HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

johndhi

1,195 karma · joined January 18, 2022

submissionscomments
johndhi··on Sandwich Bill of Materials
love it - is this a thing that's mostly used in government contracting, or do people encounter SBOM stuff more broadly than that?
johndhi··on Discord will require a face scan or ID for full access next month
I could be wrong and would be happy to be so but it seems like this to me:

If someone did a few months of house arrest for "pleading guilty to solicitation of prostitution involving a minor" it would be incredibly easy for that person to say - whoops, she said she was 25 and then they threw the book at me." And not terribly unreasonable for someone to take him at his word on that.

The real crime is that the prosecutors massively under charged him for doing an insane gigantic awful pedophile recruitment ring. No one really knew that til a long time later.

johndhi··on Discord will require a face scan or ID for full access next month
that's a grand jury charge, not what he actually pled to, right?
johndhi··on Discord will require a face scan or ID for full access next month
good call! hadn't read that.
johndhi··on Discord will require a face scan or ID for full access next month
he was convicted of soliciting prostitution (not of minors), right?

why do we assume that the people he was hanging out with knew the details of what he did wrong?

johndhi··on Advancing AI Benchmarking with Game Arena
But can't computers play several hundred thousand poker hands easily in a couple of hours ?
johndhi··on How AI destroys institutions
There are a lot of tools to address the problem that some people have bad intentions.

We publish common sense laws, and we have police officers and prosecutors, and then we have a court system to hold people accountable for breaking the law. That's one pretty major method that has little to do with the need for an institution like FDA.

I don't know if a system that relied entirely on tort and negligence and contract law to protect people from being sold snake oil would function better or worse than FDA, but I do know something like FDA (where a bunch of smart people advise very specifically on which drugs are ok to take and which are not) isn't the only option we have.

johndhi··on How AI destroys institutions
Sorry to be this person, but I don't really agree with the first sentence:

--> "Civic institutions—the rule of law, universities, and a free press—are the backbone of democratic life."

People are the backbone of our civilization. People who have good intentions and support one another. We don't NEED an FDA to function -- it's just a tool that has worked quite well for a long time for us.

johndhi··on Meta's legal team abandoned its ethical duties
as a lawyer, I'll just note that the legal system has standards for this. specifically, you can't delete stuff that poses legal risks to you once you reasonably expect a lawsuit about it. but you can delete it as part of normal business activity until that point.
johndhi··on Classical statues were not painted horribly
This is fun though I sort of wonder if it's attacking a straw man. Are there any reconstruction folks who defend these?
johndhi··on Classical statues were not painted horribly
Makes sense. This is basically how skilled painters of miniatures (Warhammer) do it.
johndhi··on AI's real superpower: consuming, not creating
Can you share some prompt examples you use to try to ensure it doesn't get "lazy" and just cherry pick from here and there?

I have a written novel draft and something like a million words of draft fiction but have struggled with how to get meaningful analytics from it.

johndhi··on “Captain Gains” on Capitol Hill
But added "annually"! That's a lot better!
johndhi··on Effective harnesses for long-running agents
Why do we need long running agents? Most of my experienced value with LLMs has been like 1 to 10 turn chats. Should they just ban longer chats to solve these issues?
johndhi··on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws
Good luck getting rid of LLMs
johndhi··on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws
Names and IP addresses are like 1% of what meets the gdpr definition of personal data.
johndhi··on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws
But how do you actually do that?
johndhi··on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws
Protecting users in the bargains we strike with big tech is a worthwhile and noble effort, but privacy law has generally woefully failed to do this.

Millions upon millions have been spent on cookie banners -- people are still arguing about them in this thread -- but there is almost zero benefit to this expense.

The main thing that's good about this, IMO, is that fundamentally training a large language model and privacy law as it's written today cannot coexist. They are incompatible. And allowing someone to break the law forever (as is happening today) is not a good long-term solution.

johndhi··on Why aren't smart people happier?
Lot of interesting views in this thread.

One thing I loved from Osho (spiritual guru) is the notion that everyone thinks they are "extraordinary" but actually the happiest person is the person who is ordinary. Being ordinary and just eating breakfast and sleeping and doing a job is - in fact - extraordinarily rare.

johndhi··on The Gypsy Life of Robert Louis Stevenson
Thanks for posting. Every time I've read a RLS book lately I've been blown away by how entertaining and well done they are.

Treasure Island - pure gold. Kidnapped - gold.

I recall in the introduction to one of them he explains he wrote these stories for boys. Adventure, danger, fun characters. If you have sons you'll know there is a certain aesthetic young boy love and these books deliver it.

I also was amazed how much I enjoyed his books for adults, like the one about being on a ship as a kid (can't find the name).

If you look into his biography you find some really hard things that I guess he transformed into writing.

johndhi··on Amazon hopes to replace 600k US workers with robots
This article (with limited data I'll note) only talks about the first part -- that it's eliminating jobs. It doesn't say that it isn't also creating jobs.
johndhi··on Amazon hopes to replace 600k US workers with robots
LLMs have only been a big deal for 2 years. are you saying that all of this middle class shrinkage arrived because of that specifically? the original comment was saying this is an LLM-specific issue.
johndhi··on Amazon hopes to replace 600k US workers with robots
>LLMs and robotics look to be the first mainstream technological development in a long while which not only reduces the number of workers needed, but also doesn't have a commensurate increasing of the size of the economy in terms of increased wages through efficiency and profits being paid as wages

What is your evidence of this?

johndhi··on Amazon hopes to replace 600k US workers with robots
presumably if they become as popular as software, they would...
johndhi··on 4Chan Lawyer publishes Ofcom correspondence
I'd think it would be allowed for UK to:

1. Tell 4chan or its registrar l to take down .co.uk urls (maybe?)

2. Tell UK ISPs to ban UK visitors from viewing 4chan

johndhi··on McKinsey wonders how to sell AI apps with no measurable benefits
I can trust a hammer will be a hammer, though.
johndhi··on McKinsey wonders how to sell AI apps with no measurable benefits
I feel like one benefit of humans is you can find someone you can truly trust under almost all circumstances and delegate to them.

With AI you have a thing you can't quite trust under any circumstance even if it's pretty good at everything.

johndhi··on McKinsey wonders how to sell AI apps with no measurable benefits
Not a crazy idea. Sergey at Google said it's best at replacing managers fwiw
johndhi··on Discord says 70k users may have had their government IDs leaked in breach
You really think governments could write rules that would help this?

The only rule I can imagine is big penalties for data being breached, no matter the cause, but do we actually think it's a multi million dollar problem for 70k photos to be released? Hard problem.

johndhi··on Seeing like a software company
I run a team of about fifteen people and for whatever reason I've never really understood or driven toward legibility. What's the point? For me getting to know and trust each person and to develop an understanding of what they are good at is the key thing I focus on. Good work follows.

Actually knowing minutiae of what they do seems like make work to me.

← PreviousPage 3 of 20Next →