HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jt2190

4,763 karma · joined October 1, 2009

submissionscomments
jt2190··on What makes software development engineering
We currently use contracts to assign which party accepts responsibility. Why is this insufficient?
jt2190··on What makes software development engineering
There are regulations.
jt2190··on What makes software development engineering
> You probably…

Yes, agreed but what is the point? What problem are we solving?

jt2190··on What makes software development engineering
This is one of those silly suggestions that comes up repeatedly, and solves a non-problem: In both the U.S. and Canada there are many instances where work needs to be approved by a credentialed and legally licensed engineer. Banning the use of the job title “engineer” in the U.S. would not change anything. (It would run smack into the 1st amendment though… it’s legal for me to call myself the King of France, and the onus is on you to decide if that’s all the due diligence you need to do before engaging me in treaty negotiations.)
jt2190··on California farmers are struggling to sell grapes as demand for wine drops
Technically yes, but it would be unprofitable to pivot. (Presumably whoever you bought your juice from was planning to make juice, and budgeted accordingly.)
jt2190··on Everybody’s home. No one’s coming over
> Everybody might prefer, in the abstract, a world of dinner parties, neighborhood friendships, and spontaneous gatherings. But on any given Wednesday at 7:45pm., it is easier to look at a screen than to host a party; easier to listen to a podcast while doing yoga than to plan a gathering. This is not so much an individual failure as a coordination failure. Modernity has shifted leisure from activities that require coordination with other people toward activities that can be consumed without the permission or participation of others. Compared to TikTok, a dinner party is a terrible leisure technology.

This extra coordination “friction” is the killer. The lesson is, if you want more dinner parties you have to reduce the extra coordination “friction” to a minimum.

jt2190··on 28% of job postings on company career sites have been open over 90 days
Remember that the average job candidate is absolutely clueless about how positions are created and filled in real life, so seeing bad assumptions like “most positions are filled in under ninety days” shouldn’t be surprising.
jt2190··on BeanShell3 in Development
> Work has resumed on the long-dormant 3.0 development line (master; the JAR targets Java 8 and is tested on Java 8 through 25) after a multi-year gap.

More details in the CHANGELOG: https://github.com/beanshell/beanshell/blob/main/CHANGES.md

jt2190··on US Military had close call after using AI for hallucinated intelligence report
The law of war is an attempt to have belligerent nations voluntarily set some limits on how far they’ll go when in conflict, in the hopes that the number of non-combatant casualties is reduced. That said, the answer to your question is that a nation that tries to follow the law of war has procedures in place to catch errors like bad intel. That is what a court would adjudicate.
jt2190··on America's Driver's License Breach Is a National Security Disaster
Ia also wonder just how hard it is to figure out the info someone’s drivers license from scratch. My license has:

    - license number
    - license class
    - license issue date
    - license expiration date (birth day and month in my state)
    - birth date
    - eye color
    - sex
    - height
Are any of these very difficult to find?
jt2190··on Douglas Hofstadter: Analogy as the Core of Cognition [video]
The video is about congnition specifically, and not necessarily about communicating with analogies.

> I get unreasonably upset when people nitpick holes in good analogies…

What you’re describing is exactly why I strongly recommend avoiding analogy when communicating: Don’t tell me what a thing is like, tell me what the thing is. This forces really thinking about how to describe the thing precisely and succinctly. (Edit: The listener will make their own analogy.)

jt2190··on Shopify acquires Tailwind
Your analysis is fundamentally flawed because you’re conflating the Tailwind’s business model, which is based on the actual realities of the market, and your ideal for how frontends should be developed.

There are millions of Single Page, and other “complex” web apps. You not liking it does not invalidate anything.

jt2190··on Global warming will exceed 1.5-degree limit, UN says
Interestingly, financial markets are a good place to see the “price” of some environmental issues. A made up example: “Should I buy bonds that are backed by electricity sales from a yet-to-be-built hydroelectric dam? Will there be enough rainfall to fill the reservoir reliably? I’ll have to receive a higher interest payment to offset that risk.”
jt2190··on New York Times and The Athletic workers demand company scrap Kalshi deal
> Instead, they felt compelled to make a trivially false claim, the claim that prediction markets do not accurately predict the future. It's trivial to prove that this claim is false, because if it were true, it would be very easy for anyone to make a huge amount of money on prediction markets.

Isn’t that what’s actually happening though? Traders are making real money from bad predictions?

“These are the Sharps actually making money on prediction markets” Odd Lots podcast (Bloomberg) 2026 https://youtu.be/MFAnQpdgkZE

jt2190··on Mark Cuban: Why US hospitals "don't know their costs"
The costs of “hospital overpreparedness” should still be clearly understood (and should probably be funded by taxpayers and not by people who need elective procedures).
jt2190··on Norway Shrugged (2024)
Is the Norwegian government’s theory that a modern company might never realize their gains, and avoid taxation indefinitely, and thus this is a forcing mechanism to extract some tax revenue?
jt2190··on The Twelve-Factor App (2025)
> Note that this definition of “config” does not include internal application config, such as config/routes.rb in Rails, or how code modules are connected in Spring. This type of config does not vary between deploys, and so is best done in the code.
jt2190··on The Twelve-Factor App (2025)
The unwritten assumption in 12 Factor is: the environment is secure. For example, a production system should always have a secure means of setting environment variables. Said another way: If a random dev can change an environment variable in production either directly by logging in or indirectly by pushing code then there is something very very wrong.

If the dev is pushing code to production they should not simultaneously be pushing environment configs, this is doing two logically distinct things at once: Changing application behavior AND reconfiguring the server environment.

If the dev is adding secrets to their local config and they’re pushing that config to insecure places that means their deployment pipeline is broken and it should be fixed. .env is never committed to source for this reason, for example.

jt2190··on Beyond Recall and the Illusion of Competence
> AI can create the illusion that you understand a system because it can make the system work for you. You ask a question and get an answer. You encounter an error and get a patch. The patch doesn't work, so you provide the new error and get another patch. Eventually the machine finds something that works.

> From the outside, this looks like competence. But if you don't understand why the solution works, you're not actually becoming more capable. You're becoming dependent on the machine to maintain the illusion.

So many things in life operate exactly like this: We don’t need to understand the why, we just accept the solution as-is and move on. An experienced professional has another skill: keeping track of which things matter enough to dig in to and develop mastery, and which things can be “good enough”. This is also informed by the “intuition of how machines behave” that the author mentions.

jt2190··on Canada will match US tariffs 'dollar for dollar' as trade talks break down
For some perspective about what’s being negotiated:

“What’s at stake in the Canada-U.S. trade deal? How looming tariffs could cost Canada 90,000 jobs”. Trevor Tombe, professor of economics at the University of Calgary

https://thehub.ca/2026/08/20/whats-at-stake-in-the-canada-u-...

jt2190··on LLMs are proof that Unix won
Clickbait is a form of Spam. Flagging is expressly recommended for spam.
jt2190··on LLMs are proof that Unix won
OT: Please refrain from commenting and just flag the article. This might seem harsh but it’s a strong signal to the submitter to find better content.
jt2190··on AI didn't erase the junior engineer's value, it increased it it
> . How do you think that lowers the value of an intern

The article shows that the market value of the intern is lower: Work was not prioritized and given to a higher-cost junior engineer.

> … pre-AI that feature would not have been given to an intern (because they wouldn't be able to own it)…

Meaning, a more-skilled, higher-cost employee would have to do some or all of the work.

Edit: Another meaning of “worth” is a “intrinsic value”. Humans have worth in this sense.

jt2190··on AI didn't erase the junior engineer's value, it increased it it
> This summer, we assigned the problem to an intern (that’s less tenure than a junior engineer). The intern led the development of this feature. They talked to the product manager to understand the problem and requirements. They wrote the design document on how to approach it, aligned with the team, and built it. Of course they did that with the help of AI, and the team they were working with.

So, interns can still produce some value. How much value?

> In our product, there was a feature which had been requested for years, but had not been built yet. It wasn’t overly complex, but it was not critical.

Said another way: The feature was of so little value that it was not even worth assigning to a non-AI-assisted intern! This is what most of us mean when we say “AI lowers the value of…”

jt2190··on Jane Street suffers $15B hit after meltdown at Situational Awareness
> Jane Street has generated more than USD 40 000 000 000 in net trading revenues in the year to Friday, even accounting for the July loss, which exceeds its entire haul for 2025, according to one of the people familiar with the matter.
jt2190··on License plate reader searches should require a warrant
I believe you’re trying to articulate the act of witnessing from the act of investigating, and where the boundary between the two is. To me it seems like the boundary should be “does the general public have access to this information?”. If so, it’s allowable. If not, then a justification should be required for starting an investigation.
jt2190··on To recruit teachers, school districts are building homes
Yeah sorry I was in a hurry. I’d originally vouched for your comment (it was dead/flagkilled), then threw up that link as a quick support for your numbers.
jt2190··on To recruit teachers, school districts are building homes
> the average is around $96,000

https://www.cps.edu/media/community-updates/2025/january/neg...

jt2190··on Romania Extends Nuclear Reactor Output by Nine Days After Danube Blasts
https://apnews.com/article/romania-europe-nuclear-danube-dro...
jt2190··on A year of fighting scrapers on my 1.5 million-page website
Yeah it's sort of weird that people are so used to using their computer to interact with other computers across the internet that the whole thing has become invisible to them: They completely forget that they're using a computer at all. Along come "bots" and suddenly everyone remembers that the whole thing involves computers. Driving the computer by hand for hours was never efficient, but is marginally entertaining I guess.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →