HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jonahbenton

3,346 karma · joined February 17, 2018

Senior super consultant. jonah@jonah.com and jonah@indata.dev.
submissionscomments
jonahbenton··on Addiction Markets
Taxing the dopamine thing does not discourage the doing of the dopamine thing. Just penalizes the addict and worsens their position.
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: What Value Do Programmers Have If AI Allows Everyone to Write Code?
This is not an ask, it is a post.
jonahbenton··on Pentagon accepts $130M donation to help pay the military during shutdown
Public school parents can't even make donations that contribute to teacher salaries.

So completely unacceptable.

jonahbenton··on Beyond the for You Page: Uncovering Algorithmic Bias in New York's Mayoral Race
Zero credibility.
jonahbenton··on TikTok's algorithm systematically boosts pro-Mamdani and anti-Cuomo content
Lots of assertions. No data. Ho hum.
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Is a POSIX like interface for cloud infra a bad idea?
The answer is probably a high level LLM supported agentic spec driven development workflow. A low level version of this can kind of be accomplished interactively with the cloud specific MCPs- noting that each major infra component has its own MCP exposing the complete API surface of that component. The prompts that could drive component interrogation (to get current state, which would no longer live in a TF state file in S3) and then would drive updates and changes would themselves need to be generated, hence the higher level agentic function. Driving the agentic prompt gen would be a spec driven workflow. You would maintain the natural language spec and would conversationally arrive at spec updates that would lead to proposed infra changes for approval.
jonahbenton··on How to find trustworthy news reporting in these times?
Almost entirely useless piece. Most of these heuristics were only true 10 years ago, no longer.

Sure, some individuals are trustworthy, that's always the case. But an individual is fundamentally an opinion.

The answer for systemic reporting is international press.

jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Can AI Coding redefine how enterprises approach digital transformation?
Have no doubt many will go down the road of vibe coding key workflows. This will work for some, for others it will be no different than other tech debt. SAAS however by definition is a tremendously complicated machine. Attempting to convey the maintainable semantics across multiple CLAUDE.mds is just not going to be a good time.
jonahbenton··on MIT Response to the "Compact"
"Therefore, with respect, we cannot support the proposed approach to addressing the issues facing higher education."
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Did Twitter's 280-character limit improve discourse?
Discourse quality is 99.9999% a trust/safety/moderation policy and tooling outcome. Content can be problematic on any of dozens of dimensions (tone/energy/relevance down to actual criminal consequences) at any size. Whether conversations retain signal and communities develop and grow trust entirely depends on what decisions moderation does or does not make.

Did shorter content chunks simplify the moderation problem, in the context of an org that wanted to build communities? Absolutely. Does Twitter post Elon have completely (completely) different goals and values? Of course, yes, opposite end of the spectrum. What relative percentage of resources does Elon twitter devote to moderation? Maybe 1%. So is it obvious that conversations are going to be completely different and lower "quality"? Yes, yes it is. That is a goal.

jonahbenton··on Appointment of Bari Weiss confirms shift to the right of mainstream media
Really enjoy elpais coverage.
jonahbenton··on Virtual Sovereignty: Private Internet Capital and Infrastructural Power in U.S.
(2022)
jonahbenton··on US unveils design for $1 Trump coin to mark 250th independence
Now under control of a dictator!
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Why did COM/SOAP/other protocols fail?
They were trying to solve both enterprise integration and user app deployment. In another example of "worse is better", HTTP/REST (ish) for the former and browsers for the latter won. Just so much easier and good enough. That browsers and HTTP were the same "platform" of course helped. COM/DCOM/SOAP/CORBA and others were just way way too much work.

Relatedly, nobody really does REST as Roy F initially defined, which is now referred to as HATEOS. Also too much work.

If you haven't read the Worse is Better paper, definitely worth it. Top 5 all time.

jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Would you try a crossword that changes around your answers?
I used to like these in old magazines that would have multiple clue sets for the same puzzle layout. Try the hard one, then do the easy one. The mechanic in an interactive context strikes me as challenging. Is it just time? Is there a hint submechanic? Is there a points mechanic? Is there a difficulty labeling (like give me the Saturday version first, then switch to Wednesday). How much cognitive load to add to the game? I'm also a little skeptical that the (implied) llm generation of clues or hints could be implemented without frustration. It seems like an interesting idea to explore but many paths in that game design tree seem like they could be frustrating rather than fun.
jonahbenton··on Hypothetical thought: Open AI announces ads on ChatGPT, what happens next?
Inevitable. Ads is where the real money for eyeballs is, consumer side. Payola to slide in recommendations when user asks a question or is otherwise suggestable- how can they not take that money. Exact same experience and trajectory as ads in search and native ads in content only more so, more subtle.
jonahbenton··on Looking for a new job, but want to be picky
AIs can help with the initial searching but specialized domains have their own networks, of recruiters, relationships, processes. Places with high demand roles will see no purpose in being overwhelmed from open public postings. Space itself will have security requirements. In short this is a networking problem, not a googling problem.
jonahbenton··on Nvidia bets big on Intel with $5B stake and chip partnership
Bets big is overstating it. Pocket change for nvidia and a few percentage points of intel. A bit more than just issuing a press release but only a bit.
jonahbenton··on Trump designates anti-fascist Antifa movement as a terrorist organization
No, it's a joke.
jonahbenton··on Trump designates anti-fascist Antifa movement as a terrorist organization
Antifa is a meme, not an organization, you say.

And now you see: that is the point.

jonahbenton··on U.S. investors, Trump close in on TikTok deal with China
Useful additional context

https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/top-trump-ally-may-soon...

jonahbenton··on Secure_packager: A simple tool for distributing data/models securely
Good idea
jonahbenton··on Ask HN: Does anyone have any screenshots of fucked company?
Library of Congress links to a bunch of saves

https://www.loc.gov/item/lcwaN0020126/

for instance

https://webarchive.loc.gov/legacy/20020911074203/http://www....

jonahbenton··on Addison Fischer: Math genius in search for Satoshi
He is the right age. The other Satoshi candidates have seemed too young.

The case otherwise is less strong to my eyes than for some others but not meritless.

jonahbenton··on Global Atmospheric CO2 Lags Temperature by 150 yr [pdf]
Not a trustworthy publication. The piece itself is garbage.

https://svs.gsfc.nasa.gov/11362

jonahbenton··on Old timers, what did you read to study Unix or languages by the book?
Don Knuths AoCP

SICP, Abelson and Sussman

Stroustrup

Aho and Ullman compilers

A Commentary on the UNIX Operating System

GNU C Library

Michael Kerrisks books are newer but are exceptional

jonahbenton··on Poor man's bitemporal data system in SQLite and Clojure
We hermits enjoy its use in our lairs, worlds of pure thought.
jonahbenton··on SomaFM 25th Anniversary
Big congrats. Listener from the beginning
jonahbenton··on Show HN: A GPT-generated Bible-style trilogy – 10k reads
Couldn't care less about "scripture." Waste of everyone's time. What prompts did you use. What role did the model play.
jonahbenton··on AI Can Solve the Fiscal Crisis for Cities–If We Let It
City Journal is ordinarily not that smart but this one is particularly pointless. Most cities are property tax based. An analysis by income tax is going to not contribute anything useful to the conversation.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →