720 karma · joined May 16, 2015
If I thought the other person just wanted a fight, I'd ignore them. If I thought a good discussion might be had I'd go something like
"I think X and Y is good evidence of A. Why do you think that isn't the case?"
I think that's what the problem is. The post in the screenshot is unnecessarily combative. It's not conducive to good discussion. It doesn't have anything to do with beliefs, it's just picking a fight. Change 'right' to 'left' or whatever group and it would've been flagged just the same.
If the latter, then, again, a lot of people disagreeing with you isn't generally good evidence of being correct. You might be correct, but the downvotes aren't the thing that proves it. Personally, I'd have a think about why.
If it's the former, from what I've seen here comments get removed for tone or being off-topic, not for disagreement.
You're entitled to vote how you want, of course, but taking disagreement as evidence of being correct generally isn't sound logic.
> (I also fully expect this comment to also get flagged.)
I think we can do better, claims of persecution are just as tiresome as groupthink.
A few weeks ago someone was ranting about something (some movie he claimed was being given the woke treatment). I told him that he shouldn't get so worked up about it. In hindsight, his response should've been predictable. "Oh, so I'm not allowed to have an opinion?". I told him it was fine to have an opinion and share it, but that I thought he should just skip watching the movie and not get worked up about creative choices he disagreed with. I wasn't trying to "suppress wrongthink", I just found it very tiresome.
Edit: granted that wasn't about science, but I find the dynamic is often similar.
A quote from one of the moderators:
>Intellectual curiosity is everywhere, and it’s present in all demographics,
>We want Hacker News to grow in all demographics, because there’s just intellectually interesting contributions from all of those communities—a greater diversity of content, of conversations, of topics, et cetera.
Which is just another way of stating the guidelines:
On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.
Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, or celebrities, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.
The stuff you don't like is already off-topic, unless there is intellectually interesting discussion to be had.
alias.co checkout
alias.br branch
alias.ci commit
alias.st status
alias.cm commit -m
alias.unstage reset HEAD --
alias.cob checkout -b
alias.pp pull --prune> For one, redescribing a symphony as a 'silent void'
Doesn't read that way to me. Vibrant life has become a silent void, and the pain of seeking that past is a melancholic symphony
It did not guarantee anything outside of that. Soundness of design and ensuring inputs and environmental factors conformed to the spec was up to the engineers.
The y-axis (Yield in percent) values don't seem to match the data points. For example, the point for Feb '01 is labelled '7%' but the point is just above the 6% mark and well below the 6.5%. What am I not understanding?