HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

johnecheck

466 karma · joined September 8, 2024

Game Dev (https://stargamb.it)

Sucker for epistemology, systems, and languages.

@7hird.dev

submissionscomments
johnecheck··on The anti-abundance critique on housing is wrong
"Sane and normal people can't participate in every local government decision unless it's their job. Hence why we have representative democracy".

While true, times have changed. The information flow is orders of magnitude faster and have you seen any sane and normal people lately? The norm is spending hours scrolling social media. The argument that nobody has spare time/attention and thus we all need representatives falls flat to me.

We need to explore alternative forms of representation to allow people to choose their level of engagement in various levels of government. Perhaps I'm happy to delegate all national matters to a representative I trust but want to regularly weigh in on local decisions.

Between the technical challenge of trust/security and the inevitable political resistance to such ideas, I sadly don't expect to see them implemented any time soon.

johnecheck··on Hawley and Democrats vote to advance congressional stock trading ban
Apologies, I missed that line.

The '[the act] would prohibit members of Congress and their spouses from trading or holding individual stocks' made me think it only applied to them.

johnecheck··on GOP’s Josh Hawley and Democrats vote to advance congressional stock trading ban
"And other forms of speculation"...

Like buying the stock? You're not talking about reform - you can't remove speculation from the stock market without banning stock markets entirely.

I agree that market manipulation (especially by those in power) is an enormous problem. Can we hope to truly fix that? Or are we just going for damage control by banning derivatives or the entire stock market?

johnecheck··on GOP’s Josh Hawley and Democrats vote to advance congressional stock trading ban
That's not what's happening here. It's not a one-time Trump exception, it just doesn't apply to presidents.

To me, it's completely obvious that this legislation should apply to the president. All the legislators know that too. Perhaps they're afraid. Perhaps they're ambitious. Either way, I'm not a fan.

johnecheck··on When we get Komooted
I am not a lawyer, but don't employees (and maybe even users) have a breach of contract claim here?

At least in the US, if you tell me 'We'll never sell out' and I take a job with no equity because of it, that's a verbal legal contract and I have grounds to sue if you then sell out.

In theory, at least, our legal systems discourage/prevent this sort of lying and backstabbing. In practice, perhaps not.

johnecheck··on AI Market Clarity
Which original meaning?

I mostly try to avoid the two capital Cs: Capitalism and Communism. These two terms mean so many different things to so many different people, I'd argue no other words have quite so much baggage or derail conversations quite so effectively.

Taking a side in that conflict means you'll be expected to answer for whatever evil people have gotten up to while paying lip service to your preferred ideology. I'd rather discuss how to improve our world using terms not arguably stained with the blood of millions.

johnecheck··on Cryptocurrency exchanges begin offering tokenized securities
As with all assets, you risk its value dropping precipitously due to events outside of your control.

Specifically, I worry that decreasing supply and the corresponding upward pressure on prices will cause transaction fees to increase and therefore volume to decrease. Decreased volume might lower liquidity and allow an event like an old wallet coming online to trigger a price shock and maybe even a broader crisis of confidence in bitcoin's ability to serve as a store of value.

johnecheck··on Cryptocurrency exchanges begin offering tokenized securities
That sounds like a strategy that's going to work really well until it doesn't.

Perhaps I'm wrong. Good luck!

johnecheck··on France launches criminal probe of X over alleged algorithm ‘manipulation’
What constitutes illegal algorithm manipulation? What obligations to impartiality do digital space providers like Musk/X have?

Not sure what laws exist but it seems tricky to design a coherent legal standard around what sorts of algorithms are allowed. I'd rather just be able to choose between open-source algorithms, that way we can just not use the one that pushes {Billionaire}'s latest post to the top.

johnecheck··on A human metaphor for evaluating AI capability
Would be nice if we actually knew what was done so we could discuss how to judge it.

That recent announcement might just be fluff or might be some real news, depending. We just don't know.

I can't even read into their silence - this is exactly how much OpenAI would share in the totally grifting scenario and in the massive breakthrough scenario.

johnecheck··on A human metaphor for evaluating AI capability
My thoughts were similar. OpenAI, very cool result! Very exciting claim! Yet meaningless in the form of a Twitter thread with no real details.
johnecheck··on OpenAI claims gold-medal performance at IMO 2025
The key bit here is whether the LLM doing the cherry picking had knowledge of the solution. If it didn't, this is a meaningful result. That's why I'd like more info, but I fear OpenAI is going to try to keep things under wraps.
johnecheck··on OpenAI claims gold-medal performance at IMO 2025
Wow. That's an impressive result, but how did they do it?

Wei references scaling up test-time compute, so I have to assume they threw a boatload of money at this. I've heard talk of running models in parallel and comparing results - if OpenAI ran this 10000 times in parallel and cherry-picked the best one, this is a lot less exciting.

If this is legit, then we need to know what tools were used and how the model used them. I'd bet those are the 'techniques to make them better at hard to verify tasks'.

johnecheck··on GPT-5-reasoning alpha found in the wild
Wow. That's an impressive result, though we definitely need some more details on how it was achieved.

What techniques were used? He references scaling up test-time compute, so I have to assume they threw a boatload of money at this. I've heard talk of running models in parallel and comparing results - if OpenAI ran this 10000 times in parallel and cherry-picked the best one, this is a lot less exciting.

If this is legit, then I really want to know what tools were used and how the model used them.

johnecheck··on OpenAI achieved IMO gold with experimental reasoning model
Wow. That's an impressive result, though we definitely need some more details on how it was achieved.

What techniques were used? He references scaling up test-time compute, so I have to assume they threw a boatload of money at this. I've heard talk of running models in parallel and comparing results - if OpenAI ran this 10000 times in parallel and cherry-picked the best one, this is a lot less exciting.

If this is legit, then I really want to know what tools were used and how the model used them.

johnecheck··on LLM Inevitabilism
So you don't have any real info on the costs. The question is what OpenAI's profit margin is here, not yours. The theory is that these costs are subsidized by a flow of money from VCs and big tech as they race.

How cheap is inference, really? What about 'thinking' inference? What are the prices going to be once growth starts to slow and investors start demanding returns on their billions?

johnecheck··on Hypercapitalism and the AI talent wars
Any announcement of AGI will be immediately controversial. Valuation increases will depend on whether people actually believe it and what they're able to sell. Expect public opinion to be fickle and share prices to be volatile.

Decent odds we see some pretenders make that announcement before the real deal. A company with the real deal would probably make bank, but I don't pretend to know when that will come or who that might be.

johnecheck··on Hypercapitalism and the AI talent wars
The full quote is less bleak.

Democracy is the worst form of Government except all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.

~Winston Churchill

johnecheck··on Programming Language Theory has a public relations problem
Here's how to justify it: If you want to talk about something (program), you want the right language. We've got powerful languages capable of everything any computer can do, but new ideas often call for new ways to express them.

Building a language is about accepting massive up-front investment to build something that hopefully meaningfully improves user experience. Or you can build to learn about the inherent beauty of computation and formal languages, but I find that a little less compelling.

johnecheck··on Ask HN: Where are the AI-driven profits or promotions?
Garry Tan almost certainly has incentives to promote this tech.

That doesn't make him wrong though.

johnecheck··on Ask HN: How are you productively using Claude code?
I've been using Claude Code to decent results. Its not 10xing my productivity but it can do tasks like that. I haven't done much to configure it, I just regularly clear the context and @reference the relevant files.

What language are you using?

johnecheck··on AI coding tools make developers slower but they think they're faster study finds
I feel LLMs save me time too but I worry my perceptions don't match the reality.

Got some data?

johnecheck··on You can still enable uBlock Origin in Chrome, here is how
"For now" seems like a detail worth adding to the title if we know Google is patching this in Chrome 140.
johnecheck··on Spain and Brazil push global action to tax the super-rich and curb inequality
Bad take. Obviously if you you cut a factory into a million pieces and hand them out, you've lost value.

Investment tools cover all your concerns here. (Hopefully paired with a regulatory framework that prevents scams (looking at you, crypto))

johnecheck··on Spain and Brazil push global action to tax the super-rich and curb inequality
I don't think some heavy handed communist system should try to abolish all inequality either.

But does that mean income inequality is good?

Maybe in moderation, but I feel it's pretty obviously harmful when taken to an extreme. Policies to reverse the trend of concentrating wealth and power are worth considering.

johnecheck··on The Death of the Middle-Class Musician
I don't really. You're right, ofc. The details about what taxes pay for UBI and who pays them are obviously of key importance.

I don't claim to have the answers. My point is just that there are interesting benefits that are worth weighing against those costs.

johnecheck··on The Death of the Middle-Class Musician
Working on it ;)
johnecheck··on The Death of the Middle-Class Musician
My assumption is that UBI is a significant transfer of wealth from the richest to the rest. Isn't that the whole point? Exactly how to structure the taxes that pay for it is naturally a key question.

Given that, it's pretty safe to assume markets that cater exclusively to the ultra-wealthy will be harmed by reduced demand as their customer base shrinks. Higher tax rates will also exert downward pressure ob stock values as companies make less profit and investors tighten their belts. (Especially if there's a wealth tax.)

johnecheck··on The Death of the Middle-Class Musician
You're broadly correct.

Don't let the uneducated messenger distract from UBI itself though. Proposed seriously, it's about reducing asset values and high incomes to redistribute that value to everyone who isn't losing more value than the UBI. The real argument is that it would mean short-term economic costs to build a more robust system with a bigger pool of people with the safety net and risk appetite to start/join companies.

johnecheck··on The Death of the Middle-Class Musician
Your analysis is spot on. UBI funded by taxes is redistribution.

Is that a bad thing? It would obviously have some negative effects. We'd immediately see damage to luxury brands and yacht sales. The art markets would crash. Stock markets would feel some pain.

The upside though? My hunch is that making most people feel secure enough to risk starting/joining businesses is fuel for a strong and innovative economy. The fact that so few of us are able to take those risks is a constraint on growth.

← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →