HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jsweojtj

508 karma · joined May 1, 2014

submissionscomments
jsweojtj··on GitWikXiv: Toward a successor to the academic paper
I've always hoped that the PaperBricks, http://arxiv.org/abs/1102.3523 model would catch on.

My summary of the idea:

There is an awful lot of redundancy and wasted effort that goes into most papers. From introductions that need to be rewritten every time (when linking to a solid introduction would be both better and less time consuming). Each piece of a piece of a full paper (intro, data, analysis, ...) could be peer-reviewed and published individually. A full paper could then be built from these paper-bricks. Anyway, recommend reading the paper as it's well written and clear.

There's also a YouTube video by the author explaining it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4sorEcLjN04.

jsweojtj··on Faith vs. Facts
Would you say that the Christian belief that Jesus was born of a virgin is one of those "fact-beliefs" or "faith-beliefs"?
jsweojtj··on Churchill’s disaster – Gallipoli
You're thinking WWII.
jsweojtj··on Faith vs. Facts
> Not all religions believe the same thing. ... Not every religion is the same.

The article doesn't even suggest anything of the sort. Further, it extends "religious thinking" to include things that aren't religious in the usual sense (anti-vaxxers, for example). The entire point of the article is that there is a different kind of thinking going on when the belief is "religious" vs when it's a belief about reality.

As the article states:

> when people consider the truth of a religious belief, what the belief does for their lives matters more than, well, the facts. > ... > scholars have determined that people don’t use rational, instrumental reasoning when they deal with religious beliefs.

Which, if true, should be:

1) fully grappled with, and

2) actively opposed.

Magical/religious/superstitious thinking leads to strongly held beliefs that are impervious to being updated by evidence in a rational manner. Some of these beliefs might be benign or even pro-social -- true -- but at best this process of gaining beliefs is definitely unreliable. At worst, well, we know how it ends at worst.

jsweojtj··on New Hacker News Guideline: Avoid Gratuitous Negativity
No. No no no no no no no.
jsweojtj··on Amazon Dash Button
Out of clothes today,

out of detergent, as well.

Hi UPS man.

jsweojtj··on Show Me the Data: Using Graphics for Exploratory Data Analysis
They linked to the Anscombe's code, but I wish they also linked to the code that produced the rest of the analysis. Looks cool and I wish I could run it myself!
jsweojtj··on Excitement Over Gravity Waves Comes Crashing Down
The fundamental constant you're looking for is the fine-structure constant (often referred to as alpha). It's a dimensionless ratio of physical constants, and if its value changes, physics is different.
jsweojtj··on Could You See the Curvature of the Earth in This Airport?
> And of course, if one also has a scale, the weight of the ball can be used to see whether the floor is level.

Can you elaborate on this? Why would the weight be different if non-level? Unless you're meaning that the center-of-mass of the ball would be ~2 centimeters further from the center-of-mass of the Earth and 1/r^2 means a decrease?

jsweojtj··on Astrophysicists propose new twist on Big Bang
We should distinguish "testable in principle" and "testable in practice". Simply because it is currently not testable in practice, does not mean that it's not testable in principle.

Saying a scientific hypothesis is untestable "in principle" is a deathknell while untestable "in practice" is not.

jsweojtj··on Academic Urban Legends
While I can imagine that being amazing if that could be done well, but it seems like a really difficult problem to get right.

I would prefer an approach like PaperBricks caught on instead: http://arxiv.org/abs/1102.3523 -- where a single section of a current paper could be published by itself.

I think it would be both amazingly useful and could speed up the iteration rate of science substantially.

jsweojtj··on Adventures in Cognitive Biases
as an astrophysicist, this one annoyed me: https://www.dropbox.com/s/udoug25cpd2zpiy/Screenshot%202014-...
jsweojtj··on New RFS: One Million Jobs
>> Creating jobs is a strange goal. > Why? Who says efficiency should be humanity's goal? Is humanity a machine to be optimized?

I think saying that creating jobs is a goal is more accurately the viewpoint that humans are cogs.

Say there's an efficient way to do something, for example: a machine that weaves fabric.

If the goal is to create jobs, we could stop the machine and hire people to do the job. In fact, I bet we could force people to do it in a really inefficient and tedious manner that would require lots of people to replace a single machine.

The disadvantages: slower. more expensive. more error-prone. people's time-wasting.

The advantages: these people have a job so now you have a 'valid' excuse to give people an income.

jsweojtj··on Anti-Tesla sentiment and the death of optimism
Adventured was saying that the US is a counterexample to the proposed statement that meant non-restrictive or non existent patent systems will be bastions of innovation.

In no way was Adventured arguing that because of the patent system, the US became a bastion of innovation.

jsweojtj··on The Dyslexic Programmer
I also don't read aloud in my head for the most part. I get caught with this exact problem with character names -- I have to sound it out for the first time when I try to say it.

However, you are making a different point. Anyone who reads 'fluently' recognizes the shapes of words in one glance -- whether he reads aloud in his head or not. No one is looking letter-by-letter.

jsweojtj··on The evolution of chess: Game lengths and outcomes
I have to admit that I (also?) was expecting the shaded region to give something like the standard deviation about the mean, not the confidence in the mean.
jsweojtj··on 2 billion-year-old African nuclear reactor
> laws of physics were the same then itself rests on the assumption that the laws of physics were the same then

No, that's definitely not true. Here's a good (somewhat technical) overview of these kinds of scientific investigations:

http://relativity.livingreviews.org/Articles/lrr-2011-2/

The pdf should be free to download and there's an entire section on the Oklo reactor.

jsweojtj··on 2 billion-year-old African nuclear reactor
> But how do you interpret astronomical observations? By using the currently understood laws of physics, of course, so it becomes a bit of a circular argument.

One of the best ways to measure this is to use quasar absorption spectroscopy to probe the precise energy level spacing of atoms (like iron, magnesium, and so on) from billions of years ago with the energy level spacings found in the same atoms of today.

If the fine-structure constant (for example) were different by some amount in the distant past, its effect is calculable -- and the spectroscopic signature of a different fine-structure constant is distinct from any other physical effect (redshift of the spectrum, etc.).

There are some intriguing results that have come out over the past decade or so, with new information coming in all the time.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4