816 karma · joined February 15, 2012
EPR (and more relevantly, Bohm's version of it involving spin entangled particles) showed that either one has hidden variables or nonlocality. Bell's work showed that local hidden variables is not possible. Hence, nonlocality is the conclusion and the argument to demonstrate the incompleteness of quantum mechanics falls apart.
The Many Worlds interpretations kind of gets away from this by exploiting another assumption in that work: that results from experiments actually happen in the sense that the other outcomes don't. Most people at the time would have just assumed that, but MW points out that experiments need not have definitive results, instead we have multiple results of experiments correlated with multiple versions of experimenters who think they have results. Thus, the correlations we see only need to be reconciled when the two groups of experimenters get together to compare notes, a perfectly local notion. Of course, some descriptions of MW, with branching of the universe, is rather nonlocal, but a proper formulation of MW is possible without any of that.
By the way, a key feature of Bohmian mechanics is the reliance on position as the "hidden variable". The spin of a particle is not an aspect of the particle itself, but rather of the wave function guiding the particle. In the spin experiments, the correlation with the environment once measurement has happened, separates the overlapping spin parts of the wave function and the particle is then being guided by that singular spin. Hence the appearance of the particle behaving as if it had that spin, but the particle is not actually spinning, whatever that would mean for a point particle.
Given how that debate is not even agreed upon, it is hard to believe that one could come to much of an understanding of the Festival and its need with humans.
1. Promote comments above code. So the syntax for comments is the default. A simple notion is a markdown file where the process to create the program is to concatenate all the code blocks in order of appearance. Everything else is irrelevant to the code generated, but relevant to the developer. The idea here is to just promote communication of the reasons why and basic philosophy that leads to the code. The what should largely be easily readable from well-written code, but the reason for this choice versus that choice is what the comments want.
2. Reorder code. So each code block has a name and can be inserted in other code blocks. Order is irrelevant. This allows one to have, say, conditional logic easily readable without the actual code in between being executed. Functions can serve this purpose too, but the advantage of this style is that one can see the woven code together and read it as a whole in addition to this separated version. It helps prevent functions from being used purely as a reordering mechanism and to have functions being used only when its features are truly needed, such as repeatedly calling the same code. This allows for an in-between of avoiding copy-and-paste and avoiding unnecessary function calls (too many can lead to bouncing all over the place to see what is actually being executed).
The first two together is what is generally taken to be the mains of literate programming. This third one, however, is what I love about it.
3. Arbitrarily changing the code bits before insertion. This allows a lot of little DSL applications, easily inserting code from one language into another (e.g., writing markdown that converts into HTML that is embedded in a JS render function). This can also be used to do copy-paste-modify on a programmatic level. I often find this step to be one just before making an actual function, but somehow it helps me step through it all more easily.
4. Arbitrarily arranging inputs and outputs. Basically, write code entirely the way you (or your team, but probably just you) want to write it. If you want HTML, JS, and CSS all located together in functional units but put into separate files, no problem. If you want them coded in separate files but them brought into one HTML file, no problem. You want to manage configuration, installation, compiling, ..., no problem. You can write these files all separately, together, in pieces of relevance, etc. The danger is of course that your preferred style will not match others, but the hope of the original comment before code will allow people to follow. Essentially, you can read a top-level project management file that tells you where to look for all the other bits and it is faithful because this is how the system is being created.
--- A system that I created that does all of that is https://github.com/jostylr/literate-programming It does work and I tweak every now and then, but it certainly is not in an ideal state. It is a npm installable command line program and there is a 10% written book linked to from the README (free to read on Leanpub in HTML style). Almost every command is documented in there, but just barely.
It is a markdown-based tool. I had experimented with creating a different tool called pieceful-programming which would allow for changing the basic literate style (say instead of markdown, using asciidoc). But I did not complete it (yet?).
I used my tool for web programming, allowing me to freely arrange backend and frontend code as I see fit.
I had not heard of his death. Thanks for posting about it.
In the Bohmian model world, particle positions would be real. They may not be measurable to the inhabitants to infinite precision (assuming quantum equilibrium, i.e., the particles are distributed according to psi-squared), but the particles have definite postions in this world. It has in it no need to postulate anything about measurement. Observables and all that are deduced from the theory.
It is important to ask what in a model has a fundamental existence, what has an implied existence, and what is just a useful term for something secondary to all that. In Bohmian mechanics, particles (things with position) have a fundamental existence, the wave function has an implied existence because that is how the particles move about, and spin has a secondary existence since it does not have a separate existence from either of those two objects, being solely deduced from the motion of the particles.
The Bohmian model is well-defined and has an easy correspondence between the entities that are real and our experience (stuff has position). It does not require observers to be complete. A Bohmian world could happily exist without PhDs, humans, mammals, life forms, etc.
What's real in CI? Not really sure, but I guess the wave function and measuring devices? It does require something that corresponds to measurements and the evolution of that classical world is distinct and separate.
This is the context of calling BM a realist theory. I would just call it an actual theory.
Bohmian mechanics illuminates the quantum randomness, allowing it to be analyzed. The theory happens to be deterministic (ignoring creation/annihilation), but it derives the apparent randomness from all that and it clarifies the meaning of psi-square.
It can be made consistent, namely, adding a foliation (a notion of a canonical present moment) makes it work out fine. The foliation is not detectable, it gives the right predictions, it is mathematically sound, etc.
But it does feel philosophically sketchy and not fundamentally relativistic. However, there is a paper https://arxiv.org/abs/1307.1714 which explores how to derive foliations from the wave function itself and thus would be as relativistic as in theory involving the wave function.
The article also points to other articles with a variety of ideas how to deal with nonlocality in Bohmian mechanics.
It is also odd to say that position cannot be measured. We can tell in an experiment whether something ended up over there or over here. It would be reasonable to then try to have a theory that correlates the position measurements with something that has a position. Now it is not necessarily the case that there has to be such a thing, but it seems like a reasonable first step.
We can even see trails of particles in cloud chambers and the like. Why is that an IPU?
I will grant that it does not have to be the case that the only possible explanation is that of particles with position. But it certainly seems like if there is such a theory (and, of course, there is), then it would seem reasonable to consider it as quite plausible.
It also helps to ask you what is real in your theory. Are wave functions real? They certainly can't be measured in their entirety. Are operators the real thing? We don't measure them, but rather get something close to their eigenvectors/eigenvalues. Are those real?
Many worlds is the closest version with nothing added, but even that requires some kind of mass density function to make explicit connection with our lived experience. While it doesn't add too much in the way of extra mathematical structure in the theory (integrate over the wave function in a certain way: https://arxiv.org/abs/0903.2211 ), the implication in terms of what it says reality is actually like certainly involves a heck of a lot of IPUs.
The nice thing about the parallel transport point of view is the extension to spin. Again, it will look locally like the usual tensor product, but by using an index set for the tensor product being just the set of positions itself, one can again get a non-trivial parallel transport that does just what one would expect.
This is what restricts the permissible wave functions.
One reference for this is my own thesis from about 20 years ago:
There were some papers that were published from that, but they mainly focused on the general topological story rather than having very much in the way of identical particles.
One thing we never did accomplish from this point of view was explaining why fermions went with half spins and bosons integer spins. But at least we did get it reduced to just the two choices.
EPR is the argument that showed any local theory agreeing with the results of quantum experiments must have hidden variables. Bell showed that any hidden variable theory must be non-local. Conclusion: theory is non-local.
Many worlds escapes this by not having definite results of experiments or anything else. Since anything that could happen does happen, there is no need for non-local communication to achieve the (non)results.
Bohmian mechanics is a mathematically consistent theory (uniqueness and existence proven for a wide range of Bohmian systems) and it gives rise to an explanation of the quantum formalism. One can choose to dismiss because of prejudice, but there is no mathematical or physical reason to do so. Its biggest flaw, being nonlocal and thus philosophically (not actually) incompatible with relativity, is what Bell established as having to be the case for any theory with results.
The story with quantum field theory is more questionable, but there is a perfectly fine setup with creation and annihilation of particles, thereby being compatible in spirit with much of QFT. The biggest problem is that technically QFT has problems with having a well-defined wave function. But there have been Bohmian inspired methods of solving that problem, basically using boundary conditions that respect the preservation of probabilities under annihilation and creation.
Catalina finally made me do a completely fresh install with transferring data files as the only touch from the old system. Since the fresh install, it has worked perfectly, but before that the system would randomly keep repeating the last typed character. I could not live with that behavior.
Also got a new MBAir 2020 (Catalina) and that has been perfectly fine and solid as well.
Here is the preprint: https://arxiv.org/abs/2003.07267
They are using the linearity to say that the effect is not magnified as it would be classically, but it is in the context of repairing damage done by a measurement.
A book to read, though older, is Tyranny of Kindness and it expands on the plight in vivid detail of our current system.
The article is an anecdote, but it tells the narrative of how the current setup is pretty difficult for people, particularly single mothers with children. They are already at the mercy of people and find no help for charity. In the article, it even mentions how the family that gets supported moves out of their subsidized apartment. It also mentions how brutal the current system is in terms of cutting off benefits.
I made a more detailed comment in response to a similar question: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=237910967
There are schemes for UBI which don't actually cost much more than we are spending. It can just be reallocation with more clawback in taxes. If one wants to.
Similarly, if there were not people to clean offices, then have the office workers do it (assuming there are offices, of course).
For things that are really essential and cannot be done away with, the cost would go up. It seems reasonable to pay more for vital services. That may mean higher taxes or some other payment arrangement, but it is only regressive if the taxes are done in a regressive way.
There may also be deflationary effects (namely eliminating the giant waste of BS jobs): https://medium.com/@austingmackell/the-deflationary-effects-...
A UBI would change the job market. But whether it is a distortion or fixing some externality cost that was distorting the market is certainly debatable.
I don't think there is a great track record of jobs being run by the government (or farmed out by the government to other organizations) as being idyllic workplaces.
Also a bs job is soul crushing and work-ethic destroying.
The only true power comes from being able to walk away from the control of anyone else, being able to simply say "no". For that, one needs a UBI.
The book goes into great length of the pathology of the welfare system and its non-profit charity profiteers. Of course that was 27 years ago.
It obviously depends on the UBI. If it covered children, it would be absolutely better for the recipients. If it does not cover children, as in Yang's plan, then it is questionable, but it still could benefit a lot because many do not get it at all:
https://medium.com/basic-income/there-is-no-policy-proposal-...
UBI, on the other hand, rewards anyone who works on top of the UBI supplement. There is no need to choose between working and getting the "free" money everyone else is getting.
The thing about UBI is that it in no way, shape or form, prevents people from doing whatever is needed or profitable.
There are a number of people which have sufficient funds to live off $1000 a month and they continue to work. Heck, even the bloggers who talk up such schemes are still producing something of value to the society.
Humans like to work, just not necessarily for a boss. A UBI removes any disincentive from working and allows you to keep what you make except for the tax rate unlike welfare which taxes income at 100% . It allows you to be creative. Right now, we are ignoring the contributions of millions, if not billions of people because they are kept at the edge of survival. Imagine if we created a world that allowed all the billions of the world to contribute imaginatively, cooperatively, and productively. That is what UBI promises, but it does require faith and trust in humanity (read Rutger Bregman's Humankind book for a primer as to how to shed the lies we've been told about human nature).
As for hard maintenance of systems, that will probably cost more to pay people to do it, but it seems very reasonable to reward essential hard work more than we do now.
One final thought. What do you expect you or others you know would do if you had $1000 a month per person in your family given? Maybe some would want to sit around for decades doing nothing, but that personally sounds like an awful life to me and I suspect most would agree.
In terms of how much to give, the idea is to eliminate poverty. Children should not grow up hungry and fearful nor in shame of their parents. That is the fundamental goal. Our current welfare programs do not address this (see Tyranny of Kindness from 1993 for an in-depth personal account of the system then -- it has not improved though it has changed).
So go with the poverty threshhold numbers and see how it goes. I think $1000 a month sounds perfectly reasonable.
Also, various programs are income related and so without changing them at all, they can become less needed.
As for healthcare, while I am dubious about government run healthcare, from what I've read, the government pays for over half of the healthcare costs in this country already. The US also spends twice as much in terms of GDP on healthcare as most other countries. So if we were to reduce the healthcare costs to the level of other countries, then our government could cover universal healthcare without paying more for that. And since premiums would disappear, it could even tax a lot more without changing the ultimate take home pay after taxes + premiums.
In theory, that is how it could go. I don't believe it would turn out well, but that's because I don't believe the government would handle healthcare well. It is not because of the cost of it. And given our current system, I could probably be persuaded to try it.
A large part of it is the lack of financial resources that the residents have. The lack of financial resources is directly related to redlining and the fact that Baltimore is a majority black city. But whatever the reason, money is what is required.
At $1000 a month, someone could take that UBI and spend half of it on a loan of $100k (30 years). That's a lot of capital and it could provide an individual with a home in Baltimore. A family would have even more capital to work with. This gives a great deal of flexibility and a lot of resources in neighborhoods without any. Further development would take place, giving these neighborhoods the kinds of businesses that wealthy white neighborhoods take for granted (such as grocery stores and banks).
What the UBI does is not just provide some financial amount right now, but a guarantee of future payments regardless. The risk of default would be far, far less and the promise of sustained financial reward for investment in these areas, without booting out the current residents, would be far greater.
If one also couples the UBI payments with a more aggressive tax on the wealthy, particularly on the ownership of multiple residential properties, then one could really damp down prices. From what I have read, several cities with massive housing price increases such as Vancouver and NYC have vast amounts of essentially vacant places because wealth has flowed into these places as wealth investment instead of living investment. But that policy is a separate one to consider, to be sure.
This country has plenty of resources. If we give people a minimum amount of money, those resources can start to be divided up much more equitably (peacefully, profitably) without the overt (and corrupting) hand of government deciding who gets exactly what.
UBI is untethered to any conditions on people. So there are no bad incentives created by the system (no good ones created either, of course) nor is anyone part of some group that they try to homogenize into something unproductive.
We do want to be valuable to one another. Right now, we are valued by how much money we have. The dream of a UBI is to move beyond such a silly measurement of human worth and let the measure of value be based on actual deeds. We don't need a boss to tell us what to do. We just need to be a part of a community. Stuff happens, we respond.
With the lockdown, many were given permission to do nothing. And many, many people found ways to do something nonetheless. We seek to give, to participate, to find our own way.
Even privately held companies can find the ballast useful. By inflating the employment numbers, they can simultaneously seem like a big company as well as one that promises huge efficiency gains for those buying it and willing to trim the fat.
The larger the organization, the more it can handle excess ballast. These are the ones who can often get rid of small competitors by buying them or by getting regulatory capture to get rid of them. That's part of the regulatory bit -- get politicians to craft regulations that only a large bureaucracy can fill and that is an immediate impediment to small-time competitors regardless of any other start-up costs.
A Programmer's Introduction to Mathematics by Jeremy Kun is wide ranging and appropriate if there is also interest in programming.
Nature and Growth of Modern Mathematics by Edna Kramer is a wonderful book if history is a passion as well.
Elements of Mathematics by John Stillwell is a broad overview of subjects. It has a crisp mathematical feel to it.
Vector Calculus, Linear Algebra, and Differential Forms by John & Barbara Hubbard is a beautiful introduction to the multi-dimensional aspects, but it is a book that should happen after knowing one dimensional calculus. .
If your child hasn't been exposed to Guesstimation, then a book on that is highly recommended. The book with that title by Weinstein and Adams is a nice guide to investigating that realm.
If the child does arithmetic from right to left, as is sadly too common, the book Speed Mathematics Simplified by Edward Stoddard is a great remedy for that.
Everyday Calculus by Oscar Fernandez could also be worth a look.
Most people do seem to need to decompress by doing nothing useful for a time; I find a month per year of work turns out to be about right. So let's say you do whatever you need to do to recover (games, videos, books, ...). What can you imagine doing after all that escapism becomes boring? It may not be employed by a boss, but would it be a useful contribution to society?