. In short: Portland cement, water, and aggregate (sand and crushed natural rock or gravel) are mixed or "batched" and harden by a chemical reaction called hydration to produce a solid material similar to natural stone but with many practical advantages over rock.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2