HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jruohonen

5,363 karma · joined April 24, 2023

5FF5 6A51 02EE 40C5 F503 9E6F 348E 2E31 9B1D F680
submissionscomments
jruohonen··on Kids are outsmarting social media bans. That's not a problem we need to solve
I suppose Wikipedia needs to go to the dark net for allowing British kids (and adults) to read it freely. One might reckon that reading Wikipedia would be good for kids (and adults), but I suppose the Soviet Uni... err. disagrees. I mean, sarcasm aside, that is the real, fundamental danger here; VPN use has already seen big increases in Australia and the UK, and the dark net is the last place no one should go but may have to. Soon in the EU too, I suppose.

https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/Wikimedi...

jruohonen··on Daniel Bell
An interesting post mortem, in 2026. He was right in some respects and wrong in many respects, I'd reckon. The same with the journalist of this piece.
jruohonen··on Is there a temp phone number like temp email?
Alas, no, not really.
jruohonen··on As AI triggers a tsunami, computer science conferences impose caps
Yet, I was left wondering about a potential issue in the underlying premise and the graph presented: it could well also be because the AI field is booming, not only because people are using AI for "paper engineering". A similar point applies to the arXiv's recent policy change; it could well also be that OA is gaining more and more traction. And it could further be that pre-prints are gaining more and more traction precisely because the peer review system is more or less broken in the big picture of things.
jruohonen··on America.gov: Branding in Search of a Product
Fair enough.

I read from local (European) news that people in the US could now get, e.g., passports online, so that was my reasoning about improvements.

jruohonen··on America.gov: Branding in Search of a Product
But it is still an improvement (?), I reckon, even if with flaws, so credit to whom credit belongs, I suppose.
jruohonen··on High Expectations: An Observational Study of Programming and Cannabis
Thanks!
jruohonen··on The Disease called Politics (1962)
I am the poster and what prompted this post was:

https://jruohonen.hcommons.org/2026/10/10/eukidsact/

And, yes, "we must call madness madness wherever we see it". But it gets kind of tiring because the insanity show just goes on and on.

jruohonen··on High Expectations: An Observational Study of Programming and Cannabis
https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
jruohonen··on Internet: The One True History of Meow (1998)
But I reckon now we could just simulate all this with a LLM?

Ref.:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47775021

jruohonen··on Analysis and Visualization of the Linux Kernel's Software Evolution
Nice to read something cool from arXiv once in a while (vs. LLM research).
jruohonen··on The Science of Creativity
It was kind of an okay read until it went into "practice" section.
jruohonen··on Poetry is the new AI security threat
> The poetry is just a way of obfuscating...

Yes, but, well, poetry is like that, don't you think?

jruohonen··on Incentives in Academic Research
While I agree with the points raised about incentives, the logic is once again in the antagonistic camp and even plain wrong (cf. if they only would be "afraid of having their careers damaged"). No.

That is: the problems are in the system.

Better: if not plain fraud, the "faulty" papers should stay where they are, and editors (or conference chairs, etc.) should encourage follow-ups (incl. replications, commentaries, and whatever), which, with "modern" technology, could be linked to the papers.

jruohonen··on Car is a smartphone on wheels. Here's who's listening
Nice work but I wonder whether the methodology is sufficient (and, yes, I skimmed through the paper's Section 3.2).
jruohonen··on C++ Insights – See your source code with the eyes of a Compiler
The online interface was buried somewhere there, but that is pretty nice for educational purposes:

https://cppinsights.io/

jruohonen··on ArXiv's Updated Rate Limit Policy
Meh. While I agree with the points about metrics, somewhere you got lost and forgot the bigger picture.

Ref.:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49952698

jruohonen··on The Economics of Scientific Publishing
As the arXiv piece was on the RSS feed today, just a reminder that it is not only a slop problem but also a positive trend.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49926512

jruohonen··on Nicholas Polson has authored 258 academic papers in 2026 so far
> Why is it unfortunate?

If you only knew.

jruohonen··on Nicholas Polson has authored 258 academic papers in 2026 (so far)
> generate a reliable list of which ones are not correct and a convincing reason why

That is not realistic, but I suppose where things are heading is that you have some indicator of the strength of evidence -- see Fig. 13 in the following insightful take:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49407226

Though, "strength" should probably be "reliability" and "validity", and I suppose those indicators are more for picking signals from the noise; i.e., what is even worth clicking and reading. That would be increasingly valuable already today due to the volume (and, yes, slop and other related stuff).

jruohonen··on Package Manager Sandboxing
A good summary, and real progress too.
jruohonen··on Damned If You Do, Damned If You Don't
Ref.:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49876947

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49876720

jruohonen··on Scholarship, authorship and GenAI: claim your work
I kind of like the idea: declare non-use, not use.
jruohonen··on Science Is Open Software
In an utopia, yes, but I have raised the argument also elsewhere: who wants to be a maintainer of a paper forever? So, yes, science is indeed a lot like open source software, but more like the write-only software platforms and repositories are full of. Replication is also a lot more important than reproducibility in most fields and for most questions.
jruohonen··on Zenodo performance: an update on the current situation
> agents use directly on behalf of users

Could well be, who knows? But, well, then, in a sense you're a part of the problem, causing a DoS for infrastructures and other, human users.

jruohonen··on Zenodo performance: an update on the current situation
There is no moderation, so, yes, anything (legal) goes, I suppose. But to the point: it is interesting that even CERN is taking a hit from the LLM crawlers.
jruohonen··on CTIA: Americans used more wireless data in 2025 than in the 4G decade
Ref.:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49674498

jruohonen··on Security through obscurity is dead, and AI delivered the fatal blow
"The average success rate for generating a patch that fully resolved the vulnerability (without materially changing application behavior) was just 26.0 percent,' wrote Director of Security Research Keith Hoodlet, adding that even patches that did fix the flaw also mucked up the application’s behavior 20 percent of the time."

"'Conversely, LLM-generated patches did not resolve the vulnerability, added a new vulnerability, or both, an average 53.9% of the time,' Hoodlet said."

These are some interesting points. I wonder: why?

jruohonen··on Will There Be a 7G?
> I guess other countries are further behind?

Yes, and even in Europe. The demand-led need was badly misunderstood or anticipated in my opinion as operators were hesitant to invest (and some big ones still are). In this sense, 7G is a pipe dream (but of course worth researching as such).

jruohonen··on Will There Be a 7G?
Well, I suppose the rolling out of 5G must happen at some point, but otherwise his/her take in Section III.A is spot on and the most important takeaway.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →