5,429 karma · joined July 14, 2015
If you don’t use a CDN at all, the destination IP leaks what site you’re trying to connect to (if the domain is well known). If you use a CDN without ECH, you send an unencrypted domain name in the HTTPS negotiation so it’s visible there. ECH+CDN is an attempt to have the best of both worlds: your traffic to the site will not advertise what site you’re connecting to, but the IP can still be shared between a variety of sites.
It’ll be interesting to see how countries with lighter censorship schemes adapt - China etc. of course will just block the connection.
If someone makes a new tech that makes that impossible, 10 principled FSF-enjoyers will write content for it and nobody else. Web standard bloat is bad, but it didn’t cause this problem, and you can’t fix it by creating a new spec.
You can see what the best-in-class hoop jumping looks like in a bunch of open source projects that do binary releases — it’s nontrivial. Or you can see all the machinations that Flatpak goes through to get userspace Mesa drivers etc. working on a different glibc version than the base system. On every other major OS, including other free software ones, this isn’t a problem. Like at all. Windows’ infamous MSVC versioning is even mostly a non-issue at this point, and all you had to do before was bundle the right version in your installer. I’ll take a single compiler flag over the Linux mess every day of the week.
Do you distribute a commercial product to a large Linux userbase, without refusing to support anything that isn’t Ubuntu LTS? I’m kind of doubting that, because me and everyone I know who didn’t go with a pure Electron app (which mostly solves this for you with their own build process complexity) has wasted a bunch of time on this issue. Even statically linking with musl has its futziness, and that’s literally impossible for many apps (e.g. anything that touches a GPU). The Linux ecosystem could make a few pretty minor attitude adjustments and improve things with almost no downside, but it won’t. So the year of the Linux desktop remains illusive.
You generally have difficulty actually running contemporary build tools on such a thing, so the workaround is to use —-sysroot against what is basically a chroot of the old distro, as if cross-compiling. But there are still workarounds needed if the version is old enough. Chrome has a shorter support window than some Linux binaries, but you can see the gymnastics they do to create their sysroot in some Python scripts in the chromium repo.
On Windows, you install the latest SDK and pass a target version flag when setting up the compiler environment. That’s it. macOS is similar.
Both are way more annoying than anything the platforms without symbol versioning suffer from because of its lack. I’ve never encountered anyone who has packaged binaries for both Linux and Windows (or macOS, or the BSDs) that missed anything about Linux userspace ABIs when working with another platform.
Stable ABIs for certain critical pieces of independently-updatable software (libc, OpenSSL, etc.) is not even that big of a lift or a hard tradeoff. I’ve never run into any issues with macOS’s libc because it doesn’t version the symbol for fopen like glibc does. It just requires commitment and forethought.
[1]: https://www.nj.com/news/2013/08/man_fined_32000_for_blocking...
It’s worth noting too that B+ tree databases are not a fantastic match for ZFS - they usually require extra tuning (block sizes, other stuff like how WAL commits work) to get performance comparable to XFS/ext4. LSMs on the other hand naturally fit ZFS’s CoW internals like a glove.
> RustFS is a high-performance, distributed object storage software developed using Rust, the world's most popular memory-safe language.
I’m actually something of a Rust booster, and have used it professionally more than once (including working on a primarily Rust codebase for a while). But it’s hard to take a project’s docs seriously when it describes Rust as “the world’s most popular memory-safe language”. Java, JavaScript, Python, even C# - these all blow it out of the water in popularity and are unambiguously memory safe. I’ve had a lot more segfaults in Rust dependencies than I have in Java dependencies (though both are minuscule in comparison to e.g. C++ dependencies).
Usefully handling allocation errors is very hard to do well, since it infects literally every error handling path in your codebase. Any error handling that calls a function that might return an indirect allocation error needs to not allocate itself. Even if you have a codepath that speculatively allocates and can fallback, the process is likely so close to ruin that some other function that allocates will fail soon.
It’s almost universally more effective (not to mention easier) to keep track of your large/variable allocations proactively, and then maintain a buffer for little “normal” allocations that should have an approximate constant bound.
Windows has specific platform requirements they spell out for each version - those are generally your best bet on x86. ARM devs have it way worse so I guess we shouldn’t complain.