HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jrochkind1

28,711 karma · joined March 14, 2012

submissionscomments
jrochkind1··on RAG Is Simpler Than You Think
More LLM-generated text about LLMs.

Is anyone else actually finding it harder and harder to read LLM generated text? I find it quite tiring, my brain just does not want to get through it.

jrochkind1··on Nine PBS sues Iron Mountain over blocked access to archival data
So you would probably not in fact assume SWEs would have sympathey for other SWEs then, I'd guess!
jrochkind1··on Nine PBS sues Iron Mountain over blocked access to archival data
You're right, management should have "decided" to triple their budget in order to have double staff, have management with IT experience, have triple the IT staff and pay them double, and pay more for IT vendors/equipment as well, while keeping programming the same. Or heck, they should have increased programming too, why not. Maybe quadruple the budget.

I don't know why they didn't decide to do that, I guess they just make poor decisions to be cheap. Otherwise it's a complete mystery.

jrochkind1··on Nine PBS sues Iron Mountain over blocked access to archival data
It is definitely not having sufficient budget, although I doubt management was "trying" to be cheap.

They probably have 1-2 IT staff, who have been paid significantly under market value compared to private sector.

Management was not management of an IT organization, and probably did not really understand the trade-offs or what they'd lose by not spending more money on IT. Their IT staff was probably super busy and over-worked and also (not to throw them under the bus) not experienced enough to really advise them, and if they had and had tried to advise them, would management have decided that doing less programmatic work to pay for it, and having IT people at least temporarily spend less time on whatever they do to support regular business, to set up and support backups, was worth it? Maybe, maybe not. Again, the managers probably have little experience with IT. The whole organization is probably well under 100 people.

Source: I work in non-profits.

Why is HN always focused on suggesting there's a person who could have easily made the right choice if they weren't an idiot?

jrochkind1··on Nine PBS sues Iron Mountain over blocked access to archival data
> You'd assume SWEs would have sympathy for other SWEs.

Only if you haven't been reading HN very long!

jrochkind1··on Nine PBS sues Iron Mountain over blocked access to archival data
it sounds like Iron Mountain specifically markets itself as "we will never turn over your data without a court order", so whether contractually obligated to do that or not, choosing to do that when they have a legal choice to do so is part of what attracts and keeps customers, and not choosing to do voluntarily would harm their business and lose them customers. Perhaps they could legally choose to turn over the data, but they choosing not to. A court order would give them no legal choice, and they would then turn over the data, and it would not harm their attraction or retention of customers, because that was always the deal, only with a court order.
jrochkind1··on Stateless MCP has recaptured my interest
Why was MCP ever stateful in the first place?
jrochkind1··on AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog
Still better than AI generated text.
jrochkind1··on Frame selection is the whole game: notes on making LLMs watch video
"Dedup started as one comparator and grew a channel every time real footage embarrassed it."

Is it possible to ever read a piece by LLMs that isn't written by LLMs?

jrochkind1··on SQLite Critical CVEs or LLM Slop?
I only know about this what I learned from OP and you guys.

It sounds like you guys think OP was mistaken, whatever analysis NIST was doing that they reduced in 2024 would not have prevented this anyway?

Legit question, I'm trying to understand!

OP says:

> Hit by a massive surge in vulnerability reports, NIST effectively hit pause on deep analysis. CISA and other Authorized Data Publishers (ADPs) tried to step in with their own enrichment efforts, but the global pipeline is now fragmented and drowning in a massive backlog. Because no step in today's system actually requires a proof-of-concept or bug reproduction, a plausible-sounding fake advisory can slide right through the pipeline and end up in GHSA, downstream databases, and enterprise scanners.

Do i correctly understand you are saying you think they've mistunderstood the diagnosis of what changed, the 2024 change to NIST didn't actually make it any more likely for a fake advisory to go through pipeline?

jrochkind1··on SQLite Critical CVEs or LLM Slop?
OP suggests something at NIST changed in 2024, where they stopped doing as much verification as they did before.

To be sure, the suggestion is not funding cuts, but an increase in workload with same funding.

Here is the 2024 NIST announcement OP links to: https://nvd.nist.gov/general/news/nvd-program-transition-ann...

> Currently, we are prioritizing analysis of the most significant vulnerabilities. In addition, we are working with our agency partners to bring on more support for analyzing vulnerabilities and have reassigned additional NIST staff to this task as well.

The OP described this as "NIST effectively hit pause on deep analysis. "

It does sound like they stopped doing something they used to do in 2024. I personally have definitely not spent a lot of time directly interfaced with NIST on cybersecurity in decades past, I know nothing about it, just what I read in OP.

Are you saying the OP was wrong to call what NIST used to do "deep analysis", and/or that the thing NIST stopped doing was "purely ministerial/clerical" in a way that it would not have caught fake reports anyway, contradicting the OP? Or other?

Again, to be sure, the OP's suggestion was not that this was caused by NIST funding cuts, but by "a massive surge in vulnerability reports,"

jrochkind1··on SQLite Critical CVEs or LLM Slop?
The federal government ought to be funding NIST sufficiently to actually do sufficient analysis. Do we care about funding civil "cyber" defense or not?

(Obviously the answer is not, we only care about funding offensive capabiltiies).

jrochkind1··on Postgres LISTEN/NOTIFY actually scales
Ah, thanks. I am not following at all how an application can do this.
jrochkind1··on Postgres LISTEN/NOTIFY actually scales
If I understnad right, they are saying it scales (to theri needs) with a custom patch to pg changing their semantics, right?

It does seem interesting, and possibly welcome if there were a configuration option or even a way to set individual notifies as serialized or not.

jrochkind1··on So Reddit has decided that plain HTML is unsafe
and yet, it remains, in many subreddits.
jrochkind1··on So Reddit has decided that plain HTML is unsafe
It's also like the only place left on the internet to reliably find real people reviewing things with real opinions.
jrochkind1··on OpenAI and Hugging Face address security incident during model evaluation
I did not realize that "cyber" had become assumed short for "cybersecurity". So depressing.
jrochkind1··on Why I am not going to buy a computer
In this case, effort has _not_ been put in to make sure the docs are of high quality, and the potential readers know that, which is surely relevant.
jrochkind1··on Dupes took over the world
thanks! I obv knew less about violins than saxophones!
jrochkind1··on Dupes took over the world
It's interesting you used both saxophone and violin as your examples, as they are very different historically.

Violins are basically ancient and evolved gradually over huge time spans, yes.

But saxophones -- invented by a guy named Adolph Sax and patented in France in 1846! It really was a kind of new thing, combining aspects of brass and woodwind instruments in ways that hadn't been done before. I think it's fair to say he invented it as a new instrument. (What legal protection that should get how is another story, I don't know that I like patents honestly). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saxophone

Sax was really mad about manufacturers reverse engineering and copying his saxophone without a license and tried suing them etc, for the period before his patent expired, but it was still being copied a lot -- it was a new thing people were excited about. Once the patent expired, it was definitely a free for all.

jrochkind1··on Regressive JPEGs
I haven't been able to see it even setting Chrome developer tools to crazy slow network speeds. Maybe chrome developer tools simulation isn't enough to see it?

The observations you are reporting are from images you created yourself and you know are in fact progressive jpegs? (not "regressive", although that's funny). There are of course other techniques to start with a lower resolution image that do "work" (in the sense of actually displaying a lower resolution image first at least).

jrochkind1··on Fired by Google for creating the Google workspace CLI
So it was done on the clock as a project at Developer Relations team, I don't know if that should be called a personal project or not, maybe, it does seem Developer Relations projects could be one person's idea and execution, but just to be clear on what happened.

It was released 2 and a half months before Google IO.

The way I read this, they decided to announce it at Google IO because of the attention the project released by the Developer Relations team got. No one with inside knowledge has said the "official tool" (not from Dev Relations) was already planned when it was released. Maybe it was. Maybe a guy on the Dev Relations team would or should have known it was if it was. Easy for me to believe it was not however.

jrochkind1··on 5k menus from the New York Public Library’s Buttolph Collection (1880-1920)
I just immediately went with the arrow keys on my MacBook.
jrochkind1··on 5k menus from the New York Public Library’s Buttolph Collection (1880-1920)
I want to know if this was hand-coded or what; would love a re-usable template to make exhibitions like this! Very good online display of digitized materials with interpretative journey.
jrochkind1··on IP Crawl: Living atlas of open webcams discovered on the public internet
What, no plotting on a map?
jrochkind1··on Fired by Google for creating the Google workspace CLI
Are we talking about the same twitter thread? This one? https://xcancel.com/JPoehnelt/status/2069482265953087602
jrochkind1··on Fired by Google for creating the Google workspace CLI
I don't know that I'd call the repo "non-Google-affiliated", but whatever it is, it is still up [1] in a google-owned github organization [2], which also includes several other repos with the line "This is not an officially supported Google product," such as this one that's two years old [3].

So, yeah, whatever it is, I'd say it looks normal.

[1] https://github.com/googleworkspace/cli

[2] https://github.com/googleworkspace

[3] https://github.com/googleworkspace/redriveapp

jrochkind1··on Fired by Google for creating the Google workspace CLI
I don't see anything about the product that made Google leadership look bad? I don't see that anyone else external to Google thought so either, before they fired him? Firing him makes them look bad, however.
jrochkind1··on Fired by Google for creating the Google workspace CLI
I read the twitter thread, don't see any clear information about what the t's and i's even are, or if they were crossed and dotted.
jrochkind1··on Fired by Google for creating the Google workspace CLI
> but yea it's true he didn't dot the i's and cross the ts.

How do you know that's true? Do you have information the rest of us don't?

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →