Since it's HN, I thought I'd make a plug for understanding your customer.
614 karma · joined July 1, 2009
Since it's HN, I thought I'd make a plug for understanding your customer.
Tianaco, I don't want to argue the merits of your concerns but this is not the correct place to discuss it. Try sending PG an email? My immediate reactions were adjectives like baiting, hijacking and trolling. I don't mean to call you names, but this was just how this whole thread came off to me as.
I don't appreciate that when I come back to this thread that the majority of the comments about the state of the female entrepreneur. I also believe YC is the exception instead of the rule.
This conclusion could be applied to any profession. Of course, there are earnings multipliers applied to VCs because the pay scale and bets are larger.
What most universities do have are business plan competitions. These usually offer significant prizes and great feedback.
Also, any reason for the secrecy as to what university it is?
http://startupschool.org/, "Wheeler Auditorium" links to http://facilities.calperfs.berkeley.edu/wheeler/.
Which lists:
>MAILING ADDRESS
>Cal Performances
>101 Zellerbach Hall #4800
>University of California, Berkeley
>Berkeley, CA 94720-4800
However, this is just the mailing address for Cal Performances. It just happens that Zellerbach is another large auditorium/performance center.
Wheeler Auditorium is in Wheeler Hall. If you get confused where it is, it's near the Campanile (big clock tower).
Not sure who to be ashamed of more; my alma mater or the internets for reading comprehension and fact checking.
Edit: Now that I think about it, #101 is likely the box office at Zellerbach. We really should get a sign there that says: 'Startup School is at Wheeler Auditorium.' Map: You are here, Wheeler over there.
I'm wondering what sets this site apart from the other app review sites?
I think a lack in the market is a site that lists on sale applications. A lot of applications do one day or weekend sales. I hate it when my friends say, "Oh, did you get X for free when they had it on sale?" Well, I didn't know about it!
Immediately comes to mind is political change (political in the sense of the interaction between a governing body and the people/users). Usually this involves a nontransparent decision process by a centralized power. This thread was particularly enlightening: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=803287
Also in education, one cannot forget the social element. Any game changing innovation today will likely embody some web2.0 ideals.
Not only does it contribute to the spread of innovation. I hate to use the word viral but in today's world it likely will have to spread virally through the internet. Reminds me the adoption of the printing press, arguably the greatest educational innovation, was really helped by pornographic material.
What really interests me in the web2.0 and education space is crowd sourcing. Not only Wikipedia but Wikibooks.
Edit: Expanded on web2.0
I think the most shocking of all was enrollment. My gut said that Harvard would be the most selective but when comparing metrics like pre-enrollment salary & GMAT, Haas and Stanford were more selective. I wouldn't expect such a big difference in enrollment percentage and class size but there is.
Haas '10: 6.3% Applicants: 3779 Enrolled: 240
GSB: 6.7% Applicants: ~5400 Enrolled: 360
HBS '10: 10.3% Applicants: 8661 Enrolled: 900
I meant shape as in size! Clearly it's not about shapes as they are all square. My English gets poor right around time for food.
You need some kind of natural progression in the demo so people can understand it more. Maybe start with only a few shapes. This could go for the game as well.
This game is not as easy to understand as like bejeweled or Tetris but I can see where you are coming from. The real thrill in those games are being able to set up a large chain.
What makes a game like this fun (and actually most games) are upgrades and level ups. Try having things you can put points into. First thing that comes to mind is special "attacks" or cubes. Maybe a cube that affects two levels of cubes instead of just the same size.
I believe while other hardware companies are racing to the bottom in prices, Apple is able to extract premium on its hardware and this is really reflected in the gross margin and bottom line.
Could Apple produce a 600$ laptop? Sure. But it is not worth the temporary gains they'd see. A low end line would cannibalize the margins of their other computers. The quality would probably suffer and it would hurt their brand equity. Apple could introduce an economy line of computers and take over way more of the market, probably grow their sales by 25-40% in a year. To me, that is a strong statement... in that they could but they don't.
I think one thing that Apple will have to contend with is the image. As iPhone's and Macbooks become more and more mainstream, the elitism behind it is decreasing. They will need to do some kind of segmentation (and price discrimination). I wouldn't be surprised if they came out with a higher end Pro series priced around 2500.
Full disclose, I do own a few shares of AAPL. So I believe the future is bright for Apple.
Also, reach out to some celebrities and see if you can get them to tweet you. I know some maybe receptive if this will help them get more users. I.e. if you know that users who followed Martha also likely followed Newt Gingrich, you could build a suggestion engine. (you maybe able to scrape twitter for this data?)
Hopefully this feedback was of nonzero value. Unfortunately, I don't think HN is the same demographic as the one you are targeting :)
Edit: Oh I just had an interesting idea. When people sign up for your service, give them an opt-in to also follow celebsutra. Whenever someone follows a celeb through celebsutra, you RT their action. (@biggestcelebfan just follow @bigceleb through @celebsutra) This could be a kind of discover engine for people to find people with the same interest. I know it's a little spammy, make it an easy opt out but it could easily create a viral loop.
That's not true. Let me explain. In this model (1 dimensional spectrum, be it distance or whatever), if a third player entered the market and the other two players are located at the center then the new players rational choice is to be on either side of the incumbents. He therefore sandwiched the middle player and stole all of his customers, the middle player will then move to the outside and again a player will have been sandwiched. The cycle repeats.
But if you add in costs associated with relocating (time or revenue lost or rebranding or moving costs) then this no longer is an effective strategy. A player might realize that this would happen and purposely not locate in the middle in order to avoid a fight. I don't quite remember the solution to a three player model but that was also based on an assumption that there are only three players.
It gets highly complicated when there is the possibility of new entrants. The lesson could be watch out for new entrants and stay nimble (so it is cheap for you to react when there are new entrants).
Economics should always be applied to real life with many caveats. It's been a while since I took my semesters of game theory but here's some brief problems with real life applications.
One dangerous assumption in the hoteling model is that there are no costs to changing your position. That is, the two parties will keep relocating until they're at the Nash equilibrium (neither party can benefit from relocating). This is just plain wrong in real life. Political candidates lose a lot of credibility when they reverse stances on something. It is true that after primaries, candidates then to become more moderate but most other applications of hoteling are dangerous. (Edit: same goes for changing marketing stances, product positioning, pricing... etc.)
Removing relocation/repositioning costs illuminates another unrealistic assumption: there are only two players. If you have huge costs to relocating then you don't want to allow a competitor to come in and take your half of the market because he positioned himself right next to you (i.e. M, N, O). If you add in these two assumptions, players might actually want to have an agreement to separate such that any new entrant would not be able to gain as much profit as they are currently making (while still each controlling 1/2, (i.e. at .33 and .66 on the spectrum or something).
A third assumption is that it is a one dimensional world or that consumers judge choices only along one spectrum. If you add in that another competitors could compete not just on the "beach"... Or if a competitor could differentiate itself on a topic that consumers care about more (not all spectrums made equal)... Or spectrums change, the median consumer could shift from one year to another.
I could go on but the point is to not assume the can opener. In entrepreneurial terms, maybe all the competitors out there are "hoteling," could that be justification to be different? Purple Cow? Or maybe it is better to make a few consumers love you than many to just like you.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SOSfMzwA5C0
They accepted an offer with a 6 month buy out clause so it is possible they never intended on keeping the money.
I just have major doubts about their numbers. The way the founders present them is very suave but thinking deeper in is really questionable.
Other highlights from the show are in: They had 40% of University of Arizona (about 14k users) in 8th months.
30k revenue in 1 year.
Not exactly a smashing success, but a start. Just a few doubts when examining them deeper.
Definitely addicting but too short. Should match you up against peers based off how you did in previous games.
Example: When they say now is not a good time. Instead of asking, "Would next week be a good time to discuss how we can help?" Ask, "What would be a better time to discuss how we can help? Wednesday or Friday?" This way, instead of a response of "No, I can't." You'll get an appointment.
I hated being a salesman but that was probably the one rule I learned and actually kept. Always be closing. (someone had to say it)
Another thing I think you should try is up-selling your current customers. Contact some customers that you've had interaction with (maybe exceptional customer service) and see if you can get them to sell one of their peers on your service and provide both of them a discount.
Segment your market and then try targeting them at where they spend their time. See which one is the most lucrative or cost effective. i.e. Sure most of them are on Facebook but from a CPC perspective and conversion rate, Facebook might not be the best. Facebook might be too competitive for whatever you are trying to do (i.e. singles matching) A booth at the anime/comic convention might do better when you look at paid subscriptions/cost.
My problem (and other's) with yelp is their discovery system is muddled in with their revenue model. That is you can't really trust the algorithm because they're also putting restaurants who paid at the top. So it no longer is a user revenue but an Adword. Not cool.
I mean plurchase loads, just unable to connect to the server. So the tools worked but the social networking did not.
I think a lot of people shop online at work and many of those are behind firewalls. A quick online search threw numbers at me like 50% and scaling upwards to like 75% as you get into the "facebook generation."
Btw, great product. I also love how when I tried to test if it was a browser issue and loaded up IE that it notified me that my browser was "too old."
They did do a release with some statistics. http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/09/20/techcrunch50-had-intern...
"There were more than 1,200 simultaneous connections at peak points, and bursts of up to 88 Mbps inbound bandwidth usage."
and 28 wifi access points and more than 100 cisco switches incase Wifi was down.
Jason Calacanis said in an interview they paid 86k for the two days. Not sure if this is right but it could be a rough ballpark.
What do people invest in? How do they spend their money? How do they lose their money? I'd love to see the kinds of insights that could be gleamed from it. Of course the data will have caveats but I could see reports like: 90% of mint users who own apple stock also buy apple product or maybe 90% of users who buy apple product short microsoft stock?
At the simplest, it is a player versus player game. You are playing against peers that are getting smarter and more experienced matching yourself. This is way more meaningful than playing against computers.
A few more insights in order of skill.
Critical thinking is key. There are usually multiple ways to win. When direct damage is not going to cut it, you might have to go to plan B or C. Given your collection of cards, you can make multiple types of decks. You have to categorize all your cards and try to build a team out of them.
It teaches economics. Kids are (usually) limited by your allowance. Some cards are really good (or rare) but maybe buying 10 cheaper alternatives makes for an overall better deck. You already have certain cards, can you trade for the remaining ones? (Bartering and sales is a skill in it's own right) Can you feel that in the new season the archetype will be an aggressive deck causing this card you own to go up in price?
It involves next level thinking. Your opponent executed a seemingly unfavorable move. Is it because he has a trick up his sleeve? Or is he trying to bluff you? Is he trying to read if you have a trick? This of course varies based on skill but it is something experienced players learn (even young ones)
You have to deal in possibilities and assess your situation. You know your opponent has used x out of his 4 possible copies of this card. He has only (4-x) left in his deck of 50 so he is unlikely to draw it. Maybe the current board position is favorable for you, you are ahead in life so you should win within 4 turns. Or maybe you have 2 cards left in your whole deck that can help you win, you have yet to draw them but you need to set up the board position so that if you do draw it...
(In all card games, advantages can be distilled into two types: tempo and card. Tempo is when you are getting out ahead of an opponent in terms of board position. Card is when you have more cards in your hand. Aggressive decks sacrifices card for tempo, control sacrifices tempo for cards. Control decks chance of winning increases as the game wears on.)