HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

julianmarq

608 karma · joined April 2, 2017

submissionscomments
julianmarq··on The Battle Inside Signal
> I think [recognizing nazi ideology is] easy for humans to do so.

It isn't, not even when you are one of those who thinks "anyone who disagrees with me must be a nazi"—meaning that in theory you could just train a model with things you like and things you don't like and label the second group with "nazism"—because your opinions can and do shift often too and so the model would become outdated by the month, if not by the day.

> And besides, as I said in another comment. I don't have all the answers

And yet you speak with such certainty, as if you did. On that note, in your first comment you proclaimed that you were willing to sacrifice your privacy, and yet you used an anonymous account to make that declaration.

julianmarq··on Need advice or assistance for son who is in prison
I commented how I already read the comments (particularly those by the green usernames) and they didn't change my mind about that particular situation; I don't understand what is going to be accomplished by yet another comment simply repeating that.

Yes, he killed two people, and he's doing the time while clearly taking the process of rehabilitation very seriously. That's the whole point of prison, or at least it's what it was supposed to be.

julianmarq··on Need advice or assistance for son who is in prison
> Both manslaughter and murder count as "killing."

Your use of quotations seems to imply that you're saying that GP used the word "killing". That's incorrect; the word used was "murder" and, as GP already said, manslaughter is not murder.

I might have misinterpreted your use of quotations, but in that case then I don't understand the point you're trying to make.

julianmarq··on Need advice or assistance for son who is in prison
I read the question and answers and felt a little cheerful at the idea of someone turning his life around and even thought to myself that maybe the system works sometimes.

Then I came back here and read a few of the comments, particularly those by the new throwaway accounts (except for the top one). I shouldn't have read the comments, particularly those by the new throwaway accounts (and not because they might have changed my mind about the question and answers; they didn't, far from it).

julianmarq··on React created roadblocks in our enterprise app
> hating on React

It would be great if developers stopped treating tools they like with this much sentiment. For starters, it would mean fewer flamewars.

They're just tools, criticizing them is not "hating" and your liking them is no endorsement (for anyone other than you, anyway).

> With low-code backend tooling and React, I can promise you I can make a better website than with just Python no matter how much Django template wizardry one can muster.

How can you "promise" this? How can anyone "promise" this? I'm not even sure I understood what you meant by this. Even more so in this case as the tools you mentioned are geared to different types of applications.

The only way I can parse this sentence is that you're claiming that react is indisputably better at [not sure what you meant to do since you said "website" and a website doesn't need a backend$, but you mentioned backend regardless] than any tool in [whatever other language/framework, clearly, even if you're using Python as example] and I'm gonna need a source on that one. It's a pretty strong claim, assuming I didn't misinterpret it.

$ Technically, a website doesn't need a frontend either; it's debatable whether a website even needs javascript, but certainly not react, which is a library for creating web applications.

julianmarq··on AWS announces forks of Elasticsearch and Kibana
> people who like open source (generally left-wing people doing stuff for betterment of society)

Do you really think that liking open source is in any way correlated with politics?[1] I'd like to read a source on that one, because it's certainly not been my experience. Maybe we've contributed to different projects and/or read different people.

But even that aside, you think that everyone who likes open source is condemning amazon and on elastic's side? That is even more suspect. Just as an example, the creator of sourcehut has been criticizing elastic all week, and all of his posts—at least one of them explicitly saying that Amazon is definitely allowed to do what it's doing—have reached the front page here. And he's someone whose "liking open source" credentials are good enough, I think.

[1]: I'm not even going to get into other implication, that wanting to improve society is also in any way related to any given political leaning.

julianmarq··on Update on an Employee Matter
> In HN, I've been seeing way more comments supporting the "freedom of speech" for those who stormed the Capitol

In HN, I've seen people saying that the concept of free speech is outdated and that societies that support it are doomed to failure.

> While I don't necessarily agree [on the importance of freedom of speech]

This doesn't quite reach as far as the example I gave, but it is representative of what at the very least half of of comments in HN are like, when the subject is free speech. I always find it a little ironic.

> That might tell more about what sites I visit, but whatever

Given the difference of experiences, it might just be biases, including selection bias. And yes, I include myself in that statement, though I try to take note of comments beside mine defending freedom of speech, if nothing else just so I don't lose hope.

julianmarq··on EU Commission: ‘No longer acceptable’ for platforms to take key decisions alone
I'm not really surprised that governments (or similar, such as the EU) are starting to become suspicious of the issue that private companies—who primarily profit off their users' data—have somehow anointed themselves as arbiters of speech.

It should have happened sooner, really. Hopefully this leads into ways to foster innovation (such as with decentralized networks) and competition, to break these giants' monopolies on the flow of information.

julianmarq··on The Lies that can Undermine Democracy
> I don't have much confidence in how to counter it. It feels like a big chunk of our population have got sucked into a cult - how do you deprogram so many people?

Up until this point, I was very much agreeing with his take, but from this point forward it devolves into the usual paternalistic, quietly self-righteous and "subtly" anti free speech narrative this type of articles way too often seem to take.

This was a little sad to read. I used to think that Fowler was one of the smartest people I know about, I've now corrected that to he's one of the most "knowledgeable on software engineering and architecture" people I know about.

julianmarq··on Citing 'Censorship' Concerns, North Idaho ISP Blocks Facebook, Twitter
The comments here confuse me. Over the past months/years, I've read many a comment here insisting that whatever Facebook/Twitter/etcetera allow or don't allow in their platforms is absolutely not censorship[1]... But a significant amount of the comments in this post are saying that this move is "fighting censorship with more censorship", which is, by itself, tacitly saying that what the social media companies do is indeed censorship.

For the record, I don't think that twitter or facebook banning/blocking whatever they want is censorship[2], legally speaking... And neither is this, for the same reasons.

[1]: And some others who don't care and go as far as to say that censorship is okay and free speech doesn't work, among other things.

[2]: Unethical, manipulative, a betrayal of the spirit if not the law of "free speech"? Totally, but still not censorship.

julianmarq··on GoDaddy Boots AR15.com
Up until this point, I thought that when you bought a domain from a registrar, the domain was yours (since you can transfer it, after all), but now I'm not sure, and the article is not clear. How could godaddy "boot" someone? Isn't the domain theirs?
julianmarq··on 70TB of Parler users’ messages, videos, and posts leaked by security researchers
I replied this to someone else, but I think it works here too: The irony, for me, is that if I were in favor of censorship, I would be the first person I censor, instead of using an online forum to speak in favor of censorship. I feel that there's irony in using a widely accessed medium just to talk about how censorship is the way to go.
julianmarq··on 70TB of Parler users’ messages, videos, and posts leaked by security researchers
> Do you see how by using the word “censorship” [...], you have made it difficult to continue this conversation?

Not really, no, what makes it difficult for me to continue this conversation is that I had no interest in having this conversation in the first place. My first comment was just asking the other person how he dealt with these threads, as I wasn't sure what he meant exactly or if he had a trick or something.

I certainly didn't want to start arguing the merits of free speech again (I already said I found it disheartening to read).

> I didn’t present any position at all other than saying that neither extreme is realistic

And since I never spoke in favor of any extreme, I argued with you because your point about "everyone being pro-censorship" wasn't apropos... Something you seem to know too.

> look for people arguing about specific behaviors; avoid people arguing over the definition of the word “censorship”.

I've seen the same people arguing both in favor of the same "specific behavior" you mentioned and against free speech[1]. And no, those discussions were anything but productive or nuanced. With that in mind, I have no interest in looking for that.

[1]: Not that differentiating between that and censorship wasn't already a distinction without a difference (as I already implied in my previous comment), but I must say that those discussions did make it evident that they were ultimately arguing for the same thing.

julianmarq··on 70TB of Parler users’ messages, videos, and posts leaked by security researchers
Just in case, the irony, for me, is that if I were in favor of censorship, I would be the first person I censor, instead of using an online forum to speak in favor of censorship. I feel that there's irony in using a widely accessed medium just to talk about how censorship is better.

And here's an example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25715809

(It bears noticing how the post whose thread that comment belongs to is certainly not about the banning of Trump or parler).

julianmarq··on 70TB of Parler users’ messages, videos, and posts leaked by security researchers
Before I give you one of the recent examples I saw, I'm curious about why you're asking for examples in the first place. You already seem pretty disinclined to agree with me as evidenced by how you keep trying to suggest that I'm talking about condemnation of unprotected speech, which I haven't and have said so several times. My first comment was merely asking someone for clarification on how he parsed these threads; I didn't even talk about the subject at hand because I have no interest to and yet that's almost exclusively what you have tried to talk about. Not sure what exactly would be changed in this conversation by my giving you an example. You've been assuming bad faith on my part from the get go so I feel it would be just another fruitless exercise, or lead into another discussion on the merits of free speech I certainly don't want to get into, again.

By the way, you're completely free to defend these gigantic corporations deplatforming whoever they want; I wasn't talking about that in my original comment. That implication was already present in my first reply, but maybe my saying it outright will convince you that I don't mean anything bad with my comments.

julianmarq··on 70TB of Parler users’ messages, videos, and posts leaked by security researchers
> Maybe downvoted far down the thread

No, and no. Please don't tell me what I have or have not seen myself.

> [Trump and parler again]

Okay, this is the third time so I won't try again to tell you I have no interest in talking about that. I'll just say that the first time I noticed generally well received[1] comments in favor of censorship was almost two years ago, in a thread that had nothing to do with Trump (and I'm not sure if parler even existed by then). According to what I've noticed, it has been growing in prominence since.

[1]: Which is to say, they weren't downvoted nor pushed downthread and even though they had several replies disputing them; they had just as many agreeing.

julianmarq··on 70TB of Parler users’ messages, videos, and posts leaked by security researchers
> But pretty much no one wants preapproval of every utterance either, so everyone is also “anti-censorship”.

I've seen people arguing that the concept of free speech is "outdated" and that societies that hold it are "doomed to collapse", just as an example of what I meant in my first comment.

> so pretty much everyone is “pro-censorship” to some degree

Please, don't. You're arguing against an extreme of my comment instead of what I actually meant[1] (which, of course, you're free to do, but I would also be just as free to dismiss it as a bad faith argument), but also you're extending something you might believe onto others. You're of course free to be "pro-censorship", but you don't know what everyone else thinks, and certainly not what I think.

> The use of the term “censorship” is itself a negative signal, as it preempts useful discussion by imposing a false dichotomy.

I completely disagree with this. The example I gave is absolutely an argument in favor of censorship.

> If you see someone talking about “damping positive disinformation feedback loops” or something like that, rather than “censorship”, that’s one signal there’s a substantive discussion taking place.

Excusing it by saying "dampening positive disinformation feedback loops" is excusing censorship. You might refuse to call it such, but I don't have a reason not to.

[1]: For starters, I'm aware that there's unprotected speech for a reason, and I never called condemnation of such speech "censorship".

julianmarq··on 70TB of Parler users’ messages, videos, and posts leaked by security researchers
> I was referring to the comment where you say HN is “bizarrely” more “pro-censorship”. Where you see “pro-censorship”, many see speech that historically has never been protected

I didn't use the word "bizarrely" and I'm not talking about condemnation of unprotected speech (and again, not just because I'm not from the USA). I've seen people arguing that the concept of free speech itself is "outdated" and that societies that hold it are "doomed to collapse", and that's just an example.

> [Trump]

Again, I wasn't talking about parler nor about Trump. I would appreciate it if you stopped trying to imply that I'm talking about stuff I'm not, or steering the conversation toward subjects I've never even alluded to.

julianmarq··on 70TB of Parler users’ messages, videos, and posts leaked by security researchers
> [US limits on free speech] seem to be relevant to this discussion.

But not to my comment, and not just because I'm not from the USA.

I'm not speaking in favor of parler if that's what you assumed (for some reason). Specially if it is, like the top comment said, just a propaganda machine trying to enforce a single viewpoint. That's antithesis to free speech.

julianmarq··on 70TB of Parler users’ messages, videos, and posts leaked by security researchers
> best to just scan and pattern match the kind of exchanges occurring before moving swiftly along.

How do you do that? I've noticed lately that HN commentary (at least in threads like this) has trended increasingly pro-censorship[1] lately, and it's pretty disheartening to read.

Would rather do something like what you say, but I'm not quite sure what you mean.

[1]: Which is a bit ironic, thinking about it.

julianmarq··on Twitter deletes China embassy's Xinjiang 'emancipation' tweet
What point am I missing exactly? I don't understand how that sentence is apropos.

Sure, fact-checking has never been so "fast or efficient"... But it clearly is still not yet fast or efficient, or perhaps promoted, enough.

But even that aside, I don't understand what's the point I apparently missed. I can only think that the implication is that fact checking already is as good as it'll ever be and, even assuming that that was true (it isn't), then we should just give up on free speech and resign ourselves to censorship? Well, I didn't "miss" that point, I just don't agree.

julianmarq··on Twitter deletes China embassy's Xinjiang 'emancipation' tweet
> I still believe in the merits of free speech as regards reasoned good-faith open debate [...] such communication is in fact significantly dangerous.

These two sentences cannot be true at the same time; one is either in favor of free communication or one isn't. There are many ways to name the idea of "I'm okay with speech as long as I deem it to be in good faith/not dangerous", but free speech is not one of them.

It's the entire point: "I might hate what you say, but I'll defend your right to say it."

> If recent events haven't convinced you, I honestly don't know what will.

Why would anything convince me of the idea that something I deem to be the basis of progress in civilization, is actually not so?

To give an example: The church had significant power—even over the state in vast swathes of Europe—in the middle ages, and they were pretty censorious. Yet the renaissance still happened, in no small part thanks to the printing press and the huge boost it gave to the sharing of knowledge.

Interestingly, the reformation also happened around that time, and with it brought quite a few religious wars, with both groups making claims that don't sound all that unlike to "the other side is spreading falsehoods and there's no other way to stop them".

Nowadays, catholics and protestants seem to be mostly okay with each other, and I'm sure today's conflicts will eventually become a thing of the past too. But it will not be thanks to censorship.

> that's without getting into an argument about who gets to judge what is and isn't misinformation.

This is an argument against your point, not in favor of it, I think. Who's the arbiter of what's misinformation? Twitter or any of the other gigantic and "evil"[1] corporations?

> You mean aside from the increasingly violent divisiveness of politics in the past dozen years?

Interesting, many claim that misinformation is at fault of that divide. Just as many instead claim that it's siloing, filter bubbles and echo chambers the real culprit.

> I'm not intending to prove it exhaustively in my post so much as to say that it seems like it might be the case. I welcome evidence to the contrary.

But the burden of proof is on the one who affirms, not on the one who denies. Believing something just because it seems like it might be true and because one hasn't looked for counterevidence can be unfalsifiable. To wit, one might just believe it and that's that.

Which is, of course, one's prerogative. Free speech and all that; everyone is free to believe anything.

> People have many methods to fact check right now.[...] Indeed, the information age has made fact checking more accessible than it has ever been in history

Case in point. There might be many ways to fact check and it might be more accessible, but clearly not enough, for whatever reason. For example, in this case, if it were easier and faster, you could have more readily looked for evidence of your "any society holding free speech as sacrosanct is doomed to collapse" claim, I think.

[1]: Well, they're "evil" as long as the discussion is not about free speech but instead about any of the other unethical things they do. When the subject is censorship, many people are in their favor, it seems.

julianmarq··on EFF's response to social media companies' decisions to block Trump’s accounts
> If you post something to say, Twitter, that is now their content that you have given to them for their benefit with the sole purpose of extracting value from the attention the content you handed over to them brings through the sale of advertising.

Unless the article shared here yesterday titled "you are wrong about section 230" is itself wrong... Then everything in this part seems to be wrong.

julianmarq··on EFF's response to social media companies' decisions to block Trump’s accounts
> they'd have lost my support.

The implication being that everything the EFF has done against corporate control of the internet is only good as long as their criticism doesn't extend to corporate censorship?

I hope I'm misinterpreting this.

julianmarq··on Twitter deletes China embassy's Xinjiang 'emancipation' tweet
> In some parts of the United States being denied utilities can (and does) lead to death as a result of exposure. I don't believe comparing this to deplatforming from the internet is a good faith argument.

Without getting into the point of the conversation[1], taking the most extreme interpretation of someone else's words and argue against that would be the no good faith argument in this case, IMO. The HN guidelines encourage to steelman the other person's point and argue against that; you seem to have done the opposite.

In other words, the other person didn't argue that removing access to social media was akin to killing you (like it would be for a few people if they didn't have access to electricity), but that it would be a huge inconvenience (like it would be for most people if they lost access to electricity).

[1]: I'm starting to not see the point in discussing the merits of free speech or what constitutes free speech or censorship. I believe free speech is fundamental, and for that reason it's anyone's prerogative to think otherwise. Getting into that discussion at all is also a bit ironic.

julianmarq··on Twitter deletes China embassy's Xinjiang 'emancipation' tweet
> I hope I'm wrong about [society being doomed to collapse because of free speech]

I'm confused, then why did you say this?

> I used to agree with this line of thinking

Unless I'm misinterpreting this, you seem "not to longer agree" with the merits of free speech. If so, then why do you hope to be wrong about it eventually disappearing?

> the past dozen years or so of the information age have made it abundantly clear that simply having the truth on your side and making a rational case for it is not even remotely sufficient to counter the spread of misinformation.

Even if I agreed with this—which I don't—the answer to this hypothetical reality is definitely not to start removing actual information.[1]

For instance, having tweets like that exist would be good counterevidence to all to apologia of certain bad actors that goes around, even here in HN.

> Honestly, I'm not sure that free speech as a concept will be able to survive the information age

Usually the first ones silenced are the ones promoting censorship. That's what I'd usually say anyway, but it is pointless; I would be silenced eventually too and I don't want to be silenced, even if it happens to me after it does to the ones who are "inadvertently" asking to be silenced.

> It seems as though any society holding it sacrosanct might be doomed to collapse from divisive pressure both internal and external.

Do you have historical evidence to back up this claim?

All in all, my hope is that we find easier, better ways for people to fact check, instead of removing data wholesale. Language is the basis of civilization, so restricting communication is not the way to go. Improving it is the way to move forward; it has always been so, I think.

[1]: And to note, I'm not saying that what was said in that tweeted article wasn't an awful lie. The information is not the content, the information is the fact that it was said at all.

julianmarq··on ACLU Counsel Warns of 'Unchecked Power' of Twitter, Facebook
> We should be far more worried that Twitter gave the president a free ride for so long

Twitter has given and continues to give people just as or even more deranged than Trump free rides. They don't care, because either a) they agree with those people or b) censoring those people could give them bad publicity and could hurt their ad revenue.

Meanwhile, people like Trump get banned all the time because their politics are okay to ban according to the advertisers/investors/media/population Twitter wants to please. Trump himself stood this long because, even if the people twitter wants/needs to please hate him, his tweets made them money—even from the people who hate him, who nonetheless hang onto his every word—by virtue of being the president of the USA and thus having far more reach than the usual "right wing nutjob".

Twitter waited until now to ban him because in their calculations, I presume, losing less than two weeks of money that Trump's insane stream of thoughts might give them is compensated by the good publicity of this making them look righteous in front of everyone else.

Sadly it works, even here in HN everyone forgets the usual narrative of "these corporations are evil, let's break them down and/or regulate them more heavily, and, for the love of God, let's stop their sinister spying on us", and starts defending these monopolies like no tomorrow as soon as they censor/ban someone they don't like. Even if it's a completely meaningless gesture like this one.

julianmarq··on Microsoft tried to buy Nintendo, but got laughed out of the room
> does sound like a racist caricature

But it isn't. How about we stop assuming offense by default and instead we try to expect that other people are as reasonable as we are? For that matter, that one is in the guidelines here.

julianmarq··on Microsoft tried to buy Nintendo, but got laughed out of the room
> but mockery seemed plausible

How about we stop assuming mockery just because it might seem plausible and instead we lean toward "no offense intended" by default?

julianmarq··on WhatsApp gives users an ultimatum: Share data with Facebook or stop using app
It's very interesting how upon news like this, everyone rightly jumps at the throat of the evil corporation pushing for more control of everyone's information. But when the discussion is about free speech—which this stuff is directly related to, just in a subtle way—then suddenly at least half the comments are clamoring in defense of the large corporations' right (to censor) to host whatever they want in their platforms.

All because "the users don't know better, so it's good to filter the information they get access to" or because "information overload is somehow more likely to push people to the extremes than siloing and letting people live in filter bubbles" and other similarly paternalistic justifications. It's interesting how facebook trying to get the information is bad, but using that information, among other things, to filter what its users see or not is apparently good.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →