HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kakwa_

1,465 karma · joined August 10, 2015

submissionscomments
kakwa_··on How the government prints and distributes money [video]
> This is so disingenuous and reeks of a superiority complex

Well, no. I doubt anybody on Earth (including bankers, billionaires or governments) truly can grasp all the ins and outs of money/debts creation and all the consequence it has on the economy and society. At best they can have a local and short term view which are in their best interest.

For example, 1929 crisis, more than 90 years after the events is not a completely settled question among scholars up to this day (not so much on the origins but more on the effect of the responses of Hoover/Roosevelt distinct policies and the policies of other countries around the world at the time).

To make a really bad analogy, the current financial system is a bit like this big old legacy system with COBOL, some partial rewrite in Java, some ad-hoc hacks created when it crashed. It's a huge mess to entangle, not always logical, but it kind of works except when it doesn't. And nobody really knows fully how it works. The current financial system is a bit like that, except it's a 300/400 years old (~creation of the first central banks), has seen tons of crashes and hacks, and has laws, procedures, customs and policies as "source code" which makes it really hard to read.

kakwa_··on How the government prints and distributes money [video]
Well, wealth allocation (through money and debt creation in our modern world) is a really complex topic. And it plays into various aspect of human knowledge and behaviors, from Maths and Physics to History, Sociology and Psychology.

It's a very difficult topic to grasp and is subject to various changes, from vested interest of groups (said group which itself could be composed of competing entities) to ideological decisions.

Crying wolf and having borderline conspiracy theories about "how the government is here to robe you!" and "how the elites are here to maintain ignorance!" doesn't help this discussion.

The real discussion is how wealth should be allocated: toward which goals? (consumption? investments? which kind of consumption or investments?) by who should it be allocated? (banks? selected individuals? governments?) What is the "correct" wealth distribution (high or low inequality, more or less towards investments or consumption etc).

If you frame the debate this way, you start to have more constructive criticisms of today situation and the current system (Which don't get me wrong, is definitely flawed and biased toward wealth concentration).

And I've seen videos on Youtube doing exactly that, contrary to the video linked there which is more about ranting, is poorly structured and doesn't give a clearer view of the situation.

kakwa_··on Markdown is an excellent choice for documentation
Well, to quote Jordan Sissel (author of Logstash) "Wiki means: where documentation goes to die".

I found maintaining a good documentation inside a wiki tough. People (including me) will tend to create new pages willy nilly, never deleting old ones. The layout is generally rough, you generally have a basic structure, but under that, you see a mess of pages at every levels. The information is often out of date and often redudant which creates noise even if you have quality pages (and even if you have a good search).

The plus side of a wiki is its accessibility. Committing a text file inside a git repository is a tough ask to none technical people. Asking them to "fork" and do a pull request is even harder.

But to maintain quality documentation inside a wiki, a dedicated curator is almost always needed.

It's also not in or near the logical path of code/product changes. You need to login into a dedicated system, find the page you need to change or where to add a new page and finally do the edit. It's kind of hard to have a systematic good documentation in such circumstances. Also, doing reviews and documentation versioning (in sync with product versions) is kind of hard with a wiki.

For all these reasons, I tend to prefer putting my documentation right next to my code in a markup language (simple Markdown README.md for simple projects, RST+read the doc for more complex ones, but that's a personal preference). You have far more incentive to edit the documentation, versioning is automatic, documentation versions are in sync with your product versions, review is easier (just include it inside the PR, same as code review).

The downside is less outside accessibility. It's also a very "low altitude" documentation, great for documenting individual libraries or components, it's not so great for things like documenting overall system architecture, or organizational stuff like processes, basically anything not tied to one specific component.

In the end, wikis have their role, but I found they are generally overused and miss-managed.

kakwa_··on Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on stock repurchases
Well, yes and no.

For the assets, such as the physical aircraft, if left unattended for long, they will slowly degrade.

And if a company fails, it's not that easy to recreate the same one from scratch, all the organizational structures of the company, the partnerships, the contracts with suppliers, etc, need to be reestablished. Not impossible, but at the same time, not that easy.

And it's only seeing it from the narrow view of one company failing. If the whole economy has a significant portion of companies failing, it will mess-up things a lot more.

kakwa_··on Why the second wave of the 1918 Spanish flu was so deadly
If it was fearmonguering, it was not intentional on my part. Sorry for that.

Indeed I missed the mild cases which are not quantified but likely quite numerous.

kakwa_··on Why the second wave of the 1918 Spanish flu was so deadly
The mortality rate of Covid-19 seems higher than that.

The around 3% mortality rate is what you get by dividing the number of deaths by the number of infection (past and present) (as of today: 5359 / 140875 = 3.8%).

But this is incorrect as the number of currently infected people is quite high (half the total number of infections) and unfortunately, a few will die in the near future.

If you divide the number of deaths by (recovered + deaths), the mortality is much higher (as of today: 5359 / (70174 + 5359) = 7.1%).

Which seems actually about as high as the Spanish Flue right in between the low and high estimate (20M/500M, 50M/500M). And it's source for worries since our medical systems are 1) much more developed than in 1918, and 2) they are not yet completely overloaded. If it were to spread rapidly and overload our health systems, the mortality rate could rise even more, let's hope it doesn't reach that level.

kakwa_··on Tesla produces its millionth car
That's one way to see it.

Another would be to say in the end, it's the same "mature" market, one more EV sell is most likely one less ICE sell.

And it's not like EVs have tremendously changed the equation, the price is about the same (total cost of ownership), the capabilities are about the same (slightly better on some aspects, like performance, slightly worst in term of autonomy and refueling/recharging time). Right now, EVs are not extending or creating a market but are triggering a re-composition of this market.

Maybe in the future, we will see more deeper changes which will trigger a major shift (autopilots that work? reduction in cost? (EVs are engineeringly simpler than ICE vehicles)) but we are not there yet.

kakwa_··on It takes now 53 weeks salary to earn same as 30 weeks in 1985
Also, another aspect to consider is what is the basic minimum to be integrated in society and exist socially.

In the 20ies cars were not a social necessity, but beyond the 70ies, not having a car generally means partial social exclusion (more difficulties to get a job, etc).

Today, not having a computer/smartphone/tablet and an internet subscription would impact social integration.

This basic minimum need is not set in stone, it's a shifting target. Rephrasing the problem with "What is the current median revenue Vs What is the basic minimum to be an integrated member of society" would be a better way to put it.

kakwa_··on It takes now 53 weeks salary to earn same as 30 weeks in 1985
I feel it's slightly more complex than that.

With a new significant portion of the workforce able to work, you enable on one side, new economic needs (more transports, more kindergartens, etc) and on the other side you enable more production of goods which in theory should improve the material conditions of a society. Basically a society should be more efficient if it stops excluding half its available workforce.

But a the same time, housewives where not passive actors in the economy, they did had an economic impact (raising children, etc), just that this economic impact was not measured previously. However it was probably not equivalent to a paid job in term of economical impact, and for obvious emancipation reasons, it's definitely not a state to return to.

kakwa_··on Tell HN: How to run a startup for $6 a year
you can pick very cheap domains with some tlds.

For example, my .ovh is costing me around 4$ per year and there are probably even cheaper tlds.

kakwa_··on Mining my mailbox for top email service providers
Well, it's the first barrier.

If you mess-up really bad you will have bad deliverability across the board.

The mistakes can be numerous:

* bad setup like broken DKIM

* bad sending parameters like opening too many connections by IP to a given provider

* bad content format like too many large images

* bad actual content

* bad recipient list management with lists containing lots of typos, none existent mailboxes, spam traps, etc

* miss-managing unsubscribes

* bad bounce handling

If this happens, you can have some if not all of your IPs blacklisted, maybe even your domain. In worst cases, a whole IPv4 range is blacklisted.

Then a second aspect to take into account is the open rate and the click through rate (people actually clicking a link in a marketing email), this one can vary depending on the company activities, and also the quality of their marketing content, but is generally in the range of a few percents at most. And then, you also have to take into account the actual impact in term of sells which will be even lower.

Deliverability is import, it's not rocket science, but it's a lot of small items various people at various stages (tech, creatives, marketers, etc) must be cautious about which makes it actually quite hard.

kakwa_··on Mining my mailbox for top email service providers
It can be quite hard to detect. A lot of this services will not have an easily recognizable marker.

It can be for various reasons:

* They can use these services themselves

* They can support full customization of domains, including for the "message-id" and the "received" headers.

I'm working as SRE in a fairly large marketing provider (not sure in term of %, but we provide services for quite a few large brands sending several millions emails per day), and we do this full customization by default. There are other way to recognize us (other headers in the email or the pattern for the tracked url for example), but the one described in the article will not work.

It would also be interesting to be able to detect which MTA is used by these service providers. Is it an in-house one or an off the shelf one? The two off the shelf ones I know for mass sending are Momentum and PowerMTA which are both owned by Sparkpost but they might be others.

kakwa_··on Bocker – Docker implemented in around 100 lines of Bash (2015)
A similar approach is used by distributions such as Debian/Fedora/Ubuntu/RHEL.

In these distributions, you have tools ("pbuilder/*builder" in deb base distributions, "mock" in rpm based distributions) which create a chroot, grabs the build dependencies and install them from the repo, build the package and then throw away the chroot.

It's really convenient for many reasons:

1) tracking and referencing build dependencies is far better as you have to declare them explicitly, no more "but it used to compile on the old machine... what am I missing".

2) you don't add kludge on the host running the build as you start from a fresh chroot every time.

3) you can target many distributions/versions from one building host (I'm regularly building RHEL 7 and 8 rpms and Debian 7, 8, 9, 10 debs from my Debian sid for example, without too much worry of weird side effects due to my particular setup.

The downside is that builds can take a bit more time, but that's clearly something I'm willing to trade-off for more systematic and (semi-)reproducible builds.

I even spent a few nights a month ago to have a newer version of mock that supports EL8 available on my Debian (for those interested: https://github.com/kakwa/debian-rpm-build-tools)

kakwa_··on TeamViewer stores user passwords in registry, encrypted with hard-coded key
IIRC, in the case of firefox, a key is generated at profile creation, and then the password saved are encrypted using this key.

It's basically security through obscurity as the key stays clear text UNLESS the profile is protected by a password a human must type every times he opens Firefox.

kakwa_··on “My wife has complained that OpenOffice will never print on Tuesdays” (2009)
The eleven years old me was doing the contrary: starting a crappy/sticky PSU fan with a screwdriver not realizing there was a "slight" risk of electrocution (never got a chock however, I guess I was somewhat aware of the danger).
kakwa_··on Rolls-Royce plans mini nuclear reactors by 2029
Well, no.

The Flamanville 3 EPR nuclear reactor is a mess (and I've seen it first hand, working on one of its subsystem a few years ago). The regulations bodies, aka the ASN (Agence de Surete Nucleaire) played its role, and uncovered various issues, most worrying, defects in the reactor vessel itself (and also there was some attempt by the manufacturer to hide these defects). And it's only one of a long chain, the were others like concrete being poured without/insufficient rebar or improper composition, various welding issues on pipes or machinery. And each time, it was not some minor mishaps requiring a quick fix but a major mistake requiring undoing what was done, redoing it properly and causing months of delays.

Basically, this is an Engineering and Project Management failure. On this kind of giant projects, logistic, coordination and management is key, the design is also key (system of systems, interfaces between systems etc) and it failed spectacularly here.

From the political side, despite some calls to just stop the construction from minor parties, the commitment from the politicians to see it built has remained strong all along. And there was also a deep commitment from the French state to the Nuclear industry, with the government bailing out Areva just a few years ago.

The Finish one is not better off, with the same kind of delays. The Chinese ones are in production (after significant delays) but 1) They learn from the mistakes of the first twos 2) They have probably better experience in large projects given the past construction boom in China 3) Some issues were probably put under the carpet as the Chinese government is not exactly renowned for its openness.

kakwa_··on Rolls-Royce plans mini nuclear reactors by 2029
No,France has not built any new nuclear power plant in decades, the only one being built (flammanville 3) is a mess, and there are goals to reduce the share of nuclear to 50%.
kakwa_··on Tesla Surges Above $500, Leaving Analyst Targets in the Dust
Well, in truth they most likely have something like a decade or so to adjust which is both not a lot and enough for such organizations to adjust.

Sure some manufacturers will go bust and collapse, but other will adapt, and new ones will be created.

I'm quite puzzled by Tesla's valuation, such a valuation is betting on it becoming a huge actor in the post IC automobile industry which is not a given.

I'm also skeptical about the "Iphone moment", functionally the Iphone was a huge step forward (basically having a small computer in your pocket vs having something just doing phone calls, SMSes and snake), but a Tesla, well, right now, it's still a car which does more or less the same thing as any other car (just slightly better in some aspect, slightly worst in others).

It's also not the same market, the Iphone appeared in the booming market of mobile phones which was seeing exponential growth at the time. And also, the gain in functionality and convenience was enough to transform the market from consumers willing to pay at most ~100$ for a flip phone to consumers willing to pay 1000$ for a smartphone with all that entails in term margins and profitability.

The car market by contrast, is not seeing such a growth, and it's unlikely consumers will be willing to spend that much more for their car.

There are potential market shift possible which could be caused by things like reliable autonomous vehicles, tighter regulations forbidding IC vehicles in some cities, cheaper cars (as EV are mechanically simpler, it's a possibility), but these are somewhat elusive.

Tesla valuation is at the very least a huge bet.

kakwa_··on Getting Drivers for Old Hardware Is Harder Than Ever
Well, no.

Or at least no in the near futur.

Debian dropped support of ppc32 with stretch.

kakwa_··on Learning at work is work, and we must make space for it
Well, no (or at least I guess it depends which educational system you are talking about).

On a few educational systems, you have dedicated curriculums for technicians and artisans/craftmen, with theory in classes, practice in labs and internship on the job.

Even if learning on the job is a big part (roughly half of the training), it's not purely that.

kakwa_··on FUSE for macOS is no longer open source
Well, in this specific case, I think the best outcome would be for Apple to merge the module in the MAC OSX kernel so it's there by default, FUSE is kind of a de-facto standard and is clearly a widely useful piece of code.

But, big picture, yes a lot of OSS projects have the same issue. Funding is clearly one aspect, but another aspect is also to work on having less "single person projects" (and I'm not talking about one time PRs but a genuine second core developer). I'm not sure how to encourage that however, maybe more commonly adding "HELP WANTED!" in the project README, maybe a button "I want to become a permanent contributor of <PROJECT>" button in Github, I don't know. If you are alone on a project, even if funded, chances are you will loss interest after a while, leaving the project with tons of possible improvements not realized, and a on/off maintenance, having more "N>1 core developers projects" would help mitigate that.

kakwa_··on Economists Are Rethinking the Numbers on Inequality
It's a bit more than cycles.

The huge reduction in the XXth century was due to many factors.

You start in the XIXth century with the development of Anarchism, which, to oversimplify, spawned various movements such as democratic socialism or communism on the political side, but also syndicalism (anarcho-syndicalism). The appearance of these forces started to change/influence things even before WWI with a few laws regulating working conditions (ex: 6 days week in 1906 in France voted after the Courrières mine disaster, or in Germany with a basic form of social security put in place in the 1880ies).

The two World Wars, and specially the various states (France, UK, Germany Russia) defaulting on their debts (either through inflation or complete un-acknowledgment of the debt) basically killed the rentiers (previously it was really nice for them, 5%, with an economic growth of 1 to 2% and practically not inflation).

The rise of the legitimacy of the State also helped a lot. This is due to the rise of Nationalism, the efforts of various states to build a common identity, and also the technological developments which permitted for a state to reach every corner of its population (transport and communication). This lead to the legitimacy of states to raise taxes which would have caused revolts previously.

WWI and specially WWII also shifted mentalities hugely, it's quite interesting that countries either monetarily or literally in ruins created Social Security systems.

Lastly the degree of technological development and its progressive deployment between 1820 and 1980 (in Europe and North America) hugely improved material condition for most people. The equation is a bit different when you are past 80% of the economy being subsistence farming.

Yes, some past events did change wealth distribution (the Plague for example), but a change on that scale is not something ever seen before in History, the XXth was pretty exceptional in that regard.

kakwa_··on Sweet Home 3D is a free interior design application
Great tool and also quite easy to use.

I've actually used it to simulate/chose my furniture and furniture placement quite recently.

Here the result using the ray tracing renderer:

https://mirror.kakwalab.ovh/misc/Sejour_5.png

https://mirror.kakwalab.ovh/misc/Chambre_3.png

Yes, that's mostly Ikea furniture. And consequently the 3D models are likely to exists and can be grabbed from 3dwarehouse/sketchup.

kakwa_··on It's 2019, but It Sure Feels a Lot Like 1998 for Stocks
It could be worst, he could have invested in Russian loans like Louis, his French counterpart, and not recoup anything past 1917.

https://www.cadtm.org/Russian-bonds-never-die

(basically, the Russian Empire borrowed a lot of money (several billions of Gold Francs), specially in France, and the Soviets, when they came to power, defaulted on these debts).

When Emptying the house of my late grand-mother after she died we actually found a few of these bonds.

I got one and, now, it's in a frame as part of my home decoration (I didn't feal like asking Mr. Putin for my ancestors' money back).

kakwa_··on One Reason the U.S. Military Can’t Fix Its Own Equipment
IP laws were partially suspended/taken over (with after the war compensations) during WWI. I'm thinking for example of Marconi's patents for wireless communication or also a few weapons design.

As for the contractors, the story of hms Prince of Wales against Bismarck comes to mind, with contractors sailing into battle to help mitigate reliability with its guns.

So there are precedents, in case of a dire need a state will enforce a deeper control over what is required to fight a war.

kakwa_··on Git repository summary on your terminal
An option to ignore some of the directories of the repository would be a nice addition (ex: ignoring ./vendor/ in golang repository).

Otherwise, nice tool, thanks for creating and sharing it.

kakwa_··on An Illustrated Guide to Useful Command Line Tools
Well, it's not always so simple.

If you are in a small team of 5 or 6 people, with less than 100 servers to manage, sure, it's doable.

But if you are part of a very large team of 50 or more sysadmins, with a large infra in the thousands of nodes with various OSes and vintage of OSes (even if Unix only), things can get tricky quite quickly.

First a lot of people will want their favorite tools to be installed which can result in a huge mess of special toolboxes not being consistently installed (different path location, tool set varying from server to server).

Second, these tools, specially the shiny newer ones, need to be built, packaged and maintained properly which represent a significant load, specially across several OSes/Vintage of OSes.

Third, as a general rule, having an install base with as few packages as possible is generally a good thing, on one hand it reduces the surface of exposition of a server, on a second hand, it helps auditing for security vulnerabilities as "dead weight" dependencies (ex: libX11 for an editor which is both terminal based and graphical based, but only used in its terminal form on a server) will not trigger false positives in term of CVEs.

kakwa_··on 7M Adobe Creative Cloud Accounts Exposed to the Public
Well, putting in place authentication can indeed be difficult, but making the ELK nodes only accessible by a limited set of IPs (preferably private ones) instead of being directly public facing should reasonably be expected.
kakwa_··on Slimbook collaborates with the PowerPC laptop
That's not accurate. For years I have run Linux (Debian and Gentoo mostly) on various architectures, including on an old PowerBook Pismo (G3) and an IBM Power 5, and I have rarely encountered architecture related limitations.

True, you will encounter issues (proprietary software, arch specific software (ex: chromium)), but these are not the norm. Wet fingering it, I would say at least 95% of packages worked without any issue, and this includes big things like Firefox, Libreoffice, OpenJDK, Apache...

I was a bit sad when Debian dropped support for ppc32.

kakwa_··on Why UTC is used as the acronym for Coordinated Universal Time
Well, French is commonly spoken every day by a lot more 76M people, it's more in the area of 200 to 300M people. If you go in Marocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Ivory Coast, Cameroon and other former colonies in Africa, you can reasonably expect people to be fluent, at least in cities.
← PreviousPage 8 of 19Next →