HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

joelg

1,497 karma · joined October 5, 2015

https://joelgustafson.com
submissionscomments
joelg··on Magic Leap is neither magic nor leaping
> Quick guide to spotting non-existent tech

> - Refusing to give a launch date

> ...

> - Confusing working hard with making progress

Some of these are valid, but some are inevitable for any tech that is actually revolutionary. Magic Leap's actions seem so far to be consistent with both theories. It's kind of unfortunately true that it's impossible to distinguish between the exaggerated-for-media-coverage-sake case and the actually-world-changing-but-really-technically-difficult case.

joelg··on Overview of New JavaScript APIs Now Supported by Most Mainstream Browsers
No Safari support yet, but I'm really excited about the new Fetch API to replace XMLHttpRequest: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Fetch_API
joelg··on Symbolic mathematics on Linux
Also worth noting is scmutils [0], which is a symbolic computing library for MIT Scheme that Gerry Sussman [1] wrote and uses to teach 6.945 Symbolic Systems and 6.946 Computational Classical Mechanics. The documentation is sparse, but it's incredibly powerful, especially if you're already familiar with Scheme.

[0] http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/gjs/6946/refman.txt

[1] ... And many others including Hal Abelson and Jack Wisdom

joelg··on Thought as a Technology
Not only might it be more fun, but you'd build a better intuition about what to expect from it (or even how it works).

It's like how people often make fewer mistakes with slide-rules or abacuses than pocket calculators, since the former two require you to check your answer against your intuition, while the latter just tells you "the answer" to your (potentially ill-formed) query. Trusting a black box can be quite dangerous.

joelg··on Thought as a Technology
I think there's a subtle danger to "cognitive outsourcing", or at least an important distinction to be aware of. "Cognitive outsourcing" works like an oracle, but many of our best tools work more like bicycles: very direct, very fluid, very analog, with continuous feedback that helps us build an constructive intuition. Bicycles extend the range of what a human can do; oracles do something that a human tells them to do.

Sometimes this difference is a function of how information is displayed and how it reacts to the user. Terminals and REPLs are inherently oracles; spreadsheets connect our fingertips directly to raw information.

Other times it’s just a difference in the conceptual model that users construct. Some people think of Google as an oracle ("what is the weather like?"); others as a bicycle ("weather"). Those who bicycle around Google aren’t just “better at Googling”; they have a fundamentally different view of what they're doing.

This isn’t to say that oracles are inherently wrong or that bicycles are always better, but there’s a huge difference between truly augmenting a human and merely interfacing with one. It’s important to know which idea is appropriate for any given problem space.

(most of this comment was ripped from here: http://joelgustafson.com/ideas/2016/08/25/oracles-and-bicycl...)

(see also http://mental.bike, which I don't know why I own)

joelg··on The Case Against Python 3
"Python 3 Is Not Turing Complete"

... Not only is this blatantly false, but the author acknowledges it as such and seems to think that it is still OK to write this sort of sentence. Backing a pure falsehood with anecdotal support from "actual Python project developers" does nothing to change its veracity. I can't respect anything else in this article after seeing this kind of sensationalism.

Perhaps the author doesn't understand Turing-completion (I'll give the author the benefit of the doubt), but even if so it's inexcusable to throw around this sort of technical language this casually.

joelg··on Ask HN: What is your favorite book on English grammar?
Eats, Shoots, and Leaves.

It's more humor than education, and more punctuation than grammar, but it's entertaining and sarcastic and very fun to read.

https://www.amazon.com/Eats-Shoots-Leaves-Tolerance-Punctuat...

joelg··on Learn X in Y minutes
OT: XinY is a misnomer, since Y is constant: each of the articles is of fixed length. It would be really cool (more helpful) to have some sort of dynamically resizable guide to a language, where I could adjust its length and detail with a little slider at the top!
joelg··on Ask HN: What is the best way to visualize vibration of a thing?
Perhaps the FT visualization sides from Steven Wittens' Tools for Thought presentation might inspire you: https://acko.net/files/gltalks/toolsforthought/#28
joelg··on How to Make a Computer Operating System
Another great free OS resource is MIT's 6.828: Operating System Engineering.

"This course studies fundamental design and implementation ideas in the engineering of operating systems. Lectures are based on a study of UNIX and research papers. Topics include virtual memory, threads, context switches, kernels, interrupts, system calls, interprocess communication, coordination, and the interaction between software and hardware. Individual laboratory assignments involve implementation of a small operating system in C, with some x86 assembly."

Lecture notes from 2012: https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/electrical-engineering-and-compu...

Video lectures from 2014: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kDRHsNauoxk&list=PLfciLKR3Sg...

joelg··on Artificial Intelligence Lecture Videos
It depends on what you want out of it! If you're looking for immediately practical skills, of course you're better off taking 6.036 (machine learning). That's not the point of 6.034, which is something more vague that emphasizes intuition over rigor. Personally I think that offering both - a skills-oriented class and an idea-oriented class - is super cool and unique and I wish that pattern was more common.
joelg··on Ask HN: What is your favorite Google chrome extension?
Papier - replace your new tab page with a markdown scratchpad. Dead-simple, local, and beautiful.

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/papier/hhjeaokafpl...

Visual History - augment back/forward with tree-like hierarchy navigation (disclaimer; made this one)

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/visual-history/nkc...

joelg··on Esoteric Topics in Computer Programming (2002)
> Indeed, the lambda calculus was never meant as a real programming language.

In fact, not even Lisp itself was originally meant as a real programming language! McCarthy invented it as a notation for mathematical proofs, and one of his grad students thought it might make a good language.

joelg··on Ask HN: Christmas Gift Ideas to Introduce Kids to Programming/Tech?
Wow! I haven't even thought about Snap Circuits for years.

My parents bought me a set when I was a kid (before I began coding), and I loved them. I distinctly remember learning how the relay switch worked, thinking about how to create a paradox with it - I turned it over and over in my mind and then built a circuit that turned the relay off when it was turned on, and vice versa. Made the relay make a shrill buzzing noise and made me feel like a god.

joelg··on The Long, Remarkable History of the GIF
Ted Nelson would be so proud.

The atomicity of the internet - sealed documents at URLs - is really regrettable. A much more powerful design (although admittedly more complicated) would have been a "turtles all the way down", IPFS-style approach where any asset could be transcluded or linked into. But I don't think we'll ever see it.

joelg··on Recharts – A composable charting library built on React components
Animating the loading of charts and force-directed graphs are the <marquee> and <blink> of the 2010s. In 5 years, they'll seem grotesquely tacky.
joelg··on Ask HN: 8 years working, now 3-4 months off to learn. Looking for advice
I took 042 and 006 simultaneously, and wish I'd have just skipped 042 altogether. I'd seriously consider jumping straight into 006, and adding something else (SICP, 6.945, learn a new language, or commit yourself to a personal project).
joelg··on Show HN: Auto install npm dependencies as you code
Lots of people addressing security and remote code execution by typo.

Yes. You're right. If it scares you, don't use it.

It's always possible to run malicious code by typo, and this is only a little different from installing dependencies from the terminal. Even when you do spell a package's name correctly, you still don't know for sure what you're installing.

The guy just made a cool thing - it seems a little out-of-scope to freak out over security when npm was never really there.

joelg··on MIT and DARPA Pack Lidar Sensor onto Single Chip
It's a feedback loop, and a very effective one. The stronger the brand is, the more credibile your article will seem. The more credibile articles, the stronger the brand becomes.
joelg··on Special projects
It may have been down for maintenance for millennia since your comment, and just come back now, but none of us noticed!

Insert your favorite Matrix déjà vu reference here.

joelg··on The Alice and Bob After Dinner Speech (1984)
I feel like the most accurate predictions start as satire or comedy, not as serious bets. Satire plays to our gut instinct of what we suspect from the nature of future, and is shielded from technical criticism, so people feel more comfortable to take a stab at it without having to hedge.
joelg··on How climate change is rapidly taking the planet apart
Ironically, I grew up in Minnesota.

My only hope is that I can retire from a career of ignoring climate change to a tropical, palm-treed Duluth.

joelg··on How climate change is rapidly taking the planet apart
So what can we - the average HN crowd - actually do?

Bret Victor's essay on what a technologist can do about climate is a well-reasoned perspective targeted at people in the tech industry, and it's at least a start. What else?

http://worrydream.com/#!/ClimateChange

joelg··on Just: A library of dependency-free JS utilities that do just do one thing
And it would be. The use case is when you need one function and want as small an import as possible.
joelg··on Pokemon Go is a huge security risk
1. Google no longer owns Niantic, they spun off as their own company last year.

2. The security risk isn't that Niantic is going to turn evil, it's that Niantic becomes an access point for other (evil) hackers.

joelg··on Mozilla Fathom: Find meaning in the web
Tim Berners-Lee loves to wax poetic on the evolution of our mental model of what's important and what we consider to be the nodes in the computing graph:

TCP/IP: "It's not the wires, it's the computers!"

HTTP/HTML: "It's not the computers, it's the documents!"

Semantic Web (/Fathom): "It's not the documents, it's the things that they are about!"

https://www.w3.org/DesignIssues/Abstractions.html

I look forward to the day when the idea of discrete, atomic documents is finally abstracted away in the same manner that we abstracted away the physical machines that host them.

joelg··on Let’s make peer review scientific
Haha - not my project, I just work on it for now. But thanks for the great ideas!
joelg··on Let’s make peer review scientific
That’s fair. We think it’s important to be able to reference anything within the system with arbitrary resolution, so that’s our goal. Whether that implements well or not is certainly a technical challenge, but hard problems are the fun ones, right?
joelg··on Let’s make peer review scientific
Plugins and views!

We're currently working on a significant architecture refactor that will enable 3rd party plugins to view arbitrary data assets inline, like a reactive spreadsheet or a D3 visualization.

We're also working on deeper, richer hyperlinks between documents that would let you reference or quote other publications in the system with arbitrary resolution (down to the section/paragraph/sentence/number).

joelg··on Let’s make peer review scientific
Of course! Importing from markdown/latex/git, export to PDF/XML/etc, and lots more are coming (not in that order). We're still in very active development, so there's a lot left ahead on our roadmap.

If anyone is serious and passionate about helping out, we're hiring!

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →