HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kakwa_

1,465 karma · joined August 10, 2015

submissionscomments
kakwa_··on Report: Tim Cook could step down as Apple CEO 'as soon as next year'
I think Apple has kind of a culture problem where the whole organization has to look-up way too much to its chief to make key decisions.

This could have worked in Jobs times, because of the personality & vision of the latter, plus a rapidly evolving market.

But this was no longer possible once the dust settled, specially with a logistician/beam counter like Tim Cook.

Every bet he made was an abject failure, from the Apple Car to the Vision Pro.

His only success was the M series macs, a really good but by no mean revolutionary step-up on a now minority segments of Apple's main market (i.e. internet terminals).

Even the chaos relating to Apple's AI efforts seems to clearly indicate a clear lack of leadership and vision.

For me, he will probably be remembered like Apple's Steve Ballmer. But even with a Nadela-like replacement, Apple needs probably a good hard look at itself and its internal culture.

kakwa_··on Sam Altman's pants are on fire
Netscape was fairly known by the public during the .com bubble, it's now a distant memory at most.
kakwa_··on Let's Help NetBSD Cross the Finish Line Before 2025 Ends
https://technically.kakwalab.ovh/posts/silly-sun-server-intr...

Some architectures are no longer practical with Linux. The kernel might still support it, but distribution support is sketchy.

For a SPARC64 server refurb project, the choices were pretty much OpenBSD or NetBSD in my case.

kakwa_··on FocusTube: A Chrome extension that hides YouTube Shorts
I'm also an UnTrap happy user.

It's an awesome anti doom-scrolling antidote for Youtube, with a lot of customization possible.

I would definitely recommend it.

At least try it to see how much Youtube's design & recommendations actually trick our brain into passive watching and dooming scrolling.

kakwa_··on French ex-president Sarkozy begins jail sentence
Groupe Le Monde (Xavier Niel, founder of Free and 42 schools, wed to Bernard Arnault's daughter (French Bourgeoisie is a small world)).

But Le Monde Diplomatique's redaction has been able to remain independent thanks to it's 49% shares and veto right.

It's also fairly small (~10 permanent journalists + independent contributors, ~150k monthly readers).

It's not really the kind of journal able to sustain a long investigation, it's more "social commentaries with a left-leaning/alter-mundialist point of view".

kakwa_··on French ex-president Sarkozy begins jail sentence
It's actually kind of worse. Because you get a mix of Dassault (the company)'s agenda (defense spending, pro-industry) and a push for the fairly conservative views of the Marcel Bloch/Dassault descendants themselves.

To be fair, le Figaro was The French conservative newspaper long before the Dassault's ownership (like +100 years prior), so it's more a case of "Le Figaro has a more comfortable budget to push its views".

The closest I can think of in the US context is Bezos owning the Washington Post to both push his personal views and Amazon's interests.

Or maybe lately, Larry Ellison's take over of Paramount/CBS (but it feels more like he is buying a toy for his son).

kakwa_··on French ex-president Sarkozy begins jail sentence
No, it's not some kind of clickbait strategy to drive views. Driving an agenda is.

Most of French media, specially newspapers, are money sinks only surviving because they are useful to push the rent-seeking business or ideological agenda of their owners (Dassault, Bouygues, Lagardere, Arnault, Bettencourt, Saade, Pinault, Niel).

Also, just for context, Martin Bouygues, Bernard Arnault and Vincent Bollore, the respective owners of TF1 (main French TV channel), Le Parisien (major newspaper) and CNews/Europe1 (major TV channel & radio) are personal friends of Sarkozy (a la "witness at your wedding, god father of your son or let's celebrate your election on my yacht" kind of way).

The Figaro (main right-wing newspaper in France) and its owners, the Dassault family, are also not far away.

Seeing the Figaro website was actually quite funny. Because the evidences are so damming, their main page was textbook "how to propagate fake news with plausible deniability". It was mainly pro-Sarkozy Editorials/Tribunes from non-journalists people, articles titled with quotes from Sarkozy's supporters and the few articles actually on the case were about the side stories.

French press ownership map:

https://www.monde-diplomatique.fr/cartes/PPA#&gid=1&pid=1

There are only two truly independent major media left in France: Mediaparte (the ones we have to thanks for Sarkozy's well deserved condemnations) and Le Canard Enchaine (a bunch of scandals, but lately, the "Affaire Fillion").

The rest is either owned by billionaires, state run, or is far smaller and doesn't have the aura, size & credibility to reveal such scandals.

kakwa_··on United finds loose bolts on plug doors during 737 Max 9 inspections
It's not necessarily a question of persons (and the CEO did a resigned after the Max crashes).

It's more a question of culture (oversimplifying, sales vs engineering) and this is harder to change most of the time. Apparently, even the Max debacle was not enough.

kakwa_··on Tesla Drivers Have the Highest Crash Rate of Any Brand: Study
Different contexts and not really comparable.

1) The whole airspace environment is heavily regulated (ATC, rules, etc), cooperative (think transponders or TCAS for example) and usually quite sparse (several miles between planes).

2) Pilots are regularly trained and evaluated for these kind of take over in case of emergency.

3) You have two pilots monitoring each other.

4) The development cycles for these automations are far longer, and the QA a lot stricter.

5) At least in the most critical phases (take-off, landing), the automation is not exactly end-to-end. It's more the case of grouping batch of steps together into bigger actions to reduce the load on the pilots. The pilots are still quite busy during these periods and very much in the loop.

kakwa_··on An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation
Or you simply are extremely cautious not knowing how bureaucratic and slow the PSF is or is not.
kakwa_··on Fourteen Years of Go
Golang is not a complete replacement for Python and/or Java and/or C++.

For example, if you were to create a complex native application (browser, game, cad software, etc), C++ is still probably the best choice. For data manipulation/transformation or glue scripting, Python is still a more convenient choice. If you want to structure an extremely large codebase and depend on tons of "Enterprisy" stuff, Java is most likely a good choice. (note: I'm caricaturally oversimplifying)

Also software is rarely created in a vacuum:

1) software teams have certain skills and habits

2) new software is often created in a preexisting context

3) In fairness, language choice is often not that critical

4) Developers can be extremely vocal about technology choices, often way beyond the reasonable

For all these reasons, even if we fall right in the Golang niche (small to medium size web api/app, "devops" tools/infra management and partially, some DB use cases), choosing Java/C++ over Golang could actually be the right choice.

kakwa_··on Twitter's onion service is serving an invalid TLS certificate since 3/6/2023
Maybe, but then, why the onion service is still up?

This feels more like uncontrolled infrastructure rot/lack of maintenance rather than a conscious decision to cut unnecessary parts of it.

kakwa_··on Fourteen Years of Go
Given Golang popularity, it probably managed to solve more than Google's internal issues.

It most likely ticked quite few boxes right:

* easy syntax

* fairly extensive std lib

* easy memory management & mostly painless GC

* easy shipping of dependencies (everything in one file, including runtime)

* order of magnitude less tricky parallelism.

In a world where Golang doesn't exist, quite a few recent software would probably look really different:

* Etcd but in Java (hello Zookeeper)

* Terraform but in Python

* Docker but in C/C++ or Python

* Kubernetes, but in Java and/or Python and/or C++ (hello Mesos) * Prometheus, but in Java and/or C/C++

And honestly, for most of these, either because alternatives in such languages do exist and mostly failed, or from performance/stability concerns, I think we would not have been better of.

kakwa_··on Fourteen Years of Go
Well, having a working Node 18 in 10 years might prove really difficult.

Recreating the whole outdated stack is often doable, but it's really time consuming and often feels more like archeology than Computer Science.

What you really want is strong backward compatibility so that Node "30" still manages to build projects from 10 years ago.

kakwa_··on What the Goddamn Hell Is Going on in the Tech Industry?
> A few decades ago anyone with a billion dollars could start making cellphones

Did you mixed-up million and billion?

A billion dollar is a gigantic pill of money. This feel a bit like saying "anyone with a British crown on his head can reign over the UK".

Also, looking at Fairphone, they operate with a fairly reasonable budget: all revenue, including phone sells in 2022 are around $60M, and if we exclude production, ~$17M are needed to pay for product development, marketing, support and all other expenses for a year. At 2 years to create a phone, that's ~$30M.

kakwa_··on The beauty of finished software
Looking at the git logs (https://git.savannah.gnu.org/cgit/coreutils.git/log/) that doesn't seem to hold true.

While the days around 2003 when the project had +2500 commits per year are long gone, coreutils is still fairly active, with ~200 commits per year.

Even looking at really simple tools like 'yes', git blame shows a bunch of fairly recent changes.

On commands with specific repository like grep (https://git.savannah.gnu.org/cgit/grep.git/log/), the project actually peaked not too long ago, in 2010, with 355 commits a year. And the current activity levels (82 commits 2023) are not that far off this high.

Of course, commits are not everything. I expect the actual code changes to be smaller (lots of 1-5 lines fixes vs ~100 lines new functionality). But these tools are still evolving quite significantly.

kakwa_··on I accidentally saved my company half a million dollars
You are lucky, I got nothing for heavily suggesting a ~1M/year saving.

The only "personal" reward I get from that is: whenever I feel guilty for not having done much in a given day, I remind myself that by this action alone, I've saved my company several times what I would ever cost them.

Helps with self-esteem, but I don't think my company see it that way.

kakwa_··on Internal slides on the work of the Google "Ads Quality" team
These 2008 slides talking about "Ads Quality" really sound weird compared to today.

The screenshots, with the ads being clearly visible, surrounded by yellow boxes, and not taking too much screen real estate, are quite striking compared to the Search Result page now days (which feels a lot more blurry and sneaky).

At the same time, we now get mandatory ads on Youtube, and personally, I was quite chocked by how low quality these can be. Best case, it's your traditional sugary food ads, worst case, it's propaganda or border line scam promo.

Maybe Youtube always was that bad for the ~2/3 of people not using ad-blockers and I was blind to it.

However, with the recent layoffs, the end of free money, the slow death of Twitter/X and the push for more monetization (ads on Youtube, API monetization on Reddit, etc), it feels we are reaching the end of an era.

kakwa_··on Why every microwave sucks these days
Toshiba, given Midea bought their home appliance division, yes:

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-03-17/china-s-m...

Looking through amazon, all the most basic models at a ~$80 to $110 price point really look almost identical beyond a basic facelift. They nearly all have a power and timer knob, the same stamped steel internal and side panels and roughly the same max power. At most, you see different generations.

kakwa_··on Apple to make tools and parts to fix phones, computers available nationwide
Sad thing is, Apple used to make keyboards that were even easier to replace than Thinkpad ones:

https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/PowerBook+G3+Pismo+Keyboard+Rep...

kakwa_··on Mazda slaps developer with cease-and-desist for DIY smart home integration
Indeed, in a car accident, the car itself is rarely to blame.

But that was not my point.

At the end of the day, no matter how well it's built, a car is a several tons lump of steel launched at significant speed. It's an inherently deadly machine.

Having a lapse of attention while driving a car? you might easily cause a someone to die.

Having the same lapse on a bike? you might cause some broken bones.

Having the same lapse while walking? you are good for some "Oh... I'm sorry".

kakwa_··on Software disenchantment
Honestly, with some adjustments, the same incentives also hold true in every industry.

I would personally put the low quality of our code more down to immaturity and lack of tooling.

kakwa_··on Mazda slaps developer with cease-and-desist for DIY smart home integration
Are cars really that safe?

I mean, safer relative to what they used to be, yes.

But compared other modes of transportation, not so sure.

kakwa_··on Ubuntu Linux snuck into high-end Dell laptops
Honestly, these days, I would be surprised to not have Linux hardware support with any PC I might buy.

At least, in my experience with the 3 brand new computers I got (T460s in 2016, T14s in 2021, Custom Desktop (Ryzen 5, ATI 7900 XT)), everything worked out of the box.

It's been ages since I had a real issue (like the dreaded Broadcom wifi cards back in the days).

kakwa_··on Encrypted traffic interception on Hetzner and Linode targeting Jabber service
Implement a proper Proof of Possession system (PoP) and make Let's Encrypt opt-in instead of opt-out.

Given that in the end, Let's Encrypt/ACME relies on PoP of a DNS domain, DNSSEC setup on the domain should have been a prerequisite.

In addition, an explicit opt-in should be required, for example, with a requirement for a CAA record pointing to LE.

---

As a side note, this whole situation leaves me with a really weird feeling.

On one end, I will always be grateful for LE enabling tls/https generalization.

On the other, I kind of feel betrayed and/or ashamed that LE/ACME almost willingly introduced protocol flaws weakening the whole CA infrastructure and that we (me included) didn't challenge it more when LE was introduced.

kakwa_··on Show HN: Building a 42-inch E-Ink frame for generative art
Not really. In a lot of industries, +20 years old tech and even +20 years old equipment are normal and competitive.

In tech, yes, 20 years is a lot, but that's more of an exception.

And imho, it's slowing down: A 20 years old computer, like an Athlon 64, today, could probably run most of the usual basic workloads (mail, text, word processing, browsing) with up to date software. It would be slow, but it would work. An 1983 years old computer in 2003 was just obsolete and completely unfit to run any of the usual 2003 software.

kakwa_··on Show HN: Building a 42-inch E-Ink frame for generative art
Devil's advocate, but one might argue patents actually incentivize progress.

Without patents, there is far less incentive to seek progress. What's the point for a for-profit organization to spend resources on Research, just to see your innovation immediately copied?

And if said for-profit organization still innovate, it has a strong incentive to keep its innovation as secret as possible. Patents by contrast, incentivize sharing, on one hand it makes the innovation public knowledge, and on the other licensing agreements usually exist.

And in the end, 20 years is really short compared to human history.

Are patents an ideal solution? Hell no, this system is too easily abused (patent trolling, patent thickets, etc), and feels really wrong at times (patents on life-saving drugs for example). But so far, that's the best compromise we manage to mostly agree on in terms of worldwide IP recognition.

kakwa_··on Google changed ad auctions, raising prices 15%, witness says
I'm wondering what was the overall effect on prices in the end.

Did the prices really increased by 15%?

Or did the bids, specially the second highest, roughly dropped by 15% meaning the price stayed the same.

Or something in the middle.

kakwa_··on Argentina's Senate approves bill to eliminate income tax
Well ressources are not infinite. And in such conditions I would rather prioritize by need rather than by mean.
kakwa_··on Gaia-1 a 9B parameter generative world model for autonomous driving
> We have had fully autonomous airplanes and trains for decades now.

On the surface, yes. Looking more closely, kind-of-but-not-really.

A plane auto-pilot is not really meant to fly the plane from gate to gate. It's more a series of automation simplifying each action performed during the flight. But each action have to be triggered individually and controlled by the pilots.

For trains, full automation is not common at all. You see it see it mostly on a few metro lines, which is an ideal case (platforms can be secured, homogeneous equipment, very static route, short track enclosed in tunnels). On a classic railway networks, we are still at the stage of a few experimental projects.

So, even with trains and planes, we are hardly there yet. And these are much simpler systems to automate: they are operating in heavily controlled environments, with a traffic that is not that dense (compared to a city street) and with tons of help from the infrastructure (think ILS for plane landings, or ETCS signaling & speed control for trains).

So, a self-driving car in an open environment like a street? No, we are there yet, and in my opinion, we are still one or two decades away from seeing that.

← PreviousPage 3 of 19Next →