HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

johncolanduoni

5,429 karma · joined July 14, 2015

my public key: https://keybase.io/johncolanduoni; my proof: https://keybase.io/johncolanduoni/sigs/ZUjmc07ldkvSmh8asZn9tbdF2DBdptDfB3Y-eMh9gXQ
submissionscomments
johncolanduoni··on Netflix’s AV1 Journey: From Android to TVs and Beyond
I wonder if it fundamentally only really makes sense for film, video games, etc. where a person will actually tune the range per scene. Plus, only when played on half decent monitors that don’t just squash BT.2020 so they can say HDR on the brochure.
johncolanduoni··on OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race
If the AI boosters are right about what the technology will be capable of in 5 years, at least some of the big player’s investments will be literally the most profitable investments that ever happened. This is a potential mispricing, not a system inherently incapable of paying off long term like the subprime mortgages were. I don’t think another step-change like we saw with GPT2/3 is likely in the mid-term future, but I don't think anyone has shown it’s virtually impossible.
johncolanduoni··on Russia Bans Roblox
They’re referring to sanctions - persons/businesses residing in Russia, certain specific individuals and those working for specific Russian entities are locked out of much of the Western economy. I think it’s reasonable personally, but I can understand how a Russian 1000km from the Ukrainian frontline who used to sell jewelry on Etsy would be pissed.
johncolanduoni··on Russia Bans Roblox
Not all governments are equal - though this cuts both ways.
johncolanduoni··on Russia Bans Roblox
Not all sanctions only require you to validate that the bank isn’t from that country. Usually disbursing money (which Roblox does as a two-sided marketplace) requires actual KYC.
johncolanduoni··on Russia Bans Roblox
Some stuff on Roblox is free, perhaps they were only enjoined from accepting payments?
johncolanduoni··on Russia Bans Roblox
VPNs on cheap VPSes are blocked quite a lot too.
johncolanduoni··on Valve reveals it’s the architect behind a push to bring Windows games to Arm
In a narrow sense, it did move along the story point at the end of HL2 (I won’t explain how because there’s no way to do so without massive spoilers). But yeah, it would be weird to call in HL3 just because of that.
johncolanduoni··on OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race
Oh I don’t doubt any of this - it’s just that you don’t usually see the CCP publicly making arguments that they need to sacrifice the long term for the short term. They have a brand for how they public ally justify their decisions, and it’s definitely about the inevitable, long arc of Chinese history of whatever.
johncolanduoni··on IBM CEO says there is 'no way' spending on AI data centers will pay off
Commercially, Watson was a joke from beginning to end. If their argument is that Watson’s failure indicates a machine that can at the very least convincingly lie to you will definitely fail to make money, that’s an insipid argument.
johncolanduoni··on Anthropic acquires Bun
Why would he stress about a theoretical inefficiency that has very little effect on the finished product or development process? Especially one that could be rectified in a weekend if needed? The game industry is usually pretty practical about what it focuses on from a performance perspective with good reason. They don’t build games like they’re demosceners min-maxing numbers for fun, and there’s a reason for that.

I also wonder how many people who sing the praises of an HTML file with a script tag hosted by Nginx or whatever have ever built a significant website that way. There’s a lot of frustrating things about the modern JS landscape, but I promise you the end results were not better nor was it easier back before bundlers and React.

johncolanduoni··on OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race
I’m circumspect that anyone knows how it’ll play out. I think there’s strong evidence a correction is coming, but some talking head is predicting it’s going to be this week every week, and have been for a while. Nobody has convinced me it’s likely to look like the Great Depression yet.

I also think the circular dealing fears in particular are overstated. Debt financing that looks like this is common in semicon, and I doubt there are any serious investors that haven’t already priced it in. If the bust is fatal for AI investment, it’ll just be bankrupt companies owing money to other bankrupt companies.

johncolanduoni··on OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race
> The point about Solow's Paradox is that the gains of certain high productivity technologies do not provide society-wide economic benefit

Some people certainly argue that about the computer age, and it’s not totally unsupported. But I don’t think the evidence for that interpretation (as opposed to a delayed effect) is strong enough that I’d want to automatically generalize it to a new information technology advance.

To be clear, I don’t think China’s reticence is necessarily wrongheaded. But “we will usher in an age of undisputed dominance in a decade or two instead of right now from this investment” is a weird argument, especially from a government as ostensibly long-term focused as China.

johncolanduoni··on Anthropic acquires Bun
Okay, but it’s a web game. Those will make up less than 0.1% of the downloaded bytes required to render the first frame of the game. One image asset will dwarf the entire gzip/brotli Next.js/React framework.
johncolanduoni··on OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race
Pointing to Solow’s Paradox is kind of weird to me. Productivity growth accelerated in the 90s and 2000s, so it’s easy to tell a story where the computer age simply didn’t accelerate things until it had sufficiently penetrated the economy. If AI follows the same pattern, betting big on it still makes sense: China would probably be the predominant superpower if the computing developments of the 70s and 80s were centered there instead of the US.
johncolanduoni··on OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race
Well, they didn’t say OpenAI was right. I think that a lot of the people working there believe that. It was kind of built into the original corporate/non-profit structure (that they since blew up).
johncolanduoni··on OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race
The shenanigans that set off the GFC were much more nakedly corrupt and didn’t have even a fig leaf of potential usefulness to anybody to justify them. The revolution failed to materialize then. If the AI bust isn’t worse for the median person than 2008, I don’t think people in power have anything to fear.
johncolanduoni··on IBM CEO says there is 'no way' spending on AI data centers will pay off
I suspect the reality is that they missed the boat, as they have missed tens of other boats since the mainframe market dried up. I guess you could argue they came to the boat too early with their pants on backwards (i.e. Watson), and then left before it showed up. But it’s hard to tell from the outside.

Maybe that will turn out to be a good decision and Microsoft/Google/etc. will be crushed under the weight of hundreds of billions of dollars in write-offs in a few years. But that doesn’t mean they did it intentionally, or for the right reasons.

johncolanduoni··on Anthropic acquires Bun
What effect do you imagine Next.js has on a bunch of code manipulating an HTML canvas? For vanilla code directly using browser APIs it’s basically just a bundler configuration, and while it’s not optimally configured for that use case (and annoying for other reasons) it’s probably better than what someone who has never configured webpack before would get doing it themselves.
johncolanduoni··on Anthropic acquires Bun
My point isn’t that you absolutely need that, just that the negative effect on your game development are pretty minimal if you’re not leaning on the SPA framework for anything related to the game. If your game is going to be embedded into an otherwise normal-ish website, this isn’t a terrible way to go (I’ve done it personally with a game mostly written in Rust and compiled to WASM). You can get gains by splitting your game and web site bundles and loading the former from the latter explicitly, but they’re not massive if your bundler was already reasonably incremental (or was already esbuild).

Thanks for assuming I “read” about bundlers somewhere, though. I’ve been using (and configuring) them since they existed.

johncolanduoni··on Anthropic acquires Bun
He may have been serving a game in a canvas hosted in a Next.js app, but have done all the actual game (rendering, simulation, etc.) in something else. That’s a decent approach - Next can handle the header of the webpage and the marketing blog or whatever just fine.
johncolanduoni··on IBM CEO says there is 'no way' spending on AI data centers will pay off
No, I don’t trust a word Sundar or Satya say about AI either. CEOs should be hyping anything they’re invested in, it’s literally their job. But convincing investors that every thing they don’t invest in heavily is worthless garbage is effectively part of their job too.

What is more convincing is when someone invests heavily (and is involved heavily) and then decides to stop sending good money after bad (in their estimation). Not that they’re automatically right, but is at least pay attention to their rationales. You learn very little about the real world by listening to the most motivated reasoner’s nearly fact-free bloviation.

johncolanduoni··on IBM CEO says there is 'no way' spending on AI data centers will pay off
There’s no marginal tax impact of discarding it or not after 5 years - if it was still net useful to keep it powered, they would keep it. Depreciation doesn’t demand you dispose of or sell the item to see the tax benefit.
johncolanduoni··on IBM CEO says there is 'no way' spending on AI data centers will pay off
It makes it suspect when combined with the obvious incentive to make the fact that IBM is basically non-existent in the AI space look like an intentional, sagacious choice to investors. It very may well be, but CEOs are fantastically unreliable narrators.
johncolanduoni··on Anthropic acquires Bun
I’ve never understood the security utility of the Deno flags. What practical attack would they protect you from? Supply chain seems to be the idea, but how many npm packages do people use that neither:

* Get run by devs with filesystem permissions

* Get bundled into production

johncolanduoni··on Mozilla's latest quagmire
Maybe I’m using the wrong web browsers - mine have always had those problems (except that the pseudo-relationships were with real, horrifically bad people).
johncolanduoni··on Google unkills JPEG XL?
Usually it’s Mozilla not wanting to implement something Google wants to implement, not the other way around.
johncolanduoni··on The HTTP Query Method
Whatever the original intent was, POST definitely does not return a new record consistently in most actual APIs. It's frequently used for actions that don't conceptually create anything at all.
johncolanduoni··on The HTTP Query Method
Apart from the sectarian conflicts about what REST means, having a HTTP method that proxies can cache like a GET but allows bodies is pretty useful from a purely practical standpoint. You can do this with POST, but it requires proxy-specific configuration.
johncolanduoni··on The HTTP Query Method
For some reason the RFC focuses on idempotency, but then says it's explicitly intended for enabling caching semantics. Caching a query that mutates visible state doesn't really make sense, and like you point out if you just want idempotent modifications PUT already has the relevant semantics. I guess we haven't learned our lesson from making the original HTTP semantics super squishy.
← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →