HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jwells89

4,281 karma · joined July 3, 2023

An iOS/macOS dev and tinkerer with an interest in UI design.

https://www.wells.dev/

submissionscomments
jwells89··on From 14 years old till 29, my experience with desktop Linux
I started in the mid-90s, and though I didn’t use 95 much I did use 98SE (which is aesthetically very similar to 95) and 2000 plenty.

For releases with the classic Windows look, I think 2000 is best. It makes a few refinements to the theme that at least to me make it more pleasant to use than 95/98.

jwells89··on From 14 years old till 29, my experience with desktop Linux
GNOME resembles macOS in that it's not yet another Win9X-like desktop, but that's about where it ends. Its closest commercial cousin is probably iPadOS, even though that's not what the GNOME devs were trying for. While it's obviously not as limiting as iPadOS is, much of the UI and interactions are strikingly similar, as is the overall ethos.

Where macOS has always been about progressive disclosure with tons of little power user affordances hidden in plain sight, GNOME is more about paring everything down to the bare essentials in a polished way.

jwells89··on From 14 years old till 29, my experience with desktop Linux
I think this would be a great feature, though faithfully reproducing a Mac desktop will likely be difficult, between making Command/Meta-based key shortcuts consistent through the system and making sure the global menubar actually gets populated.

The latter of those is actually the more difficult of the two. Last I knew the GTK plugin that provides application menus through dbus was broken, and many GTK apps don't have a menubar anyway (anything that doesn't fit into a hamburger menu gets binned). Qt apps are better here but there's some bug under Wayland that prevents menus from being pulled from those.

There really ought to be an XDG standard for UI toolkits to provide their menubars to system bars, HUDs, accessibility utilities, etc with.

jwells89··on From 14 years old till 29, my experience with desktop Linux
> There's an enormous number of Windows users who hate Microsoft's changes to the Windows GUI and wish they could still run XP or 7.

The Windows 7 UI has aged pretty well too, even if the glossy visuals have become somewhat outdated (though personally I think they look better than modern flat stuff). I rigged up an old laptop of mine with 7 not too long ago and plugged into a modern monitor and it was striking how nice it was compared to 11.

High-fidelity 1-click reproductions of XP/7 for Linux would be very popular, I think. Bonus points if they can use the hundreds (thousands?) of XP and 7 msstyle themes on sites like DeviantArt.

jwells89··on Linux: We need tiling desktop environments
Something that isn't clear to me is why there has to be a hard divide between CSD and SSD. Is there anything in the Wayland spec that prevents UI frameworks from saying, "hey windowmanager/compositor, here's where control widgets go for this window", allowing WM-drawn controls to live on the same plane of existence as program-drawn controls? That along with some way for the WM/compositor to tell the UI framework if the user wants a discrete titlebar or if they're cool with the UI framework doing its own thing seems like it'd make everybody happy.
jwells89··on Linux: We need tiling desktop environments
That would be a useful feature, so long as there's some associated UI that makes it obvious that the feature is active along with an easy way to toggle it off. Seems like it could be one of those features that users accidentally trigger without realizing it and then feel "trapped" not knowing how to make it stop.
jwells89··on Linux: We need tiling desktop environments
Yeah, many years ago I ran a crunchbang-style setup with openbox and tint2 and while the low resource usage and customizability was great, it was irritating having to find and set up daemons, tray items, etc (all of which seemingly coming with their own list of incapabilities/tradeoffs) for every little thing. I absolutely sympathize with minimizing bloat, but it feels like things like volume keys should fall within the scope of bare minimum out of the box functionality.
jwells89··on Linux: We need tiling desktop environments
Might give them a try when I get the chance, but I'm skeptical that those will be much better than tiling for my usage, particularly as someone who prefers a centered main monitor and angled secondary monitor over ultrawides.
jwells89··on Linux: We need tiling desktop environments
I've never been able to make tiling-first environments work for me (even if they have a floating mode). Things that aren't terminals or text editors tend to not tile well, particularly on smaller screens, and using them entails a level of window micromanagement that I don't engage in with floating-first environments.

The ability to overlap is also actually pretty valuable for me. Often I don't need to see a whole window, just the pertinent portion, and sometimes window edges peeking out from behind my browser window act like post-it note style reminders.

It's nice to be able to snap windows into grid positions on occasion (preferably without aero snap, the animations for that erroneously trigger way too often on multi monitor setups) but it's easy enough to bolt that onto a floating WM.

jwells89··on Is Telegram really an encrypted messaging app?
You’re also not stuck with the official client and all of its decisions like with Signal. In addition to the official Qt and Swift/Cocoa Telegram clients, you can find third party clients written in WinUI and GTK as well as a CLI client, which gives users the choice to use the one that fits their wants/needs best.

I use both on desktop for different people and the desktop Signal client doesn’t hold up well in comparison. In some ways it feels more clunky than the iMessage ancestor iChat did 20 years ago.

jwells89··on Apple explores robotics in search of life beyond the iPhone
The impression I get is that there's a substantial appetite for experimentation with (and attention for in general for) macOS among Mac fans that hasn't been satisfied since iOS began to suck all the air out of the room many years ago. It's understandable that Apple might not want to rock the boat too much for more general audience Mac users, though. Perhaps some kind of "enthusiast mode" for macOS that could act as a playground for these things is in order.
jwells89··on NASA announces Boeing Starliner crew will return on SpaceX Crew-9
The shuttle program had several problems, but perhaps the biggest was something of a "design by committee" issue. Too many interested parties wanted it to do too many things, making it somewhere between bad and mediocre at all of them, to say nothing of the costs.

To build reliable, economical rockets and spacecraft (at least those burdened with the task of escaping Earth's gravity well), you need to be able to intensely specialize and streamline them to the greatest degree possible, with what complexity remains pulling its own weight several times over. They need to be really good at one thing, with any other use cases coming as a bonus.

jwells89··on JavaScript dates are about to be fixed
It was nice. As long as you weren't doing something totally inadvisable like using IE 7 or something, things generally worked fine. Blink, Gecko, WebKit, whatever. Even random tiny FOSS browser projects wrapping somewhat outdated builds of WebKit or Gecko worked ok the majority of the time as long as you spoofed the user agent string of one of the big guys.
jwells89··on I sped up serde_json strings by 20%
Built in JSON encoding/decoding is one of the things I’ve enjoyed about Swift. It’s nice when it’s not necessary to shop around for libraries for common needs like that.
jwells89··on Apple Adopts 6 of OWA's Browser Choice Architecture Recommendations
The thing I worry about with replacement of SFSafariViewController is if the replacement will replicate its behavior of making each app's instance its own separate little world that keeps random apps from being to easily stick its hand into the "real" browser's cookie jar. It's certainly not in e.g. Google's interest to implement that behavior in Chrome for iOS.
jwells89··on Apple Adopts 6 of OWA's Browser Choice Architecture Recommendations
I’ve gotten that banner on Maps and YouTube too. Super irritating, and to me should be subject to just as much regulatory scrutiny as default browser on iOS has been. Google writing their web apps in ways that favor Blink/Chrome should also be looked at.
jwells89··on SwiftUI for Mac 2024
Also prefer Xcode. As long as you stay away from XIBs and Storyboards it’s more responsive than Android Studio.

And yeah, if you let a project lapse on gradle and library updates for any length of time at all be prepared for a fight to get it all brought back up to speed. Swift Package Manager is generally less of a headache.

Some of AS’ “smart” features are also more of a hindrance than a help at times, and don’t even get me started on ProGuard (which has no Apple ecosystem equivalent).

jwells89··on SwiftUI for Mac 2024
My reason is that frameworks are generally more wide and deep than can be found elsewhere. It’s not difficult at all to build a polished app with nothing but Swift and AppKit/UIKit, with few or no third party libraries, which is increasingly rare in my experience (certainly not the case with WinUI or Android Framework). The next most comparable thing is Qt Widgets, but that’s for practical purposes restricted to either C++ or Python and is seemingly not receiving much attention any more than it’s been decided that the more “bring your own everything” style Qt Quick is the star of the Qt show.

AppKit/UIKit aren’t afraid to be opinionated either which is occasionally annoying but 90% of the time a good thing, because that makes for tested and supported happy paths that work well. Android Framework is the biggest contrast here, being littered with multiple half-baked ways to do everything, none of which Google has shown any particular preference toward until in just the past few years.

What would get me to move for my personal projects is something with that solidly “batteries included” aspect to it (there’s no excuse for needing to rope in a third party library to get something as mundane as a scrolling sortable table view with headers in a desktop UI framework, that’s like new cars coming without wheels) and similar opinionation, along with support for Swift or compiled Swift-like language.

jwells89··on Procreate's anti-AI pledge attracts praise from digital creatives
It has to do with what the resulting model is used for. It gets particularly dodgy if its commercial usage, because most if not all of the data used for training wasn’t licensed for that, making for a “laundering” effect.

Though I also think there’s an argument to be made that images need to be properly licensed to even be “analyzed” in this way, because it’s ultimately an unauthorized copy even if it involves picking the image apart and obfuscation. They were published with the intent of being viewed by the public, not for being reproduced in any shape or form.

jwells89··on Procreate's anti-AI pledge attracts praise from digital creatives
Artists are increasingly souring on Photoshop and looking for alternatives in response to the increasing presence of generative AI in it, so in some capacity, yes it is.
jwells89··on Millennials Are Becoming Boomers
One’s mortgage payment in even a moderate cost of living area can quickly go from manageable to difficult or impossible if something suddenly curbs their earning potential, and barring a lucky break that pays the mortgage off, this possibility will loom large for decades with the chances of things going wrong increasing with each passing year as health declines.

Decades ago when housing prices and pay were better aligned, there was a much better chance of being able to scrape by if it came down to that, plus it was easier to pay the house off in a reasonable amount of time giving that less of a chance to occur.

Point in case, where I live a pretty typical pre-interest-spike house payment is twice the gross income of someone working a full time minimum wage job which doesn’t cover food, utilities, clothes, etc. Not only does this put ownership out of reach for a lot of people, but makes it possible to quickly turn precarious for even many of those who can afford it.

And this just gets worse for more expensive areas where the disparity is much more extreme like in the SF Bay Area.

jwells89··on Mpv – A free, open-source, and cross-platform media player
Not something I have experience with so can’t speak to that.
jwells89··on Mpv – A free, open-source, and cross-platform media player
The explanation I’ve read in the past is that the difference lies in how VLC was initially focused on playback of video streamed over a network (hence the name Video LAN Client), which was generally more rocky a couple decades ago when the quality and bandwidth of the average connection was lower and the only routes between the client and server could be highly indirect or routed through weak nodes.

In that environment, playing at all without constantly dropping out or buffering is the goal, which is more achievable when fudging accuracy/correctness (which wouldn’t have been possible anyway).

Not sure how true that is though, it’s not something I’ve ever verified.

jwells89··on Mpv – A free, open-source, and cross-platform media player
This has always worked well for me, handling anything that’s thrown at it with ease.

Things may have changed since then, but when I first encountered the project several years ago it seemed like the thing that made this project stand out compared to other player projects was a big emphasis on correctness and accurate playback. There have files I’ve encountered that for example VLC will play with quirks (color reproduction is not quite right, etc) that mpv plays perfectly.

jwells89··on Firefox Browser Ported to HaikuOS
That makes a lot of sense, and I agree. Perhaps a good baseline to develop against today to produce a similar result on modern hardware would be something like a Core 2 Duo or Core i5-750 and Geforce 9600 GT.
jwells89··on AMD's Strix Point: Zen 5 Hits Mobile
Seems like this could be fixed by a system setting that disables automatic graphic switching which can be controlled by power profiles. That way the user can set the machine to use iGPU only when on battery, regardless of what programs want.
jwells89··on AMD's Strix Point: Zen 5 Hits Mobile
It might also be good to mandate 10+ hours of battery life when the laptop is in power saving mode. A number of laptops that'd otherwise have decent battery life are hampered by things like half-baked power management of discrete GPUs that doesn't completely cut power supply to those components. Manufacturers should be more heavily testing under this mode.
jwells89··on Firefox Browser Ported to HaikuOS
Mac OS 9 felt pretty darned fast on my 400Mhz iMac G3 back in 2000. Same for Windows 2000 on my parents’ PIII 750Mhz Dimension 4100. The only time anything felt slow is when a significant amount of data needed to be loaded from their hard drives.

Not all machines were like this though, we also had a Compaq Presario with some kind of Celeron running 98SE and that thing did feel slow more often than not, especially after several months of usage with the cruft buildup that comes with that.

jwells89··on SanDisk introduces the first 8TB SD and 4TB microSD cards
Don’t know if Sony counts as a “tier 1” manufacturer, but Xperias still have SD card slots as well as headphone jacks.
jwells89··on Ask HN: 19yr old child suffering from internet gaming disorder? Any suggestions?
I don’t have much to add, not having any experience as a parent, but wanted to say that it may be wise to take care in applying pressure in this situation.

Some people (including myself) have a tendency to retreat into games when feeling overwhelmed or when it seems like life is being consumed by responsibilities. In my case the game tends to be WoW, owing to the era in which I was a young adult. As I’ve aged I’ve been able to curb this tendency pretty well, but that can be tough to do before one’s ability to self-regulate has developed.

It might be worth trying to understand where the 19 year old is sitting in this regard. There may be a deeper reason why they’re being pulled into that Roblox tower defense game that needs addressing. Are they happy with where they’re at and what they’re doing? Do they feel like they still have enough time to themselves after taking care of their responsibilities? These are the sorts of questions I’d ask.

Of course it’s also possible that there’s no issues here at all, I obviously don’t know their situation, but it’s something to consider.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →