HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jrajav

3,038 karma · joined May 23, 2012

http://stackoverflow.com/users/1013153/jrajav https://github.com/jrajav
submissionscomments
jrajav··on Lessons learned reinventing the Python notebook
Generally notebooks are used specifically when statefulness gets in the way, and an interactive feedback loop is the entire end goal, not the means. Being able to iterate on operations at a cell level with reactivity is totally game changing for such use cases. If you don't get where that would be valuable, you probably just haven't encountered such a use case yet.
jrajav··on Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renewing free tax site
I couldn't say stupid but I could say there's a whiff of bad-faith arguments in the air...

But of course the direct answer is that throwing the full faith and credit of the US (that is, in showing earnest and steady effort to pay off its debts, something that worldwide investors count on) straight out the window would immediately tank the value of the dollar, which wouldn't be good for anyone paid in dollars.

If the implication is that we should not bother to run our finances honestly and responsibly because of some idea that the checks written by lawmakers aren't for things we all agree on, then it seems like a bit of a non sequitur. The time to decide on that is when we decide who writes those checks, but we have every incentive to commit and honor our debts after that.

jrajav··on Cindy Lee might be the future of music
And yet they still regularly hold Bandcamp Fridays (0% commission) and haven't shown any signs of reducing or locking down functionality. The acquisitions are certainly worrying in theory, and it's worth keeping a close eye on their operations, but for practical purposes they're still one of the best distribution venues for artists in terms of 'bang for buck' (buck being your fans' attention).
jrajav··on Netflix blows past estimates as subscribers jump 16%
You just explained the headline. Netflix has successfully weaponized edge cases for profit - the "success" part crucially hinging on surviving the initial news cycle and coming out the other side with their reputation intact. The money grab was spread across so many disparate demographics and use cases that none could coalesce to a single, easy-to-message gripe. All it cost them was a few key slices of trust from discerning customers. Take enough of those slices and your business will fade - but who cares, for this financial year?
jrajav··on Everything we can't describe in music
Yeah.... no. Why audio-nerd forums were ever so infantile as to brand themselves with "muff" and "slutz" isn't much of a big mystery, but we haven't lost anything of value by seeing those 'cute' names off. I'd like to chat about synthesizers with fellow nerds without feeling rightfully embarrassed about the name in the header.
jrajav··on The V8 Sandbox
Very curious what your unique definition of 'computationally intensive' is, that manages to not include one of the most significant computational workloads worldwide, both in terms of absolute volume and impact on human productivity. Namely, web browser rendering performance.
jrajav··on Why isn't dental health considered primary medical care?
And why exactly is it that we aren't continually having this debate over skilled workers building and maintaining road infrastructure? Firefighters? Police officers? Postal workers?

I truly don't understand how we have many successful and thriving examples of publicly funded services, yet somehow healthcare - which we all equally need, and which is equally a backbone of a healthy society - is somehow unique in needing profit incentives to function.

The free-market theory only applies to products which you have a choice to engage with, and which are not essential to life and the basic productivity of all society.

jrajav··on The High-Risk Refactoring
If anyone at any company judges an engineer who crafts code that is easy for other engineers on their team to immediately pick up and start work on as more replaceable, that person is hopelessly incompetent. That would normally be a basic skill every engineer is expected to pick up before getting too far in their career.

If anything, an engineer with a clear tendency to try to write themselves job security is the one that should be replaced ASAP.

jrajav··on YouTuber liable for bogus DMCA notice "awareness campaign" targeting Bungie
Yeah, there is a particularly sour taste to this case, even if it is legally sound - given how utterly broken and opaque Youtube's DMCA takedown process is, and how Bungie have themselves taken advantage of it.

It feels a lot like Bungie understands how vulnerable their reputation is already on this point, and is acting a bit out of desperation to try and scare anyone off of any further acts of protest, rather than a more legitimate defense of their IP.

jrajav··on London's Great Stink
Nothing about "vaccines linked to autism" ever looked bad. It was one study with sample size n=12, widely and firmly discredited, then used as the basis for a huge epidemic of motivated anti-intellectualism.

Whatever the amount of evidence is that is appropriate to build regulations on, it's certainly far, far above that.

jrajav··on Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they are the solution
I'm honestly curious what the real meat of the objections to this were (I never heard much about this sticking point). Why would you want duplicating coverage anyway? Is it not strictly better for any consumer to only be paying for the extra coverage you want on top of the public coverage?
jrajav··on Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they are the solution
Get out of here with the "my team" / "your team" nonsense and the trolling in general. It's perfectly possible to make your point with reason and civility instead of cheap, shallow jabs, and if it isn't, well - probably not a point worth making.
jrajav··on Tai chi reduces blood pressure better than aerobic exercise
That's not chai tea, that's chai tea flavored syrup.
jrajav··on Atlantic Ocean is headed for a tipping point. Extreme climate within decades
It should also be really obvious that there are many ways to prevent these problems at the source. We can ramp up regulations on pollution to be much, much stricter than they are now, and give them real teeth. We can combat overseas pollution with sanctions and trade agreements. We can reject politicians who stymy these efforts, and sometimes even backpedal efforts by leaving the Paris Agreement and making a fuss.

There are many avenues open to solving climate change problems that don't involve inventing global terraforming.

jrajav··on He spent his life building a $1M stereo
Just to support your point, there are many professional digital audio products used for recording that quite literally run on USB 2.0. For instance, this well respected interface that supports 32 channels in and out up to 192khz: https://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/DigifaceUSB--rme-dig...
jrajav··on UI considerations for designing large data tables
I found the link interesting, that is why I clicked on it and upvoted it. Perhaps some of us here are interested in good UX design, particularly for hard-to-get-right areas like dense data tables. What satisfies your intellectual curiosity may not be the same for someone else.

Ironically, everyone in this thread complaining about the submission not being appropriate for HN are violating the guidelines.

jrajav··on Consumer Reports finds 'widespread' presence of plastics in food
How many cycles do we have to go through of "oh, recklessly dumping this substance into the ecosystem probably doesn't have any ill effects, and you should prove it does before being such a negative nelly"?

Just once, I'd like to sacrifice consumerism at the altar of my and my family's internal organs, versus the other way around. We're a few decades late to finally be putting full product lifecycle accountability in the laps of manufacturers everywhere.

jrajav··on Cold showers on overhyped topics (2017)
> The only type of bug that static typing reduces is the sort of bug you'll find by running the code.

This is a pretty solid argument in favor of static typing, then, unless you somehow have a test suite that exercises every possible code path and type variation in your codebase, and also keeps itself perfectly up to date. Because otherwise you're rarely running all of your code and verifying the result.

jrajav··on Cold showers on overhyped topics (2017)
Golf takes gear, course access, and above all large amounts of free time. It's certainly not something almost anybody can afford to do. Access and the time to commit are things those with higher economic status often take for granted when considering whether everyone can afford some activity. These factors likely come into play for saunas too - they're not a staple for any given city gym, for sure, which means you need access to a more well-outfitted gym, or to have a sauna in your own home. And then, again, free time beyond the essentials of fitness and daily life.
jrajav··on Cold showers on overhyped topics (2017)
There is a reproducibility crisis in many fields where people tacitly assumed everyone else was doing their due diligence. Many basic assumptions about confounding factors, confidence values, etc are still being criticized and revisited. You should not assume that such factors have been accounted for, instead you should join in continually asking if they have been and challenging all assumptions.
jrajav··on The New York Times is suing OpenAI and Microsoft for copyright infringement
Copyright holders already have control over who is legally allowed to view a work that has been made publicly available. It's the right to distribution. You don't waive that right when you make your content free to view on a trial basis to visitors to your site, with the intent of getting subscriptions - however easy your terms are to skirt. NYT has the right to remove any of their content at any time, and to bar others from hosting and profiting on the content.
jrajav··on The New York Times is suing OpenAI and Microsoft for copyright infringement
Artists getting paid little is a function of how easy it is to capture the value that artists create, and how willing other people are to do that capturing - not how valuable their work is. Artists definitely want to get paid and do not want to live on scraps for "passion's" sake. This is the entire argument for copyright existing in the first place, even though current copyright law has flaws.
jrajav··on The New York Times is suing OpenAI and Microsoft for copyright infringement
This is a little ridiculous. There are flaws with copyright law but making money from creative work would be even less viable than it is now if there were no disincentives at all to blatant plagiarism and repackaging right after initial creation.
jrajav··on Has gratuity culture reached a tipping point?
The obvious solution is #1. Tip credits were a greedy and completely unnecessary policy from the start that should never have made it into law. Removing them again will undercut one of the main reasons everyone still feels obligated to tip at restaurants.
jrajav··on America's Tipping Slowdown Isn't Slowing Down
The point was that it's arbitrary, not hard.
jrajav··on Two pharmacists figured out that oral phenylephrine doesn't work
What kind of precedent is there for this pattern working successfully, long term, in any industry? 'Review companies' get sabotaged all the time if they were ever reliable at all. I sure wouldn't want to rely on one for medicine I give to my family if it was anything like relying on Yelp for a decent restaurant. I'm not at all convinced that the open market is a valid locale for these incentives - it seems to come with inherent conflict of interest.

Maybe it's reasonable for us to agree that some kinds of oversight are worth funding as a society without waiting for incentives to sprout up out of the ground.

jrajav··on VanJS – A no-JSX framework based on vanilla JavaScript
I fully agree with the sentiment, but Svelte does not seem like a natural leader on that front since their version is a JS superset. Already a bit off the map for interoperability.

Solid's attempt feels more promising since it's building on existing native functionality (proxies / getters), and has intuitive, low-footprint usage (just function calls and reference comparisons).

Edit: It seems I'm not up to speed in fact, I hadn't seen Svelte 5 and runes yet, which are not compile-time. I will need to give it another try. I agree in general that signals and signal-based APIs are the future and definitely better than hooks at least, and a single agnostic standard would be good for everyone.

jrajav··on VanJS – A no-JSX framework based on vanilla JavaScript
The flipside of this is that in React you are paying the cost of active vdom all the time, even when it doesn't pay off by optimizing large batched updates. In Solid, you sometimes have to optimize for some eager updates, true. That will have to be done at some point, though, when the situation calls for it - in either a specific or a general way. It feels natural to shift that optimization to the state layer, and completely eliminate the need for vdom, at the expense of some more thought and active, upfront work. It's a similar tradeoff to spending more time crafting static typing that works well, versus forgoing static types. The tradeoff seems to have good effect too - Solid seems much faster than React both on paper and in practice (my personal experience).
jrajav··on OpenAI suspends ByteDance's account after it used GPT to train its own AI model
Reddit gating NSFW content with login is pretty obviously a play to increase signups and therefore engagement. Making scraping less feasible might just be a bonus, but attributing the whole thing to that is a stretch.
jrajav··on Terminal graphics protocol
Respecting a single real person's basic requests about use of their own image is "politically correct" now? It's worth considering at what point your knee-jerk reactions have gone off the deep end on the other side.
← PreviousPage 3 of 21Next →