HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

johnzabroski

148 karma · joined November 18, 2008

Founder @ Simmaculate - bespoke software start-up, Christian, Hockey fan
submissionscomments
johnzabroski··on On the Engineering of SaaS
Upvoted, but the author cites his own book in his blog post, which I read. I would just have to say, stay away from that book. It is vacuous. It gave a few decent recommendations, but the title was misleading and it was very verbose.

I remember telling Theo's brother my review at an NYPHP post-meeting bar gathering. The look on his face was classic. Like he tasted bitter beer.

johnzabroski··on Google rolls out algorithm change in the US
Fixing their billing procedures and optimizing their price list for services. This is pretty tricky stuff and easy to get wrong, because there are many factors that influence how hospitals get paid, such as stoploss rules, carve outs, worker's compensation groupers, various mother-baby rules, etc.

Often times hospitals receive $0 for something they should be getting $10 million per year for, just because nobody ever contests the NOPAY response. Finding that sort of error isn't easy.

johnzabroski··on Google rolls out algorithm change in the US
There is a thing in HCI called the End-User Model Fallacy, where engineers try to create an interface based on a prototypical end-user, and then the real end-user spends time trying to figure out how they think the interface works, and it becomes a vicious cycle where the engineers think they are improving the interface, but in reality are just causing the real end-users to come up with a new model of the interface that they can use to get their work done.

This Fallacy was first described to me in Brenda Laurel's Computers as Theatre. http://c2.com/cgi/wiki?BrendaLaurel

johnzabroski··on Google rolls out algorithm change in the US
For a lot of professional needs, the most valuable information is hidden in the deep web. For example, many MIS/DSS/ERP/CRM/TLA systems don't provide a lot of public information about how their systems work, so if you are trying to evaluate the market place, it would probably take you 3-6 months of research.

For example, I work at a healthcare services start-up, and we have one person full-time researching our competitors and figuring out how to differentiate us in the marketplace, as well as figure out what keywords someone might search for to find this kind of product. We're mainly mathematicians and smart programmers who found a way to break into the market initially, not marketers, so our terminology doesn't match domain experts well.

Anecdotally, I think most users are VERY bad at ranking how valuable information is. For example, we'll get paid $100,000/year for something that takes 1 week and provides zero insight into their business, and then they will refuse to pay us at all for something that makes them $30,000,000 a year! This is so common that I am wondering if its more a symptom of human nature than our customers.

johnzabroski··on My Company Is Using OCaml for web development. Why?
> Actually, you have allocated most of your comment for advertising your blog…

Sorry if it came across that way. I really don't check who reads my blog, there is no comment mechanism, and I do not like linking it anywhere except to friends. Even then, I prefer they not read it directly. My blog is mainly a personal thought dump and collection of links.

johnzabroski··on My Company Is Using OCaml for web development. Why?
You were agreeing that we full circle with from ODBC to REST. I am saying you don't seem to have understood the commenter's sarcasm.
johnzabroski··on On Writing Books for Programmers
I prefer books that are highly rated on Amazon.com. I generally don't care how long they are. I mainly ask myself,

Am I the right audience for this book?

If I am not the right audience, can I gain a new perspective by reading this book?

Who is recommending I read this book?

Am I buying this book just because I lack expertise in an area? If so, why am I not asking an expert what book to read and what to look for in a good book? See, for example, Victor A. Wagner Jr's guide to reading C++ books: http://www.rudbek.com/books.html On IRC chat, Victor usually repeats the advice in Peter Norvig's essay Teach Yourself Programming in 10 Years

If I am reading Lambda the Ultimate, and somebody with seniority on that site (e.g. Allan McInnes) says read Franklyn Turbak's book on programming languages, then I generally follow that advice. Smart people tend not to read nor recommend crap.

johnzabroski··on My Company Is Using OCaml for web development. Why?
If by 'REST+DOM/JS' you mean "Random Bad, Hodge-Podge Code Filled with Callbacks and pervasive use of global variables", then yes, bad programming will always have a place - for PHP programmers.

Most really awesome apps being written these days, that use HTML, are using the CANVAS tag and doing stuff like building terrain maps of buildings and showing people holding 4.5" smart phones where in the building druglords are. Crazy stuff like that.

johnzabroski··on My Company Is Using OCaml for web development. Why?
Do you know what ODBC is, and why most smart programmers dislike it and try to stomp out its stupidity?

The model for writing drivers, and plugging in drivers, in ODBC, is R. E. T. A. R. D. E. D.

Edit: I forgot to mention that using the drivers suck, too. The ODBC transaction interface is basically RPC, and is becoming out-moded with recent language research on remote batch execution.

Usually, you have a custom transport protocol for client/server, like the Microsoft SQL Server Tabular Data Stream protocol. It is ultimately not very extensible. Imagine something like LINQ today. Would be nice to just send that expression tree to SQL Server, and not have a client-side or middle-tier ORM tool have to transform the tree into SQL.

johnzabroski··on My Company Is Using OCaml for web development. Why?
RE: You don't have to lay out your GUI's with a markup language designed for typography - The modern VT100.

Are you referring to HTML and CSS?

RE: You don't have to keep state with a stateless protocol.

You are referring to HTTP.

RE: Now you get a nice (mostly) standardized interface and you get to build a lighting fast native GUI for your app.

What are you referring to?

johnzabroski··on My Company Is Using OCaml for web development. Why?
Your view of how to solve problems seems very programmer-oriented and not business-oriented.

Stuff like how to process a REST request is simply details. I don't understand why you are focusing so much on this aspect, but I have seen this anti-pattern so often that it repulses me; most examples of RESTful APIs are bullshit, written by people who did not take the time to actually understand REST principles. A good example I documented on my blog is how awful and stupid the ThreeSharp Amazon S3 library is for C#. And writing it in the same style in F# would be just as ugly and stupid! I also discuss why it is a joke that S3 itself is called a REST API, and point out how the language examples in Amazon's documentation is COMPLETELY inconsistent from language to language -- there is no correctness-preservation across language implementations!!!

Incidentally, when people say "web development", they can mean many things, with True REST being just one of them. Most people are actually referring to corporate intranet applications, such as data entry forms and stock analysis tools that chart trends, provide real-time data feeds, etc.

johnzabroski··on .NET Reflector no longer a free tool - An open letter to the .NET community
Thank you very much for that tidbit.
johnzabroski··on .NET Reflector no longer a free tool - An open letter to the .NET community
There are some outstanding open source .NET libraries that blow away what you can get in Java. Likewise, some COTS .NET libraries blow away equivalent Java libraries (e.g., for unit testing and inversion of control, query-driven source code analysis, etc.).

But comparing .NET to anything other than Mono is apples to oranges.

johnzabroski··on .NET Reflector no longer a free tool - An open letter to the .NET community
I didn't know that. Thanks for the info about the debugging support. I guess I have to give them credit for that.
johnzabroski··on .NET Reflector no longer a free tool - An open letter to the .NET community
I'm very familiar with engineering compilers and de-compilers. Have you seen Microsoft Phoenix? It lets you sink/hoist intermediate representations; the key for this would be having an API that allows ordering graph rewriting rules so that you can take the MSIL and convert it the right higher-level form (e.g., should this use LINQ? Well, what does the app settings say the user wants to see the code as?). Anyway, since Reflector is written in C#, it would be able to develop a clone much faster using code generation, since I bet Reflector uses a ton of Visitor patterns and needless C# boilerplate.

I won't promise performance comparable to Redgate's Reflector, but my rule of thumb is Correct. Clear. Fast. In that order.

johnzabroski··on .NET Reflector no longer a free tool - An open letter to the .NET community
The ripoff is in the fact that they have added nothing significant to the product other than making it more difficult for people to obtain.
johnzabroski··on .NET Reflector no longer a free tool - An open letter to the .NET community
I could be interested in building a Reflector clone if somebody would write an F# plug-in to the project. I would probably start with looking at the CCI-Metadata project on Codeplex, and the Microsoft Phoenix compiler framework. Mono has similar libraries, but I only know a very small subset of Mono.Cecil API.

Cheers, Z-Bo

johnzabroski··on Yacc is dead
Vladimir Safonov's Trustworthy Compilers is another good reference on this subject, in addition to the books already mentioned here on HN. Safonov works through some examples of real-world languages, and argues why hand-written parsers are superior to Yacc-style parser generators. He gives examples of ALGOL-68 and FORTRAN.

I don't know of any definitive text that covers a wide range of practical examples that I've been totally satisfied with, though. Even Safonov waives his hand a little, saying the parser is the one part of the compiler to be written by the most experienced and best compiler engineer on the team, because it influences the performance of everything after.

johnzabroski··on Wrong scientific beliefs that were held for long periods
U.S. primary and secondary schools do not accept the constructivist school as dogma. Perhaps you have simply misunderstood the differences he was stressing.

For more information on this, you should probably look at what Seymour Papert has been doing in Maine lately.

johnzabroski··on The things make got right (and how to make it better)
Who said anything about new build systems?

All the build systems he was thinking of are not even worth criticizing, including make.

Check out Vesta, created about 25 years ago...

make is a complete mess. Trying to put lipstick on it and dress it in a champagne gown doesn't change the fact you got stuck with the ugly girl for the prom.

johnzabroski··on The things make got right (and how to make it better)
You're not comparing it to the state-of-the-art, which, ahem, was developed over 20 years ago: Vesta.

Your ideas on how to make it better seem produced by having your head down typing away at the monitor, rather than seeing the big picture.

Read a visionary system like Vesta. Then re-write this article, and forget about Make.

johnzabroski··on The things make got right (and how to make it better)
You're aware that the author of this article is the author of a book titled GNU Make Unleashed, right?

Who is swalling the snake oil?

johnzabroski··on Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps
You need a more complete history of Microsoft to know the full story.

Back in the early DirectX days (1996), Microsoft was working on a technology called Chrome Effects that was intended to compete with VRML as the world's ultimate "Networkable Graphics" format. This history is covered in books such as <em>Renegades of the Empire</em>. This was stuff from back when Michael Abrash worked at Microsoft!

johnzabroski··on Address Validation Using the Google Maps API: A better way to enter addresses?
I made some comments on the user's blog entry.

For our company, we would have loved to use Google for all our web API needs for addresses, but we can't, due to corporate firewall restrictions and the map display restriction mentioned by a reader's comment on that blog entry. Also, don't mistake this for true address validation, which is expensive.

johnzabroski··on Facebook is not worth $33 billion
Correct!
johnzabroski··on Facebook is not worth $33 billion
Joe Walton wrote a book about it.
johnzabroski··on James Gosling: Why I Quit Oracle
You may be interested in taking the Mansion's Tour. Stop by the Visitor Center. It costs $20 but you get to ride a energy-efficient Charlie Car. If you get the right tour guide, he will point out to you Larry's house on the tour.

For good food at reasonable prices, try The Barking Crab.

johnzabroski··on James Gosling: Why I Quit Oracle
Correct.

Larry also owns a beach house in the mansions area of Newport, Rhode Island, aka sailing capital of the world (the main street connecting to the dwarfs is called America's Cup Avenue).

johnzabroski··on Stylebot for Chrome: Web Developer Toolbar meets Greasemonkey
I posted a comment on the "Open Source" Google blog that was apparently not approved (when I posted, there was 0 comments, and now there are 4 comments, none of them mine). See: http://google-opensource.blogspot.com/2010/09/changing-look-...

I pointed out that there is nothing innovative about Stylebot. This idea has existed for years under the name SiteMesh. The difference is where in the software pipeline you are putting the SiteMesh/Stylebot logic. SiteMesh is actually more general, in that it is not tied to Chrome.

I don't understand why my comment was moderated out. It was not offensive, just pointing out the fact that there is no innovation here.

johnzabroski··on Evercookie: A cookie that undeletes itself from 8 different storages
so who wants to team up and create a _N_evercookie plug-in for browsers.
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →