HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

juris

527 karma · joined October 10, 2017

ycombinator.snide241@passmail.net
submissionscomments
juris··on US judge: Art created solely by artificial intelligence cannot be copyrighted
So! Here's my really dumb question: what is the difference between the two?

I agree, in that first instance and at first glance, clearly copying. There are plenty of incredible copy artists in China who fabricate like copies of fine art, who approximate the role of our AI here.

There might be something to be said later about the nature of what makes a work transformative and whether the use of an AI is sufficient for it, but setting that thought aside, let's slide the scale from the meatspace to the rasterized space.

For the second: our mockey mouse is the spitting image of mickey mouse. Maybe the lines are a breadth of a hair off the fine print from what was submitted to the USPTO. Maybe it is by all intents and purposes using the same line width for his outlines, etc, but due to some fluke with how AI works, Mockey has three buttons instead of two, or (incredibly) 5 fingers instead of 4. Or maybe Mockey is exactly better proportioned than the cartoon friend we know, appealing more to our gross human sensibilities, but some may still construe him to be Mickey Mouse from a distance.

That image can't be copyrighted (as an AI can't obtain a copyright). Disney can't claim that image as Mickey too, lest they claim every permutation of his characteristics possible, the territory of which is really large.

Still, it stands to reasonable, common law: if its the 90s, and I drew Mockey myself and put him on a bag and made enough money on it that Disney goes after me, it's a sensible outcome that Disney wins this in court, and its primary defense is that this likeness violates their copyright. Yet if an AI made this in 2023, suddenly there is a gray area, as I am selling a likeness that nobody owns (by virtue of a lack of personhood in its creation). I feel that's a bit odd, and something people may try to exploit with this ruling. At the same time, if we give that to Disney, what's the end of the scope of copyright?

juris··on US judge: Art created solely by artificial intelligence cannot be copyrighted
Hm; maybe you are right in that I am conflating 'copyright' and 'the ability to commercialize'. So to follow up, I'm under the impression that the copyright of a character enables companies to create and sell licenses to third parties to use the likeness of the character under terms limited by the license, and that any commercial usage outside of that paradigm is a copyright violation.

EG. it's 1998 and the Pokemon Company licenses MadCatz (defunct) to create Pokemon themed N64 controllers. Such a license is limited to N64 controllers; let's say under the terms of the license, MadCatz can't turn around and make a Pokemon themed bag in the style of ugh, Rat Fink. MadCatz can't make N64 controllers, and the Pokemon Company knows this, and really doesn't want them botching up their brand with horrific art, too. Copyright protects brand.

Now legally speaking, I can put a depiction of pikachu on a powerpoint slide in a school report and call it 'fair use'. But the second I sell that art on a bag (regardless of whether I put the words Pokemon on it), I've violated copyright laws, because the purchaser of my bag has deprived our poor Pokemon company of potential income. Womp-womp. Dumb as it is for Nintendo to come after me (as they go after the makers of Pokemon rom hacks, et al), it makes some sense, depending on how I scale up.

Fast forward to 2026 and now we have GPT-8 (flip it sideways for infinity, as we have reached the Singularity by this time). Pokemon is old as the hills and is celebrating its 30th anniversary (Jesus!). I use an AI with the prompt "fat yellow thunder mouse", and it generates a "pikachu but better", uncannily like the iconic character (because it's the only yellow thunder mouse anyone ever draws) but cute in all the ways that our AI knows how to get to humans, and I decide to coin it in an NFT and put it up for sale. Let's say the Pokemon Company is particularly litigious in its old age and is a veritable Disney. Or hell, let's suppose Disney bought the Pokemon Company (and now Misty is a Disney princess, just like Leia).

Given that: I own the NFT (in the sense of your software library example), no-one owns the art (AI-generated), Pokemon owns the brand and the concept of a Pikachu, and this particular depiction is recognized to be pikachu "but kinda better", we live in one of these worlds:

1. Disney is owed money from the proceeds, and can request cease of production / legal remedy 2. It is not owed anything, as the art itself was generated from an AI.

Which makes more sense?

juris··on US judge: Art created solely by artificial intelligence cannot be copyrighted
Interesante: so I would consider AI to be necessarily transformative. The idea is that the art it produces could never be a copy, because of the effect the rest of its data corpus has on the output.

There are several layers of transformation, feedback loops, etc. I don't know exactly how it all works (I'm not an AI engineer) so there's a lot of hand waving here.

So to understand this:

1. In a world where someone owns the rights to the Mona Lisa, if I ask it to produce Mona Lisa as exactly as it can, and it produces the Mona Lisa (uncannily so, in layers of paint), can it be said to be a copy? Was there a violation? Or, per this ruling and by virtue of being produced by an AI, should that work be free to sell?

2. If I ask it to produce 'Mockey Mouse', and it produces a likeness uncannily approaching Mickey Mouse, should that work be free to sell without claims otherwise?

juris··on US judge: Art created solely by artificial intelligence cannot be copyrighted
I think it does though if you try to sell it... I mean Disney does occasionally go after artists selling baby yoda plushies that have been cropping up all over Etsy. Part of that is how busted copyright claims systems are, but they suuurely have some legal right to the likeness of yoda himself, especially in plushie context. Surely?
juris··on US judge: Art created solely by artificial intelligence cannot be copyrighted
God, I haven't even considered that. Design trolling! Prompt for an apple, iterate over all fashionable logo design styles, implicitly own the copyright all of them, then sit and wait. You're more likely to get a 'hit' as brand logos tend to be simple.

I would imagine that context matters a lot in trademark law and in design art though, since there's a lot of namespace collision in that domain. For there to be a violation of trademark or copyright, there needs to be a material loss or harm on the part of the owner of the copyrighted material, and it needs to be in the same space that the owner operates in.

Like if I generate a banana brand logo for my Banana Plumbing Co., and your AI generated similar banana line art prior, unless you were using it for plumbing it would (probably) be hard to enforce in court.

So towards preventing bulk image generation and trolling, I don't know if this ruling was especially necessary.

leaving the disadvantage of this ruling in that it encourages people to use AI as an excuse to sell like art? :D can't say I hate it though.

juris··on US judge: Art created solely by artificial intelligence cannot be copyrighted
Just spitballing here, because this is very fun to think about.

If I reproduce the likeness of Mickey Mouse via an AI, then because an AI made it, is there no defensible claim from Disney to own the copyright? That doesn't make intuitive sense, as we 'sort of know' that Disney owns the likeness.

Meanwhile, if I produce one single image that I own via copyright, and feed it to the AI as a prompt and receive a derivative of that image back, per this ruling I would not own the proceeds. It makes some sense-- an AI made it, and further, I did not produce enough instances of this art and the branding behind it for its likeness to be sufficiently "mine". I don't quite own the "mindshare", so people would not recognize the brand as being anybody's, really. So this is different from the way that Mickey Mouse is recognized.

But what if a bunch of artists were to band together to create a license of sorts for the use of an AI they altogether build? Suppose they collectively own a portfolio of copyrighted materials, characters, etc, that they use to feed the AI. Wouldn't they own the proceeds of the likenesses produced by the AI, as would provide legal justification for their licensing of the AI, and to defend their collective works in the same way that Disney can?

juris··on Caught by MuseScore's Dark Patterns (2021)
Yii, yep, this checks out. Recently I needed to transpose a few pieces, so I opened a trial with the intention of just using their app software to transpose a contributor's piece down a few keys so I can manually tabulate it for the lute.

The website claims that you require the closed source mobile app and a pro account for the transposition feature (and makes no mention that the open source software natively supports this). Argh! Stupid, stupid, stupid.

I decided not to go for the (partial) refund, and have half a mind to go in there and just grab all their midis for some generative AI come-uppance (not that you really can... you are limited to 300 scores per month), but the only people that hurts are those poor kids who were conned into submitting their arrangements to that platform. Bad feelings all around.

juris··on Taxonomy of Procrastination
Nahaha, great writing! Though, the irony of reading this and articles like these (as they often come up, or maybe that is my selection bias)... right now? Thanks, Jim.
juris··on Ask HN: What lesser-known accessories do you use with your computer?
Mobile dev here; I had an issue with organizing the vast quantity of mobile devices I have been given for testing.

* Significant QoL gain: take a trip to the dollar store to buy three short CD racks; if you lay them on their sides next to each other, you can mount your laptops and mobile devices vertically!

Much nicer than stacking your devices screen to screen, and you can keep them charged and connect them as-needed.

* Ergo Anti-pattern: I built a 35 inch deep desktop out of 2x4's, perched it on top of ikea motorized risers, all above a "LifeSpan" brand desk treadmill scrounged from Craigslist because I thought Torvalds's setup was cool (circa mid-quarantine).

This year I built a wooden frame with hatch doors above the treadmill and keep my goofy gaming chair forever parked on top of them.

juris··on Show HN: I made some ambient music generators that run in your browser
XD yes! I want to jack my earbuds into the stock market: time and sales frequency denoting tempo and trade volume denoting dynamics; with a real time candle analyzer modulating between keys. Each company would be a different song!
juris··on Show HN: I made some ambient music generators that run in your browser
I really dig this; I always have a need for background music while working and the context switching is really bothersome! Maybe I can finally ditch the youtube music sub and just support your project.

Actually, I've been thinking to write my own for baroque-era music-- those rulesets are well-enclosed and have all kinds of tricks for escaping resolution. Perfect for long D&D sessions! :D

Do you have any communities / resources you go to for inspiration for your work?

juris··on Quantum observers with knowledge of quantum mechanics break reality
The tao that can be named is not the real tao.
juris··on Amazon is stuffing its search results pages with ads
I wonder if it would be cheaper for small-time sellers to cozy up to brick and mortar store representatives than it would be to fight for space on Amazon.

Does Amazon lose market share... back to brick and mortar?

juris··on Medical Mystery Grows as U.S. Consulate Workers in China Fall Ill
You just need line of sight from a hotel room across the street. "Two parents" fits the bill of two heads at a bed, as well as these attacks occurring primarily at hotels.
juris··on Medical Mystery Grows as U.S. Consulate Workers in China Fall Ill
Following US patent application number: 20180139557

Is it possible to conceive a weapon that generates sound at specific distances in space using ultrasonic signals as a carrier to get -into- hotel rooms? Can sound do this much damage to the human brain?

juris··on F.C.C. Repeals Net Neutrality Rules
Hehe, you know, line of sight solutions like lasers would be epically cool here.
juris··on F.C.C. Repeals Net Neutrality Rules
Depends on where you live. Every city has different laws about how to run cable underneath the ground. The first cost you pay is figuring out where everyone's cables are. The second cost you pay is convincing the city to let you do it. The third cost you pay is doing the digging.

If you spin it off as a service to your block, then it might be possible...?

juris··on F.C.C. Repeals Net Neutrality Rules
No way, man. People hate their ISP's, and would love to be able to switch.
juris··on F.C.C. Repeals Net Neutrality Rules
I think that would be a good value proposition for a city that does not already prefer one ISP over another. Interesting idea to spin something like this up.
juris··on F.C.C. Repeals Net Neutrality Rules
This wouldn't be a problem if ISP's weren't de facto monopolies. If there was competition in this space, then there would be incentive to improve the infrastructure and Internet speeds. However, ISP's kill competition by making legal arrangements with local governments to only do business with them, and by cutting competitors' cables. Since we have no way to guarantee reasonable speeds to small time websites now, we should pursue antitrust legal and foster competition in this space. Comcast didn't realize it, but net neutrality was their own safety net.
juris··on The Corrosion of High School Debate
Spreading is good practice for speed reading and enunciation. Their coach has failed them if they allow it to continue into the competition room, unless they have asked both the judge and their opponents whether it is OK.

Key thing here: parents judge rounds. These lay judges aren't trained to listen to 300 wpm. They don't know any better though-- they'll still come back to the tab room and say "wow, these kids are really great, I didn't even understand what they were saying!" Yuck. The politicians of tomorrow.

And if your opponents haven't trained spread, what's the use of you spreading? Are you that insecure in your ability to sway others with logic and reason that you would resort to speaking quickly? Maybe instead of getting riled up by the game you should learn a real skill: listening. You'll find more of their flaws that way.

If you can't speak in a way that your listeners can understand, then your words are worthless.

← PreviousPage 3 of 3