HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kadenshep

-14 karma · joined August 18, 2017

submissionscomments
kadenshep··on Why Isn't Debugging Treated as a First-Class Activity?
I've loved this aspect of CL. I often repeat a self-quote of mine (somewhat patronizingly) to my teams.

Often times, it's not necessarily how something works, but how well it breaks. Things will break, so engineer for it. You'll be happy, the team will be happy, and the business will be happy.

Debugging and error handling are first class activities. Building a thoughtful, "well engineered" tool chain around these activities is the mark of a great platform (and the developers behind it), in my opinion.

kadenshep··on Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully rescued
Not only does it not make me a hypocrite, being a hypocrite has no bearing on the substance of the argument. Questioning motives is perfectly valid, especially when there is a preponderance of evidence to substantiate that question. Appeal to motive is a fallacy because it has no effect on any statements made, so you're definitely confused on that front.

But when you present contrived scenarios to make a point (i.e., lying), your motive can and certainly should be questioned. Unless you're going to argue with most western court systems about the validity of doing that.

What were you honestly hoping to achieve with such a pathetic and ill-thought-out response?

kadenshep··on Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully rescued
Please elaborate? I presented an actual perspective. You have gone around these threads and insulted and demeaned people with a different opinion than the majority and then even equivocated these criticisms to a debate about a fictional character ("You guys might as well be bickering about Spider-Man."). That's not only incredibly dishonest, you really should be ashamed to stoop to such a level publicly. Intentionally framing a debate as not important or just a "flame war" is exactly how you get mindless echo chambers. Musk is a public figure who has had substantial investment in his companies via U.S. tax dollars. He's not a Marvel character, you doughnut.

Not once have you called out people hurling personal insults towards people that have a minority opinion on this board, you've done the exact opposite.

You have implied my statements violate some aspect of HN, but you're going to need to specifically point out which statements do that. Dissent is not violation. You might not be interested in the dissent or critique but you can't use your position as moderator to quell it.

And if you're actually willing to be honest with yourself, or even devote some amount of diligent effort to pretend you're here to upload intellectual standards (despite discouraging dissenting opinions), you need to explain why blatant personal attacks are being allowed in threads you are most definitely reading.

> I'll add that all you're doing by venting like this is feeding the very PR you deplore,

Dang, that's a unsubstantiated view point and you know it. I'm honestly in shock you think that's a valid point to make (I'm not). Please explain how someone who gets public attention as a status quo is somehow actually being fueled by his critics. This talking point comes in up various contexts and is always meant to dismiss critique or even worse, victim blame. What the actual fuck are you on?

To recap since you most definitely again will side step any critique of moderating actions:

* What rules am I violating and where. A simple quote of my statement and the rule will suffice.

* Why are you framing the debate as if it's about a fictional character, when it's the CEO of a company who receives significant funding from U.S. tax payer dollars.

* How does critiquing a public figure's positive media coverage in a small thread somehow get the news to continue positive coverage?

kadenshep··on Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully rescued
You think it's okay to debase the chief of the rescue operation, ignore the advice he took from multiple teams, and cherry pick a personal email correspondence with one guy that basically just says "keep trying" just so Musk can dance around, yet again, people pointing out a potential PR stunt?

I don't know what level of social ineptness is required to ignore not only the blatant insult against the chief, but Musk's presumably unintentional insult to the rest of the team that informed the chief what they thought about Musk's idea to carry a 300lb tube through volatile currents in a tight, murky cave system.

Talk about domain specialization.

kadenshep··on Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully rescued
>Because your entire series of posts in this thread thus far have been nothing but questioning the motives of Elon Musk

It's not a question. I quite literally detailed what factually has happened. It isn't up for debate. He again, quite literally, decided to discredit and defame the lead of the rescue efforts in attempt to white wash several people calling him out on a very, very obvious PR stunt. They were halfway through the rescue operation while he was tweeting about hauling a 300lb pound tube through a tight cave system.

>Even if you're correct you're a hypocrite to complain about someone doing the same to you.

Pointing out and supporting a common criticism of a largely public figure is quite different than personally attacking someone reiterating that critique. If the difference is not appreciable to you then there's like 50 different things that need explaining and I am definitely not going to waste my time doing that.

>The only reason I knew that Musk was even involved in this whole mess was because of his detractors.

Really? Not the mainstream media outlets reporting about it? Or the 600k+ shares on various tweets? You found out because of random internet comments complaining about it, in threads that had nothing to do with those reports?

That seems very, very far fetched and beggars belief.

>I don't personally see any reason to doubt Musk's stated motives

You don't think a clear, consistent pattern of doing the same thing over and over again for unoriginal benefits is not a valid reason to doubt someone's motives? That seems pretty naive.

Allow me to reiterate what just went down:

Elon Musk came out and publicly attempted to put down and dismiss the chief of the rescue operation, the other people who chose not to use the submarine, while also bolstering up the guy he had a personal email correspondence with just as an attempt to counter people's criticism that he is, yet again, just engaging in empty PR (ask yourself why he is constantly engaged in this).

Your suggested and proposed response to this, by your own words, is not attempt to educate people on what's actually going on here, but to simply ignore it. How do you think that's actually going to pan out? Why is doing nothing against misinformation that aids corporate propaganda okay, but somehow personally attacking people with vague fallacies not only somehow rationally acceptable (it's not, but I'll let you attempt to answer it), but suddenly worth your time?

Seems a bit odd.

kadenshep··on Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully rescued
Why?
kadenshep··on Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully rescued
>There seems to be a large outspoken group of people who go out of their way to talk about Musk despite their apparent dislike of him

I'm sorry what? Musk constantly gets tons of PR over nothing from news outlets, to reddit, to HN. It's really strange that a reasonable response to constant bombardment of Musk's half-baked ideas and PR stunts is somehow attributable to people's dislike of Musk personally. How is directly providing concrete and factual events to counter a corporate narrative and to dismantle a cult of personality "going out of [their] way" or even evidence of some kind of odd personal hate towards Musk?

The entire response is a really cheap, nonconstructive appeal to motive and is quite frankly full of vague personal attacks.

I would maybe give you the benefit of the doubt here by saying you probably just don't participate in the same media channels I do, but you're blatantly aware of the situation given your hostile apology to the current perspective on all things Musk. This is so strangely reminiscent of when Steve Jobs was around.

kadenshep··on Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully rescued
No it hasn't. Industrial and scientific advancements are to be credited with this. Not asinine resource allocation systems, that have in fact needlessly let people die.
kadenshep··on Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully rescued
So the guy actually in charge of the entire thing is somehow wrong, but Elon personally emailed exactly 1 person in charge of 1 team who said "keep working on it", which definitely justifies the entire surrounding PR bonanza and Musk personally showing up to the dive site to do... what exactly?

It'd odd that Musk's attempts to discredit the guy in charge of the entire of the operation is somehow not worth pointing out, who no doubt had input from multiple teams he was working close with. Musk then proceeded to release 3 messages between Musk and 1 person, specifically picked to continue this PR spree.

To reiterate, the guy in charge of the entire operation said the submarine wasn't going to work with their mission. Musk then proceeds to cherry pick exactly 1 email correspondence between him and 1 other person to invalidate the official's position on the matter (and the fact that the sub was in fact, never used). In Musk's magical bubble (as you can see from the Twitter replies), this is somehow both reasonable and enough to justify his ever continuing pop-sci PR spree.

After a certain point, you need to start questioning why he's always in these PR spats and why nothing substantial ever happens to actually validate Musk. I do not personally understand what level of sheer, unbridled optimism is required to look at what Musk is doing and go "Yeah, that's totally okay and noble!"

To end:

* Musk constantly tweeted/reported on his own team's developments throughout the entire process, even though basically nothing was actually happening.

* The guy in charge of the operation said the vehicle would not be used

* Musk show's up to the dive site for some selfies, talks with people while taking some extra selfies, and then immediately leaves.

* In a true display of ego, Musk proceeds to screenshot 1 email chain between him and 1 other person because he was factually called out on this matter.

* Musk fan boys across the internet praise him for doing all of the above and contributing exactly nothing.

kadenshep··on Massive Comcast Outage Hits the US
OP would need to elaborate on why it would in the first place. Bald assertions need only be met with bald assertions, especially when those assertions have real world examples negating them.
kadenshep··on Massive Comcast Outage Hits the US
No it wouldn't.
kadenshep··on ‘Everyone is breaking the law right now’: GDPR compliance is falling short
You are being silly. You completely misread what I said and bnw you're attempting to reference insanely improbable scenarios.

Just point out the exact part of the law you guys are having a problem with. If you can't do that, it's because you're just making shit up.

kadenshep··on ‘Everyone is breaking the law right now’: GDPR compliance is falling short
What part of "super fuzzy high level overview" was confusing?
kadenshep··on ‘Everyone is breaking the law right now’: GDPR compliance is falling short
Oh lord speaking of copyright law, trying to rationally discuss Copyright law during the Oracle vs Google case on this site was basically an exercise in how much mental pain you were wiling to take. Comments that only contained direct quotes from the case to negate what the OP was stating were downvoted. The Google fanaticism was insane.

I'm going to guess what's happening here is a good amount of developers work for companies where GDPR would directly impact their revenue directly or indirectly (and most likely jobs as a whole). This is especially true for smaller "middle man" analytic firms and general web agencies. It pays to be anti-GDPR.

kadenshep··on ‘Everyone is breaking the law right now’: GDPR compliance is falling short
Let me just respond to this in short: No. They're not circular.

The same vague claims keep getting repeated, with absolutely nothing to back them up. Not even a "here's the problem with the law in our case" super fuzzy high level overview. It's always about the effort of adhering to the law without any discussion about why these companies are facing difficulties in the first place. Not the actual difficulty with implementing the law, just the vague effort they've put up with.

Hundreds of thousands of businesses have not had issue with the law. Suddenly some guy on HN with two "top tier" law firms at his back faces this unimaginably heavy burden and extreme obstacles when trying to adhere to the law. Sounds like a nightmare, in the sense that it never happened.

OP's post and the many others like it are just typical American business favoritism against any kind of regulation masquerading as a personal True Story (TM). I still remember when cookie warnings were "hard" to do and businesses actively implemented them in obviously shit ways, in bad faith with the regulations. It's so obviously contrived for a particular audience it's kind of absurd it immediately doesn't get flagged.

kadenshep··on ‘Everyone is breaking the law right now’: GDPR compliance is falling short
There isn't anything in GDPR to cause the problems he is describing. It's realistically the most probable scenario.

If I'm not allowed to call out dishonesty then there's basically no point in discussing any subject.

kadenshep··on ‘Everyone is breaking the law right now’: GDPR compliance is falling short
This is the exact opposite experience we've had.

We're all over Europe and the U.S. It was pretty painless. Our business does not rely on the ignorance of users or the abuse of their privacy. What "army of lawyers" did you have and why was the spirit of the law not enough? We had several different business units get through compliance without any problems.

This isn't a hard thing to address at the end of the day (so long as your entire business doesn't depend on it). I just can't help but feel a few ways A) You didn't understand what the law says B) what your lawyers were actually worried about or C) this story is just made up.

What specifically were the discrepancies in the interpretation of the law between various countries that caused two "top" tier law firms to be unable to come to a clean consensus?

kadenshep··on Toward a Mature Science of Consciousness
We can work on figuring out all of those in parallel.
kadenshep··on We're Baking ‘Have I Been Pwned’ into Firefox and 1Password
I mean, what wording confused this concept specifically?
kadenshep··on We're Baking ‘Have I Been Pwned’ into Firefox and 1Password
You're ignoring how most users need things in front of their face. Most users are not privacy or security "aware" in any manner. Putting it in the UI or actively promoting these services is beneficial to the common web user.

And if it fails, it's at least worth it to learn why it failed. Was the UI bad? Did it not promote the service in the right way? Did users not understand the purpose of the tool?

I think the juice is worth the squeeze.

kadenshep··on Amazon Workers Facing Firing Can Appeal to a Jury of Their Co-Workers
If only there was some sort of organization that workers could collectively be apart of and contribute to. An organization dedicated to worker's rights, an organization that would make sure whimsical decisions couldn't aversely affect people's lives because they're in the wrong class in an organization/society.

I understand the comment is snarky, but it's really quite absurd in my mind that this is an actual headline, instead of it being a bad joke (which I guess it kind of is). Because it's not even your "peers." It's mainly still just upper management trying to put on a facade of peer judgement.

kadenshep··on After harsh criticism, Facebook quietly pulls services from developing countries
They tried a moderation system. An active and passive moderation system. Conservatives in the U.S. claimed it was "biased" so they stopped. Despite the fact that Facebook had clear records about disinformation campaigns and how untruthful they were. To keep the faux appearance of "intellectual curiosity" they scrapped the moderation team and now eventually the news feed. Talk about political correctness.

When rolling out their platform to other countries they obviously "learned" from yesteryears experience about dealing with disinformation and decided that doing nothing was better than doing something (no matter how perceivably flawed, or how substantially flawed it actually was, which is just foolish). Boy did they learn their lesson here, at the cost of other people's lives. Fortunately, such rhetoric rarely has jarring repercussions in the U.S. (for now).

Blame humanity. Some of the best engineers in the world tried to solve the problem but were only meant with whining about unfairness. No doubt had they employed enforceable, decent standards when moderating content on the implementation of their platform for other countries it would have just been dragged under the meaningless label of "censorship." So they didn't bother apparently. Foolish and privileged.

But at least we treated all sides equally. It only was paid in blood.

kadenshep··on Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Military Contracts
There's nothing secret about hiring people who can think rationally and morally. It's typically part of the interview H/R screening process.
kadenshep··on Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Military Contracts
Do yourself a favor and re-read my post. And yes. It's an agreed upon view point.
kadenshep··on Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Military Contracts
Yeah, this is an incredibly unordinary talking point and it's not honest. At the very least it's just troll bait. "I hope your org gets sued." For what, not hiring crazy racist people?

It's okay to call a spade a spade, instead of trying to masquerade these "differences" as some kind of valid, constructive view point. It's incredibly politically correct and it's annoying.

The chances of you actually being a good, intelligent engineer that harbors absurd and morally repulsive view points tends to be astoundingly low in my experience. It's often been my experience that engineers that seemingly struggle with abstract concepts tend to harbor pretty nutty viewpoints once you start talking with them. There seems to be a pretty heavy correlation here, in my experience.

And I keep saying in my experience, but I think the phenemon is well understood across the industry. The chances of you not believing in the scientific valdity of global warming, or being okay with the current mess that is the health care market, and being able to model and reason about abstract concepts tends to be... misaligned. Or if you can't even rationally talk with people without being disingenuous. These tend to be decently understood subjects and if you're not able to comphrehend them the chances of you being able to reason about technically hard problems in an efficient manner is going to be low.

Hackers aren't supposed to be politically correct, yet this talking point gets brought up every thread and it's pretty boring and old.

I've worded the above like 3 different ways to avoid the predictable responses.

And for the record, I look at U.S. conservative candidates with extreme suspicion because of the above. I don't mind differing opinions. I hired an anarchist which is completely opposed to nearly everything I politically believe. Except for a few key points. His ideas are academically sound, well researched, and he's not xenophobic/homophobic or just generally unscientific. That's a far cry from what happens when U.S. conservative politics get involved.

kadenshep··on Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Military Contracts
My employer knows two things about me:

A) I will not work on/for military/defense products/clients, unless there is some blatantly obvious noble characteristic about the project (I come from a background in video analytics).

B) I will not work on/for conservative products/clients.

Luckily I'm in a job and industry where both of these are pretty unlikely.

I've done the latter (B) once and I really, really regret my role in it to this day. It only took once, just once, but it just happened to be one of the of the worst offenders in the U.S. political landscape. Knowing that I basically optimized disinformation campaigns and built media platforms for some of these people eats at my soul, especially when I see the current state of the U.S. -- I helped some jackass convince a whole slew of people that electing a fraud was the Right (TM) choice. Now we have concentration camps for children (with no reunification process), our healthcare is even worse than it was somehow, we're in multiple trade wars, and we definitely don't give a single shit about the environment (look at today's news feed about the U.S. drilling policies). And I helped it happen.

Sorry for the rant. But engineers have a moral duty to be selective in who they're aiding. I was all too happy to watch pretty graphs go up, and up, and up. I was foolish. I just cared about the project and how challenging it was. Good on the engineers at Google for being principled.

kadenshep··on Truth Decay: Initial Exploration of the Diminishing Role of Facts and Analysis
It's a framework for exploring this issue. It's largely done to frame the topic and explore what solutions we can employ to stop "truth decay" from happening. It's partly for future research/researchers and part educational material for those who might not be familiar with the current phenomenon of "truth decay." I enjoy how well defined the model is (and the litany of citations and historical examples to support it).

I've personally felt that the erosion of institutional confidence is (and will be) extremely damaging to the U.S. I found this paper while googling around for topics/perspectives on that particular subject.

kadenshep··on Truth Decay: Initial Exploration of the Diminishing Role of Facts and Analysis
Link to the full paper (PDF): https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/research_reports/...
kadenshep··on Pregnancy Discrimination Is Rampant Inside America’s Biggest Companies
>I only wanted to highlight there are companies on the other side of the spectrum too.

I am fully aware of that, hence some of my statements. I think it's contrived and not being completely honest, at the very least it seems pretty irrelevant.

kadenshep··on Pregnancy Discrimination Is Rampant Inside America’s Biggest Companies
There is both an abnormal amount of promotions that you have somehow personally witnessed -- doesn't sound like you were even involved with, we'll also ignore implicit psychological biases here -- while you happened to overhear THE core group of people involved in some conspiracy to enable your overall incredibly inordinary talking point.

There's a word for this: contrived.

It is extremely unlikely that such a company would exist in the current landscape, one willing to needlessly promote women, especially when considering their prior or current pregnancy status. I'm having myself a pretty big giggle.

← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →