HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

justsee

1,496 karma · joined June 26, 2010

submissionscomments
justsee··on Assange Hearing Day 6
There's a demonstrated lack of understanding around important details of this case in your responses.

The accusation you raise is a key part of the interview with Melzer.

The original witness statement was intentionally destroyed, and the supervisor of the policewoman who conducted the questioning wrote an email telling her to rewrite the statement.

(The original copies of the mail exchanges between the Swedish police are actually displayed in the article.)

The statement that forms the basis of that claim "was edited without the involvement of the woman in question and it wasn’t signed by her. It is a manipulated piece of evidence out of which the Swedish authorities then constructed a story of rape."

As to your attempted lazy smearing – it doesn't really do you any favours here.

As a final plea, perhaps read-up on the details so you can get a better understanding of the case:

https://www.republik.ch/2020/01/31/nils-melzer-about-wikilea...

justsee··on Assange Hearing Day 6
Melzer goes into detail about how the women didn't accuse him of rape.

It's worth engaging in the facts on this issue, rather than gripping onto a received narrative in dismissive fashion, and the interview really goes into significant detail, including behind-the-scenes behaviour of Sweden that Melzer was privy to as UN Special Rapporteur on torture.

It's one of those articles where people go in with the perspective you show here, and come out the end of it stunned by the truth of Assange's unjust treatment.

In fact Melzer starts out by stating he began with the same attitude, initially refusing the case as "My impression, largely influenced by the media, was also colored by the prejudice that Julian Assange was somehow guilty and that he wanted to manipulate me."

It is probably one of the best summaries of his case I've read, from a highly credible, independent investigator:

https://www.republik.ch/2020/01/31/nils-melzer-about-wikilea...

justsee··on Assange Hearing Day 6
Actually it's clear from Melzer's thorough investigation, where he reviewed the entire case material, including original Swedish documents, that this was an operation to frame Assange and extradite him to the US – and nothing to do with the two women, who were very clearly pawns in the process.

It's really worth reading the interview closely to understand how thoroughly justice has been perverted in numerous countries to get at someone who revealed horrendous crimes.

justsee··on Assange Hearing Day 6
It's important to remember the Swedish authorities were never interested in testimony from Assange.

It's worth reading this interview [1] with Nils Melzer, the UN Special Rapporteur on torture, which reveals in shocking detail the level of manipulation around this entire case.

As Melzer says "You just have to look at how the case was run: For Sweden, it was never about the interests of the two women."

[1] https://www.republik.ch/2020/01/31/nils-melzer-about-wikilea...

justsee··on Facebook to block news on Australian sites after new law, riling lawmakers
Exactly. It's a perfect example of crony capitalism.

A political party in a symbiotic relationship with Murdoch (whose press outlets operate as the communications wing of the Coalition) eagerly pushes a rent-seeking law and claims it's about supporting journalism.

This is the same political party that does everything it can to defund public interest journalism (via the ABC and SBS), regularly gives indefensible grants to Murdoch, and has created a climate where police raids on journalists is the new normal.

The code deliberately excludes smaller publishers and the public broadcasters from any of this rent-seeking, and the ACCC in recent years has allowed significant media consolidation: allowing Murdoch to buy up most regional papers, and allowing Nine to buy Fairfax (Nine held a political fundraiser for that political party immediately after the election).

The state of journalism in Australia is dire, even compared to US and UK standards, and that's largely to do with intentional political acts.

Facebook and Google are in the right here.

justsee··on An Update About Changes to Facebook’s Services in Australia
This is the right move by Facebook (and Google) in the face of naked crony capitalism.

It's an effort by the Morrison government to engage in rent-seeking on behalf of Rupert Murdoch's News (which essentially operates as the communications arm of Morrison's government), Nine (which held a fundraiser after the last national election for Morrison) and other media groups.

Yes, there are many valid criticisms of and concerns we should have with tech giants, but this proposed code doesn't deal with any of those concerns.

Australia's former Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, who has stepped up his war against Murdoch's influence on Australian Democracy in recent years, was incredibly perceptive and scathing of this proposed code recently [1].

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XiFTT_QgqIc&feature=youtu.be...

justsee··on Facebook threatens to ban Australians from sharing news
Good to see this move from Facebook, not because Facebook is without issues, but because the proposed scheme is truly awful.

Google seemed a little hung out to dry going in hard with the messaging across its products with no announcements from Facebook.

Hopefully with Facebook's rather aggressive messaging Labor and crossbenchers will pay closer notice to the nuances of this issue.

Stratechery provided a great overview of just how bad this 'News Media Bargaining Code' is [1].

[1] https://stratechery.com/2020/australias-news-media-bargainin...

justsee··on WebBundles harmful to content blocking, security tools, and the open web
It looks like you've responded to the wrong thread.

(I posted one comment on this article, and a few follow-up comments to people who engaged with it.)

justsee··on WebBundles harmful to content blocking, security tools, and the open web
Again, I did not state "WebBundles = a blackbox". That is your misinterpretation of my comment which I took the time to clarify:

"I am hardly claiming any one initiative takes us straight there [to a black box of the web]".

I was extremely clear on that, and further explained that we must consider Google's pattern of behaviour and commercial interests here – not one specific action.

Ignoring my good-faith clarification you seemingly continue to suffer this misconception – that I asserted something I didn't ("back up your description of WebBundles as a black box"). You may be more interested in engaging with and refuting arguments based on a convenient misconception, but I really am not.

For anyone seriously interested in this topic from the perspective of the open web and content blocking, the blog author summarised his concerns in a Github ticket [1].

(The responses throughout the Github issue reflect a similar strategy of a 'fingers-in-the-ears, everything is fine, what are you talking about' approach)

[1] https://github.com/WICG/webpackage/issues/551#issuecomment-6...

justsee··on WebBundles harmful to content blocking, security tools, and the open web
That claim comes from you, as a Google employee?

I didn't say that, and I would assume most HN readers understand I was moving from the specific concerns content blockers have with your 'WebBundles' proposal to commentary on the wider motivations of Google: that its business interests logically drive it to find ways to thwart content blockers which frustrate their ad-tech ecosystem.

A web architecture which does not allow content to be modified – one that results in websites being a 'black box' – is the ideal outcome for Google's ad-tech ecosystem.

I am hardly claiming any one initiative takes us straight there - that would be quite the poor strategic play from Google. But Google's changes to Chrome to frustrate content-blockers [1], through to AMP and now WebBundles paint a disturbing picture for independent observers.

For examples that might speak to the institutional strategies employed by Google, recall the claims from Johnathan Nightingale that Google systematically sabotaged Firefox over a decade [2].

Those claims are telling not just for the institutional analysis, but for the revelation of an honest mindset among Google engineers internally:

"I think our friends inside Google genuinely believed that. At the individual level, their engineers cared about most of the same things we did."

When I see the valid claims made of serious issues around AMP and WebBundles, and see honest, heartfelt responses from Google engineers that it's all fine and a beat-up, I can't help but think of Nightingale's observations.

"Hey everyone, it's all fine. We mean well. Don't worry - nothing to see here."

[1] https://www.cnet.com/news/google-holds-firm-on-chrome-change...

[2] https://www.zdnet.com/article/former-mozilla-exec-google-has...

justsee··on WebBundles harmful to content blocking, security tools, and the open web
The blog author summarises the core issue here [1].

WebBundles are an attack on user agency: the right to filter content on the open web.

Google putting forward a proposal which directly attacks the ability of general-purpose blockers to operate is not a case of "nothing to see here, I did something I think approximates this situation years back".

The moral case of "blocking = theft" clearly isn't getting political traction so an alternative or accompaniment is pushing standards to destroy the rights of user agency.

Keep in mind Gorhill's statement on justifying uBlock Origin [2]:

"That said, it's important to note that using a blocker is NOT theft. Don't fall for this creepy idea. The ultimate logical consequence of blocking = theft is the criminalisation of the inalienable right to privacy."

Noble and correct, but if this technical war is successfully waged as mentioned it all becomes moot.

Some may desire that the internet moves to a set-top box model of pressing buttons to get an un-inspectable, unmodifable content window for consumption, but many of us do not.

I can't think of anything worse: the open web transformed by ad-tech behemoths into some kind of locked-down hotel entertainment system.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24276819

[2] https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock#philosophy

justsee··on WebBundles harmful to content blocking, security tools, and the open web
Things like AMP and WebBundles clearly appear like a self-interested attack on the open web by Google, all the while making reasonable-sounding noises about efficiency and speed.

With the inexorable rise of ad-blockers, allowing 'User Agents' to be true agents of the user is a threat to Google's business model, and any significant engineering and standards efforts by that company can and should be evaluated by assuming the driver is not web altruism, but ferocious defence of their business model.

Interesting to see Google accounts drop in to misdirect on the essence of the argument outlined in the article: the essence being that bundles create private namespaces for URLS, which is an attack on the agency of a user in consuming content.

It should be unsurprising that Google wants to blackbox websites. If these kinds of initiatives succeed the philosophical debate around whether a user has the right to filter content running on their machine becomes moot, because technically they won't be able to.

The bottom line is: Google's business model is threatened by users being able to control the content they consume. Splitting hairs on how bad WebBundles will be in practice wilfully or otherwise misses this larger, more important point.

Operating in an Australian context, it's exasperating arguing forcefully for Google and Facebook [1] in regards to the new shakedown laws outlined brilliantly by Stratechery [2], all the while knowing there are very real criticisms that should be discussed, such as AMP and WebBundles.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24186376

[2] https://stratechery.com/2020/australias-news-media-bargainin...

justsee··on Response to Google open letter
1. Yes we haven't heard yet whether they will appeal, but the law as it currently stands creates a legal context where you can understand publishers wanting more information about Facebook users who comment on their posts. There are some perverse shakedown incentives created by the current situation.

2. Thanks - poor wording on my part. I meant to communicate that Facebook avoids liability in their terms, and of course the court determined the actual liability falls on publishers posting content.

justsee··on Response to Google open letter
When you consider the wider legal context, this also makes sense* .

This is because Facebook requires page owners to assume all liability for comments.

This has resulted in publishers losing defamation cases based on third-party comments made on their posts [1].

* (regardless of whether you feel, as I do, that the proposed legislation is a politically-motivated protection racket for a favoured media mogul)

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/media/2020/jun/01/australian-med...

justsee··on Response to Google open letter
Yes a good point.

It's also worth remembering Foxtel demanded it get paid to retransmit ABC and SBS content, which was reduced to some lesser, unknown figure last year [1].

Apparently content is worthless unless it is privately funded.

[1] https://www.afr.com/companies/media-and-marketing/foxtel-and...

justsee··on Response to Google open letter
Google isn't in the wrong here, and framing this as just an honest consumer-first regulator doing their job omits critical context to help people understand what's happening.

The party in power federally is the Coalition, and they are deeply entwined, in a symbiotic relationship, with Rupert Murdoch's News Ltd: illustrated by endless editorial lines supportive of the Coalition in media across the country, revolving doors of Coalition advisors and News Ltd staff, through to regular questionable and controversial decisions in favour of News Ltd.

A great example was Foxtel being given a $30 million grant with no process, documentation or explanation around it [1]. It was simply explained as 'media reform'.

Like those 'media reforms', these proposed ones are also highly politically-driven and largely to the benefit of News Ltd.

This is not about supporting our news media here: the public broadcasters (ABC and SBS) dominate online and yet the proposed legislation deliberately excludes them from any claimed profiteering from Google.

This is just the abandoning of any free market principles the Coalition claims to have to provide support for their domestic media wing, in the form a local protection racket.

The claim of profiteering from search result listings, as you also imply above, is just not true.

As one ex-News Ltd and Google-associated Twitter account has emphasised, Google delivers billions of free clicks to publishers and makes very little ad revenue around search results. [2]

A good brief summary of the situation can be found from a local tech commentator, Justin Warren [3]. Two valuable points he makes:

* big publishers are salty over failing to see classified ads would get destroyed by online

* there are legitimate concerns with Google and Facebook, but they're largely orthogonal to any of this

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/jul/19/gover...

[2] https://twitter.com/neilwrites/status/1295200085152694272

[3] https://www.eigenmagic.com/2020/08/17/draft-news-media-and-d...

justsee··on Interview with Bill Gates on Covid, social media
In the above comment I'm advocating for honest debate, not HCL.

That debate has of course not been particularly honest: amplifying the weakest proponents, fabrication of negative data with the Surgisphere scandal [1] and fixating on studies which don't replicate the claimed beneficial outpatient (pre-hospitalization) treatment processes (low-dose HCL, zinc, azithromycin).

However none of that means HCL is actually effective, just that the public debate being prosecuted is quite weak when looked at carefully.

It could just be that once a mainstream position is established (which might be correct!) it becomes easier to engage in influencing to enforce or signal tribal commitment to the established consensus in place of continued honest debate.

I really don't want to hear about the cultural beliefs of the weakest advocates, or of studies which don't replicate the claimed treatment.

I want to see engagement with the strongest advocates, and studies which irrefutably rule out the specific treatment, and if they rule this out as just another alluring low-cost, ineffective treatment, then at least we've reached that point honestly.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jun/12/covid-19-studi...

justsee··on Interview with Bill Gates on Covid, social media
It was disappointing to see that segue from Gates.

Consider that the pile-on of that doctor - an African from Cameroon where Christianity is blended with traditional tribal superstition - happened around the same time as the Professor of Epidemiology at Yale School of Public Health published a Newsweek piece on how HCL is a valid early-stage treatment [1].

I understand this is how the media works: an advocate of HCL who has fringe cultural beliefs was retweeted by Trump, so the story was irresistible and endlessly amplified (including here by Gates).

But the quality of debate would be so much better if the media engaged with the (superficially) strongest proponents of a position (such as Harvey Risch) and aimed withering criticism and analysis at them instead. Shouldn't the focus be on dismantling the claims of the most, not the least, credentialed proponents?

Instead the media from all quarters deliberately amplifies the most fringe proponents, so now HCL is shorthand for expressing disdain for particular cultural beliefs, and those 10 million views were significantly driven by most media outlets covering her.

[1] https://www.newsweek.com/key-defeating-covid-19-already-exis...

justsee··on Interview with Bill Gates on Covid, social media
We aren't recapitulating the e2e debate, Gates is in his interview.

Someone like Gates pushing for the end of private speech at scale is always going to be of interest to the HN crowd.

justsee··on Brave Browser and the Wayback Machine: Working Together
Very happy to engage in an ethical debate on this one.

This line about 'swapping ads with their own' has been an attempt to imply in the reader's mind that Brave was / is nefariously replacing actual ads with their own, which is not true.

The truth is Brave blocks all ads by default, and nothing more.

Do you believe it's ethical for a user agent to block ads, or that it's unethical and a form of theft?

I'm with gorhill of uBlock on this [1]:

  That said, it's important to note that using a blocker is NOT theft.
  Don't fall for this creepy idea.
  The ultimate logical consequence of blocking = theft is the criminalisation of the inalienable right to privacy.
Separate to this, Brave has a rewards system users can choose to enable which can show OS-level notifications of advertiser content in a privacy-respecting way.

The ethics around this are clear:

* if a user wishes to opt-out of an insecure, fraudulent and privacy-harming ad-tech ecosystem for content on the open web that is their right

* if that same user wants to opt-in to a privacy-respecting alternative ad model which operates in a very different way, that's also their right

Attempting to claim the combination of these optional user choices is 'ad swapping' in a nefarious, unethical sense is simply dishonest.

A more accurate phrase considering the individual user choices involved might be 'model swapping'.

As a user I deliberately choose to swap the current ad-tech model with a new, innovative model. That model may have to evolve, but from a technical and human perspective appears to be much better than the current status quo.

[1] https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock#philosophy

justsee··on Brave Browser and the Wayback Machine: Working Together
As a privacy-minded, ethically-motivated technologist I support Brave for their strong position on privacy - a position in which they are peerless amongst other browser vendors.

I am always open to changing my mind, yet when I see the same untruths mustered to poison-the-well ('swapping ads with their own' - not true) I wonder why the same dishonest and distorted talking points come up instead of any valid criticisms.

What you call 'cryptocurrency nonsense' is a model that potentially threatens to overturn Google's ad model, and with it the current ad-tech ecosystem.

That obviously means there's a huge number of high-stakes players who are very keen for this particular model not to 'take' in the online world, and so we see the same untruths constantly amplified.

Brave must be doing something right, and even if there's a purist's position which says their model is not the holy grail, I'd prefer innovation and disrupted business models over a continuation of the current ad-tech status quo.

justsee··on Ask HN: I'm away from the software industry since 2017; what has happened since?
Next.js positions itself as a hybrid framework, and is recommending SSG (static site generation) by default over SSR.

See this discussion [1] with the response from rauchg (framework author and Zeit founder) outlining where they are heading.

This ability to easily mix SSG and SSR pages within the one project, the PHP-inspired philosophy of simple file-based routing for pages, and pre-configured babel / webpack with easy customisation are a few things that draw people into next.js dev.

Like anything that deals with reasonable complexity there are a bunch of concepts to understand, but once that happens next.js feels like a thin layer around "it's just react".

I particularly like being able to drop api functions with a standard req / res signature into `pages/api` to immediately have some server-side api endpoints available, which can be deployed to Zeit's now as Lambdas with minimal fuss. It significantly reduces the friction of thinking about and implementing front-end sites with custom api endpoints for whatever you're building.

[1]: https://github.com/zeit/next.js/discussions/10437

justsee··on Brave Passes 10M Monthly Active Users, Sees 19% Growth Since 1.0 Launch
Your first criticism demands people ignore Hanlon's Razor ("never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity") and buy in to a most bizarre business model: that the Brave team had a plan to defraud users of donations to unverified creators.

It's hard to overstate how absurd this is as you work through the implications: it means this business model is in conflict with the obvious goal of growing the ecosystem of verified creators as quickly as possible, and assumes incredible ignorance from the Brave team about likely revenue from users unwittingly donating to unverified creators.

The reality is without creators actively pushing their supporters to donate to them via Brave's rewards system the funding flow would largely be Brave 'promoters' pushing creators to use that funding channel.

Instead of this nonsensical explanation it's easy to understand the simple and correct one: Brave had an aggressive growth marketing strategy where they imagined being able to email unverified creators with emails about how much $$$ they could collect from users who had started donating to them, and in doing so accelerate verification of creators.

The stupidity here is that they didn't properly consider that some creators would rightly object to an implication Brave Rewards was an approved donation channel for that creator, which could theoretically risk cannibalising donations that would otherwise go through other channels (that it would likely be a negligible amount doesn't make it any less unethical). Brave did the right thing in fixing it in an early public beta, which is the point of public betas.

Your second criticism about user agent spoofing depends on a fundamental lack of awareness about the whole history of user agent strings, which is basically a story of challenger browsers spoofing the user agent string of the dominant browser within an ecosystem for compatibility reasons [0].

That you attempt to assert that UA spoofing is a nefarious practice (but presumably only for Brave, not for every other browser that does this, such as Chrome for Android which presents as Safari[1]) is yet more evidence of the low credibility of these criticisms.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_agent#User_agent_spoofing

[1] https://developer.chrome.com/multidevice/user-agent

justsee··on Brave Passes 10M Monthly Active Users, Sees 19% Growth Since 1.0 Launch
I followed that episode closely.

To claim it demonstrated intentional fraud rather than poor UX and rewards architecture in an early beta (which was immediately fixed) is simply not credible.

The only funds flowing through the system at that stage were from Brave's own marketing budget through the form of user grants.

The concerns were about theoretical, future issues if Brave ever broke out as a mainstream browser and rewards / payment solution.

Even now, a year after the issue was fixed, it remains to be seen whether Brave's payment system draws in anything more than Brave's own distribution of tokens (through grants and ad rewards to users).

As an early adopter I'm aware of honest, thoughtful criticisms (browser monoculture with Chromium) and... this is not one of them.

justsee··on Brave launches 1.0
Surveillance capitalism simply describes the business model of spying on users to build hidden psychological / behavioural / demographic profiles which are then sold through opaque backroom market mechanisms, all with zero regard to consent.

You can have a positive view of each separate word (depending on context) and the term still works perfectly in describing the business model society is beginning to reject, through mechanisms like the GDPR and CCPA.

justsee··on Brave launches 1.0
Recent cross-platform options with surveillance capitalism:

* Google Chrome: mandatory

* Firefox: opt-out [1]

* Brave: blocked

That's the primary issue.

It's great that Brave is pioneering a new opt-in, privacy-respecting funding model for the web - we need innovation here - but it's a secondary issue.

[1] Thanks to Google $, slowly changing presumably thanks to forcing effects of Apple's increasing privacy defaults in Safari

justsee··on Brave launches 1.0
People can't suddenly start sending you BAT.

They can attempt to send you BAT in the browser, but it shows that you're an unverified creator, so the browser essentially 'holds' the BAT and attempts to send to you for a period of time (I think 90 days).

You sign up at https://creators.brave.com/ for your website / reddit / github / twitter / soundcloud / etc and verification happens depending on the platform, then you're shown as a registered creator in the browser when someone visits.

You get the BAT donation and just like any income would have to consider tax implications.

justsee··on Using Firefox for a faster, calmer and distraction-free internet
Actually because Brave aggressively and efficiently blocks ads and trackers by default it has a much better battery & performance profile.

They've blogged about this in detail. One recent post was : https://brave.com/accurately-predicting-ad-blocker-savings/.

Stating that they're simply an advertising company misses a significant amount of innovative work they're doing in-browser too.

They're building a new business model and infrastructure that is diametrically opposed to the current surveillance capitalism model, and this infrastructure can replace donations, sponsorship, advertising and subscription models in a way that reduces transaction friction significantly, and could very likely challenge a significant number of powerful incumbents.

justsee··on Some tea bags may shed billions of microplastics per cup
As I understand it even the 'paper' teabags contain plastic which is why they shouldn't ever be disposed with any organics waste (and possibly raise similar health concerns due to being immersed in boiling water before being ingested).

A quick search reveals an article[1] stating:

> Most bags, including those made by the five leading tea brands in the UK – PG Tips, Tetley, Twinings, Typhoo, and Yorkshire Tea – use non-biodegradable polypropylene as sealants in their bags. A spokesperson from the makers of Yorkshire Tea confirmed to Resource: “Our tea bag material contains around 25 per cent polypropylene (PP) which we believe is typical for the market. It’s a component of the material that allows us to heat seal the bag.”

[1] https://resource.co/article/should-you-put-tea-bags-your-foo...

justsee··on How the UK Security Services neutralised The Guardian
Having been a close reader of The Guardian over many years I'd very much agree with your observations.

It still has the shimmer of a left-leaning paper on soft social issues, but on many matters of significance it's clearly being used to influence left-leaning voters towards an acceptance of a right-wing, authoritarian, security-state worldview (the irony being it keeps up a pretence of the reverse when covering Trump etc).

The article itself was an outstanding deep dive into the history of The Guardian investigative reporting, appeared to reveal behind-the-scenes information I wasn't aware of, such as the effective disbanding The Guardian's veteran investigate reporting team.

← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →