HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

john-h-k

384 karma · joined March 23, 2025

https://johnk.dev
submissionscomments
john-h-k··on Why not Matrix (2023)
Why? Because it makes reading significantly easier
john-h-k··on Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest “smoking detectors”
> No, this is a statistics trope. “Our revenue has grown 50x this year” always means “our revenue was <something laughable like $100> and now it’s <something still laughable like $5000>”

Orthogonal. I said it doesn’t imply it, and it doesn’t. It may suggest it’s likely - and it does - but it does not imply it.

john-h-k··on Beyond Food and People
The whole first analogy feels a bit backwards.

Crocodile tries to kill human, human kills it as the stronger animal. That seems very natural.

Crocodile tries to kill human, human decides it’s natural for crocodile to do so and lets it live due to complex human morality. That feels much more “human exceptionalist”!

john-h-k··on 4k NASA employees opt to leave agency through deferred resignation program
Okay but doesn’t seem relevant to how effective NASA currently is
john-h-k··on Evaluating publicly available LLMs on IMO 2025
The time investment a human has to make to get 31% on the IMO is worth far more than $400
john-h-k··on Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest “smoking detectors”
It doesn’t imply that. I’m pretty sure it is all false positives, but that number does not imply that. It could simply be that only ~1 in 84 smokers was being fined before
john-h-k··on I Ported SAP to a 1976 CPU. It Wasn't That Slow
But if you ported the ABAP to a static language it would be significantly faster than both
john-h-k··on Why is the Rust compiler so slow?
My C compiler, which is pretty naive and around ~90,000 lines, can compile _itself_ in around 1 second. Clang can do it in like 0.4.

The simple truth is a C compiler doesn’t need to do very much!

john-h-k··on AGI is Mathematically Impossible 2: When Entropy Returns
> Specifically, that some semanti spaces (e.g., heavy-tailed, frame-unstable, undecidable contexts) can’t be computed or resolved by any algorithmic policy — no matter how clever or powerful. The model does not underperform here, the point is that the problem itself collapses the computational frame.

I see no proof this doesn’t apply to people

john-h-k··on AGI is Mathematically Impossible 2: When Entropy Returns
> You stated to "feel" generally intelligent (A's don't feel and don't have an "I" that can feel) - Your nuanced, subtly ironic and self referential way of formulating clearly suggests that you are not a purely algorithmic entity

This is completely unrelated to the proof in the link. You have to clearly explain what reasoning in your argument for “AGI is impossible” also implies human intelligence is possible. You can’t just jump to conclusions “you sound human therefore intelligence is possible”

john-h-k··on Income Inequality Depresses Support for Higher Minimum Wages [pdf]
> Show me literally any study that correlates the amount of work performed/the value of work/the ability of the worker with wealth. I'll wait.

Not too long ago I dug a large hole, and then filled it back in again. It was very difficult and tiring, and entirely useless.

If you accept that I don’t deserve money for this, then you reject the premise that effort/work is the only factor determining value, and “utility” or value to others also matters

john-h-k··on We found a germ that 'feeds' on hospital plastic – new study
If I had to develop a building designed to incubate the most horrendous possible types of pathogens (w/o bioengineering), it would end up basically being a hospital.

Obviously hospitals are good, but they are inevitably a perfect environment for pathogen incubation and there’s no easy solution to this

john-h-k··on 100 years of Zermelo's axiom of choice: What was the problem with it? (2006)
Bertrand Russell coined an analogy: for any (even infinite) collection of pairs of shoes, one can pick out the left shoe from each pair to obtain an appropriate collection (i.e. set) of shoes; this makes it possible to define a choice function directly. For an infinite collection of pairs of socks (assumed to have no distinguishing features such as being a left sock rather than a right sock), there is no obvious way to make a function that forms a set out of selecting one sock from each pair without invoking the axiom of choice.

(From Wikipedia but I’ve always found it good)

john-h-k··on OxCaml - a set of extensions to the OCaml programming language.
It's ironic of course because Rust (the language) is named after the fungus called Rust, rather than iron-oxide
john-h-k··on The European public DNS that makes your Internet safer
If you read the link, it seems to be about avoiding phishing and malicious links, and nothing to do with banning piracy/etc sites
john-h-k··on The librarian immediately attempts to sell you a vuvuzela
> Can you resist ads where, say, AirBnB pays OpenAI privately to “dope” the o3 hyperspace such that AirBnB is moved imperceptibly closer to tokens like value and authentic??

This would be a very impressive technical feat

john-h-k··on Bypassing GitHub Actions policies in the dumbest way possible
There is no meaningful way to get around this. Ban them in `uses:` keys? Fine, they just put it in a bash script and run that. Etc etc. If it allows running arbitrary code, this will always exist
john-h-k··on Apple to end support for Intel Macs next year: macOS 27 to require Apple Silicon
It’s a brick, except a brick that can do the vast majority of things a laptop can do other than update to the newest OS and install the very latest software?
john-h-k··on Taurine and aging: Is there anything to it?
This has to be taken as one of many data points. Many things that are good for your body will also drive increased cancer growth
john-h-k··on NYC Drivers Who Run Red Lights Get Tickets. E-Bike Riders Get Court Dates
I wonder if Uber/Deliveroo/etc could implement a penalty for doing a delivery - when you are marked as an e-bike deliverer - "too fast". Obviously they have no incentive to do it, but it seems the easiest single action to slow them down
john-h-k··on NYC Drivers Who Run Red Lights Get Tickets. E-Bike Riders Get Court Dates
Presumably doing it via the ticketing system is simpler - so why would they use the more controversial & more complex system to do it if the other works?

Of course its possible this is just being draconian or whatever, but if I were a betting man I'd wager they are doing this because it is in some way necessary

Necessary does not imply fair, or correct, or anything. Just that I would be surprised if they are doing it if the simpler alternative works

john-h-k··on NYC Drivers Who Run Red Lights Get Tickets. E-Bike Riders Get Court Dates
Important to note I absolutely do NOT notice the same dangers from bikes as e-bikes. Like yeah some bikes run reds and there are bad cyclists (just as with drivers, etc), but specifically e-bikes frequently cause issue. I have had to dodge n>2 e-bikes riding down the pavement in the last ~2 weeks, and ~0 bikes (for as long as I can really remember). It is very specifically e-bike usage, and they rate at which they move is just not comparable to normal cyclists.

> There's way too much "feels" in this discussion

I agree that hard numbers are useful, but dismissing feeling entirely isn't useful. Feeling safe is an important quality for a city.

john-h-k··on NYC Drivers Who Run Red Lights Get Tickets. E-Bike Riders Get Court Dates
> The penalty for crossing though red and getting hit by a car is death for any cyclist and a likely accident but very survivable for a car.

But the legal penalty is nothing to do with what risks you took. You could have the view that the state should punish making mistakes that can kill your (in which case the bike penalty would be higher), but I (and I assume most) people wouldn't say this.

The reason the penalty exists is to disincentivise the action. If people were truly rational with all these risks, the problem wouldn't exist in the first place.

It would be incredibly odd to suggest, say, that burglars should have lower sentences if they risked their lives while doing the burglary.

john-h-k··on NYC Drivers Who Run Red Lights Get Tickets. E-Bike Riders Get Court Dates
I can't speak for the accuracy of it, I just thought it would be useful to provide the context
john-h-k··on NYC Drivers Who Run Red Lights Get Tickets. E-Bike Riders Get Court Dates
> They're fixated on cyclists running red lights and stop signs, not distinguishing between different kinds of bikes

Absolutely agree this is silly and cities should be encouraging cycling.

> We want to encourage people to bike less and drive more

assuming you meant to flip this?

An e-bike that can even do 20mph comfortably is much closer to a moped than a bicycle, partly due to weight, and partly due to "ease of speed". Obviously a person can easily cycle 20mph, but it just isn't the kind of thing you do on in a crowded area. Very different when it is just a throttle. So grouping them in with bikes, rather than mopeds or similar, is just extremely silly

john-h-k··on NYC Drivers Who Run Red Lights Get Tickets. E-Bike Riders Get Court Dates
It does provide reasoning for the asymmetry:

> “Since e-bikes do not require a license, drivers of e-bikes can simply ignore their traffic summons with no repercussions whatsoever, making any enforcement futile,” the police spokesperson said. However, the new requirement that cyclists appear in court, or face an arrest warrant if they fail to, creates “a strong incentive to show up in court.”

john-h-k··on NYC Drivers Who Run Red Lights Get Tickets. E-Bike Riders Get Court Dates
Important context that may explain it somewhat further down in the article.

> “Since e-bikes do not require a license, drivers of e-bikes can simply ignore their traffic summons with no repercussions whatsoever, making any enforcement futile,” the police spokesperson said. However, the new requirement that cyclists appear in court, or face an arrest warrant if they fail to, creates “a strong incentive to show up in court.”

Cannot speak for its accuracy.

Anecdotally (London not NYC) I feel like I am "endangered" by e-bikes much more often than cars, because they seem to regularly skip red lights and come silently shooting out from the other side of a car while you are crossing, which a car simply cannot do. They are far heavier than a normal bike and seem to be closer to a small incredibly quiet moped.

Obviously lives-saved is the most important metric, but that doesn't mean the "feeling of safety" component is worthless. The comparison around deaths is only useful if those figures are primarily car deaths caused by running red lights.

I feel like the most sensible policy is requiring licenses for e-bikes above a certain power level (not easy!) and then bringing parity to the treatment of cars vs e-bikes after that

john-h-k··on Poison Pill: Is the killer behind 1982 Tylenol poisonings still on the loose?
It was mean to be a lighthearted joke more than dismissive, apologies. Very interesting though
john-h-k··on Poison Pill: Is the killer behind 1982 Tylenol poisonings still on the loose?
I used a similar defence when someone mysteriously broke a school computer years back
john-h-k··on Poison Pill: Is the killer behind 1982 Tylenol poisonings still on the loose?
> When Pishos smelled an almond-like scent, Donoghue asked the county's chief toxicologist, Michael Schaffer, to test the capsules, and Schaffer's team determined that four of the 44 remaining capsules from the Janus' bottle contained nearly three times the fatal amount of cyanide

(From the wiki page)

This is super interesting, because there was a NileRed video testing this and finding that cyanide doesn't really smell like almonds at all (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WYagO-nup6c).

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →