HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jstrafy

53 karma · joined October 22, 2021

submissionscomments
jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
It doesn't! Which services do you use that are built with these standards?
jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Thanks, Charles!

We actually had a call a few months ago, September I believe. I'm also in your Circles Matrix room!

Haters are great, always good to have an opposite opinion and people feel strongly enough to write something (whether good or bad)!

Agreed on that though, shoot me an email! You should also get speaking to Jackson (https://twitter.com/otherJackson) who's working on data standards for the web as a whole.

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Fixed and will be live once site refreshes.
jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Great idea, annoyingly they don't have this type of API interaction! If so, would build a great client app that allows people to take the best parts of Facebook without the many negatives.

Thanks!

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Thanks!
jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Thanks for the comment. Having an FAQ would have been a nice way to cover this as it seems you're not the only one!

We plan to monetise through paid premium features, none of which have been included in the first public version of the product. So previously didn't think it was relevant to talk monetisation!

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
- Ads on any sort of app are generally targeted. Meaning they use personal information, including browsing history, to serve you specific ads that you are more likely to click on. By encrypting data at rest and, asking for little personal information, we purposely make it more difficult for us as a company to serve targeted ads. Ideally it would be impossible and this is what we aim for in the short term.

- Fair point. Noted.

- Both points here would be a relatively easy step, so will figure something out. Thanks!

- Noted. Thanks!

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Hey, thanks for the considered comment! Appreciate the thoughts here, and all are noted. We'll answer a lot of these concerns with next steps.
jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
All noted. Thanks!
jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Yes, in hindsight this is in my mind! First time founder and Circles was the first piece product/code that I wrote on my own accord, evolved quite a lot but still some decisions I would make again.

Web-app seems to be the consensus here so will definitely keep that in mind. Thanks for the feedback!

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Appreciate the comment! We do this to see if there is an existing user for a connection (like any chat app). We don't store the contact book on a server nor process anything other than that.
jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
I can understand the hesitation, it's something we'll consider changing back or making opt-in.

Thanks for the grace there, and that's a problem we are solving. You might have X contacts on Circles but you're only going to see from those you have placed in a circle. So only content from people you actually want to see from.

In terms of syncing contacts, we don't store any contact book information on our servers. We pass through the contact book to see if a user exists there, we return them back as a connection. If not we return them as someone you can invite.

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Skeptic's take is always appreciated!

- They do. There's definitely overlap there although because groups are often centred around a topic (school, work, hobby), it's generally not the place to share things that aren't directly concerning the group/people in the group. Eg. I want to a great building I've just visited, I'm generally not going to share it to the group chat for my class in my masters, but I would like certain people to see about it. Circles here are closer to a broadcast list.

- Somewhat true, I think there are many points of failure in that case study. Our hypothesis is that by making a social network function entirely through circles, people will have a much more enriching and intimate experience. This has been proven true with current users, despite it not being for everyone.

- Noted. Thanks for this.

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Hey! Love the landing page for StoryArk & thanks for the ideas!

Super similar concept. A few apps I've seen pop up in the space are Lalo (https://www.lalo.app/) and Waldo (https://waldophotos.com/).

Yes, we initially had it this way and it seems from this HN launch that's what users prefer! The feature is flagged so we can bring it back and will likely do so (having an opt-in as you've mentioned).

Would be great to connect and share learnings. If you'd like send me an email (james@oncircles.com).

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Thanks - that's awesome to hear! We're still early days and would love your feedback. Feel free to send me an email (james@oncircles.com).

It would have been a great idea to add a small price in the app store, as my core assumption was that people would not pay for a social networking app alone. Maybe I will change my assumption there. You don't need to answer this if uncomfortable doing so (or can send by email) but how much would you pay today to know the app is sustained ad-free?

Otherwise, we are fortunate to be funded by a single angel who gives us freedom to decide the path of the company. He invested with the recognition that the tides on privacy and social media are changing and that a more intimate, private social network would be a definite solution in the future (In his words, "the two most important parts of anyone's network are the closest circles and the fringes, so Circles focuses on the former").

Our next stop was to build a Circles designed interoperable chat that would allow you to send and receive messages to pretty much any major third party app. We would charge for this. However, right now we collect no individual data from our users and most user information is encrypted at rest, making it very hard for us to build any real ads mechanism.

In relation to group chats, there is a notable difference in how Circles are set up. In a group chat everything is shared to the group, and all the members are directly connected to each other because they are in that group. Circles in their current setup are closer to broadcast lists.

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Appreciate the comment. As mentioned in some comments we will continue to push the privacy front as far as possible, until then we've tried to be clear about communicating where we are with that (and clear about what we're not yet doing privacy wise).

1. The vast majority of our privacy is in product experience. Sharing with less people instead of everyone, making reactions and comments only visible between mutual contacts. 2. Names, Posts, comments and replies are encrypted at rest. 3. We sync your phonebook for contact discovery and don't store it on our servers. Therefore it is not linked to your identity. This is a hard problem to solve as Signal wrote in this blog post (https://signal.org/blog/contact-discovery/)

That said, privacy is a super important issue and external testing and open-sourcing is something that we desire to do. So thanks for the checker here!

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Great question. The major difference is that you need to add people to Circles to see from and share to them, the entire UX is focused on Circles.

Often people don't use the list feature on Facebook because a core product assumption of Facebook is that everyone you add is your friend, and lists are not a priority in the Facebook experience. The Facebook sharing experience is also centred around engagement, where more numbers makes you look better. So users have the option of using lists on Facebook but there's little incentive placed there.

Lists also don't have much impact what you see. This means on Facebook the vast, vast majority of content still comes from people you don't really care about and random content accounts from businesses and influencers. So secondarily, Circles feed is simply chronological and only contains direct content from people you have added to a circle.

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Thanks! It's been interesting as I used the first prototype to learn how to code. There's been breaks between then and now but that was 18 months ago - a lot of the premises for building Circles have been adopted by IG. Close Friends, Send to Groups, DM focus and easy account switching.
jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Thanks for the feedback! It depends on the context, I think for most it is too much work but we're not focused on building a tool for everyone right now (on that I wish we could be more targeted in our marketing).

True most networks are passive, and the public networks are catering for this. I would also agree that the chat apps is a great solution for close connections and often use this as their primary social network for this reason.

From experience, because chat is a linear thread, conversation focused and notification heavy, it's really not good for sharing things that don't directly concern the person/group you're talking to.

So Circles is all about creating a space for sharing your life with those who matter most, sharing things that you don't necessarily need to share but would like to away from the spotlight of social media. For example I've been sharing my travels in Portugal to my close friends and family circles (around 20 people who are mainly not interconnected). If I did this on chat I would be opening/maintaining 10+ conversations about myself! This is the problem we're solving currently.

That said, overall I agree that there's an overlap there that takes away from the value we offer to people right now. Gotta start somewhere though!

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Super simple, I didn't know how to code 18 months ago so when we started (was just I at that point), I stared building with what I could.

The front end is built with React Native (JS) as it provides a way for us to more or less maintain two OS with one codebase. It also is somewhat simple for us to convert out code for web with react-native-web. We do use a series of community build packages (more than I would like) but that's how its went for us early stage.

The back end is built with Rails as a simple API layer, keeps it simple to make models and controllers and build lightly with the focus on the architecture. Phone verification integrated through Twilio and we use Lockbox for at-rest encryption.

Hosted serverless on AWS EB (if going back I would stick to Heroku at least until this point and beyond).

As an experiment we also were building on top of the Matrix protocol (https://matrix.org/) with their Ruby SDK, but the cons outweighed the benefits in the end. Would love to figure out a solution here, and love the idea of interoperability championed by products like beeper.com.

Overall, I think that React/React Native and Rails is a good stack for hacking MVPs and would recommend.

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Thanks! Love the feedback.

Good point and something we haven't experienced before. There definitely needs to be a workaround. We had manual search and add in a previous version so

The answer here is UX. Google+ UX was clunky at best, where their circles feature was essentially just an add on to the Facebook experience (which facebook then replicated through lists). On Circles, the whole app runs through Circles and we've focused the app entirely on the benefit of adding people to Circles and creating more intimate connections with people.

Great point. I think for influencer, B2C type accounts, for now people should definitely continue to use Instagram as its not something we're entertaining for now. However, the way WeChat (I lived in China for a while) splits personal and business connection is fantastic and something I think about a lot.

In time we'd love to explore the route of a hybrid interoperable chat (beeper.com and texts.com) and social app, where B2C accounts are relegated to a more minor part of the experience (90% real life connection, 10% other). This works amazingly in WeChat because the little communication they have incentivises B2C accounts to communicate with signal and also makes WeChat monetise beyond advertisements.

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Hey there - Thanks for this & nice handle (you can change it later)!

The app is invite only but I've posted an invite code in the OP (FULLCIRCLE), also will remove the invite proxy in the onboarding in the next update. Hopefully you'll still try!

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Thanks!

That's true, same with Facebook links and in some ways, close friends on Instagram. Our argument here is that rather than having it is as one-of-many features, we're focused on making a joyful experience around this single feature, creating a different space for sharing.

Feedback noted though!

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Thanks for all these comments, all noted. You're right, a demo would be nice and also super simple to do.

Also a great point, as mentioned in the OP, I've been off social media for some time because I hated them. So bar the standard stuff of onboarding, posting a piece of content etc. We've pushed to do the exact opposite of a normal social media app. Some examples:

- You must add someone to a Circle to see them in your feed, and share to them. - Reactions and comments are only shown between mutual contacts. So if you're viewing a post - Names and Posts are encrypted at rest, and we don't ask/take any data we don't need. We want to push this further in time but our intent is that we actively eschew collecting specific data about individuals, so don't have incentive to make the app driven by ads/addictive features.

Google+ was interesting but ultimately was just Facebook with more friction (eg. connect with as many things and people as possible). We're using the Circles concept to target the inner parts of your network, rather than everyone. Still a WIP, though!

Also good feedback, we focused on mobile because of limited resource but a web option would be great. Is there a specific reason it's a no go for social apps?

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Sorry about that! At which point did it stop working?

Most bug feedback I've gotten since going live has been at the verification page for your phone number. If this is the case, the solution has been to go back a page and submit your number again - happy to support here over email if you'd like!

Our strategy revolves around the intimacy of the sharing that the app has created so far. Despite being simple (and buggy it seems!), you really only need 2-3 family/close friends to make the app joyful - successful or not we've aimed set up the app so that you get that experience as soon as possible.

An (non mom-test) example here is in how it improved my close relationships. My aunt passed away from cancer a few months ago, but before that we were able to share moments on Circles that otherwise would have not made it into chat and/or the typical social apps. Beyond holding the experience dearly, the possibilities of intimate sharing outside of typical social media made her invite her friends.

We can of course bake a bunch of viral marketing features into the product (and have started doing so) but getting this single thing right is by far top of the list.

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Thanks for the comment! I think it's a great question, the hypothesis with Circles is that a vast amount of people would like to share online but don't because of the dynamics of these other social apps make them uncomfortable.

So in that the hurdle has been overcome because people are able to share content and interact in ways that they 'can't' do elsewhere. There's also a group of people (like myself) who avoid typical social media, so downloading a different solution is less of a hurdle because it's designed for them.

However, you point about people 'hating' social media yet still using it is well and true. It's almost like fruit vs mcdonalds, everyone would prefer to be an avid fruit eater and have control of their diet, but few do in the end. In that we believe the only moat for social networks is providing utility that other networks can't - YC wrote a really good blog post on this in relation to WeChat (https://www.ycombinator.com/library/3t-how-wechat-grew-to-be...). We're obviously not there yet but it's a start.

Also, if looking for a solution to that messaging problem, Beeper and Texts.com are creating something exciting there. Perhaps the social media equivalent of these services will be enabled by interoperability by DeSo, ETH or the like. Interesting to think about.

jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Cool. Appreciate this. We build cross platform to give people choice but most dev time has been spent on iOS so its further ahead. Agree that the Android needs baked longer. Will fix!
jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Cool. Thanks for this feedback! We started with mobile because that's the dominant force these days but depending on movement it would be great to create a web-app or desktop client.
jstrafy··on Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?
Thanks for the comment! Found that years of studying and working in Architecture and Design that I shared my work online maybe 2 times so it was that thinking that formed a lot of the architecture. If you share different things with different people, why not have the same mechanism online?

I guess the question we're trying to answer now is whether we narrow in on creating a more intimate social network for regular use or create a type of social-email hybrid for this exact use case.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2