HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

k_sze

2,432 karma · joined December 21, 2012

Python, Django, Groovy, and Grails beginner. Hacker Reborn. Dislikes the syntax of Objective-C. Abhors PHP.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/k_sze; my proof: https://keybase.io/k_sze/sigs/uWPMz0iLZVW--W0utFDhUqLRvuFGKOamBD6AesHm3U0 ]

submissionscomments
k_sze··on No patches for digital audio releases
I also remember that Kahvi Collective re-released one of their netlabel albums, "Tangents", to fix a mastering error, although they decided to actually charge for the new version due to mastering effort - their albums are usually pay-what-you-want on Bandcamp (including 0 dollar if you just want to download the FLAC version).
k_sze··on No patches for digital audio releases
My hypothesis about no-patch is that there is no incentive. You can't report an audio problem like you report a software bug. I can't imagine a situation where the kind of audio problem described by the author is show-stopping.

Audio problems are also subject to subjective judgement. What one considers a problem might go completely unnoticed by other people. Heck, the content creator may even argue that it's part of their creative output.

In some cases, there is less ambiguity. e.g. you really shouldn't hear any voice when the track says "instrumental", but does any consumer protection law care about that? Like, in Hong Kong, we have "Trade Description" laws that protect consumers against merchandises or services that don't match the advertised descriptions, although I have no idea if those laws would help here. What judge would not roll their eyes and tell you to just settle out of court? But if you settle out of court, I'd bet their laywer would try to add gag terms to the settlement. Are you really gonna allow yourself to be silenced in order to get a 10.99 USD refund?

Maybe we could create incentives if 1) audio hosting platforms actually allow listeners to report audio problems in a _systematic_, _publicly visible_ way, like you would file bug issues on GitHub, 2) leaving the problems unfixed will lead to demonetization of the content.

Also note that the performance of art seems to become perversed when (big) money becomes the incentive. If you know where to look on the web, there are groups who fansub anime and who will go out of their way to re-encode original bluray releases because they think the audio is out-of-sync, or because they think the picture of the original looks like shit in terms of colour temperature/lightness/saturation/gamma. And they seem to do it out of the passion of sharing the joy of watching anime.

While fansubbers have total freedom to decide when to do a patch or re-release, your professional audio engineer working for Warner Bros (again, hypothetical) doesn't have that freedom. If they report a problem about something already released, the first question they get asked by their boss would be "does this hurt our bottomline?" And probably overwhelmingly often, the answer is "no" because we don't have a system that builds the right incentives.

k_sze··on HN comment April 9, 2012: Bookmark this comment. See you in 2022
They might have put it in their Outlook or Google calendar, haha.
k_sze··on I need to stop being boring
> Why do you feel the need to do so many extra-curricular activities related to child education?

Because this is Hong Kong, and if you want to get into a good high school, and then a good university later in life, this is what you do here, unless either A) your kid has really high IQ and would skip years or B) you are rich and don't mind just paying your way through international schools.

My kids are not case A), and I'm not rich enough for B).

Schools here ask you "what credentials do you have (other then regular education)?", "have you won any competition?", etc. I'm not even doing that much, compared to other really competitive families.

k_sze··on I need to stop being boring
Same struggle. Except my elder daughter isn't "screaming and raging about the tiniest things" (yet). She's just... a total mess at a few things (self-motivation, self-awareness, responsibility, tact), constantly getting chastized by my wife.

I don't have fun with my kids. I have no more friend in real life (even before the pandemic). I can't even play computer games when I want to because my kids take too darn long to finish their homework and we live in a small home in Hong Kong. Even weekends are basically more studying and extra-curricular classes for my kids (ballet, phonics, mental math, painting). I've lost motivation to do much else. Nowadays I just burrow myself in reading fantasy novels when I have any time for myself, not even because I really enjoy them, but because I lack creativity and motivation to do much else.

k_sze··on An unsolved math problem on the Colorado River
Slightly surprised that an article in the US would use both imperial and metric units (acre feet and celsius). Is that particular to the field?
k_sze··on Can't Help Myself by Sun Yuan and Peng Yu (2021)
I had a similar experience myself a few years back.

I live in Hong Kong. Sometimes sparrows make nests in odd places. There's a footbridge about 10 minutes from my home. The footbridge has draining holes for the rain.

I think a pair of sparrows once made a nest in one of those holes. One afternoon, as I passed under the footbridge, I saw a baby sparrow on the pavement. I guess it fell from the nest. It was still alive and chirping, it had no idea that there's no way for its parents to rescue them. There was another young woman close-by, watching it, not knowing what to do about it. I'm a nerd. I would have no problem taking it home and trying to raise it. My kids would have loved the experience, even though my wife might have objected. However, I was on an errand and I couldn't just scoop up the little thing and walk home. I didn't have a proper container to put it in. I was still looking around, trying to find something to safeguard the baby sparrow until I can make my way home, when suddenly a man walked by. The man was looking at his phone, he wasn't paying attention to the pavement. Squish! The baby sparrow was dead, its brain and guts all spilled out. The young woman who was watching gave a sharp gasp. I was utterly heart-broken.

k_sze··on Piece of paper quiets Intel Alder Lake stock coolers
Did your paper cowl make a difference to the fan speed?
k_sze··on HB11's hydrogen-boron laser fusion test yields groundbreaking results
> Its first demo has produced 10 times more fusion reactions than expected

I'm not a physicist or a professional scientist in any way. But is this at all normal? 10 times means a whole order of magnitude. Is that a sign that the math is wrong somewhere or that some measurement is wrong somewhere?

k_sze··on Countering threats from North Korea
Why does Google even need to mention North Korea in the title?

A vulnerability is a vulnerability. Why bring politics in, right in the title? It would feel much more OK if simply said in the text, that a NK hacker group is currently known for exploiting it.

Imagine it was a vulnerability being exploited by a TLA of the US of A. What would Google say? Or would they have received a gag order to not talk about it at all? But then what happens if some third-party researcher discovers the vulnerability independently and reports it? What would Google say?

k_sze··on Russia says it used 'hypersonic missiles' in Ukraine: Report
Huh? How does that prove the exact opposite? Mexico said they won’t join anti-US alliance. Ukraine still wanted to join NATO right before the invasion.
k_sze··on The Boschian Horror of ‘Elden Ring’
Thanks. You just made me discover more great educational YouTube channels.
k_sze··on The Boschian Horror of ‘Elden Ring’
You make me really regret throwing away my Demon’s Souls disc when I was depressed years ago. I now have all of the Dark Souls games and Sekiro, no Elden Ring yet.

But having all the games would probably allow me to more fully appreciate the art’s evolution.

k_sze··on Russia says it used 'hypersonic missiles' in Ukraine: Report
Russia is not trying to annex (the whole of) Ukraine, at least that’s what they say. My understanding is that Russia wants a neutral buffer zone between themselves and NATO. This is basically Putin’s negotiation conditions. Putin isn’t even asking Ukraine to join CSTO, if I understand correctly.
k_sze··on Russia says it used 'hypersonic missiles' in Ukraine: Report
> I would imagine this is simply because they’re out of cheaper missiles.

Not necessarily. I have no idea whether Russia sells their missiles, but if they do, this might act like a field demonstration?

Edit: some people on Twitter believe that it is a deterrent signal to NATO: https://twitter.com/ClintEhrlich/status/1505099402980958209

k_sze··on Russia says it used 'hypersonic missiles' in Ukraine: Report
Not endorsing any side of the conflict, but just the fact that humanity is able to make missiles that fly at 1.7 km/s is mind boggling to me. Imagine watching that fly overhead on a clear day. Actually I suspect one might totally miss the sight even if they were told “It’s coming. Watch for it.”
k_sze··on AEG combi microwave unusable after update: device thinks it is a steam oven
“Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn’t stop to think if they should.” - Ian Malcolm, Jurassic Park
k_sze··on In praise of opinionated frameworks
> Because they "hook" into the component lifecycle.

For me, "hooks" in other frameworks/libraries that I have encountered don't work like that. Usually, the hook is something static and predefined by the framework/library, and _my_ code attaches to those hooks. The way you explain React hooks sounds like we're _conjuring_ hooks in the components willy-nilly, and then attaching things to them. However, I have never found an explanation for the name "hook" in the official React documentation; the explanation might be somewhere in the documentation, but I never found it.

k_sze··on In praise of opinionated frameworks
Why are they called hooks in React though? I have a hard time associating meaning with it, given the way React hooks behave.

And I really dislike React hooks because it is so, so "viral" to the code base - "viral" in the sense that any non-component that uses a hook must also be a hook; and so, before long, either the majority of your application code becomes hooks for no other reason than the fact that you want to use a hook deep in the call chain, or you take the hook out and keep passing the argument down.

k_sze··on My Experience Working and Living in China
I don't know what you're talking about. My family-in-law is from Mainland China. My wife's sisters are married to different provinces. My nephews and nieces all pick up their non-Mandarin mother tongues.
k_sze··on My Experience Working and Living in China
Strangely enough, my family has been running a business in Dongguan (not Guangzhou, but close enough, still a major Cantonese industrial city of Guangdong province), since 1980s and we have seen nothing like that.

You can't say they "refuse" to speak to people in Mandarin because they simply _can't speak_ Mandarin. Back then, many people simply did not have enough schooling to learn Mandarin, and so they simply couldn't speak it (at least not fluently). The government was not stupid. There was utterly no reason to enforce Mandarin and deprecate Cantonese when they were expecting so much investment from Hong Kongers (who usually did not speak Mandarin either) during that period.

Cantonese TV stations and radio stations are still doing just fine today. And then of course you can't have just Cantonese when there's an influx of labour from other parts of China, which is why, as a simple matter of economic adaptation, Mandarin gradually picked up. But Cantonese is not being threatened in any way. In fact, there is now a more widespread understanding of the importance of Cantonese, because it is _closer_ to Middle Chinese from the Tang and Song dynasties than many other dialects. It's an important dialect for properly studying and appreciating Tang poems. I know people in more Northern parts of China who know Cantonese songs from the 80s and 90s of Hong Kong because they appreciate the more classical wordings and rhymes of the lyrics.

k_sze··on My Experience Working and Living in China
It's not elimination. It's called "having a standard language so people can communicate". People still speak their non-Mandarin mother tongues at home and in general. Local dialects are still used at the bank, at government service centers, etc. It's just that you must _be able_ to communicate in Mandarin in case somebody from another province walks in. Some local schools, especially for minorities, still teach their mother tongue in school as a subject, on purpose - e.g. schools in Xinjiang.
k_sze··on My Experience Working and Living in China
> Those who refer to themselves as Cantonese do not feel superior, but they have generally felt pushed around by Beijing.

That's not even necessarily true, people all over China refer to themselves by their province, sometimes even prefecture or city, simply out of pride. People are proud of being from Shanghai, or proud of being from Fujian, etc. People are aware of tongue-in-cheek stereotypes regarding their own hometown among the larger Chinese population, and that makes each of them feel special and proud.

k_sze··on Introduction to GPUs with OpenGL
I'm mildly surprised that people still write tutorials using OpenGL nowadays.

I thought the concensus is that 1) OpenGL is bad due to hidden states (and if I remember correctly, the hidden states can behave differently depending on the vendor, which exacerbates the problem), and that 2) people should move to Vulkan (or Metal, or DirectX 12).

k_sze··on Vulva Spaceship aims to counter prevalence of phallic spacecraft
Does that make docking with phallic spaceships easier?
k_sze··on Interop 2022
What I meant is that, in the areas that are not well standardized, and where the browsers don't agree with each other, who is to say that Chrome is right and that Firefox is the one being incompatible/non-conformant? In this sense, the scores are not independent.

Among the areas listed, I understand that at least 10 focus areas are well-standardized and the major browser vendors agree amongst themselves regarding the interpretation of the standard. So that means 60% of the score should be independent. There are 5 other areas that were pulled from Google's and Microsoft's Compat 2021; those might not be well standardized, in which case 30% of the score might be disputable. (UPDATE: I think the 5 additional areas are also well standardized, so I guess you could also say they are independent and not subject to dispute.)

And then the remaining 10% investigative areas are quite probably disputable.

k_sze··on Interop 2022
Furthermore, I think the meaning of these numbers is a bit hard to grasp because the three numbers are not and cannot be independent from each other.

Just as a thought experiment, imagine you saw Chrome/Edge and Safari being 0, and Firefox being 100? What would that even mean?

k_sze··on Please, delete all new places since the start of war 23th of February
Ah, ok. I missed that section. Now things start to make sense.

What I don't completely understand, for two reasons, is why foreign map publishers would allow this pseudorandom offset to exist on their mapping apps:

1. The obfuscation algorithm has basically been cracked.

2. I don't think the Chinese gov can do much about foreign companies, except maybe by proxy, by pressuring the national trade liaisons or some such.

k_sze··on Please, delete all new places since the start of war 23th of February
Refer to my other reply: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30523751
k_sze··on Please, delete all new places since the start of war 23th of February
Right, if you look under the "GPS shift problem" section, it does mention that it is due to the difference between the GCJ-02 and WGS-84 datums.

So it is not like the regulations are saying "you must shift the coordinates by this amount", which would be stupid. It's just that foreign map publishers have not obtained the license to use the correct datum for Mainland China, so they make do with another one.

← PreviousPage 6 of 31Next →