HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jrock08

173 karma · joined May 9, 2014

submissionscomments
jrock08··on An open letter to Paul Graham
And I'm not going to point-by-point refute arguments that aren't particularly convincing, but here's some thoughts.

> Closely related to poverty is lack of social mobility.

It's not just closely related, when considering income inequality the two converge. It's simple arithmetic really. When poverty wages are a lesser multiplier (i.e. income inequality were less) of wealth wages (let's say 2), then it's obvious how to lift oneself out of poverty, split a home with another person earning an income.

> you don't have to grow up rich or even upper middle class to get rich as a startup founder, but few successful founders grew up desperately poor

Sure, but a rich founder has a clear advantage, in the same way that a founder at Harvard has a clear advantage. It's a lot easier to ask a friend/colleague/parent for money than a stranger.

> For example, let's attack poverty, and if necessary damage wealth in the process.

Yes. The way we attack poverty is to spend money to improve schools, spend money to improve transit, spend money to provide food for low cost. Where does that money come from, taxes. If we just talk about fixing poverty, we run the risk of not actually spending money and fixing the problem. Ignoring the greater context of politics, and the almost 100% sign on of republicans to the Grover no new taxes pledge, in order to actually get a mandate to fix anything, the alternative has to be upfront and direct about taxes.

If you'd like me to address arguments directly feel free to respond with something less dickish than telling me to read an article that I've already read.

jrock08··on An open letter to Paul Graham
It's not clear that reducing income inequality is bad, please explain. The arguments against eliminating income inequality rest on the idea that people won't do a hard or bad job if it didn't pay more than other easier or nicer jobs. While there are very likely jobs that people wouldn't do for a small multiplier on some ideal base pay for some ideal good job. Increasing marginal tax rates, which is the actual way that actual people suggest we handle income inequality, doesn't actually put a cap on pay.
jrock08··on An open letter to Paul Graham
Unless you are trying to be obtuse, or hate brevity, the statement "eliminate income inequality" and "eliminate excessive income inequality" read exactly the same. No one is arguing for a move to a fully socialist state, so "eliminate income inequality" in the US means "tax the highest bracket more" and/or "add a higher tax bracket and tax it more" and/or "add a wealth tax". If you honestly look at the arguments rather than just arguing petty semantics you'll be better off in the long run.
jrock08··on ‘Nice’ Is a Four-Letter Word at Companies Practicing Radical Candor
There is a huge difference between racism, and telling someone that their idea isn't fully thought out. The social justice movement doesn't care about the latter in the slightest. Discouraging racism and sexism in a workplace isn't censorship any more than discouraging swearing is.
jrock08··on Car turns driver in for hit-and-run
Why is a personally owned self driving car a better solution than robust public transit? Self driving cars still are inefficient if they need to be parked and likely don't magically solve congestion if they take up as much space as current cars on the road.
jrock08··on Walmart’s $10 Smartphone Has Better Specs Than the Original iPhone
> I wanted a Samsung phone but a pure Android experience

That's Samsung's fault.

> Shouldn't have to buy a phone direct from Google to get that.

Oh, I completely agree, but Samsung doesn't want to simply provide OEM Android because they think that the add-ons distinguish them in a crowded market.

> Apple is a hardware company Google is not.

But Apple's limited hardware offering is why they can guarantee you such a pure Apple experience. The equivalent exists in the Google ecosystem. It's buying one of the phones directly from the Google Play store. The only difference is that in the Apple ecosystem there isn't choice, so you don't get to see better hardware spec'd phones that run IOS, while in the Android ecosystem you do.

jrock08··on Walmart’s $10 Smartphone Has Better Specs Than the Original iPhone
> You shouldn't have to buy phones direct from Google

> My iPad 3

You do realize that you've undermined your point here right?

jrock08··on The Tech Bust of 2015
Revenue is a much better indicator of growth.

Yelp 2012: 137M; 2013: 232M; 2014: 377M

SAFM 2012: 2.3B 2013: 2.6B 2014: 2.7B

So, SAFM grew ~5% while Yelp grew 100%

jrock08··on How to know if where you live is “up and coming”: fried chicken vs. coffee shops
He's literally using fried chicken as an extremely thinly veiled way of measuring the number of black people in an area.

This is a good article on why "fried chicken" when paired with other things can be racist. [1] Since "up and coming" is basically code for gentrifying, it shouldn't be that hard to see why this is actually racist.

[1] http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/02/heres-wh...

jrock08··on What a City Would Look Like If It Were Designed for Only Bikes
Why?

I use panniers for my groceries, however, the grocery store won't allow me to just bring my bike inside, so instead I have to take the panniers off my bike and put them in a cart. Using my bike as the cart would make sense.

jrock08··on Paris city centre goes car-free for a day
So, helmet laws are actually a terrible example of "effects aren't what you want", at least, it's a terrible example if the implication is that we are getting an effect that we don't expect. Now, it's possible that the legislators didn't understand this, but cycling advocates were and are well aware that helmet laws cause reduced bicycle use. Here's an article with sources which claims to be from 2006, the website copyright notice is 2013, so at the very least, it's from right around when Australia implemented it's helmet law. http://bicycleaustin.info/laws/helmet-laws-bad.html
jrock08··on Paris city centre goes car-free for a day
Cycling in Australia dropped by about 2% between 2011 and 2013. [1] The biggest issue with helmet laws though is that they significantly neuter bike share programs because people don't want to cary a helmet or use a shared helmet.

[1] page 26 http://www.cycle-helmets.com/cps-2013.pdf

jrock08··on Paris city centre goes car-free for a day
If the only vehicles using the road are public transit vans, we can clearly reduce the size of roads and the infrastructure. The vastly reduced wear and tear on the roads would free up government money for investment in public transit.
jrock08··on Paris city centre goes car-free for a day
Cars are absolutely a dominating factor in biker safety. In NYC in 2012 and 2013 there were 7766 injuries and 30 fatalities of bikers reported which involved cars as compared to 537 injuries and 3 fatalities of bikers which did not involve cars.

See page 2 for source: http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/2012-bicycle-crash... http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/2013-bicycle-crash...

jrock08··on Paris city centre goes car-free for a day
Oh man, you are the first person to bring up the elderly and disabled. I bet we can't figure that out at all so we better not try.

Or, municipalities continue to provide on demand transit using small vans to the elderly and disabled, since no one said there can't be exemptions to the car free rules.

jrock08··on The Illinois Mathematics and Science Academy, a public live-in high school
This is something that I'm uniquely qualified to comment on.

I am an IMSA alum who was by and large, a below average IMSA student during my first two years. However, I learned a lot just by being exposed to my very smart classmates. Eventually, in my senior year I matured and started to work harder and got good grades. Had I stayed at my original high school I would have skated through at the top of my classes without much adversity. Then, based on the average college dropout rate of students from my original high school, I would have faced adversity in college and not know what to do. IMSA is a big part of why I am where I am today.

jrock08··on Women view professional advancement equally attainable, but less desirable [pdf]
Social cost isn't made up and it isn't really the same as seeking approval. It's related to, but deeper than simple approval. For example, you might not care that someone thinks you are a bad parent for not dressing up your daughter as a pirate, however, you do care that the PTA now won't take your opinion seriously because you "aren't invested in your child's education".
jrock08··on Women view professional advancement equally attainable, but less desirable [pdf]
You know it's pretty childish to dismiss someone's experience right? He didn't say he was seeking approval, he said that when he does the most minor childcare thing he gets praise, while when neither he nor his wife do some completely asinine thing (dressing their daughter as a pirate) his wife (not him) catches flack from the teachers for not being "more involved". Dismissing this as "narcissistic" is completely misreading his comment.
jrock08··on Google Wants to Make Silicon Valley as Bike-Friendly as Copenhagen
I can't find aggregate statistics for Palo Alto, but here's the 2012/2013 statistics for the New York Burroughs.

Cyclists killed 1 pedestrian (in 2013) and injured 560 pedestrians for a mortality rate of .1%.

Drivers killed 326 pedestrians and injured 24411, a mortality rate of 1.3%.

Clearly bikers are killing pedestrians and are very dangerous.

See page 2 for source:

http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/2013-bicycle-crash...

http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/2012-bicycle-crash...

jrock08··on Google Wants to Make Silicon Valley as Bike-Friendly as Copenhagen
Trucks in Palo Alto kill pedestrians http://sfbay.ca/2015/04/19/bcn57palo-alto-pedestrian-dies-in...

Drivers in Palo Alto kill pedestrians http://abc7news.com/news/driver-arrested-on-suspicion-of-fat...

jrock08··on Google Wants to Make Silicon Valley as Bike-Friendly as Copenhagen
Interestingly, closing roads and reducing the number of cars would improve the number and availability of foot crossings. It's funny you mention good city planning, since a lack of good city planning is actually why we are in this situation in the first place.
jrock08··on Google Wants to Make Silicon Valley as Bike-Friendly as Copenhagen
> The infrastructure issue isn't so simple.

It's really not that complicated though

> In my local we are in a real estate boom.

Congrats.

> There are many groups claiming that cars will not be so prominent in the near future.

So say we all.

> That view is taken onboard by zoning people when deciding on new buildings.

Good

> Rather than demand sufficient parking spots and upgrades to roads and mass transit,

Define sufficient? Many municipalities have historically had rules requiring 1 parking spot per 2 bedrooms, minimum 1 per unit. This adds a strange externality which changes the types of developments that are built. Upgrading roads isn't under the purview of the developer. Upgrading mass transit is similarly under the purview of the local government, not the developer.

> developers are allowed pretend that a large number of residents will bike to work. That means larger condo blocks with poorer connections, harming bikes, cars and transit.

Again, this really isn't the developers fault.

> There are a few "green" office blocks around here without any parking spots. So employees park on the street, annoying local business who want those spots used by customers.

The local governments should start charging more for parking then. Clearly parking is under-priced if people can park their all day.

> This is similar to the "elder housing" theory

It's really not like that at all. The "theory" here is that people won't buy a car because owning a car will be unnecessary or too expensive.

> In fact, old people go to lots of appointments,

Appointments that they probably shouldn't be driving to

>have carers that don't live with them,

Which if scheduled correctly shouldn't require 1 parking space per resident.

> are often visited by large numbers of family members.

Again, this is more a scheduling problem. Every resident's family doesn't need a dedicated parking spot every day.

> It's just a scam by developers to squeeze more condos into a given space without upgrading infrastructure.

I'd say that drivers and car companies have been running a scam for the past 50 years. Everyone got so used to their underutilized highways and ample parking that everyone bought a car. Unfortunately, as the population grew and got more dense that's not a reasonable status quo anymore, so either, we have to figure out how to fit more cars into less space, or we have to accept that the heyday of cars cars cars is over and learn to live without them.

jrock08··on Google Wants to Make Silicon Valley as Bike-Friendly as Copenhagen
Why shouldn't we spend some money to pave a bike path that could be well used. When I rode on the bayshore pathway, there were parts of the path that had been partially washed out, leaving about 3 feet of 2-5 inch ruts. Elsewhere there were infrequent, but pretty much constant 1 inch ruts in hard packed dirt. Elsewhere they had filled the path with a softpacked pea-gravel. You shouldn't have to break out a mountainbike and deal with drastically changing road surfaces to commute to work.
jrock08··on Google Wants to Make Silicon Valley as Bike-Friendly as Copenhagen
You're posing a false choice between biking and public transit. Biking and public transit can be improved together since, when properly designed, biking to public transit is a very easy way to extend the effective "bikeable" commute distance. Why do you think creating bike infrastructure would be more expensive than improving public transit?
jrock08··on Google Wants to Make Silicon Valley as Bike-Friendly as Copenhagen
False choice much?
jrock08··on Google Wants to Make Silicon Valley as Bike-Friendly as Copenhagen
Most local road infrastructure is already largely covered by general fund taxes, so if anything bikers should be able to use the roads they've already paid for.

http://taxfoundation.org/article/gasoline-taxes-and-tolls-pa...

jrock08··on Google Wants to Make Silicon Valley as Bike-Friendly as Copenhagen
> That is situation-dependant.

So let's do it where it makes sense

> I have seen slow bikes cause backups on roads.

Build bike lanes.

> I've also seen heavily-used bridge lanes turned into empty bike lanes.

Why didn't bikers feel safe on these lanes? Why weren't they used, or are they used, you just don't see it because you aren't looking during the right hours?

> Even when fully used, the carrying capacity (people moved / time) of a bike lane can be far less than a lane dedicated to buses or even cars. (It depends on slope and traffic speed.)

I've never been in a bike traffic jam, but I've been in more than my fair share of car traffic jams in high density areas. This is because cars take up more space per person than bikes, bikes are a very viable alternative to single person random access transport over short to medium distances while busses are not if the routes don't line up well. Obviously, for traveling 50 miles, there isn't a substitute for a car, but the point of this is to make urban areas bike and pedestrian friendly for the people that live in those areas, not necessarily to make it easier to drive through them.

http://www.seattlebikeblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/2n...

jrock08··on Google Wants to Make Silicon Valley as Bike-Friendly as Copenhagen
> dismantlement of motorvehicle-related infrastructure. Whether it is turning car lanes into bike lanes,

Yes, it turns out we overbuilt streets and under-built bike infrastructure so now we have to reclaim some car lanes to create bike lanes instead. This is not the end of the world.

> reducing available parking in new constructions

Reducing the required parking in construction doesn't eliminate parking in new constructions if parking is actually important, it just allows the free market to actually price parking instead of forcing non-drivers to subsidize parking spots.

> or new road taxes

Are you talking about congestion pricing here? If so, you chose to drive in an area which doesn't have the throughput to handle the cars, and yes, you should have to pay a fair price to use the road.

> their avowed goal seems to be to make driving more painful.

No, the goal is to make biking safe and possible. Driving has too long been the default, so you look at every attempt to claw back some semblance of balance for bikers as an affront to your right to drive.

jrock08··on Carnegie Mellon Reels After Uber Lures Away Researchers
As a grad student, let me explain why I don't think I'm getting ripped off.

1) I have (at least) weekly meetings with advisors who can charge >$250/hr as a consultant. They are brilliant, and our conversations are enlightening, and they actually care about the outcomes of their students. This might be out of the ordinary, but I've never felt exploited by my advisors. In CS, advisors are very aware that their students are giving up significant salaries to do a PhD.

2) I get paid enough to live, not incredibly well, but I make a median salary in the area, and at this point in my life I'm more than willing to share a 2br 2ba apt.

3) I'm encouraged to do internships which do pay extremely well, and on top of my living wage at school, mean I live really well.

4) I want a job that requires a PhD. Sure I could drop out, take my masters in AI, brand myself as a data-scientist and get a job doing some ML programming at a hedge fund making 300k base with 1MM bonus, but working at a research lab, or at a tier 2 institute as a faculty member seems like a much better life in the long run.

jrock08··on [dead]
It's amazing how much an article can be both correct and miss the point so strongly.

>"The critical limitation preventing EVs from disrupting the lowest end of the traditional auto market is battery performance, but battery costs are declining every day. As battery technology improves and costs continue to decrease, low end EVs will rapidly gain on their traditional competitors."

This is literally what Tesla is banking on. You can't sell a mass market car without low cost high density batteries, but you can't invest in low cost high density batteries without proving that people will buy electric cars. Which was the point of the Roadster and now the S and X. Battery technology won't improve from golf carts because golf carts only need to go 10 miles, and we've had batteries that could do that for years.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →