HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kakwa_

1,465 karma · joined August 10, 2015

submissionscomments
kakwa_··on The French repairability index – one year after its implementation [pdf]
To extend further, very few items will run flawlessly for decades or more without some kind of maintenance.

Durable doesn't necessarily mean the product will last eternally as built.

Books usually need to be re-bound and re-covered, pieces of furniture need to be repainted/revarnished, Electronic appliances may need component replacement (capacitors, belts, etc), etc

Yes,this represent some efforts and still have some ecological impact, but being able to maintain an item that, at its core, is still original is a far cry from producing a brand new one.

But to do so, the product needs to be designed as maintainable and reparable, preferably even beyond the manufacturer support period (by using generic and easily obtainable components for example).

kakwa_··on Twitter plans to comply with Musk’s demands for data
Is the Tesla stock drop having a significant impact?

The whole tech field, including Tesla and Twitter has seen stock prices drop.

Yes Musk can leverage less money, but he also has to spend less to buy Twitter.

kakwa_··on Largest airship built in United States since 1930s to take shape soon
Is the comparison with a 747 the most relevant?

The niche use case I see for large airships (aside from pleasure rides) is deliveries in remote area with no infrastructure. For example delivering a big generator in Alaska.

In such use case, the comparison should maybe be against large transport helicopters.

kakwa_··on Postmark has been acquired by ActiveCampaign
I'm also not convince this is a good fit, but for another reason: if you're a pure Deliverability Company, it's far easier to maintain healthy relations with email hosting providers and get useful information or data from them.

By contrast, if you're a Marketing Company, well 'enemy' might be bit strong but these providers will definitely be far less cooperative, and your service might suffer from it.

kakwa_··on French fighter jet joy ride goes très, très wrong (2020)
It reminds me of a similar story I heard a while ago. As in your story, some military contractors were testing a new radar system at the factory. And conveniently, the factory was near an international airport, so they were using the civilian traffic as targets. As these planes usually don't have threat detectors, they were completely unaware they were used as guinea pigs for this new radar.

That was until someone had the brilliant idea to test the radar on an El Al plane...

This must have scared the hell out of the Israeli pilots and it seems this created a small diplomatic incident.

kakwa_··on Ask HN: Have you ever switched cloud?
Amazon sell a lot of stuff and consequently compete with a lot of legacy companies: Brick and mortar retail in nearly all fields (fashion, food, tools, appliance, books, etc), other online marketplaces (often with a mail order past) and even some tech companies.

Generally, companies are unwilling to give money to their competitor, reinforcing it.

They also might want to avoid some PR issues, as using your competitors product can lead to juicy stories depending on the situation/field.

If they are somewhat paranoid, they can also be reluctant to have their data accessible by their competitor (and I'm not talking DBs access there, even something like ELB logs can give valuable information, iirc such story did pop a few years)

Working for a marketing SaaS solution, requests from our clients to not be hosted on AWS are still quite common.

kakwa_··on Meta's A.I. exodus: Top talent quits as lab tries to keep pace with rivals
Well, personally, I'm in a situation where I struggle to spend more than half of what I earn, including my mortgage repayment.

I'm not a cheap person, if I need to spend money on something, I will. It's just that my life style and affinities mean I'm not spending much.

I'm not much of a fashion guy, so no huge collection of expensive clothes.

Nor am I a car guy (I don't even currently own one, and if I were to have one again in the future, it would simply be a tool).

When I travel, the destination is often decided at the last moment, and I'm more of a backpack kind of guy.

When I buying something somewhat expensive (price ~$1000 or more), I'm always evaluating the usefulness of the thing, for example, I kind of want to replace my folk guitar but in fairness, I rarely play my current one, and it's not like this will change with a nicer one (I also have two very nice electric guitars I've not touched in years).

Simply put, partly out of how I was brought-up, partly out of some ecological-consciousness, I do not buy something simply because I can.

Also, regarding this part:

> Its the kind of thing said by someone who has never made that much money

When I make this statement, opposition comes far more often from people "who have never made that much money". My friends with similar or greater earnings get my point of view, even if they don't have the same views, but my friends with lower incomes generally strongly disagree with this kind of view.

kakwa_··on OVHcloud fire: SBG2 data center had no extinguisher, no power cut-out
Indeed

"Bricolage", in a private context (typically DIY light home renovation) doesn't bear any negative connotations. In fact, several hardware store chains use the term (Mr. Bricolage, Brico Depot, Bricorama).

But using the term when describing a product or in a professional context is far more negative, often describing something which doesn't look well made or designed.

kakwa_··on Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 2022 goes from 90% to 26%
The irony simply comes from the "little green men" i.e. the Russian "volunteers" sent in Crimea/East Ukraine who were suspiciously well equipped and organized, almost like they were Russian Army military units in all but names.

As for the "country" sending fighters, in this instance, it's miss-representative. These are legit volunteers acting on there own initiatives outside of any government's call to arm, a bit like the International Brigades of the Spanish Civil war.

Lastly, Putin is a gambler, but not an idiot nor a lunatic wanting to end the world nor a leader in a desperate situation. He made a gamble in Ukraine because he knew he could somewhat get away with it (even if things are not exactly going according to plan).

He will not start a global/nuclear conflict over a silly matter like few hundreds foreign combatants acting on their own initiative, which doesn't mean he will not posture against it.

kakwa_··on Russia’s Possible Invasion of Ukraine
During WWII, the two rasputitsa/mud seasons generally were the only times the eastern front was slightly quieter and these seasons significantly impacted both sides.

Summer and even Winter generally saw numerous offensives by contrast.

During the first year, in October 41, Barbarossa and operation Typhoon (Battle of Moscow) stopped temporarily in part due to the rasputitsa, and only resumed when the ground froze in early November (incidentally giving time for the Soviets to reorganize the extremely weakened front protecting Moscow).

The soviet Winter offensives mostly stopped around the Spring rasputitsa, Case Blue and other initial battles only started only in late April 42. and after Stalingrad, the Soviet reconquest of the South during the 42/43 Winter stopped again around Spring 43, with offensive operation only restarting in July 43 (Battle of Kursk).

There are of course many other factors explaining these pauses (offensive strength exhausted, over-extended supply lines, etc), but rasputitsa was definitely a factor.

kakwa_··on Macron says France will build new nuclear energy reactors
4 to 6 years is possible, but more of a best-case scenario.

If you look for example, the nuclear reactor built in France in the 70ies and 80ies took generally between 5 and 9 years to build, with the newer and greater capacity reactors taking significantly more time.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_commercial_nuclear_rea...

Keep in mind that it was at the pick of Nuclear reactor construction. These are really large projects with tons of suppliers and contractors to coordinate. There is a lot of experience and institutional knowledge needed, but which has been unfortunately partially lost with the significant slowing down of new constructions in the late 80ies/90ies.

Also, this slowing down also had a significant effect on the supply chains, often leaving very few companies key components/sub-systems.

Flamanville 3 is definitely a poorly lead project and a big outlier, but, a country re-starting its nuclear construction, the first units would probably take ~10 years to come online.

kakwa_··on When is the revolution in architecture coming?
It really makes me think of "The Irony of Fate" intro:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iHdFd2RKRSI

This is the intro of a Soviet Christmas romantic comedy, with the premise that the main protagonist, quite drunk, gets into a taxi, gives the address of is home, gets there, unlocks the door with his key and go to bed, only to realize a bit later that something was wrong when an unknown woman enters... Everything was identical to his apartment (street name, number, building, keys, etc)... except he is in Leningrad and not in Moscow.

kakwa_··on Show HN: OtterTune – Automated Database Tuning Service for RDS MySQL/Postgres
Do you also plan to give optimization recommendations for the DB schema itself?

I'm thinking more specifically about indexes.

In my organization, we provide a solution where clients can run complex analytic queries periodically. We frequently have to tune the DB manually by adding an index here or there (or just brute force by switching to a bigger RDS...).

A product analyzing the query logs, combined with the estimated size of the tables plus some EXPLAINs run, and then using that to provide index/schema recommendations could help a lot.

kakwa_··on Classified tank specs leaked on War Thunder game forums again
World of Warships is at most 50ies tech.

I think the most recent ship in game is Colbert, a French AA cruiser commissioned in 1959. And in game, she doesn't feature her missile conversion in the 70ies.

Plus most of the "high tier" designs are paper ships with a varying level of fantasy from the game devs.

Lastly the game is far from a simulation, it's extremely arcady.

kakwa_··on Adobe Joins Blender Development Fund
I'm not sure how much of it overlaps with Blender and how much of it is complementary to Blender.

But Adobe recently acquired Allegorithmic and their 3D texture tool Substance.

https://www.substance3d.com/

https://techcrunch.com/2019/01/23/adobe-acquires-allegorithm...

kakwa_··on Goldman seems to be running networking software from 2008
The "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" mind set is only one part of the equation.

Most organizations acknowledge that it's generally preferable to run up to date and modern software. But at the same time, updating or, even worse, replacing a piece of technology can be extremely complex, and also quite risky, so people naturally chose the path of least resistance and keep old pieces software (or hardware) running.

And even Facebook or Google are likely not immune to that.

For example, Google used to run RedHat 7.1 (release in 2001) for a very long time, only transitioning recently to a more modern Debian OS base.

http://events17.linuxfoundation.org/sites/events/files/slide...

This is of course with huge caveats as Google has the resources and the people to basically maintain their own distribution, and practically did so upgrading this RH 7.1 base with security and bug fix patches, and including newer components such as recent kernels. But overall, the base system Google used was quite old, almost to a scary extent to be honest.

Also, the upgrade process detailed in the slides is really interesting and show how complex and involved it was for Google. For organizations less able to attract very good engineers this kind of upgrade would either be extremely painful (bugs, downtime, etc), or even nearly impossible.

kakwa_··on Go 1.17 is deprecating the traditional use of 'go get'
The timeline seems way too short for a lot of usecases to be honest.

For young projects, where it's kind of expected (trade-off of being an early adopter), or for small projects (which can be easily maintained by a third party), it's acceptable.

But for bigger/core projects this is far more problematic.

Just for comparisons, a lot of Linux distributions will maintain a specific version for ~5 years if not more (Debian, RedHat), and if for smaller components, they can do things like backport patches, or even create the patches themselves, however, for larger ones, they are reliant on upstream providing stable and maintained versions for the life of a specific version of the distribution.

Also, I've seen quite a lot of large and complex projects taking several years to reach production. In these contexts, having to constantly rework components (and re-test them, both individually and as part of the overall system) is not really feasible.

There is no ideal solution, maintaining backward compatibility is costly, and can lead to messy code bases, and it's legitimate to want to avoid that by deprecating API/functionalities. However, downstream (distribution, users of a given library) needs stability and generally cannot afford to rework their solution every 3 months (keep in mind that downstream generally relies on many upstream components, if a lot of these components break at the same time, even in minor ways, this can result in a huge headaches).

IMHO, a more desirable compatibility period, at least for big/core components, would be around 5 years.

kakwa_··on Neural networks emulate any guitar pedal for $120
Also we had electronic simulators for various instruments for ages now.

Things like Clavinova keyboards Piano or Line 6 Pods simulating Guitar/Bass amps & effects have been out their for decades now.

And while they have been quite popular due to the sheer number of sonorities and the convenience they bring (possibility to play with an headset, extremely useful to play at night or in apartments), traditional analog setups remain strong.

Playing on an analog setup still is more pleasant and more expressive IMHO, in particular "simulators" tend to mask the attack when hitting a note, and hides a lot the tension/crispation in the hands/fingers when playing, leading to potential bad habits, specially for people learning to play an instrument. Analog to digital and digital to analog conversion definitely lead to loses in expressiveness.

kakwa_··on Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster
IIRC, the US navy had 2 rigid airships in the 30ies, Akron and Macon (both filled with Helium).

Both crashed after a few years in service, in weather related accidents (with significant loss of lives in Akron case).

These two examples are not isolated cases, several zeppelin crashed in similar circumstances.

Replacing H with He solves part of the safety issues with zeppelin, but not the main source of accidents. Given how high the susceptible to weather is, due to the inherent size an light weight of zeppelins, I don't think we will see a large zeppelin being built in the foreseeable future, despite all the projects around these.

kakwa_··on Fire declared in OVH SBG2 datacentre building
Just as a side note, the name "kimsufi" comes from the French "qui me suffit", which roughly translate to "enough for me".
kakwa_··on Show HN: ustaxes.org – open-source tax filing webapp
You can do pretty much any bank operation online these days, at least the most common operation like opening an account (life insurance, PEL, CEL, livret A, etc), getting your RIB (bank ID pdf), making transfers (one offs and recurring ones), declare a lost credit card, etc.

And it has been like that for a while (I remember opening a PEL online and configuring a monthly transfer to fill it when I started working 10 years ago). Maybe all the banks are/were not at the same level, but with mine, BNP, it was possible.

Also, now, I also have bank accounts in a more "international" bank (HSBC), and to be honest, even if the website as the same functionalities, HSBC website is a lot more clunkier, mixing the old and the new than BNP's one which is reasonably good looking and easy to use.

kakwa_··on Why does it take so long to build software? (2020)
I kind of have the exact opposite in term of feelings.

Seeing Windows 95 or 98 going into a BSoD was far more common than today with Windows 10.

I also remember seeing Netscape crashing extremely frequently toward the end of the first browser war.

By comparison, today, a modern browser is doing a lot more things, but very rarely crashes in my experience.

Overall, in term of software quality, I think things have improved, specially thanks to:

* the maturing of tools like compilers, dependency managers, linters, unit tests frameworks, etc.

* the widespread adoption of development technics ensuring better quality (CI, unit tests, code coverage, automated integration tests, etc).

* the development of common building blocks such as libraries and frameworks, which enabled projects to not "re-invent the wheel" every time for low level stuff. These building blocks also being generally widely used, battle tested and more reliable than in house implementations.

* the development of OSS which drastically increase the accessibility of the previously mentioned building blocks to developers.

Both technically and methodologically, software development has seen tons of improvements since the late 90ies, early 2000.

kakwa_··on Rocky Linux: A CentOS replacement by the CentOS founder
Also, RHEL is packaging pieces of software that are not under GPL/LGPL. With permissive licenses, they could probably heavily restrict source redistribution and availability.

If half the userland is not available as source (patch and packaging included), a CentOS-like project would not be possible.

Effectively, if RedHat/IBM wanted, there are a lot of dick moves which could effectively kill Rocky.

kakwa_··on “This is the worst documentation I have ever seen in my life”
It's far less extensive than what you presented, but on the current project we are working on at work, we are using https://github.com/swaggo/swag

It's somewhat specific to golang but so far it has been relatively good for us.

The spec is directly next to the code as code comments, so it has far more chances to get updated when changes are made compared to an external documentation.

Also, the payloads and responses are directly derived from the Golang structs, so, at least on that aspect, changes in the code are automatically reflected in the spec (apart for description and examples).

We also put the interactive documentation directly in our API under /doc. It is a useful tool for developers when implementing a new url/handler or modifying an existing one. It also creates incentives to keep the documentation matching.

Overall, we had very few mismatches between the spec and the actual implementation overall, despite not having deeply tested it (be it manually or automatically). Apart from one or two mismatches that were fixed quickly, I was able to take the spec, generate client libraries from it (swagger-codegen), and use them for quite extensive demos without issues.

We are still early in the project (not in production yet), and there are definitely some aspects we need to improve (integration/automated tests to be sure doc and code are 100% matching) or to completely figure out (ex: how to handle several versions of the same API). But overall, using swaggo/swag has been a pleasant experience.

kakwa_··on Hacked billboards make Teslas see phantom objects causing them to swerve or stop
They are probably ways to improve existing roads for semi-automated vehicles without creating dedicated infrastructure (which is by itself, not possible anyway, it's kind of hard to create dedicated streets in a dense city for example).

The roads could have captors/sensors/tags added gradually to them. For example, some near field devices planted in the road and broadcasting information such as the name of the road, mile mark, line number/side or traffic lights broadcasting if they are at red or yellow or green or signs such as Stops broadcasting their presence.

This would help autonomous vehicles a lot (instead of having to scan the infrastructure and deduce the environment, the infrastructure will broadcast the environment, at least the static parts, directly), while at the same time not be that costly (compared to the initial cost of the road or even its maintenance costs).

kakwa_··on Logging Everyone Out
I'm also wondering if the caching strategy they are using is a naive one (ie: cache is valid for a fix duration, like 5 minutes) or if it's a more active one (like stakeoverflow), with cache in validations each time a page is modified/commented on.
kakwa_··on Hermann Hauser: ‘It’s in Nvidia’s Interests to Destroy Arm’
Dailymotion is a bit of an exception, and somewhat of a waste (Specially when Orange, the national/historic telco operator in France, was forced to bought them by the government, and didn't help Dailymotion development).

But one the other side, you have tons of small to mid size enterprises that got bought.

For example, Adobe has bought quite a few French companies such as Neolane (marketing solution) Fotolia (image bank) or Alegoritmic (3D texture editor) in the past few years.

kakwa_··on Automatic SSL Certificates for internal IP's for home k8 setup using LetsEncrypt
At home, with just a few devices, it's doable, but adding a ca on all the devices of a corporate network is a huge pain. On one hand, you have varying levels of control (from none to total) on the devices. On the other hand adding a ca is a bit of a pain, with the ca needed to be added in various ca collection s for different softwares (ex in linux, ca-certificates, java certificates, and to add them system wide for browsers, you need to recompile libnss).
kakwa_··on Why has college gotten so expensive in the last 30 years? A blank check in 1993
> The cost is low for the student but it's pretty high for the taxpayers.

Well, not really. In France for example, the cost per student per year looks like the following:

* Classe preparatoire (math & physic 2 years course to prepare ranked for Engineering schools): ~15K euros per student per year

* Engineering Schools: 10 to 25K depending on the specialty, with a few prestigious schools (Centrale Paris, Polytechnique, Mines de Paris, etc) in the 30 to 60K bracket.

* Literacy student in university: 5 to 7K

* Math or Physic student in university: 10 to 15K

* Business School: 15 to 20K

However, keep in mind this figures don't include housing.

Apart from Business schools and less prestigious engineering schools, most of these are public schools with low tuition fees for students (even if these are slowly increasing, Centrale Paris raised them to 3.5K recently for example).

Also, cost apart, having public schools with low/no tuition fees helps keeping open opportunities for everybody, and mitigate social and economic aspects.

It reduces the "my parents don't have the money to allow me to go through university" or "do I really want I 200K lawn from the start of my professional life?" aspects.

It's just better at giving more equal opportunities to every students, minimizing somewhat factors that are outside of their control like the socioeconomic background of their parents.

Don't get me wrong, it's far from perfect and these factors still play an important role, but at least it's an effort in the right direction.

kakwa_··on Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds
Also, a key idea of Graeber's book is that money is in fact debt (the example with English soldiers checks being used as bills in Hong Kong bars is quite striking in my opinion).

Money is basically a small abstraction over explicit debt bonds linked to material goods, making it more easily exchangeable.

This comes from the fact most economic chains are far from synchronous (example: a farmer needing tools to prepare his field, but being able to pay for said tools only after the harvest, the blacksmith needing coal and iron ore to produce said tools, but not being able to pay until the farmer has paid him, etc).

In this context, the banker (or any other lender) acts as an intermediary, evaluating if the debt can be repaid and bearing the risk instead of the creditor for a fee.

← PreviousPage 6 of 19Next →