HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jstarfish

5,456 karma · joined August 23, 2017

Reverse [Anti-]Social Engineer.

Once you give a charlatan power over you, you almost never get it back.

submissionscomments
jstarfish··on Neonatal circumcision associated with altered adult socio-affective processing
Phimosis still exists, and does affect a minority of boys. It's the official medical reason to do it.
jstarfish··on Neonatal circumcision associated with altered adult socio-affective processing
No need. They're already having less sex than previous generations.

It turns out if you redefine the mechanics of docking to the point where nobody can recognize themselves or their role in the exchange of personnel, nobody can negotiate the Fucking Protocol.

jstarfish··on Neonatal circumcision associated with altered adult socio-affective processing
> Previous preliminary research has reported an association between circumcision and alexithymia (i.e., dysfunctions in emotion recognition, social attachment, and interpersonal relations) in adults (Bollinger and Van Howe, 2011). More recently, two large-sample studies suggested a positive correlation between circumcision and autism spectrum disorder (ASD; Bauer and Kriebel, 2013; Frisch and Simonsen, 2015a). Although the causal implications of this research has been questioned (Morris et al., 2012; Morris and Wiswell, 2015), these studies suggest that early-circumcision might have an impact on adult psychosocial functioning.

This can't be right...one of those correlation is not causation situations?

I hesitate to take the side of Brian J. "B.J." Morris (a contentious individual, to be polite) but here we are.

US surgery rates have been declining since the 60s as autism diagnoses increase. Half the population in Israel, the Middle East and southeast Asia should be autistic by now.

I don't see where they looked at how many intact kids were diagnosed with autism, only that there's a "positive association" with circumcision, which means little. We fell for that logic once already with the HIV prevention claims. Fool us twice and we...can't get circumcised again?

This is interesting though:

> Circumcised infants display increased pain responses during subsequent vaccination, suggesting that behavioral effects of the surgery can last, at a minimum, up to 4–6 months

And this:

> Finally, one recent study has found that neonatal male circumcision and prematurity were associated with Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS), providing support for the allostatic load hypothesis (i.e., the result of cumulative perinatal painful, stressful, or traumatic events) as an explanation for SIDS (Elhaik, 2018).

Circumcision, vaccinations, autism, SIDS all mentioned in the same context...

Girls don't get clipped but everybody gets vaccines. Most other cultures that snip boys tend to wait until puberty. They also inconsistently vaccinate and don't have mysterious infant death syndromes.

Maybe there's something to avoiding causing infants pain.

jstarfish··on The economics of all-you-can-eat buffets (2020)
This is a very human-centric view ;)

I'm in the "every life is sacred" camp, but...even if you do kill one animal and leave it to rot, it's not a total waste, just a "cruel" one.

Other things feed off of the carcasses of animals the same as you or I do. We just consider all other organisms beneath us, so if we kill and discard something, we write it off as a total waste. Birds, dogs, rodents and microorganisms disagree.

jstarfish··on Baldur's Gate 3 Wins Game of the Year at the Game Awards
Huh. Thanks for being brave enough to articulate that. You're not the only one tired of twinks being the face of gayness.

It's a fucking RPG in a medieval setting about a sadistic world full of actual dungeons. Where are the leathermen? Why are wisened bosses of dungeons not called...Masters?

(I'm jello-sexual. Don't knock the Cube.)

jstarfish··on Chronic fatigue syndrome is more common than some past studies suggest, CDC says
My doctor is pushing me to buy some ring-shaped sleep apnea monitor.

I don't think I have CFS or sleep apnea (I'm tired because I sleep like shit because I drink way too much caffeine before bed), but it's a possibility not explored in physicals.

jstarfish··on Helen Toner shares her side
> Leadership is fundamentally about manipulating people.

This is true...if you are the leader of a cult, which exist to deify you more than benefit the group.

> If the people already agreed, they wouldn't need leadership. Your job as leader is to get them all working in more or less the same direction, even though they don't really want to.

Yes, but if you're having to puppet people to do it, it's not leadership. It's just manipulation. You should be able to do this through inspiration, and transparently in group settings, not by compartmentalizing lies and half-truths privately. That's just fucking embarrassing. Altman's leadership skills are on par with a 14-year old influencer.

I feel like you're taking the argument for why "we let Pearl Harbor happen" and using it to excuse the whims of a psychopath.

jstarfish··on Helen Toner shares her side
> Is an attempt to manipulate the other board members into firing one board member reason enough to be fired?

Yes. He's not a teenage girl, he's the CEO of a nonprofit. At his level this is fraudulent misrepresentation.

jstarfish··on Coding Addiction: How Programming Affects Your Brain
> It feels very similar to my compulsion to pick up litter. While hiking, walking the dog, etc. I. Just. Can't. Stand. Seeing. Trash. Every. Where. It really takes me out of my happy place. I'm just so much more relaxed, resolved when litter (or bugs) are gone.

Be glad you don't have compulsive hoarding tendencies.

When I spend too much time playing Pokemon, Red Dead Redemption or Metal Gear V, I find myself planning to capture every animal, pick every flower and steal every shipping container I come across.

jstarfish··on Coding Addiction: How Programming Affects Your Brain
> with none of the pesky real life issues around physically building something, getting permissions, budgets, collaborating with workers, waiting for paint to dry etc.

Huh. It used to be fun for those reasons. I've gotten so burned out on coding in recent years because once the cloud became part of the stack, so did bureaucracy-- permissions, budgets, collaboration, dictation of style, opaque errors, legal review, bespoke CI/CD configurations, security-related constraints, etc.

Coding just doesn't feel empowering anymore. It's like making a sandwich and having to go petition Congress before you're allowed to eat it.

We had an incident at work that required multiple people working on a tedious task overnight; it was refreshing to just hammer out a sloppy script, write some tests, sneakernet it and see the prospect of a long night reduced to minutes.

jstarfish··on Purple Llama: Towards open trust and safety in generative AI
Just call it what it is-- social engineering (really, manipulation).

"Injection" is a narrow and irrelevant definition. Natural language does not follow a bounded syntax, and injection of words is only one way to "break" the LLM. Buffer overflow works just as well-- smalltalk it to death, until the context outweighs the system prompt. Use lots of innuendo and ambiguous verbiage. After enough discussion of cork soakers and coke sackers you can get LLMs to alliterate about anything. There's nothing injected there, it's just a conversation that went a direction you didn't want to support.

In meatspace, if you go to a bank and start up with elaborate stories about your in-laws until the teller forgets what you came in for, or confuse the shit out of her by prefacing everything you say with "today is opposite day," or flash a fake badge and say you're Detective Columbo and everybody needs to evacuate the building, you've successfully managed to get the teller to break protocol. Yet when we do it to LLMs, we give it the woo-woo euphemism "jailbreaking" as though all life descended from iPhones.

When the only tool in your box is a computer, every problem is couched in software. It smells like we're trying to redefine manipulation, which does little to help anybody. These same abuses of perception have been employed by and against us for thousands of years already under the names of statecraft, spycraft and stagecraft.

jstarfish··on Purple Llama: Towards open trust and safety in generative AI
> For instance, it might have checked that he was in an unsupported region first, before making him jump through hoops.

Why would they do that?

Not doing it inflates their registration count.

jstarfish··on Purple Llama: Towards open trust and safety in generative AI
Now do "submissive and breedable."
jstarfish··on He blew the whistle on Amazon. He's still paying the price
> Like what the hell did you do that you really don't want others to find out..?

It doesn't matter. This still applies even if you haven't done anything yet.

Nobody wants to be friends with the kid who narcs on everyone. Show me the man and I'll show you the crime he's committed. Why subject yourself to that?

jstarfish··on He blew the whistle on Amazon. He's still paying the price
> TBH that's the only circumstance in which I think it would make sense to whistle blow.

It's equally-lucrative in Defense. You won't work anywhere ever again, but the DoD pays out enough to make it worth your while.

jstarfish··on Psychologists say they can't meet the growing demand for mental health care
> I have almost never ever heard a thoughtful person blame God, nor even say he has any sway at all.

I'm drawing from a Catholic/Lutheran upbringing from decades ago, but the verbiage is never "this is God's fault," it is kinder euphemisms like "this is God's plan" or "God is testing us."

You're expected to endure whatever it is, not react to it. Whatever it is that you're going through was always supposed to happen, so keep marching onward, Christian soldier, out of faith that God will guide you out of this and that there will be cake at the end of the trial.

> They wouldn't blame anything on God IMO, but if they did, they would be very clear that the reaction to the problems is 100% on you.

Well, Catholics lean this way I guess, but what I remember was more shaming people for being bad adherents to the faith, not so much grandma died because you touch yourself. She was always going to die when she did because God willed it.

jstarfish··on Psychologists say they can't meet the growing demand for mental health care
> Consider further a world in which there are many minds for whom sensitivity to being wrong is such a high priority, as you seem to want it to be, that they may try and avoid formulating stances or taking positions at all. Lest they be wrong. [...] Sometimes it can be helpful to have someone explain to you how you have to have some confidence in your own capacity for intuition, your own ability make decisions, in order to make anything happen.

We all live in that world. These hypothetical individuals sound like people in desperate need of direction, not self-reflection. People don't go to therapists because everything's great and they're thinking clearly; therapists have a naturally-exploitable customer base.

Left to their own devices, these wayward souls tend to end up radicalized in some way. Your suggested approach sounds an awful lot like the outcome of grooming-- "I didn't tell you to do that. You wanted to do it." Make anyone spend enough time miring in their own confused thoughts and they'll start to normalize and rationalize whatever it is. No wonder we have so many gender-confused kids running around; they're exposed to the topic constantly. If that's what therapy amounts to, we can call off the labor shortage, because any accomplished child molester has the qualifications to do this job...I'm sure they need the work.

For some reason, doctors have little problem proscribing direct advice to ailing patients-- "you're dying because you won't stop eating cheesecake and smoking meth." Why are therapists so resistant to telling clients they're unlikable assholes and they need to fix their shit? Why the "need" for florid introspection that distracts from obvious problems, unless it's an intelligence-gathering exercise, looking for something else to blame or ideate? No other professional service works like this except fortune-tellers and the church (through confessionals) and their track record is about as effective. My mechanic doesn't wax poetic about thermodynamics, ask about the journeys I've been on with the vehicle and blame the engineers when my car doesn't start.

> It doesn't suggest to me the task, or the institution that is still in its earliest years of trying to formally study it, is fundamentally flawed.

My point remains: perceptions are subjective, are easily manipulated, and are frequently wrong. Eyewitness testimony is incorrect 50-fucking-percent of the time. This institution has already had scandals involving "discovery" of false memories and other manipulations of both its own personnel and the public. I've even had one insist I was molested despite no such attestations on my part (and it not being true). Psychiatrists have vouched for the perceived rehabilitation of rapists and murderers up for parole, who then immediately proceeded to rape and kill again within hours of release.

There are other peculiarities too, like insistence that hypersexuality is exclusively an artifact of abuse (and not at all precocious/excessive access to pornography), while sex addiction is not recognized at all in the DSM-V-- yet they'll offer to treat you for something they say doesn't exist. They like to tout the idea of all this domestic and sexual abuse going on based on what patients report, but it's not like they conduct any actual investigation-- they'll believe anything you tell them at face value (it's how Sybil got away with it for so long).

On that note, they've managed to legitimize what we used to call demonic possession as multiple/disassociative personality disorder. Here's an open challenge: prove it. So far, the highest-profile cases they've put forth have all been frauds, and it's so easy to act out the symptoms of that there are entire subreddits and hashtags dedicated to overprivileged children LARPing it. Why it's even still in the book, I cannot fathom.

It is junk science. They have some neat ideas about behavioral classification and CBT is as useful for humans as it is for dogs, but that's about it.

jstarfish··on Psychologists say they can't meet the growing demand for mental health care
> I always recommend they talk to a priest instead. [...] Priests study people and have experience bonding people.

I disagree. The only difference between a priest and a therapist is that one blames God and the other blames everybody except You. Both are salesmen who externalize your problems on your behalf.

The church has a unique triangulation tactic in that they can bond a couple against supernatural forces. Therapy doesn't have that. The closest they come is blaming someone's parents.

jstarfish··on Psychologists say they can't meet the growing demand for mental health care
> your perspective is what matters

This is everything that is wrong with this institution in a nutshell.

If one is--literally--mentally unwell (ill), their perspective is flawed by definition.

The industry has found that humoring flawed perspectives drives repeat business, like me selling a drowning man a glass of water. You can't say I'm not helping him, but I am deliberately not giving him the help he needs.

jstarfish··on UK porn watchers could have faces scanned
> How will they stop kids from running stable diffusion locally and generating any kind of porn they like?

A dedicated chip that slaps Margaret Thatcher's face on all generated output.

jstarfish··on UK porn watchers could have faces scanned
> Why in the holy hell as the world's governments taken such an interest in the sex lives of their citizens?

You're looking at it too narrowly.

Anything anyone can "take away" from you has power over you. It's a dominance play.

Government controls how you engage in sex.

Telcos control who you talk to.

Media controls what you see and hear.

Automakers control how you move.

Banks control how you trade.

I'm sure there are more examples (look how difficult it is to homestead anywhere), but the point is that in gatekeeping functions critical to our existence, we're always beholden to someone. Capturing two of these forms the basis of a cult. No surprise the Church used to worm its way into as much of this stack as possible; these days it's Big Tech doing the same.

jstarfish··on AI and Mass Spying
> How we would get to that point, that I don’t know yet, but it’s a valid option going forward.

Chaos engineering. As a modern example, all this gender identity stuff wreaks absolute havoc on credit bureau databases.

Tomorrow, we'll have people running around in fursuits to avoid facial recognition. After that, who knows.

jstarfish··on AI and Mass Spying
Ha. You'd like to think so, but it's going to be awfully hard to coordinate resistance when the mass spying sweeps everyone up in a keyword-matching dragnet before the execution phase. This is the problem with every outgroup being labelled "terrorists."

Sabotage will be the name of the game at that point. Find ways to quietly confuse, poison, overwhelm and undermine the system without attracting the attention of the monitoring apparatus.

jstarfish··on Toxic comments are associated with reduced volunteer activity on Wikipedia
I (used to) answer questions in comments. It became too discouraging to post an answer that took 20 minutes to write and get immediately downvoted because someone disagrees with any single part of it (or they're trying to promote their own answer by suppressing everyone else's).

Comments can't be downvoted. MetaFilter had the right of it.

jstarfish··on Toxic comments are associated with reduced volunteer activity on Wikipedia
In the rare occasion I'm desperate enough to ask a question, I dread seeing the red inbox notification. I think I've abandoned the last three questions I asked because I couldn't stomach facing the drama I expected.

The cultural norms of internet forums should never have been allowed to take root on a Q&A site. There is nothing "professional" (or even helpful) about answering questions with out-of-scope proscriptions.

Your plumber doesn't show up asking why you want your toilet fixed, nor does he tell you your house is messy, give you dietary advice and passive-aggressively insinuate you need to fix your roof. SO responders are mini-spouse syndrome incarnate.

jstarfish··on 23andMe confirms hackers stole ancestry data on 6.9M users
Did anybody actually buy it though? This could be misdirection, or just misguided marketing based on historical instances of abuse. China isn't known for trying to repatriate descendants, and it's not exactly difficult to find Jews.

Ancestry data would certainly be of interest to a particular demographic known to discriminate by caste. There's no escaping your low-class heritage when anyone can look up your stolen DNA profile on the black market.

jstarfish··on 23andMe confirms hackers stole ancestry data on 6.9M users
Unless you speak Kikongo.
jstarfish··on 'Safe' alternatives to engineered stone bench tops may not be so safe: study
> It is a psychological condition if you truly are immune to peer pressure.

By that criteria, I must be a psychopath. Integrity is not a psychological condition. Lack of it is.

Yours is the logic that leads to people "just following orders." Nazi see, Nazi do!

In this case, it's not a culture of avoiding PPE. That's propaganda from shitty contracting firms trying to save a few bucks by not providing PPE in the first place. The illegal laborers they hire to do the work aren't ever in a position to complain.

jstarfish··on New study confirms: Many adults opt for child-free life without regret
And this is sexist rhetoric framing a stereotype.

Why should men ever be anything but men?

jstarfish··on New study confirms: Many adults opt for child-free life without regret
The occasional war corrects this imbalance. We're overdue.

The longer I live, the more I recognize that everybody has a role despite any apparent flaws. Take gays-- in a hunter-gatherer society, a clique not burdened by children to protect are free to become scouts or trailblazers; they have mobility. This childless-by-choice stuff is a modern invention and not an option for sexually-active adults otherwise.

We don't all have the same purpose. We're more like ants than we want to admit.

← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →