HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

johngalt

5,758 karma · joined July 21, 2009

submissionscomments
johngalt··on Unikraft is a fast, secure and open-source Unikernel Development Kit
Are unikernels a performance/efficiency tool? Squeezing more nodes into a single host with minimal overhead.

Or are they a tool to achieve simplicity/elegance? Fewer moving parts to troubleshoot at the OS layer, and smaller but more formal composition.

johngalt··on New engine could save internal combustion from the scrap heap
Modern cars have improved drastically since 1981 by all metrics. Power, efficiency, safety, reliability, cost, and emissions have all improved. An amazing example of iterative refinement combined with economies of scale. If there is some cabal trying to keep cars inefficient and unreliable, they are losing.
johngalt··on What is the root of my extreme negative thinking patterns?
Don't listen to your brain. It will give you a bunch of reasons to be sad, and ruminating about it will only pull you in deeper.

Ensure you have enough of the following: Sunlight, physical activity, sleep.

Set a specific time to sleep and wake. Get a step counter and ensure you are getting at least 10k steps a day. Regular walks during the daytime will help with both sunlight and activity.

After that, work on diet and social activity. If that doesn't fix it, talk to a professional.

johngalt··on We Will Never, Ever, Mine the Asteroid Belt
Never is a long time. Imagine trying to conceptualize modern shipping capabilities before the industrial revolution. It is not only that the cost per ton/mile has fallen drastically, but also the amount of purchasing power average people have. Not to mention the entire classes of industry that were created.

Costs to get to space will trend downward. Our knowledge of the solar system and it's potential for economic benefit trends upwards. At some point someone will find a way to make money, even if it is a niche application. That early industry will create the infrastructure which will open up other areas of development etc... A positive feedback process.

johngalt··on The Sucker Complex
> percentage of its population behind bars, should ramp up punishment and somehow jail even more of its own people?

Corruption isn't only about who avoids punishment, but also who is the target of punishment. In highly corrupt environments you will often find complex and often contradictory rules, that produce a default state of guilt. The only way to avoid punishment is to participate in the corruption.

johngalt··on Raspberry Pi holds its own against low-cost ARM NAS
That's a Synology released four years ago. Contrast with a model released in February this year. Not a single drive non-Synology drive on the HCL larger than 4TB:

https://www.synology.com/en-us/compatibility?search_by=produ...

It's not a hard requirement to use Synology drives, but on the newer/higher-end models the options to not use Synology drives are very limited. For example the FS2500 only has four models of SSD on the HCL and two are Synology.

IMHO, the price premium for the Synology branded drives is reasonable. Pay for the validated drives. Maintaining a broad HCL is no small task.

https://blog.synology.com/in-pursuit-of-reliability-hat5300-...

johngalt··on Ask HN: Are Cybersecurity Workers Ok?
This has been exactly my path. Can write data security guidelines and also read PCAP files fluently. However, you will not find very many of me.

Sysadmin/ops has too many offramps that drain talent before year 10. If you can integrate software/systems well, manage projects or do advanced troubleshooting; you will likely be pulled out of ops. Conversely there are an ocean of security certifications being issued to people who have very little operational/technical experience.

Data security in practice is being reduced to a policy and procedure checklist. It is frustrating for an engineering group to receive non-specific or contradictory policy guidelines written by non-technical people, but I have yet to see that change hiring or decision making. Businesses want someone who will agree to check the box. If that someone doesn't know all the details, that makes checking the box easier.

The future of cybersecurity is not skilled coordinator/PM but instead yet another non-technical management arm handing down mandates that are blind to technical reality. There isn't another option. There aren't enough people to fulfill demand, and the compensation for cybersecurity positions are often less than a senior infrastructure role. How many sysadmins really understand networking, programming, databases, etc; While also having the people skills to not alienate both management and highly technical development and operations teams? We will never have enough people at the intersection of that many skills.

johngalt··on Ask HN: Advice on Colocating Servers?
Don't. It doesn't make sense to try to jump into an area rapidly being commoditized. At most, rent bare metal/dedicated servers rather than VPS.

> Has anyone done this and what was your experience?

It works as expected. Big cost/time upfront to get all the equipment setup, then things mostly just worked. The primary challenge is transferability and standardization.

> How do you select a colo and what do you look for?

Bandwidth availability. Proximity to the team supporting it. Reputation among customers.

> How do you manage the hardware and how much savings in time/$ is there really?

Whatever custom stack is built in the colo must be well documented, and have solid maintenance schedules, and change control procedures. The cost savings exists, but it's never as much as you think.

It's difficult to articulate the specific drawbacks. It's more organizational than operational. Imagine that you have a server dropping at random times. The logs say something ambiguous, and now you have to become full time sysadmin to some elusive problem. No one in your organization will want to deal with these sorts of issues, nor will they want you to burn time on it. There will inevitably be other tasks higher on the list. Operational issues gradually build up like other forms of technical debt. No one receives applause for updating the server BIOS over the weekend. Operational discipline/maintenance inevitably becomes last priority.

johngalt··on Stop requiring specific technology experience for senior-plus engineers
This is also common on the IT/Ops side of the house. E.g. Trying to explain that VLANs, LLDP and 802.1x are not Cisco specific. Often there are just flat misunderstandings of how to identify 'technical' experience. E.G. someone lists the ability to read SIP/RTP protocol decodes and they reject this person because they don't have VoIP experience.
johngalt··on Ask HN: What was it like to use BBS?
I was a SysOp from the twilight years of BBS. To answer your questions:

The costs were mostly paid by the SysOps. In the form of additional phone lines, disk space, maintenance time etc... A user would have to worry about long distance charges.

Re: average people. At the time, there was much more of a dividing line between computer people and average person. Not that you had to be an expert, but you did have to be an enthusiast. The average person would have neither the skill nor inclination/interest.

Not very similar to social media. Closest description would be a combo of 4chan, HN, and sourceforge, but much more local and inward looking. Like comparing a small town bar vs tinder.

"The BBS industry" was so small that the phrase sounds silly to say. Certainly there were official business bbs and larger players but scale was nothing compared to modern tech companies.

The hardest thing to explain now is how novel participating in a network like this was. Prior to large scale internet access, computers were stand alone devices. Networks were arcane company owned things. Having your computer dynamically bring up what others were publishing was new and interesting.

johngalt··on Why is everything so hard in a large organization?
https://www.jrothman.com/pragmaticmanager/2002/01/volume-5-n...
johngalt··on Ask HN: Advice on bringing community broadband to Los Alamos?
Former network engineer that went into management. My email is in profile if you would like more candid guidance than I can give on a public forum.

1. Not realistic, but not outside of normal for an management infrastructure/ops position. What you are writing is what you hope for, but sometimes it sends a red flag to potential applicants. The worry many high level people have is that they will be turned into the 'do everything' person. Trim a few of the less directly related requirements off of the description (e.g. Microsoft certification).

2. Yes... but also No. There are a lot of people who push through their careers collecting credentials and turning it another rung on the ladder. Chances are you will get a rosy candidate at some point, who will put in two years of aggressively spending your budget to inflate their resume and then move on. Not that a majority of people are this way, but the filters are set in such a way that this is what you are likely to end up with.

3. Other comments will say 'pay more', but it will be difficult to meet market rates for this skillset when working with local governments. If you can't get approval to raise the comp, instead try to split this role up into a team. Governments won't pay one highly skilled person 250k, but they will pay four people 80k, and one manager 120k.

4. Politically? Find someone with pull, and make sure that it's 'their idea'. Something that they can put on their win list.

Procedurally? Don't boil the ocean. Handle it iteratively. Start with commercial areas and new housing developments. White-glove your initial smaller install and it will create the broad demand from the community to expand it.

Love what you are doing. Hope this helps.

johngalt··on What's Wrong with Tech Hiring
The problem with tech hiring is that a significant fraction of tech people are basically unskilled. Despite education and experience in some cases. Odds are either the interviewee is unskilled or the interviewer is.

In the best case where you have a technically skilled interviewer and interviewee, there is still the problem of: 'the correct answer is my answer. Even if yours also works, it is not my answer.'

Tech hiring is not difficult, but it requires the following traits in the interviewer:

1. Broad technical skills and the ability to recognize skills in others.

2. Ego is not driving them. No need to be smarter than everyone.

3. Conversational/interpersonal skills to get the interviewee to talk, and to recognize someone who will be a jerk.

The common assumption is that skilled tech people lack interpersonal skills, but in my experience 1&2 is the rare combination.

johngalt··on Operations is not Developer IT
At one point running wireshark and reviewing network traces with developers was a full time job. Guess what percentage of time it was actually a network problem?
johngalt··on Ask HN: Software engineers who have been promoted with a large salary increase?
It's not anything nefarious, just the natural blind spots of human reasoning.

Titles are cheap. Your existing employer will always want to hand you more work, but not more money. If you are handling the work well, then the pain of not having that role filled is only a memory. Your future employer has an acute problem to solve and is already primed to spend money to solve it. The net result is that (current employer) is much more likely to increase your responsibilities/scope/title. While (future employer) will pay you.

There are absolutely employers who will give significant raises to existing employees, but they are rare.

johngalt··on Ask HN: Managing career progression for those with no interest in progressing?
Some are happy where they are, but most are stuck in a rut. There is a natural tendency to just "keep doing what you are doing", and many people don't have long term plans.

For example, how many people sit down and decide to become overweight and out of shape? Yet many of us arrive there by default. It is a similar process playing out in employment. Why many people avoid learning and growing. Not that they decided to atrophy, but more that they haven't tried to avoid it.

It's difficult to produce change in others, or to get them to see the rut. If you are self motivated, it's like speaking a different language. We expect the desire to improve to be intrinsic, and that if they have the desire that they will act in a way to produce results. But both are false assumptions. There are those with no intrinsic desire, and those who have the desire, but not the habits/discipline to take effective action.

My best results has been to push them down the path. Set the goals and routines for them. Get them moving fast enough that learning/growing in a specific area becomes part of the routine.

johngalt··on How to prevent email spoofing, using an unholy combination of silly standards
SPF = This list of servers are authorized to send email for my domain.

DKIM = This specific email can by verified/authenticated by my DNS.

DMARC = What to do with email that doesn't comply with above. And how to tell me about it (if you want to).

SPF is basically useless due to the centralization of email providers. It was created to be locked to a company specific email server. E.g. Only accept mail from exchangeserver.company.com, and reject everything not from that server. Now everyone authorizes Microsoft or Google to send their mail.

johngalt··on Starlink dishes go into “thermal shutdown” once they hit 122° Fahrenheit
It is counterintuitive but A/C in general has a much smaller footprint than heating.
johngalt··on 7-11 is opening 500 EV charging stations by the end of 2022
It's a different scenario. Charging vs fueling has different constraints, and a facility designed for one is not necessarily designed for the other.

Probably more effective for some restaurant franchise to add EV charging as part of their branded setup. E.g. Every IHOP in the country has EV charging.

johngalt··on Court: ‘ghost gun’ plans can be posted online without State Department approval
> Do you think you could pass an amendment expanding the second amendment had the court ruled more narrowly on it?

Depends on how narrowly. Overall I would consider an amendment strengthening the 2A more likely than removing the 2A.

There are relatively few states with strict gun laws and more constitutional carry states every year.

johngalt··on Ask HN: How would you store 10PB of data for your startup today?
900 LTO-U8 tapes
johngalt··on In Stockholm there's currently an IT battle underway
It's amazing how often giant IT projects like these go off the rails. Exploding costs and garbage implementations. If you start the sentence with: "A 5+ year government IT project that cost over 100 million-" I already know how the story ends.

How do we improve this common scenario? What are the root causes?

The common themes are:

1. Lack of technical project competence at the decision maker level.

2. Scope creep. Where the one true system has to do everything.

3. A 'one-pass' approach where everything is expected to be delivered as a working system at the end of the project.

Even fixing two of these gives us a solid shot at a successful project.

johngalt··on Female Founder Secrets: Fertility
This may not mean much from some stranger on the internet, but I'm sorry that this happened to you. I wish you well.
johngalt··on Fossil fuel cars make 'hundreds of times' more waste than electric cars
Not exactly a fair comparison as it doesn't appear to be counting the generation of the electricity for the EV.

However, EV's still win by a large margin. It's a lot easier to make one big powerplant clean, efficient, and cost effective rather than a million little engines that have to make tradeoffs for weight/size/performance etc...

johngalt··on Software Development Outsourcing: Our Story
Summary: "we failed on outsourcing so many times that the costs exceeded any possible cost savings, even taking into account future projections."

Imagine how much it cost them to build up and tear down development teams six times. Not just in real costs of contracts and such, but also the logistical costs of training the new teams, building the relationships, finding faults, correcting errors, determining alternatives, knowledge transfers, etc... Not to mention opportunity costs of all the time spent.

Effective outsourcing is paying AWS/GCP or Heroku for whatever they can provide. Not trying to turn an expensive employee into a cheap one.

johngalt··on When costs are nonlinear, keep it small
The problem isn't that people make the wrong decisions about batch sizes or failure tolerance, but that they don't make a decision at all. The default state is a blind push towards both more changes and less pain. Not acknowledging that a tradeoff exists.
johngalt··on Will the US experience a violent upheaval in 2020? (2012)
> Is this a joke?

Yes. The person I was replying to seemed to assume that college was where people are disabused of idealism. My response was satirical.

johngalt··on Will the US experience a violent upheaval in 2020? (2012)
"education, it shifts people to the left, as analytical thinking starts undoing idealism."

True; college students are noted for their lack of idealism.

Conversely right leaning occupations such as veterans, oil rig workers and farmers always have their head in the clouds with high minded idealistic notions that don't work in the real world.

johngalt··on Ask HN: Got promoted with a near zero increase. Time to leave?
Generally you want to negotiate compensation as part of accepting the new promotion/title. Not as part of the normal review process.

If they won't budge on compensation, accept the title and add it to your resume. Start looking for better offers. If you find a better offer, then they were wrong about market rates.

johngalt··on A ‘Jobs to be Done’ Framework for Startups
Paraphrasing:

"People don't want a drill, they want the hole"

Talk to your intended audience to figure out what they want to accomplish, not just the tools they ask for.

This is a useful way of looking at things. Yet, there is a limited distance we can expect the audience to traverse before using what they are familiar with. The number of fax machines in existence shows the staying power of habits.

As a startup, look at the decison/control points specific to the 'job to be done'. This is a game of revealed preferences and principle-agent problems.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →