HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jonahbenton

3,346 karma · joined February 17, 2018

Senior super consultant. jonah@jonah.com and jonah@indata.dev.
submissionscomments
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Is the next big thing locally running coding agents?
There are many markets. Qwen 3.6 27b at a high enough quant is good enough for many use cases. But enterprise-consumed tokens come with legal/data protection agreements. They have just gotten comfortable with BYOD- there is no BYOD equivalent set of practices and protections for local LLMs (BYOLLM). So some enterprises are getting back into prem GPU capacity.
jonahbenton··on Sam Altman makes 'mic drop' offer to every Y Combinator startup
The desperation is strong in this one
jonahbenton··on Declining America
No, not this story.

This story is that of Netflix' Chaos Monkey attacking the state most rhetorically aligned/proud of The Rule Of Law and showing in myriad ways how absolutely hollow that pride was and how vulnerable The Law is.

Are these bugs that get fixed or...if that was The Last Election, maybe not.

jonahbenton··on Declining America
Can't believe this is flagged. As a USer, it is the letter I would advise anyone outside the US to write. It is the only rational response.

THIS IS NOT A PLACE OF HONOR.

jonahbenton··on A Private Way to Chat with AI
Meta making claims like "private" and "even Meta can't see." lol. Has the credibility debt of an org around a specific issue ever been higher? It's like a goldfish trying to gaslight.
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Would you tell your kids to learn to code?
For sure, the same way that agentic abilities to read and write don't obviate devoting human cognitive attention to those skills, in fact, as study after study show, the cognitive offloading/debt incurred by over reliance on agentic cognitive processing is as bad for the brain as sedentary lifestyle is for the body. Programming is yet again different cognitive work than human language reading/writing- the sequential/logical precision and the abstraction creation AND the interactive functionality are unique and valuable. Use of prompt-> code techniques for code or asset authoring AND use of LLMs to provide non-deterministic interactive elements widen the creative landscape. They have to be properly scaffolded, of course, to require requisite cognitive input to get useful output- giving people cannons they can light with a match is wrong and inhumane. But within those to-be-developed regulatory guardrails, the activity of interactive system creation including stroke by stroke visual creation and line by line code creation is still super cool, fun, and useful for kids to experience.

Also I don't see professional software becoming "black-boxed" the way compiler produced machine language is or the way ML models are. Certain isolated components whose characteristics and behaviors can be sufficiently and more efficiently specified and verified with human language sources will be black boxes but in many circumstances the code is the most efficient and precise and correct rendition and that will be the material in which human work occurs. Cheers.

jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Cryptic refusals of credit cards with Firefox?
My kid's soccer platform just (like in the last week) adopted a captcha for even public facing pages and it fails miserably on Firefox (Fedora). So pointless and frustrating. I have not dug into what captcha platform they are using.
jonahbenton··on Ask HN:Do people configure Claude Code to use other models
It can be done- both to use local models and/or cheaper cloud models- but IME it does not work very well. CC really needs the Anthropic model special sauce. A point of surprise here is we also run CC against Bedrock hosted Anthropic models and that works reasonably well even though there is a bunch of other server side functionality CC uses when using an Anthropic subscription.
jonahbenton··on Cooked
Good to compare this take with Daring Fireball. His lens is that Tim was a company man who did what was good for the narrow and focused interests of Apple the institution, which he unequivocally was exceptionally successful at. This piece is from the lens that Apple exists to serve the wider disparate and unfocused preferences of its users...the legacy of Jobs is that people think this is the case, but it is not. (I can't stand Apple gear, hardware or software. It is far too opinionated and narrowly designed for me, it makes me angry.)
jonahbenton··on Southern Poverty Law Center indicted for fraud, money laundering
Read the lawdork piece. And read the 990s from the organizations to see where the money goes.

It pays not to be bamboozled by bad faith actors like Todd Blanche.

jonahbenton··on Southern Poverty Law Center indicted for fraud, money laundering
Todd Blanche, Trump's personal lawyer, digs the DoJ deeper into irreversible reputational debt.
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: How did you land your first projects as a solo engineer/consultant?
Network, relationships, people you know.
jonahbenton··on The FCC just saved Netgear from its router ban for no obvious reason
Why is TP Link still being sold.
jonahbenton··on Chimpanzees in Uganda locked in eight-year 'civil war', say researchers
Am reading Sapiens now, missed it the first time around. Incredible book. The point it makes isn't the killing among chimps being surprising. It is not relative non killing among humans- current day events notwithstanding. Contra the BBC, various human storytelling manifestations- religion/culture/etc- make large scale coordinated peaceful actions possible.
jonahbenton··on An open letter to 21 people I know who died
Amazing piece, and she is a tremendous writer. Thank you for the submission.
jonahbenton··on 25th Amendment – A Viral Politics Game
The game treats all moves as single player. In practice all actions of this kind are coalition oriented.
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Will AI be the end of new programming languages?
I was thinking about this the other way- new languages will always be designed by humans or human/ai collaboration but the task of a certain kind of viability will involve producing sufficient useful training material- and this when humans are intended to be able to also read the code strikes as being a new kind of gate, as such material will have to be automatically produced which may involve arriving at algorithmic definitions of fuzzy human syntactic concepts that refer to taste and readability. Super interesting design problem.
jonahbenton··on No One at Waffle House Remembers FEMA Official Who Says He Teleported In
NYT needs to learn to not invest resources to verify "bullshit"- statements emitted by people who don't care about truth. The verification that something obviously false is false is a waste and doesn't penalize the bullshitter. Instead it wastes scarce truth-concerned resources, normalizes the value of bullshit, and validates the "flood the zone" media strategy. NYT has been failing at this asymmetric information war- that culminated in Trump's elections- for more than 20 years. It is time to do something different.
jonahbenton··on The loneliness of A Room of One’s Own
The title is clickbait, unfortunately.
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Identity preservation vs. information transfer in LLMs
Fair to say there is no consensus on what experience and consciousness and so forth are but it is clear that Claude does not have those things. It is a word calculator. The word calculation is sophisticated and can simulate the verbal reporting of experiential conscious beings but it does not actually have those things itself.

Said another way it is very likely that non verbal symbolic language having creatures have experience and consciousness and Claude is definitely not one of those. Its "experience" is just the calculations across word sequences within a given set of conversations.

There is a long history of writing in this space and it is interesting that these models are not really anticipated by that literature. So the line between simulation via word calculation and reporting via verbal capacity is not well understood. And the human ability to discern simulation via only a word/conversation channel is limited.

So to answer your question, a Claude could easily be constructed to fool you into infusing it with continuity of self. But being fooled by a grift is not the same.

jonahbenton··on Our Agreement with the Department of War
Rule of law. The Dept of War is not the legal name. He can eff off.
jonahbenton··on If agents become the users, what happens to the software market?
Yes. Reputation and eval layers on top of MCP.
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Chromebook leads for K-8 school in need?
Your PTA is the fastest way.
jonahbenton··on LLM-written short story about being a LLM
So totally uninteresting. There is no "being a _" experience when "you" are a word calculator. Thinking that there is or that there is something useful there is a category error.
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Info on the 1982 Apple 2 text game Abuse?
Might be here:

https://mirrors.apple2.org.za/ftp.apple.asimov.net/images/ga...

Search for Abuse.dsk.

jonahbenton··on [dead]
"sagging disapproval" is an idiotic incorrect double negative.
jonahbenton··on Back in power 5 years later, Trump has all but erased the stain of Jan. 6
He has not, and it isn't the right framing. In this telling he has also "erased the stain" on many crimes. We will see how long that whitewashing lasts.
jonahbenton··on I Stop Prompting and Start Logging: The Design-Log Methodology
These are ADRs
jonahbenton··on Why Are 50k New York City Apartments Vacant?
The fact is a fact, their diagnosis and narrative is fantasy. A fair number of the stabilized empty apartments are due to the specific points in the 2019 law that too greatly impacted the economics of stabilized apartments. Prior to the 2019 law, it was economic to operate stabilized units, but too easy to unstabilize them, hence the motivation for the law. Replacing those dynamics with section 8 is idiocy.
jonahbenton··on Big GPUs don't need big PCs
So glad someone did this. Have been running big gpus on egpus connected to spare laptops and thinking why not pis.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →