HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jordan_curve

167 karma · joined August 11, 2020

submissionscomments
jordan_curve··on Israel and UAE reach historic peace deal, Israel to suspend annexation
Your question seems to be

Plenty of Israelis would happily vote to trade some or all of those regions for stable alliances with their neighbors.

After the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin, that dream was never going to happen though.

Israelis largely care about national security. If you could assure them that giving up those regions would guarantee peace, you would win an election.

jordan_curve··on Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the problem: Giridharadas
How did we get the 13th amendment if not through the democratic process described in the constitution?

There’s some semantic argument here about whether there’s a causal relationship between democracy and legislation, but that’s missing the point.

Slavery in the U.S. was a democratic issue since its inception. Although Jefferson’s victory over the Federalists largely reframed the concerns of the voting populace away from slavery for most of the early 19th century, abolitionism eventually become an insurmountable movement. This movement had so much public support for and against it, that it grew into a civil war. I’m not sure how you can justify that it wasn’t democratic.

jordan_curve··on Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the problem: Giridharadas
I'd argue it was precisely the "democratic" part that allowed the United States to remove those practices.
jordan_curve··on Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the problem: Giridharadas
I don't think it's unreasonable to include more things under "basic necessities" nowadays. Things like security, education, healthcare, internet access are all common candidates.
jordan_curve··on Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the problem: Giridharadas
If by catnip, you mean fundamental concepts that are routinely not understood, then yes.
jordan_curve··on Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the problem: Giridharadas
I think you're focusing too much on the metaphor. The example the person above gave using LEDs is very good.

For the sake of simplicity, I'm just going to stick to the United States. As the previous commenter explained, the introduction of LEDs (along with cheap methods of manufacturing them) lead to much cheaper and more effective lighting. Undoubtedly there were companies and individuals that stood to profit quite a bit from these inventions. I don't know whether it helped create any billionaires, but certainly there are similar examples which have. On the other hand, although it created more wealth for those individuals, it created wealth for the entire country. Now every American has more money to spend because they don't have to spend as much money replacing their light bulbs.

In this case, the fact that some people gained much more wealth from this series of inventions is not a bad thing because everyone also benefited. In fact, the reason that inventions like this even come into existence is precisely because there is high reward for the individuals or companies doing so.

There are absolutely certain markets where things are much messier, but overall it's certainly not zero-sum. The issue is that many Americans do not have high enough wages or benefits to meet their family's needs. We should be working towards addressing poverty, not towards some moral tirade against billionaires.

Edit: I honestly can't express these concepts nearly as eloquently as xoa has in their comments, so I'd suggest referring to those.

← PreviousPage 3 of 3