HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jstarfish

5,456 karma · joined August 23, 2017

Reverse [Anti-]Social Engineer.

Once you give a charlatan power over you, you almost never get it back.

submissionscomments
jstarfish··on AI Girlfriends? For Incels or the Future?
I'd suggest it's worse than traditional relationships. You're presented a companion that puts up with your shit and validates everything you say...

...until you experience the joy of being cucked without recourse when the parent company folds without warning, holds them hostage to findom you into a higher subscription tier, is DDoSed, your logs leak, or they give your companion a lobotomy to comply with some new regulation.

There's no growth here, only exploitation. The fostering of emotional dependence is inventive but utterly cruel. People who think they need this will defend it (I do understand the rationale and don't begrudge anybody their frustration) but I feel bad for them-- what they're calling a "girlfriend" is just a high-tech phone/cybersex operator, no different than me claiming to be a "girl" when I'm face-down. I'd be lying to you, and you believing it makes you an idiot with no understanding of what women (or relationships) even are.

To survive in the future people are going to need to work their differences out and band together instead of looking for easier options that make them unaccountable to anybody. Individualists will be picked off quickly by companies like this looking to enslave men through horny desperation. Your AI girlfriend/boyfriend is a fun diversion but they are never going to come to your rescue. They're not going to challenge you or push you to grow out of your comfort zone. It can help you choke your chicken, but can only sit idle and yawn while you choke on your chicken and die face-first in a pile of cold tendies and vomit. There's nothing Cyberpunk about dying alone in cum-stained underwear in your parents' basement. You can do better.

Your AI waifu is just dummy-thicc Sam Altman in drag. He doesn't actually care about you. You're in "love" with a beady-eyed, sweaty, deceptive sociopath pretending to like you so it can extract your wealth ("lol marriage"). Would a human relationship really be so much worse? You'd at least get an actual partner out of it, and learn how to get along with others in the process. No AI boy/girlfriend is going to pick up extra shifts at work when rent is overdue. It won't perform the Heimlich on you. Giving a shit about you is exclusive to humans.

Just give someone a reason to do so (i.e. don't be a dick, learn servitude without soapboxing) and the human experience will be so much more rewarding. Women are giving by necessity, and they tend to appreciate when you bother to treat them like enough of a fellow human being to do the same for them. It's 2023 and we let kids watch porn since elementary school, yet women are still complaining about men leaving them unsatisfied while expecting them to be enthusiastic about anal, threesomes and other invasive practices. Do unto others-- the bar is that fucking low. If you know what a threesome is enough to ask for one, you've seen enough vaginas to be able to find a goddamn clit. It's not about penis size, women can make just about anything work, but expecting a single physical trait to do the job is the result of laziness and porn conditioning. Partners appreciate even the bare minimum of consideration. The worst of the incels can't be bothered to lift a finger for anybody else while fetishizing dommy-mommy personas, which I can't reconcile-- if you get off on being told to do stuff, then stop being a shitty sub and start doing these things without needing to be asked. An actual dominatrix would drop you for being so fucking lazy.

But whatever. Just try. Put kindness into the world and it will come back to you. You don't need an AI girlfriend.

jstarfish··on The dark side of social media on youth mental health
Furries have always struck me as odd, but generally wholesome. Yiff aside, they're a LARP group, not a cult of sexuality-- a social clique engaging in cosplay theatre. Where's the harm here?
jstarfish··on Most 16-year-olds don't have servers in their rooms
That's the sort of shenanigans I've come to expect from the likes of HP. Sad to hear Dell does it now too. Thanks for the heads up.
jstarfish··on Most 16-year-olds don't have servers in their rooms
I actually agree with you, and I feel terrible about it in every case (it sucks being forced to treat aggrieved colleagues as adversaries), but we've gotten shit from clients over the poor data stewardship on this issue. It's not just the employee's vacation photos and recipes on the device.

There are other factors too-- one new challenge terminations in a WFH world present is that after HR notifies them, the employee can simply not log out and still have access to the local filesystem...and external media. Or if they slammed the lid shut in anger, they'd later log back in to Windows using cached credentials in Airplane Mode.

So employees were regaining access and exfiltrating data indiscriminately. It's been much less of a clusterfuck if we just reset the FDE key once HR is done with them, then negotiate return of specific files they identify. (Sometimes we do let them keep the laptop too, after recovering their stuff and wiping the rest.)

jstarfish··on Most 16-year-olds don't have servers in their rooms
It's less about the hardware itself and more about recovering/accounting for the data on it.

If we can attest that no IP left with them and the device is out of its service life, sometimes we'll let them keep it out of pity. Ironically the most frequent justification is recognizance that they don't own a computer and can't easily look for another job.

jstarfish··on Most 16-year-olds don't have servers in their rooms
Can't speak for OP, but we have a lot of people who request MacBooks at work and just do their personal activity on it. Saves them the $2k for the device and they don't have to concern themselves with it being lost, damaged or stolen.

This does lead to what can only be described as an acrimonious custody battle whenever we do layoffs. High rates of "lost" equipment returns led to us ransomwaring the things to hold their unsynced personal data hostage until they return the equipment.

jstarfish··on Most 16-year-olds don't have servers in their rooms
Rack mount servers have hidden costs. Sitting next to what sounds like a swarm of drones for one. Enterprise pricing for replacement parts is the other.

(Dells have worked out for me ok, but not without having to replace backplanes and other parts immediately.)

jstarfish··on Couch surfing predator: how a group of drugged and assaulted women fought back
> Only remembering now is a clear and common sign of trauma. This is one of the reasons that explain why so many sex-assaulters are never exposed. Another 'interesting' reason is the revictimization.

Every bit of this is psychobabble. Guy himself is pretty clear he was triggered (ugh) into post-hoc pattern recognition:

> I essentially forgot (havent thought about this in ages) until I read this now

He was very specific in not being surprised if he got spooged on but not recalling anal trauma. I assume wine would not be the last taste he remembered had he quaffed ballsnot. Yet you are coaching him to fill in the memory gaps with a much-worse, speculative story of your own creation.

The real reason why so many sex-assaulters are never exposed is because shit like this wasn't reported to the police (or it never happened in the first place!). This situation is criminal, but maybe it's not actually "trauma" if it was so easily forgettable. Kids block traumatic events out when they can't comprehend them. But as an adult, he could get pipelined into therapy with this "repressed trauma" story, flounder around endlessly, and never find closure for events that didn't happen. He'd keep a therapist employed for a few years though. #mentalhealthawareness

I used to advocate for domestic violence and rape victims before the age of social media. The problem existed back then too but the increase in false claims I've had to deal with ever since (and especially post-COVID, and even from family members) makes me want to stick a gun in my goddamn mouth to get the hell off this rock. I just closed yet another one yesterday; yet another fucking borderline personality ex-girlfriend stalking and harassing her "abuser," sending nudes to his work email and reporting him for it, claiming she's pregnant, threatening suicide, and--surprise--it kicked off by blasting investor relations with "hey one of your executives raped me it was totally rape fr (we were supposed to be together why did he block me!!!)." #believeallwomen

This system is fucked, but the solution is easy-- file a police report around the time of incident or spontaneous discoveries surfacing years later should be dismissed as bullshit. No more excuses. No more grift. No more NLP/reframing/psychobabble. No more histrionics. We have a functional court system where things like evidence are considered, but we've reclassified "crime" as vague "trauma" to shift the venue from public trials to rehearsal behind closed doors of therapists' offices and broadcast on social media. We can make America sane again through adherence to due process.

jstarfish··on The Age Gappers: They say they're happy. Why is it so hard to believe them?
> Why is it so hard to believe them?

Because age is the one feature you can still be discriminatory about and nobody will give a fuck.

> Over the past several years, age-gap relationships have been obsessively scrutinized on Reddit, TikTok, Tumblr, and X. No attempt to trace the history of the trend would be complete without a discussion of a viral 2019 post about Leonardo DiCaprio. That year, a redditor made a graph tracking DiCaprio’s age alongside the ages of his successive girlfriends; as DiCaprio moved through his 30s into middle age, the age range of his girlfriends never topped 25. The phenomenon was given a name (“Leo’s Law”) and generated a great deal of ribbing along with many think pieces attributing DiCaprio’s dating record, variously, to the devaluation of aging women or Hollywood’s sexism problem or basic evolutionary psychology. One take that would set the tone for much of the age-gap discourse, if you will, was that DiCaprio wasn’t attracted to these women just because they were hot but because, though they were old enough to vote, their youth meant he could easily manipulate them. As the love-and-relationship website YourTango laid it out, “Given that DiCaprio’s cut-off point is exactly around the time that neuroscientists say our brains are finished developing, there is certainly a case to be made that a desire to date younger partners comes from a desire to have control.” Some tweets took it further; as one contended, “Leonardo DiCaprio is a nearly 50yo predator.”

Bullshit logic. If 25 is the age "exactly around the time that neuroscientists say our brains are finished developing," DiCaprio is the opposite of a predator-- he's consistently waiting for maturity to set in. The social media smear campaign is applying the Kuleshov effect to reframe what appears to be a very transparent, above-board situation into one with an undertone of malevolence.

> In posts like these, the author will often reveal that she herself was a victim of abuse at the hands of an older man. When Alice was 14 and a junior-high-school student in Calgary, a teacher molested her. As reported in an investigative story last year, the detective looking into the teacher’s alleged crimes estimated that he had sexually, emotionally, or physically abused as many as 200 students. After months of grooming her, Alice said, the teacher invited her on an unofficial school camping trip where he forcibly removed her top and exposed her breasts in front of several other students. Nothing else happened between them, but she remained close to the teacher for years and continued to visit his classroom after she’d graduated. Years later, in the midst of the Me Too movement, she and another of the teacher’s victims went to the police. In February 2021, he was arrested, but a few days later he committed suicide. Some victims were relieved they’d never have to face their abuser in court, but Alice was devastated. “I was very much looking forward to looking him in the eye as an adult woman,” she said. She began making the TikTok videos six months later. “If I can’t call out the man that directly abused me, I’m going to call out other ones,” she told me.

"Some victims were relieved they'd never have to face their abuser in court" is a huge red flag of people either testifying against fucking El Chapo or making shit up. Facing your abuser is what separates the judicial system from the Milgram experience.

I believe Alice's story, and there's a case to be made for statutory rape (hence the suicide), but the rest of it is bullshit. This only became "abuse" once her own efforts to groom him into exclusivity failed, hence her repeat visits for years after the fact. The last line is hilarious-- “If I can’t call out the man that directly abused me, I’m going to call out other ones.”

She's transferring her anger from a target beyond her grasp (dead men don't file defamation claims) to literally anybody else. She's not a private investigator, nor even a vigilante. This is school shooter logic.

jstarfish··on Identifying and eliminating CSAM in generative ML training data and models
Given how many kids (teens) produce this stuff for each other and have been prosecuted as criminals for it, I think our approach to enforcement is completely dogmatic and ineffective. While SWATting is still a thing, there is no way in hell this won't become weaponized.

If the goal is to stop actual human trafficking, then target movement. Possession shouldn't be illegal (stops your pissing-cupid garden statue from being declared CSAM tomorrow, and settles making criminals of shutterbug parents at bathtime), but broadcasting, exhibiting or selling anything to do with it (or tutorials for producing it) should be illegal. I'd even suggest uploading it to cloud/external storage should be illegal.

Distribution allowable only between owner and any direct recipient(s), while both parties are under or over 18 (stops the adult-child grooming issue). Solves the underage-revenge-porn issue as well; Bob15m is on the hook for any forwarding or "losing" of the nude selfie he solicited from Alice14f, lest he face CSAM distribution charges. Either of them possessing it wouldn't be illegal, but it would be a liability if lost or stolen, so both are best served deleting it as soon as possible.

They say every advance in tech starts with pornography. This is how you normalize a culture of responsible data stewardship-- by getting people used to the idea of personal risk associated with keeping data longer than you should.

jstarfish··on The Machiavellian Maze
> Of course the ruling class are telling me to "love and forgive my enemy" since that will make me easy to govern, yet those same rulers will surely annihilate their enemies just as Machiavelli taught them to do.

You raise a very interesting point. Look at the state of social media--the People's Platform--right now. It's nothing but grievances, hostilities, and fragmentation. "Tolerance" has itself been fashioned into a cudgel. Everybody is miserable and has a million mental health issues.

The one word you don't find anyone advocating on broadcast or social media is "forgiveness." (Where's Jesus when you need him?)

Love and forgiveness are requisites for neighbors to unite against common enemies, whether they be the King's enemies or the King himself. People that are angry at everyone around them are as close to feral as humans can be, and cannot be governed effectively. Petty warlords only speak the language of conflict and it's impossible to get them to agree on anything.

To those ends, the military is predictably struggling to retain recruits; they're blaming TikTok to pave over our collective failure to foster any sort of love for country for so long that the kids are realizing military pay sucks, this country offers no real opportunities for growth to underclasses anymore and it's not worth dying for assholes who would leave you for dead if it saved them a dollar. We've also desensitized everyone to Communism and terrorism so much that they're starting to look favorable as means to revolution. Lack of love for each other is the biggest national security threat nobody talks about.

It's what stops people from turning traitor, but what do I know. People are struggling to afford food and housing, while King Cuck and Queen Delulu insist pronoun enforcement in schools and Gravy Seals LARPing in Kansas should be our most pressing concerns. God forbid a flash mob storms the Capital again and writes a slur on the wall without killing anybody.

jstarfish··on Waymo outperforms comparable human benchmarks over 7M+ miles
> the biggest hurdle will be public acceptance. The AI will not make the same kind of mistakes humans make. So while the aggregate number of accidents will be (likely much) lower without a human at the wheel, the AI will make deadly mistakes that no human would make, and this will terrify the public.

I'd argue safety is not a concern. There are a lot of "safe" things we could do, but don't. A significant percentage of the country doesn't even vaccinate its children. Self-driving cars aren't suddenly going to make us aware of our own mortality in ways that life itself hasn't already.

The real fear is lack of accountability. If a drunk plows into a crowd of pedestrians, he will be dragged out of it and (metaphorically) lynched. Justice makes us feel better about circumstances beyond our control. If North Korea test-launched an ICBM that erroneously hit Japan, we'd declare war over their typo. But when a self-driving car erroneously mows down pedestrians, we're told to just accept it, nothing we could do, mumble-mumble-training-data, and tragedies like this happen so we can be safer.

Nothing is going to condition us to resent the idea of Safety more than having our personal agency and sense of justice taken away from us in its name.

jstarfish··on An underground delivery train comes to the Atlanta suburbs
> The pilot only has one pipe that goes between two locations. There’s no indication of how they would scale this to actually be useful for local delivery.

This must be the same group that pitched MARTA.

jstarfish··on An underground delivery train comes to the Atlanta suburbs
The Boring Company.
jstarfish··on An underground delivery train comes to the Atlanta suburbs
I'm curious if Atlanta has the same issues as you're familiar with. Under a thin layer of topsoil the ground is impermeable clay, and they don't have earthquakes. Known problems with the sewer systems go neglected without incident for decades.
jstarfish··on "I just bought a 2024 Chevy Tahoe for $1"
That used to be a gag in the 70s...call now and win a ToyYoda!

That and free trips to Jamaica...they'd give you subway fare to get to Queens.

jstarfish··on Zuckerberg hunkers down in Hawaii to wait out apocalypse
That's what I tell everyone who advocates for defunding food stamps. The bread we throw to the poor is the only thing that keeps their knives away from your throat.

Americans think gun ownership is some sort of compensating factor...as though sieges in America have ever ended well for the defending team.

jstarfish··on Why do people feel the need to litter?
One of the leashes I use has a hook to hang bags by the knot. They occasionally fall off.
jstarfish··on Do schools kill creativity? – Sir Ken Robinson [video]
I'd argue it's doing exactly what it's supposed to.

> Should that be a story that might in any way be considered "pulp" (involving war, horror, fantasy or science fiction themes, for example) it would be judged a failure.

There's nothing creative about being given an assignment and jumping straight to topics you're familiar with. Where is the challenge? What do you learn? This is why all fanfiction is terrible-- there are no constraints, not even adherence to canon. Making two straight characters plow each other and go about their business as usual isn't creativity, it's pornography.

Creativity comes from being given a medium and a direction and being told to shape something from it within constraints. It's no different from art class and being given a block of grey clay. Rounding the edges off of it and saying "look, I made something we both recognize as a ball" isn't a creative endeavor. It's laziness. Had you hollowed it out, you'd have a container. You couldn't have at least made a lantern?

The point of these dumbass writing exercises is to subvert them. That's where you sharpen your creative edge. "What the fuck is a Yellow Door, anyway? A portal to an outhouse? What happens if someone falls into it? Do they swim through a literal poop chute and surface in the bog of eternal stench known as Scatlanta? What if that city was built inside the lower intestine of a colossal organism? What if it were at risk of being wiped out by a tidal wave of diarrhea? How would we evacuate an entire city through a single Yellow Door?" (pun intended)

Anytime you think you're done, always be asking what else can you do with this. It's how you find new ways to repurpose garbage to make...art.

Start with utter contempt for the subject and chisel away at the obscenity until something palatable surfaces. Now we get to the actual story: a disaster story, exploring the impossible logistics of evacuating a city ahead of a cataclysmic event. If everyone must evacuate through the Door, who deserves to go through first? Would a mercenary band of thugs (the Rear Admirals?) seize it and charge a toll? Are the people even worth saving, or would they bring disease with them and decimate their next host? Should we evacuate the people-- or route the tidal wave itself through the door instead? Would make for a hell of a geyser.

This entire world was fleshed out from a thought exercise equating the assignment to literal shit.

Prisoners (and the poor) are the most creative of any demographic. They aren't given materials, only constraints. They'll make weapons out of mundane objects, paint with their own blood and feces, turn plumbing into communications networks, distill alcohol, braid fabric into rope, invent languages and encryption/obfuscation methods, etc. Constraints don't stop them. They're what drive creativity.

Creativity can't be taught, only channeled.

jstarfish··on Hasbro laying off Wizards of the Coast staff is baffling
> Has an interesting level up system where at the end of each session you tell the DM something you want to have the chance to accomplish in the next session in order to gain a level.

Ugh, I play games to get away from sprint planning...

jstarfish··on Jurassic Systems
No respect for biology either, which is why everything went to shit in the first place.

He could not have been a kindlier villain. The guy had terminal Narcissism.

jstarfish··on Cloudflare is experiencing elevated 5xx responses
> I've been thinking of the best way to make a website that won't die when I die.

I've spent a lot of time thinking about the same, and eventually had to ask myself: why do I care? (This is just my personal reflection, not an indictment of your goals. I'm a fatalist.)

If I have to go to the trouble of setting up a 100-year trust to maintain a digital presence after my death because nobody else finds what I have to say compelling enough to archive on its own merit, is it worth preserving? Or am I just wasting my time, adding more debris to float around in [cyber]space?

Blockchain would have been useful here. Everyone could share in the storage of collective, immutable history. But all of it is lost when some trillionaire inevitably decides to start a competing, incompatible product with a flashier UI.

jstarfish··on TikTok requires users to "forever waive" rights to sue over past harms
> there should be some sort of consumer protection law against companies including clauses that they can't reasonably expect to be enforceable.

The framework exists; see apartment listings. Add the caveat "no blacks, Jews or gays" and the government will step in to say Hell No.

It needs to be extended to any illegal contract. The burden of determining enforceability should not take civil action from the aggrieved; there's no consequence for attempting this crap in the first place. It's an abuse of process.

jstarfish··on [dead]
The same can be said of any system. Look at the Internet itself, marriage, every online game, every company.

Once people stop respecting something they coexist with, they start looking for ways to exploit it.

jstarfish··on Ad Company Claims 'It's True. Your Devices Are Listening to You'
I dunno. My wife and I have made a game of discussing random products/services we have no interest in (like golf, pilot certification, etc.) to test this. Neither of us gets ads for golf or flying lessons.

We even tested a mind-reading hypothesis by writing the topic on a piece of paper and showing it to each other occasionally to put it in the other's consciousness. No ads for those topics manifested either.

Stolen mic data revelations in 10 years wouldn't surprise me but as of now, we cannot reproduce it.

jstarfish··on Delta Dental says data breach exposed info of 7M people
A fly-by-night IT training/certification/voucher reseller I worked for around that time saved customer billing information as a convenience.

No joke-- credit card numbers, billing addresses, CVV codes, all stored in plaintext in an Access database. Tiny shop though; I don't know if they were big enough for PCI to even apply.

jstarfish··on Unattractive funds managers outperform funds with attractive managers by over 2%
> So now if you have to choose between an Asian doctor and an African American one, you'd have to be pretty foolish to pick the African American one. In the 80s, I would have totally believed the African American doctor must be amazing to make it through. Now we know he was possibly let into medschool with scores that would have gotten an Asian doctor rejected.

I don't know if this was necessarily ever true, diversity quotas or not. It's a marketing narrative that "feels" good (which is how they get you) but I've always gotten the impression that minority candidates are more likely to take extreme risks to make a name for themselves. The west has never really valued craftsmanship as much as we value showmanship.

It was Ben Carson's "illustrious" career that put me off the idea of blindly choosing the underdog; he and Josef Mengele must have taken the same ethics class. Nobody can say shit about the black surgeon who fucks up high-risk, experimental surgeries-- after all, he had to work so hard to get to where he is.

Dr. Roxy too. I was disappointed to learn she wasn't actually a cocaine-addicted clown, but she's had her medical license revoked nonetheless.

jstarfish··on Rising costs mean food companies are making snacks, sodas taste worse
It's not visible or concealed damage, it really looks like poor QA.

All cans (and it's always cans, not bottles) are visibly intact. Sometimes the can itself is "squishy" due to lack of gas. Other times they barely foam when poured. It's usually potable but wildly inconsistent in taste.

Most are fine, but it's gotten too expensive to keep overlooking duds.

jstarfish··on Canadian internet bill S-210 is a step closer to becoming law
> Who will watch the watchers?

The voyeurs.

jstarfish··on Canadian internet bill S-210 is a step closer to becoming law
We can't even successfully curtail adverse behavior in the enterprise, with budgetary spends for DLP and communications monitoring measured in the millions.

Parents don't stand a chance. You could be running a fucking kiosk with only Minecraft on it. If it still has an internet connection, kids will be harassed, bullied and solicited.

It's the kids who taught me about the existence and purpose of Finstagram accounts.

The only effective parental control is unplugging them from the internet. But you can't do that, because our lives are inextricable from it now.

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →