HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kadoban

7,571 karma · joined April 20, 2018

submissionscomments
kadoban··on Garry Tan wants US open-weight AI labs to 'distill' frontier models, too
> Anthropic paid an average of $3000 per work they scanned based on their settlement

Not sure you get to count breaking the law and getting in trouble in your cost-of-doing-business. That's a little too on the nose.

You're basically arguing that a criminal syndicate must be allowed to continue and we're required to make their business model make sense?

kadoban··on Everyone should slow down AI development except for me
> That seemed silly at the time.

Still does. It's an idiotic idea that only goes to show either how stupid Musk is or how stupid he thinks we are.

kadoban··on Real-SWE: Benchmarking AI models on private, real-world, enterprise codebases
I think you know that's basically nothing like this? The model cards have every incentive to be biased, this doesn't necessarily.

But even so, pretty much yes: companies that actually have reliable and accurate info in their releases get trusted more. It takes time because the default is to disbelieve info from biased sources, but it is possible to trust some of them more than others.

kadoban··on Real-SWE: Benchmarking AI models on private, real-world, enterprise codebases
If it builds up history and perceived reliability, this type of thing can be valuable. You're giving up transparency for it being harder to game.
kadoban··on GPT-6 Astra does 3D camera tracking and VFX in Blender
That's pretty good vfx, that'll be a useful tool. It has a couple of janky frames, the cup position is wrong on the first hard pan upwards, probably pretty easy to fix though.

I believe there's already tools for essentially this before llms, I wonder how capabilities compare.

kadoban··on Open-weights world models' parameter size doubles every ~6 months
It almost would feel like a fair graph, but it's also below that one ~outlier in the middle. So it's ignoring all data but two points and purporting to fit an exponential to it. That's within spitting distance of meaningless, right?

There's an infinite number of exponentials that fit the same two points just as well, and way more non-exponentials too.

kadoban··on The EPA is planning to scrap public review rules for data center pollution
It was created by Nixon, so yeah I'm sure the early days were a little weird (and it hasn't gotten any better since).
kadoban··on Houthis 'take control' of key island in global shipping route
> The situation you're imagining is one of a global all encompassing depression caused by a single government.

Doesn't even have to go that far (though it pretty easily can, the US is a big enough market). If the US causes a refugee crisis that affects one of China's allies, or fucks with the global oil supply enough or a thousand other things, that stuff is still annoying to China even if it's usually relatively better for them than it is for the US.

> Not unthinkable, but the Americans would feel that deeply. Do you think they want to?

The people in the US choosing do not care if the rest of America feels it or not.

kadoban··on Moonshot serves Claude instead of Kimi and collects exchanges for model training
Can these big companies that want to distill not just get the models? Like how many machines at how many different providers are running Opus 5? Nobody is just throwing the model on a thumb drive and taking it home, or grabbing an old drive that somebody was too lazy to scrub or whatever?

That would be vastly more illegal, but would it even matter? What would the practical downside be?

kadoban··on Houthis 'take control' of key island in global shipping route
> "Don't interrupt your opponent when they're making a mistake"

Yeah, that's the obvious answer, but I suspect there's a point where if the US fucks things up too quickly and too messily, there's fewer customers for China's crap and/or the random throws of monkey shit drag China into messes they don't feel like dealing with.

Slow erosion of the US's global power is likely better for them than an implosion that might cause collatoral damage.

kadoban··on Open-weights world models' parameter size doubles every ~6 months
Is it me or is that not what that graph shows? That line has ~no relation to the datapoints it's purporting to be a fit for.
kadoban··on So you want to use OpenRouter?
I think it's not even that sophisticated here, the providers are just lying.
kadoban··on Houthis 'take control' of key island in global shipping route
The context of this is which party China would prefer to win the midterms. The dems winning would distract Trump from being able to fuck up the rest of the world a bit.

My bet would be that China doesn't care much either way, they win regardless.

kadoban··on Nine coding harnesses vs. your laptop
Yeah something must be actively broken or just an awful extension for it to have that much effect.

Most things you can mess with the big effect is like, oh a thousand tokens ended up in the ~system prompt, or 10% extra or fewer work based on extra tool calls or churning through thinking or whatever.

Harness stuff if it's 8x worse that's like, it's fucked and broken, something went _wrong_.

kadoban··on Houthis 'take control' of key island in global shipping route
> the triple digits IQ of Hegseth, Trump and Bessent.

One digit each.

kadoban··on Houthis 'take control' of key island in global shipping route
At some point they might prefer stability and sanity. I would bet that at this point they don't care much either way.

China is playing long, most of the ~unchanging things are in their favor and the US already proved that they're unreliable. People won't forget that soon even if Trump is gone.

kadoban··on So you want to use OpenRouter?
You know you can define your own provider filters and orderings, right? The filters and such are not _that_ advanced, but it might do what you need if you haven't already tried that.
kadoban··on Nine coding harnesses vs. your laptop
You'd have to look where the extra tokens are coming from. If it's using extra turns or doing extra work because a tool it ~wants is missing, then adding extra things will help. Otherwise, it won't.

If it's missing guidance that would help, system prompt additions might help.

8x-10x the tokens is wild, is this for some tiny artificial benchmark? That's just too much extra for something not to be just broken.

kadoban··on OpenAI Agents API
Pi is just a nice base and it has defined extension protocols and such. You might as well start there, it's just easier and going from nothing to working to adding whatever functionality is like 2 minutes.
kadoban··on GPT-6 Astra, looped transformers, and hidden reasoning
> "this is a benchmark" is such an easy category to determine

I mean, it's not _that_ hard to determine most likely, and/or it's hard to be sure you didn't get found out by llm-assisted analysis on your traffic. It's not going to be a one-shot request and response it's going to be a whole bunch of them in an artificial way, by nature.

And then anything you found is single-use only if you're paranoid because even if they find out later, they have your benchmark now (because you sent it to them to use it even if you don't publish it).

kadoban··on Stockfish 19
> AlphaZero (which later became Leela? I'm not sure)

Pretty much. DeepMind never released their code or models, just the main ideas of their techniques and training.

Leela, which came out of the go-ai world, implemented the paper(s) and became the de-facto version everyone used for a while until other projects improved over it on both go (mainly katago) and chess (mainly stockfish).

kadoban··on Stockfish 19
Yes. The ways to improve are: faster search (which lets you search more deeply) or better evaluation of a position or better heuristics.
kadoban··on GPT-6 Astra, looped transformers, and hidden reasoning
Doing this in a way that doesn't get you noticed or fucked with is potentially going to be quite difficult.

If they have a "hey we're being benchmarked" mode, which is not hard to imagine, avoiding tripping it is going to be annoying and difficult to prove.

kadoban··on Splash-free urinals (2025)
Way back when I worked in a restaurant, there was that but then also if a customer complains they also go clean.

They're never going to be like "Oh, someone shat on the floor? We'll deal with that at the next scheduled cleaning."

kadoban··on I was on Ubuntu's first design team in 2009 London
> The fact that they didn't understand this when they proposed the idea shows you how little they knew of the Linux ecosystem, and the fact that they're still bringing up so many years later shows that they haven't learnt anything even after all this time.

The fact that they didn't ask "why?" at the time is also telling (or they didn't listen or remember, whatever reason it's not in this anecdote). They expected the greybeards who had been maintaining this shit for years to shut up and accept whatever shitty proof-of-concept looked good in a screenshot.

kadoban··on Splash-free urinals (2025)
> It's surprising it's that high (8%). I would imagine it takes as long to mop a floor that has pee droplets or mop a floor that doesn’t.

You might have to mop more often from complaints or inspection, maybe?

kadoban··on GitSpawn: Untrusted repos can execute code via AI coding agents
> AI slop nothing burger. The “exploit” has nothing to do with coding agents.

It's pretty small potatoes, but it is a harness ~bug that they treat this so poorly. It getting triggered before some of them even ask you if you trust the directory is pretty bad.

kadoban··on Go grandmaster Shin defeats AI KataGo with a two-stone handicap
Yeah, thanks, I forgot that existed. That definitely weakens my point quite a bit.

It's still not _quite_ the same thing because an advantage in playouts is not a great model for how a stronger/weaker player dynamic actually works, but it is something for sure, way more than the nothing that I said exists.

kadoban··on Go grandmaster Shin defeats AI KataGo with a two-stone handicap
That's the basic idea, yeah.

When playing white in handicap games, you want to make your opponent uncomfortable.

Play moves where the simple/safe/obvious move is just a little bit bad. Force them to choose between complex fights or a slow death of 100 slightly suboptimal moves.

It feels really wrong to defend like 10 times in a row, so if you make them do that they'll lash out at the wrong time and you can take advantage.

You also want to look for moves where...even if their best response means it's even or a little bit worse for you, there's ~reasonable responses where you win out or it goes complex.

A lot of the time it's not even crazy complex fights, it's more just situations where the judgement of what is more points is difficult.

(Note: most of this stops applying as strongly if it's a teaching game, which most handicap games are, there you have other considerations besides winning)

kadoban··on Go grandmaster Shin defeats AI KataGo with a two-stone handicap
> That humans can make sufficiently strong calculators has never been a dispute in my mind.

Within our lifetimes (unless you're quite young) it was doubtful if a go ai would ever beat a decent human. Same was true for chess a generation or two earlier. It's news because it's the handoff of man to machine being the best at a particular thing.

This current news is news from the other way, this human did _exceptionally_ well.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →