HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jwithington

568 karma · joined March 16, 2020

Not that weird for a submariner | jeff@terminalhoming.com | jwithing.com
submissionscomments
jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
Thanks!
jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
Sure, the officers and crew are ultimately responsible. But how are "we" enabling the officers and crew to do their jobs? Manually verifying minimum soundings is a terrible use of one's time AND something that a computer will beat a human at every time.
jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
is it really?? you're the second one to post this
jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
I don't think all of those problems are unique to government software. Some (a lot?) enterprise software is atrocious and disliked by end users. That's because the people making the purchasing decisions != end users.

But it's flabbergasting just how bad VMS is considering it's the navigation system for these national assets. It's not like an HR system with poor UX--navigation is essential to the safety and effectiveness of the whole platform!

jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
you should! let's geek out on it
jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
I think I should make this more clear! It serves both functions.
jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
There are probably a few thousand users of submarine navigation software. But the willingness to pay *should* be quite high, which in most other markets would translate to a quality product. The tool should help submarines:

* Prevent groundings (loss of a $3B platform, 120+ lives in worst case) * Do their missions better (increase the value of the platform)

jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
I do want to build better software for DoD, but I can't figure out how to sell in. I'd start by tackling VMS! No clue how I'd go about it though.
jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
how do you see this?? i'm a newbie to web development and selected https://github.com/yuanqing/single-page-markdown-website for something clean and minimal in design.

but those are crazy stats! what would you suggest for newbies like me?

jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
i dont doubt this! someone is accepting this work despite decades of submarine officers losing their minds at it
jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
Well, the design requirements for the Seawolf class were actually probably something like this!

Basically the Navy wanted a monster that go deep behind Soviet lines and tear things up before they made it out of the backyard.

"[Seawolf's] emphasis on fast tactical search speeds and a massive torpedo magazine were reflections of its design mission, which was to independently search for and kill Soviet submarines in the relatively confined and target rich northern waters of the Soviet Arctic littoral." [1]

[1] https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?articl...

jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
I think you're identifying one of the strongest argument against my claims. Automated, or computer assisted, reviews will only increase error rate because humans will assume that computers took care of it all.

You're probably on to something. When radar was first rolled out to all Navy ships to assist navigation (post WWII), accident rates actually increased.

My hunch is that Sailors drove ships riskier thinking that radar would save them. A bit like the findings of seat-belt safety laws: no impact on fatalities.

But I'm not agitating for full-blown computer reviews. It just feels like the software should have the computing capabilities of Excel lol

jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
To clarify: this is the real-time navigation system lol
jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
I do think that's a fair critique of my analogy on the firepower of a Seawolf class submarine.

I'm trying to relay that it's exceedingly deadly submarine. The best in the world. The envy of all other submarine classes.

I don't think there are fighter aircraft that carry enough missiles to down an entire country's bomber force.

The Seawolf was made to destroy other ships. It has all the stats and capabilities to do it. But the kicker is it has incredibly bad navigation software.

jwithington··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
thanks nick! that is not intended. let me make it public.

i called it a forum because readers in the military-world may be less familiar with "issues" in github ;)

jwithington··on Searx – Privacy-respecting metasearch engine
where's you.com lol
jwithington··on Launch HN: Jitsu (YC S20) – Open-Source Segment Alternative
Mostly communications tooling IIRC
jwithington··on Show HN: Initiative.sh, an in-browser command line for D&D
This is amazing! I dungeon master for a online D&D experience (https://www.haze-saltborne.com/). Look forward to using this when I'm generating NPCs and such.
jwithington··on Launch HN: Jitsu (YC S20) – Open-Source Segment Alternative
i thought this was a new product line within jitsi at first haha
jwithington··on Navy failures destroyed the Bonhomme Richard
The one I'm referring to was the first person on the ship who saw the smoke. They then went back to sleep or something like that.
jwithington··on Navy failures destroyed the Bonhomme Richard
So infuriating. I'm a former damage control assistant on a US submarine.

The fire response read like a clownshow, and this article doesn't even highlight the worst of it. There was a Sailor who saw the smoke and walked by it, thinking nothing of it!

Another officer thought the smoke might have been coming from the diesel generator. Why tf would the diesel generator be running???

It's hard for me to think of the software equivalent of these fundamental errors. Maybe something like finding a spike in network traffic and assuming it's load testing on prod, when you're actually getting pwned?

jwithington··on Why is Oracle worth $260B?
Is it because the discounted value of all future cash flows is $260B?
jwithington··on Ask HN: Best way to host a website for 500 years?
This is such a good interview question lol
jwithington··on The Future of discord.py
Such an opportunity for a competitor to rise up out of this debacle.
jwithington··on Show HN: I made a meme creator that makes around $4k a month
template search isn't working. did you exceed your search api's limit lol
jwithington··on PureOS – a pure Linux phone experience
i had that same confusion! they should clarify that on their site.
jwithington··on Launch HN: HomeBreeze (YC W21) – Easy booking of home repairs
I ask this and 5 days later I have to replace my water heater smh.
jwithington··on Launch HN: HomeBreeze (YC W21) – Easy booking of home repairs
Why start with water heaters?
jwithington··on Launch HN: HomeBreeze (YC W21) – Easy booking of home repairs
I've had great experiences with contractors recommended to me by other people on NextDoor.

Thumbtack is a dumpster fire.

jwithington··on Goodbye, Fleets
Finally I can view profile pictures again.
← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →