HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jonahbenton

3,346 karma · joined February 17, 2018

Senior super consultant. jonah@jonah.com and jonah@indata.dev.
submissionscomments
jonahbenton··on Why Are 50k New York City Apartments Vacant?
City Journal is a right wing rag whose opinions represent propaganda. There is one correct point that the 2019 law eliminating rent increases tied to capital improvements is broken. But its other points are simply not correct. Vouchers are not a like for like replacement for stabilization. Like work and other gates applied to SNAP and similar programs, they are fundamentally broken and inhumane.
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: How are you building your MCP servers?
Yes, MCP has to be LLM friendly. APIs are data-oriented (what used to be called machine readable). MCP is narrative/human language oriented.
jonahbenton··on Kennedy Center to Be Renamed Trump-Kennedy Center, White House Says
Has as much effect as

"Trump to be locked in the pillory for mocking and pelting" citizens say

jonahbenton··on My contribution to the idea that we lived in a simulation
It doesn't matter what the idea or narrative or hypothesis is. How do you test the hypothesis.
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: How would you monetize an AI book-writing app?
To a first approximation, yes. You are young and don't have perspective on this, but this is what old people do. Recognize the value of stories and try to preserve them.
jonahbenton··on Skills for organizations, partners, the ecosystem
It isn't between llm and skill, it's between agent and skill. Orgs that invest in skills will duplicate what they could do once in an agent. Orgs that "buy" skills from a provider will need to endlessly tweak them. Multiskill workflows will have semantic layer mismatches.

Skill is a great sleight of hand for Anthropic to get people to think Claude Code is a platform. There is no there there. Orgs will figure this out.

Cheers.

jonahbenton··on Ask HN: How would you monetize an AI book-writing app?
Uh, irrelevant to highlight sqlite and "local first" if it assumes talking to gemini. The data does not stay on the machine. Support llama.cpp, etc.

I do like the idea of a home made book workflow but no one needs a new bookstore. There are plenty of these.

I think a related area is incorporating tts for interviews esp of older family members. Support photos and audio and have some ai magic around those. Produce a family member history. That is a pdf or richer media artifact, and does not go into any bookstore. Absolutely needs local ai in that case too.

I would pay $50 for an oss fully local authoring tool (and I do pay for others like zettlr).

jonahbenton··on Skills for organizations, partners, the ecosystem
To my eyes skills disappear, MCP and agent definitions do not.

You can have the most capable human available to you, a supreme executive assistant. You still have to convey your intent and needs to them, your preferences, etc, with as high a degree of specificity as necessary.

And you need to provide them with access and mechanisms to do things on your behalf.

Agentic definitions are the former, and they will evolve and grow. I like the metaphor of deal terms in financial contracts- benchmarkers document billions of these now. The "deal terms" governing the work any given entity does for you will be rich and bespoke and specific, like any valuable relationship. Even if the agent is learning about you, your governance is still needed.

MCP is the latter. It is the protocol by which a thing does things for you. It will get extensions. Skill-like directives and instructions will get delivered over it.

Skills themselves are near term scaffold that will soon disappear.

jonahbenton··on US gov't launches 'Tech Force' to replace IT staff DOGE fired
Saying it was both diminishes the sociopathy and malevolence. It was a warlike invasion, an act of great violence, and the perpetrators should be treated as criminals.
jonahbenton··on The AI-Native Software Development Lifecycle: Theoretical/ Practical Methodology
(2024)
jonahbenton··on We lost Uber as a user – PostgreSQL mailing list
(2016)
jonahbenton··on 7-Eleven to Pay Record $4.5M Penalty for FTC Antitrust Order Violation Case
Someone at 7-11 didn't make a payment to the Trump family.
jonahbenton··on Amp, Inc. – Amp is spinning out of Sourcegraph
I think "prompts" are a much richer kind of intellectual property than they are given credit for. Will put in here a pointer to the Odd Lots recent podcast with Noetica AI- a give to get M&A/complex debt/deal terms benchmarker. Noetica CEO said they now have over 1 billion "deal terms" in their database, which is only half a dozen years old. Growing constantly. Over 1 billion different legal points on which a complex financial contract might be structured. Even more than that, the representation of terms in contracts they see can change pretty dramatically quarter to quarter. The industry learns and changes.

The same thing is going to happen with all of the human language artifacts present in the agentic coding universe. Role definitions, skills, agentic loop prompts....the specific language, choice of words, sequence, etc really matters and will continue to evolve really rapidly, and there will be benchmarkers, I am sure of it, because quite a lot of orgs will consider their prompt artifacts to be IP.

I have personally found that a very high precision prompt will mean a smaller model on personal hardware will outperform a lazy prompt given to a foundation model. These word calculators are very very (very) sensitive. There will be gradations of quality among those who drive them best.

The best law firms are the best because they hire the best with (legal) language and are able to retain the reputation and pricing of the best. That is the moat. Same will be the case here.

jonahbenton··on The era of jobs is ending
Yeah, jobs suck, and AI can do all kinds of things, but this really misunderstands...just about everything.

Pluribus is a more interesting meditation.

jonahbenton··on Kids who ran away to 1960s San Francisco
Same. Never lived there- though almost moved in the 1990s- and now feel a pull to learn/feel the history. Did also just finish Grant's memoirs- and would strongly recommend Sherman's if you haven't read those, not only for the SF parts. Some of his letters are incredible and dare I say relevant today.
jonahbenton··on The Role of Diet on the Gut Microbiome, Mood and Happiness
Uh

"We found strong correlations between greater consumption of fat and protein to lower anxiety and depression, while consuming higher percentages of carbohydrates was associated with increased stress, anxiety, and depression"

and

"We have shown that changing diet affects mood and happiness, that greater fat and carbohydrate intake is directly associated with anxiety and depression"

I am sure it is a fine paper and it is a preprint but a direct inconsistency in the abstract...

jonahbenton··on From stadiums to cyberspace: How the metaverse will redefine sports fandom
2021 called, wants its headline back
jonahbenton··on Canonical's plan to make 2026 the year of Linux on the desktop
Good stuff. Fedora's year of the desktop was 2025 lol
jonahbenton··on Show HN: Jeffrey Epstein's Inbox
Brilliant idea but many rendering and functionality problems, especially on mobile. Pls fix!
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Have I found a bug in the debit card network?
Traditionally under ACH I don't believe balance inquiry is available. But if you did a Plaid like thing to "connect" your card, your balance is available to payees.

https://docs.stripe.com/payments/ach-direct-debit/accept-a-p...

jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Have I found a bug in the debit card network?
Your orthodontist is probably using an ass (term of art) specialized medical practice billing system. Not uncommon for smaller practices. Some of these are made by the dude down the block, kind of thing. Total shit. That will be the thing that is issuing the debit. It might be querying for the balance beforehand. The thing to do is find out what ass billing system they are using, might be associated with their ass practice management system, and then talk to those people. It might be stripe under the hood but stripe is not making this mistake.
jonahbenton··on Crypto got everything it wanted. Now it's sinking
Sinking in value. Expanding nearly exponentially in breadth and depth of financial system integration.
jonahbenton··on Presidential executive order would ban all state AI regulation
Doubly incorrect. There is no power by which the executive can "ban" any state action. Is not a thing. But that isn't what the piece says. The EO would set up a "task force" to sue states that did X or Y. That is something that happens, and when the theories are at the level of quality this admin produces, those suits fail.
jonahbenton··on [dead]
There are many thousands of amazon people (still) in NYC.

MSN going NYPost with the fanciful headlines.

jonahbenton··on SpaceX and Musk called on to rescue China's Shenzhou-20 crew
Deceptive- clearly not called on by China.
jonahbenton··on The Department of War just shot the accountants and opted for speed
Given the pervasiveness of bribery across this admin, this smells like just eliminating the obstacles to a more direct and corrupt patronage and kickback system. Steve Blank might be wishing it will be LEAN when in reality it will be GREEN.
jonahbenton··on Tech and evolution are incompatible: generalization ensures niches take-over
Communication precision has been enriched and deepened, not generalized. Social media has not in any way collapsed. AI hallucination is not a semantics issue.
jonahbenton··on Addiction Markets
For one, alcohol tax is applied at point of sale, so there is a friction on consumption. Gambling taxes are applied as though gambling is an investment activity and losses can even be justified. Second, most recent studies that look at the question classify gambling as more dangerous and addictive. There is much more of a path from gambling to suicide.
jonahbenton··on How much equity to give late cofounder?
I would look at it like this, as 2 entities. There was an entity that developed this IP, this algorithm. You own 100% of that entity and the IP. If you go in with this guy, there is a new entity. You two need to do slicing pie with the new entity- arrogant smart people have a way of not putting in the work, so you need a mechanism that will accumulate equity by effort. Probably your hours are equally weighted in that accumulation. And then you need to value the contribution of the algorithm/IP to the new entity. There are ways of valuing that contribution. It could be valued as equity, or it could be a license (so there is an income agreement). If equity, maybe it is 50% of the new entity, maybe it is 25%, maybe it is 75%. It really depends on a rational valuation of that algorithm in the context of the competitive space. My honest opinion, I use parking apps, your particular innovation (no disrespect, it is an achievement, for sure) is not a game changer to me, so I would put it at 25%, but I don't know really how to structure the value of the space. But you should have an analytical opinion (not based on your hours you put in, based on how the algorithm changes the dynamics) about the importance of the algorithm to the proposition the new business has, relative to the work the two of you would do together, which should use an accumulation mechanism for allocation.
jonahbenton··on Addiction Markets
I read the Omelas story differently but maybe is the same. It's just a predatory dominance play. Some people get the dopamine hit from dominance, so for them it is a double win- their stuff is funded by others and it is the "weakness" of others (perceived by the dominant) that produces the funding. Having and eating the cake, etc.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →