HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jsweojtj

508 karma · joined May 1, 2014

submissionscomments
jsweojtj··on Gravitational Lensing by Spinning Black Holes in the Movie Interstellar (2015)
he gently tossed the tip of his nose?
jsweojtj··on Jeff Bezos Becomes the Richest Man in Modern History, Topping $150B
I bet Buffett would underwrite it w/ AMZN stock as collateral.
jsweojtj··on Grand Rapids has become a midwestern economic star generating industrial jobs
There are four numbers to compare, salary_SF, salary_GR, living_cost_SF, living_cost_GR, and two obvious ratios you could take. You chose to divide salary/living_cost for each, but you could also divide salary_SF/salary_GR for ratio_1 and living_cost_SF/living_cost_GR for ratio_2.

So, you might find that it's a 50% lower salary, and an 80% lower living cost. That would be informative.

jsweojtj··on How the belief in beauty has triggered a crisis in physics
Can you give an example of a falsified result?
jsweojtj··on 90-minute ‘super commutes’ more common as Bay Area housing shortage intensifies
That's not true for California at least, http://lao.ca.gov/LAOEconTax/Article/Detail/265

Nor for SF itself, "San Francisco had a 2017 net domestic migration of -2,332." according to https://www.sfgate.com/expensive-san-francisco/article/Bay-A...

jsweojtj··on Hubble finds first galaxy in the local universe without dark matter
Consider galaxy 1, from visible matter, we might expect rotation curve A, but we see curve B.

Explanation 1: MOND -- modified gravity at that scale, just works differently than we guessed.

Explanation 2: Dark Matter

Now this is galaxy 2, and from visible matter, we expect rotation curve B, and we get rotation curve A!

So no, if it's just visible matter interacting w/ a modified version of gravity, it should predict consistent rotation curves. But we see two types. Thus it is directly problematic for MOND.

jsweojtj··on Talent, luck and success: simulating meritocracy and inequality
Nothing about the conclusions relies on talent being measurable. It's basically going, "say talent was distributed like X, and it had effects Y on the world, what would things look like?" This doesn't imply or suggest or require that talent is measurable or knowable by anyone.
jsweojtj··on How does `cd` work?
I have had this snippet in my `.bashrc` for years. No idea who to give credit to:

    #    eg. save mc
    #    cd mc # no '$' is necessary

    if [ ! -f ~/.dirs ]; then  # if doesn't exist, create it
        touch ~/.dirs
    fi

    alias show='cat ~/.dirs'
    save (){
        command sed "/!$/d" ~/.dirs > ~/.dirs1; \mv ~/.dirs1 ~/.dirs; echo "$@"=\"`pwd`\" >> ~/.dirs; source ~/.dirs ;
        source ~/.dirs  # Initialization for the above 'save' facility: source the .sdirs file
    }
    source ~/.dirs  # Initialization for the above 'save' facility: source the .sdirs file
    shopt -s cdable_vars # set the bash option so that no '$' is required when using the above facility
What this does is, whenever you're in a directory that you'd like to "bookmark" as you'd call it. Just type `save whatevername`. Then, when you navigate somewhere else you can type `cd whatevername` and it'll change you back there. It's simply adding to this ~/.dirs file and so overwriting is taken care of by just saving the same name in a new (or the same) directory. It just appends a line.

Also, you can just type `show` and any point and it'll tell you what you've saved and where.

The nicest thing is that this persists with new logins (the only drawback is that other shells that are running don't get the update automatically).

jsweojtj··on MILA and the future of Theano
I'm curious what will happen with PyMC... incorporate another library? Is there an easily swappable library that does what Theano does?
jsweojtj··on General and Surprising
This is interesting. I don't have an intuition on how well this could work on different problems.

Do you think this approach would work for something, let's start simple, like ballistics neglecting rotation of the Earth and drag? If you fed in thousands of starting velocities and angles, and the resulting distance traveled, will this process end up with equations of motion that are as compact as can be found in first year physics?

jsweojtj··on Artificial Intelligence, Poker, and Regret
*couldn't care less
jsweojtj··on The Future of Go Summit – Ke Jie vs. AlphaGo
Does anyone know whether they isolate generations of AlphaGo and then recombine them after a while? Simulating something like, having Go being played in geographically distinct countries for years and then having the (perhaps many) traditions clash?
jsweojtj··on Families of San Bernardino Shooting Sue Facebook, Google, Twitter
I'm not sure what argument you're trying to make, but just to be clear, the attackers were explicit about their motivation in attacking Charlie Hebdo, by yelling: "We have avenged the Prophet Muhammad".

Source: http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-30710883

jsweojtj··on Families of San Bernardino Shooting Sue Facebook, Google, Twitter
So the Charlie Hebdo attack was in response to the editors and their... what taking oil from somewhere??
jsweojtj··on Uber is pushing anti-union propaganda to its drivers
I've been in two (maybe 3) unions.

Postdocs unionized and made it so that very-short-term postdoc contracts weren't allowed. After I got my PhD my advisor wanted to pay me as a postdoc for the 2 months before my postdoc at another university began -- this would have been EXCELLENT for me. But, union rules, he wasn't allowed to do this. So I had to float my own way for a couple months. Thanks United Auto Workers (the people who ran the postdoc union).

jsweojtj··on Most scientists 'can't replicate studies by their peers'
There are two ways that things can be reproducible: reproducible in practice and reproducible in principle. You are stating that you have a computation that is reproducible in principle (just in practice, unfeasible).

I find this an easy and useful distinction and your publication should NOT be prevented from being published by this measure.

jsweojtj··on The Tangled History of Big Bang Science
That top image makes a mistake when it says "degrees K". It's just 3K. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Degree_(temperature)?wprov=sfsi...
jsweojtj··on An Open Letter From Elizabeth Holmes
I find this kind of comment cropping up - can you find a source for your claim that Rice claimed Iraq had nuclear weapons?
jsweojtj··on Printable 1:24000 topographic maps for the entire US
I love this stuff!

I have a wooden topographical map made with a 3D CNC cut of the SF Bay Area hanging on my wall. It's about 18x18 inches and almost 2 inches deep out of a single piece of almost 2 inch thick piece of plywood. The part I like the most is that the layers in the plywood reveal an automatic topographical map visualization. Got it from here if curious: http://3dwoodenmap.com/

jsweojtj··on Doing Bayesian Data Analysis On the GPU: Examples
I must be missing something. Is there any output that we are supposed to be seeing? Plots of the fits or something?
jsweojtj··on Analyzing Caltrain Delays
There are a couple of reasons that this isn't the explanation.

To pick one, the random data selection in the blog post showed data from October 2015 -- Feb 2016, and this Caltrain link appears to show the bridge work starting Feb 26th, 2016.

So, no the just-so story doesn't appear to be just-so.

jsweojtj··on Analyzing Caltrain Delays
An API would go a long way and realtime information would obviously be awesome. It appears that even if Caltrain provided historical data of actual departure times per train per station, that would be a huge improvement.
jsweojtj··on A number that fascinates physicists
A further layman explanation by a researcher in this field: http://astronomy.swin.edu.au/~mmurphy/research/are-natures-l... specifically the section titled "Aside: Is it e or c varying?"
jsweojtj··on A number that fascinates physicists
You've got this backward. Alpha is the fundamental physical constant: c, e and \hbar are the derived quantities. I'll quote part of another comment that I left on this thread:

> Now for a piece that's more interesting. The fine-structure constant (alpha) is the coupling constant that sets the strength of electromagnetism. This means that its value is the thing that matters in the equation: e^2/\hbar c. Each of the other values is a derived quantity. Further, to speak a bit loosely, only changes in alpha matter -- in the sense that if the speed of light (c) changes, but the other constants (e and \hbar) change in a way that keeps alpha the same, then you wouldn't be able to tell with an experiment that anything has changed.

> Contrast this situation w/ a change in alpha -- a table-top experiment would be able to detect the change (given that it's large enough, and we have methods of measuring changes on year-time scales that are a few parts in ~10^-18 (Rosenband, 2008)), as it would mean that physics has changed in a fundamental way.

> http://phys.columbia.edu/~millis/1900/readings/Science-2008-...

jsweojtj··on A number that fascinates physicists
You've got the right intuition here. The unitless part is key for several reasons. It means that the number itself is meaningful. In your example, the ratio of 1.7 long/wide would be the same no matter what units used to make the measurement. (Obviously, the units DO have to actually cancel cm/inches doesn't work). The number for the speed of light (299 792 458 m/s) is a defined property, so that number doesn't mean anything deeply. However, 1/137... itself is directly meaningful. This is why people who work in fundamental constant research use dimensionless ratios.

Now for a piece that's more interesting. The fine-structure constant (alpha) is the coupling constant that sets the strength of electromagnetism. This means that its value is the thing that matters in the equation: e^2/\hbar c. Each of the other values is a derived quantity. Further, to speak a bit loosely, only changes in alpha matter -- in the sense that if the speed of light (c) changes, but the other constants (e and \hbar) change in a way that keeps alpha the same, then you wouldn't be able to tell with an experiment that anything has changed.

Contrast this situation w/ a change in alpha -- a table-top experiment would be able to detect the change (given that it's large enough, and we have methods of measuring changes on year-time scales that are a few parts in ~10^-18 (Rosenband, 2008)), as it would mean that physics has changed in a fundamental way.

http://phys.columbia.edu/~millis/1900/readings/Science-2008-...

jsweojtj··on How Finland's Basic Income Experiment Will Work
I completely agree that regional adjustments should not be made. A single and uniform monetary amount should be given to all. Otherwise a runaway effect is bound to happen. The places people most want to live (say Hawaii), are more expensive-- if you get to live there AND get more $$ to do it, you will get more people there. Of course then, it gets even more expensive and so on.
jsweojtj··on Show HN: Use wealthbot.io to easily setup your own portfolio management platform
I'm reading the Readme -- what's RIA?
jsweojtj··on Maze Generator and Solver
I really like this idea!
jsweojtj··on Artificial-Intelligence Experts Are in High Demand
It happens all the time, and it comes from a mix of things.

One way it happens is that you get a PhD in astrophysics with years of data analysis experience in for a data science job. Have a software engineer interview her and he might find that she doesn't know a number of basic computer sciences concepts [traversing a linked list, tail recursion, implement breadth-first-search]. His knowledge background says these basic ideas are fundamental, there are therefore serious questions about the technical ability of the interviewee.

jsweojtj··on GitWikXiv: Toward a successor to the academic paper
Thank you for this more detailed comment. It does a nice job capturing the essentials of the paper.
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →