HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jplr8922

249 karma · joined December 9, 2020

submissionscomments
jplr8922··on Fewer young men are in the labor force, more are living at home
I was told that ''fiding your passion is stupid'', and that ''its better to become an unhappy physician than a happy artist''. Since I've hit the job market I've spent thousands of $ in therapy and many weekends in various spiritual activities to reorient my life. And I still my first burnout at 30.

My opinion now is that sense of purpose AND being able to support yourself are essential; you have cash balance to keep in check with the tribe, and an emotional balance to keep in check with yourself. An adult should be able to do both. I think that people who do the former without doing the later may succeed economically, but on the long run they drain everybody and subconsciously expect others to take care of their own emotions. My father was like that, and his own children don't call him 'daddy'.

I also think its a very male difficulty, because boys learn to suppress emotions at a young age. It makes it harder to find meaningful careers, but also to sustain relationships and to evolve in your spirituality. Men drop out of school, do not enter the workforce, and lament that tinder is unfair. In my humble opinion, it is a purpose problem, not a ''how do I clean my room'' problem.

jplr8922··on Fewer young men are in the labor force, more are living at home
I think the term 'coddling ' is not the best. I grew up during the 90's in a hyper-controled environment by a macho dad and a passive mom. I was told to not become an artist, to not travel when I am young (waste of time), to learn how to drive a car, to get a job, get a degree, all that jazz. The thing is, at 32, I still have no sense of purpose in life.

When all the goals are chosen for you, it does not matter if you were over-protected or not. You cannot build true self esteem and confidence if you don't succeed and/or fail at a dream of your choice. There is no point learning to drive a car if you do not know where you want to go, to earn money if you don't know what you want to buy, and to get into a career if you have no sense of purpose.

Videogames are addictive not only because they are fun, they provide you with a goal and 'achievements'. In my humble opinion, sex for the sake of sex (real or porn), promotions for the sake of promotions or else are all caused by the same emotional male problem ; the inability to feel emotions and learn from them what is truly important for yourself. The % of young men in the labour force is just a symptom of that.

jplr8922··on “AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its failing”
Its probably a challenge for any profession where there is a legal monopoly where X service must be performed by Y individual, who also get to choose the quality of X and the number of Y in the market.
jplr8922··on Digging into Quebec's electronic proof of vaccination
Quebec government has problematic policies regarding the hiring of devs. They treat tech workers like the rest of their unionized workforce, and their wage + title depends on seniority. As a result, competent programmers avoid the provincial employer like the plague. Most IT work there is actually done by ''consultant'' firms like CGI, who deploys the devs for a 1-3 years contract. I had an interview with them, and I was told during the meeting that I was probably ''too fast for the working environment'' and was not hired. (no joke).

The culture is super weird. As an example, the focus on the french language : a dev once told me that, during a government contrat, he had to work with a french translated C++ STD library... Finally, by law, the only criteria Quebec can use to choose a external private business to complete a project is the lowest bid. They are not aiming for quality.

Finally since some people in the far regions of the province do not have access to high speed internet, phone + mail + fax is still the implicit norm to contact the government. Quebec public services does not have a strong tech culture for many reasons. We are fortunate that they did not mess up the vaccine process.

jplr8922··on Nicholas Taleb's Amazon Reviews
I agree. I once spoke with a statistics professor in charge of the undergraduate program at my university. I asked him tons of questions about the cursus, and swiftly replied "Yes the program is far from perfect. However understand that statistics is still a new field compared to calculus. I do not think that we know how to teach all of this correctly...". I wish Taleb could write a book about it!
jplr8922··on Berkshire Hathaway’s stock price is too high for Nasdaq computers
I remember it was a discussion topic during my graduate degree in finance. According to theory, the story about unsophisticated investors is stupid since you could basically start an ETF with only BRK stuff in it and sell it at a lower price.
jplr8922··on Practical SQL for Data Analysis
I humbly disagree. Its not that ''my domain is so specific'', but that data analysis in itself is a discovery process which is not straightforward. If you want to explore the jungle, you need a machete.

As for Metabase of MADlib, you are right ; I was not aware of these new tools. They look great, and I'm certain they can help a lot of people. However you assume that they are available! Not all IT departments are open to the idea of buying new software, and if the suggestion comes from an outsider it will be perceived as an insult (been there, done that many many time). And when they refuse, now what? You go back to the usual procedural languages (R, Python, Julia, etc) which are free and don't require the perpetual oversight of some DBA who thinks that all you need is an AVG(X) and GROUP BY since kurtosis is domain specific anyway.

I've meet some Excel-VBA users who couldn't care less about pro devs or decorators since ''they can already do everything by themselves''. Same thing with the SQL only, Python only, Tableau only or wathever-only crowd.

jplr8922··on Practical SQL for Data Analysis
Yup. That is exactly it. You cannot believe the number of programmer I've met who thinks that ''data science is easy'' because ''I can code a neural net too''.

Data analysis is a soft skill that you usually learn by getting your hands dirty in a graduate or professional environment. Its not something you can put on a CV like like ''X years of experience with Y programming language''.

jplr8922··on Practical SQL for Data Analysis
What do you mean by exploratory analysis? Lets assume that my dataset contains features which are not normally distributed, and I want to check for coskewness and cokurtosis matrices before and after I remove outliers with a method specific to my field of research, found in a academic paper. Am I supposed to code all of this in SQL? What is your definition of exporatory analysis, and which metrics do you have in mind?

And what if I want to make graphs to present stuff to a colleague? Am I supposed to use... excel to do that?

jplr8922··on Practical SQL for Data Analysis
I re-read my comment, and I think that I expressed myself too harshly. If you like SQL and it get the job done for you, no problem. I would see myself using that SQL query.

However in order to get there, you need to know why you need the ''hottest_temparature_last_three_days''. Why not 2 or 4 days? Why not using heating degree day? What about serial correlation with other regions, or metering disfunction? What if you are working directly with raw data from instruments, and still need to choose wich cleaning method you will use? What if you want to check the correlation with another dataset which is not yet in your database (ex: private dataset in excel from a potential vendor)?

If you know exactly what you want, sure SQL is the way to go. However the first step of a data project is to admit that you dont know what you want. You will perform a litterature review and might have a general idea, but starting with a precise solution in mind is a receipe for failure. This is why you could need to fetch all the data and then form results with another tool. How do you even know which factors and features must be extracted before doing some exploration?

If you know the process you need and only care about RAM-CPU optimization, sure SQL is the way to go. Your project is an ETL and your have the job of a programmer who is coding a report. There is no ''data analysis'' there...

jplr8922··on Practical SQL for Data Analysis
tldr ; if you hear ''but we can do this in SQL'', RUN!!!

My eyes hurt as I read this article. There are reasons why analysts dont use SQL to do their job, and it has nothing to do with saving RAM and memory.

1) Data analysis is not a linear process, it involve playing and manipulating the data in different way and letting your mind drift a bit. You want your project in an IDE made for that purpose, the ability to create charts, source control, export and share the information, ect. Pandas is just a piece of that puzzle which is not possible to replicate in pure SQL.

2) In 2020, there are numerical methods you want to try beyond a traditional regression. Most real world data problems are not made for stats101 tools included in sql. Kurtosis? Autocorrelation?

3) Politics. Most database administrator are control freaks who hate the idea of somebody else doing stuff in their DB. Right now were I work we still have to use SSIS-2013 instead of stored procedures in order to avoid the DBA refusal bureaucratic process.

4) Eventual professional development. If your analysis is good and creates value, chances are it will become a 'real' program and you will have to explain what you are doing to turn in into an OOP tool. If you have CS101, good coding in python will make this process much easier than a 3000 lines spagetti-SQL SQL script.

5) Data cleaning. Dealing with outliers, NAN and all that jazz really depends on the problem you try to solve. The absence of a one size fits all solutions is a good case for R/pandas/etc. These issue will break an SQL script in no time.

6) Debugging in SQL. Hahahahahahahaha

If you are still preocupied with the ram usage of your PC to do your project, here are two solutions which infuriate a lot of DBAs I've worked with.

A) https://www.amazon.ca/s?k=ram&__mk_fr_CA=%C3%85M%C3%85%C5%BD...

B) https://aws.amazon.com/

jplr8922··on Stock Market Returns Are Anything but Average
The author is doing a lot of work to explain that the statistical average takes a long time to converge to the expected return because the distribution is volatile (high stdv, skewness, kurtosis, etc).

Do note however that his analysis only concerns itself with the US. Including other countries would show that US is one of the few countries where stock markets were never interupted for a long period of time because of its political stability. If you dont beliveve it will keep going this way in the future, invest in other countries.

jplr8922··on Suicide rates are rising among U.S. nurses
Very good question. Here are my hypothesis, feel free to punch me ;

1) Their unions are actually some form of inneficient brokers who fails to truly represent them politically and change the system in their favor. Instead, they simply take a cut on their paycheck, and treats them like factory workers while they should be treated as knowledge workers. Even if nurses and teachers are super important, we treat them like cogs in a machine and fail to frame their role as an investment in society. They are ''cost centers''.

2) The north american medical system (US and Canada) might differ in their funding, but are very similar in their organization compared to European models. Its all about the physician-patient relation, the former being all powerful and the later being a moron. In Canada, they are actually not employed by the state, but are in fact their own small businesses. Oh and they have de facto state monopoly on crucial medical tasks, making every other actor their economic bottom bitch.

3) A huge number of people who choose the job are very empathic-saviour types, and actually are professional martyrs who must endure poor working conditions to save others otherwise they would be bad.

jplr8922··on Princeton admits record-low 3.98% of applicants
It brings in my mind Bryan Caplan research ;

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Case_Against_Education

basically, people educate themselves because it looks good, not because you learn usefull stuff. Thoughts?

jplr8922··on How to Read Books When You Have ADHD
I've been diagnosed with ADHD as an early adult, and oh boy do I hate this kind of article. They describe a human who not only have an attention deficit, but is also completly unable to cope with himself, objectives or life.

Is it aimed for a teenager with low self esteem, or a functionning adult?

Different books needs different levels of attention. An academic article needs several readings, while most articles (this one being a good example) are so crapy that you can decide after 3 paragraphs that the rest is very likely to be crap.

Also we should alway remember that ADHD is a differential diagnostic, which means that you need to deal with all the other possible problems. The comorbidity rate for attention deficit makes one size fits all solutions near impossible. Do you have supportive relationships? Are you in a field which interests you? How is your self esteem and global mental health? Physical health?

jplr8922··on Time to regulate AI that interprets human emotions?
Are the people in charge of regulating the AI which interprets human emotions better than the AI at the same task? How do we currently regulate humans that interpret other humans emotions? Fairly easy to point a case where AI did poorly. Much harder to compare the current process to the new one. Humans can be assholes too.
jplr8922··on I hope work from home continues
I wish you good luck then!
jplr8922··on Do games like Factorio or Eve Online sap the intellectual potential of humanity?
Looking back at it, I used to pay factorio too much because my day job was not satisfying. I hated the office politics, and felt in a no-solution situation. After work, my understimulated brain needed a challenge, and this is where the addictive game logic kicks in.

In factorio, there is alway something to do to increase the efficiency of the project. No boss to tell you that your ideas were not selected for mysterious reasons, that you you should not be thinking about processes but only about your todolist, no favoritism or special privileges. You are in control.

Being convinced that all workplaces were the same and that efforts in the real world were useless, launching that rocket was my redemption. It was a way to send my excess brainpower somewhere.

jplr8922··on China pressured Concordia University to cancel event with Uighur activist (2019)
I agree with you. A month ago I found myself in a debate about the moral equivalency of the US empire vs CCP. My opponent seems to think that any form of power is equaly bad and that the goals and intent does not matter. Therefore, US and China are ''both equals''. I fail to understand how can this form on one-sidedness can come from...
jplr8922··on What Data Can’t Do
Confusing performance metrics and strategical objective is not a data problem, it is a human problem. It happens to a lot of people outside the usual Blair-WhiteNationalist-IQ crowd. I do not think that advanced technical knowledge in ML or stats is required to avoid this mistake ; it is the ability to perform valid counterfactuals statements.

A good example of what I mean can be found on wikipedia :

His instinctive preference for offensive movement was typified by an answer Patton gave to war correspondents in a 1944 press conference. In response to a question on whether the Third Army's rapid offensive across France should be slowed to reduce the number of U.S. casualties, Patton replied, "Whenever you slow anything down, you waste human lives."[103]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_S._Patton

Here, US general Patton is not confounding a performance metric (number of casualities) with strategic goal (winning the war). His counterfactual statement could be that ''if we slow things down, you are simply delaying future battles and increase the total number of casualties in order to achieve victory''.

I'm not suprised at Blair decision. When we choose leaders, do we favor long term strategic thinkers, or opportunistic pretty faces?

jplr8922··on AI skills are worth less than you think (2019)
What about AI soft skills? The ability to explain your model to non-technical people? To picth your solution to executives? To understand business concepts critical to increase the value of the product? Dealing with co-researchers from a different field who might have different criterias about what is a valid factor? Dealing with a IT director who thinks he gets AI because he did stats101 over 10 years ago?

The value of AI hard skills do not exist in a vacuum. It might be true that doing AI is easier when all the infrastructure and management buy-in is there. Unfortunatly, these are hard to come by, and easy to loose...

jplr8922··on Retrospective review of Gödel, Escher, Bach (1996) [pdf]
Hi PixyMisa,

I will try to answer your both comments. I agree that an AI which can spot a rolling ball and know that a child might be following is a worthy goal.

However AI discussed in EGB is able to do much more than that. We might not ''need'' AI that meditates, but can AI which does not can really be called AI? Or does our AI only needs to copy human behaviours which we currently understand as rational?

Also regarding the pseudo-code vs brain statement, it was an attempt on my part to relate to what is called the hard problem of consciousness. The strictly materialistic view of the problem is not currently the best explanation we have, and is probably not the view of EGB.

jplr8922··on Retrospective review of Gödel, Escher, Bach (1996) [pdf]
What do you mean by ''magic components''? One of the core point of EGB is that human consciousness has a property of spotting ''unintended symbolic patterns'' created by an underlying system (ex: a piece of music written by Bach). EGB also touch the point that consciousness might itself be one of these pattern, overlying the mechanical biological machine which is the brain.

'' the brain == consciousness '' is a risky statement, since consciousness also appears to act as an an intermediary between the ''outside'' reality and the brain (ex: placebo effect, being scared during a nightmare, being stressed after a nightmare, etc).

Does the brain has magic components and can AI replicate it? If you write a pseudo-code program which replicates consciousness, will a brain appear? Programing languages are languages. Can languages replicate reality? I do not think so, and there is no ''magic'' in my opinion.

jplr8922··on Retrospective review of Gödel, Escher, Bach (1996) [pdf]
Hm interesting, do you have an recent article to share?
jplr8922··on Retrospective review of Gödel, Escher, Bach (1996) [pdf]
I dont think that AI will get close to the vision in GEB. As many said in this thread, what we have is more power and more data to solve narrow problems. One of the point of EGB is that perceived details may aggregate to something larger and form another pattern unrelated to what the algo what initially trained for. True AI will have to find a way around this.

When I was working as an quantitative strategist in a trading firm, I alway made sure that my algos had a ''killswitch'' which required human intervention in case the market did not exibit usual patterns found in the training sets. Skin in the game is the best cure against techno-evengelical optimism.

Also, I had the opportunity to practice zen meditation with a monk who had actual koan training. The idea that computer will replicate that process soon is ridiculous. Buddhist and asian philosophy are, at their cores, anti-aristotle.

Who can make this into a AI now? https://aeon.co/essays/the-logic-of-buddhist-philosophy-goes...

jplr8922··on A Brief History of the Hedge Fund
I've worked in the industry, and yeah is a good explanation. The problem is that there is a reason why some strategies are uncorrelated to the market ; because they are not trading liquid vanilla products. Institutional investors cannot invest in crazy stuff that easily. Renaissance and other unicorns are not always open to new institutional investors, and certainly not one with tons of compliance to deal with.

1) Portfolio size, 2) low market correlation, 3) above market performance.

Choose two. You cannot have all three.

jplr8922··on Early-Retirement Update
Amen to this blog post. Quality inter independence with other is more important than financial independence
jplr8922··on Young Goldman Sachs bankers ask for 80-hour week cap
Well if you end up in a toxic workplace there are limits to what you can do as ''the new one'', and unfortunatly you often have to follow along if you don't want to loose your job.

In my view there are two ways to understand this problem.

1) As a feminist issue. And it is, since no women will feel good in this kind of workplace where strip clubs are the norm. On the long run its counterproductive for society to allow these behaviours at the workplace.

2) As a creativity issue. Even in a hypothetical where women/minorities don't exist, these behaviours would still be an issue from a business point of view. The ''sport team mentality'' kills intellectual creativity. Try to sell these guys an idea which is alien to their monkey-culture... impossible. While working in these environments, I think I've read up to 10 books about ''how to pitch your idea'', not understanding what was wrong. True creativity is impossible in these circles, and their business usually fails at some point. It happened two times in my life, and I'm not 35 yet.

Getting in touch with your subconscious is like loosing your virginity ; it wont happen if you alway group with similar peers.

jplr8922··on Young Goldman Sachs bankers ask for 80-hour week cap
In my experience, most workplaces have at least one manager with a light-medium addiction problem (tends to be alcohol for olders, and marijuana for millenials). It might be hard to spot, but the best way to track it is the quality of decision making.

Unfortunatly, addiciton and other mental health problems are almost impossible for the firm to adress until its too late for everybody (disgrunted employees, missed business opportunities, etc). I hope this COVID crisis will make us more preventive regarding these issues.

jplr8922··on Young Goldman Sachs bankers ask for 80-hour week cap
Yup, I was talking about extended lunches with many beers. In my opinion, heavy drinking is still bad outside work hours. I've seen supervisors making financial decisions while hangover from their last night party. Was I supposed to believe that their judgment was not biased and faculties ready for any situation? Would you better have an inexperienced sober junior or an experienced senior under effect of alcohol as an employee?
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →