HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kamaal

13,753 karma · joined April 15, 2011

Programmer
submissionscomments
kamaal··on Jack Welch, the Man Who Broke Capitalism (2022)
>>I suppose some Americans would have preferred a situation where China stayed Communist or collapsed.

The definition of Communism per the west, is something that always fails by default. The way Chinese define communism is doing whatever it takes to win.

When you remove all the abstract words behind this game, a simple philosophy is if you do the right things you win. You can call it capitalism, communism or whatever you want.

kamaal··on First-Class Models: The Missing Productivity Revolution
Part of the reasons why so many people are disillusioned by AI. We are attempting to tame complexity that shouldn't exist at the first place.

Im guessing lots of code that was getting written was kind of verbose boiler plate, automating all that doesn't move the productivity needle all that much. That shouldn't have existed at all to start with.

kamaal··on Skip the exit interview when you leave your job
>>It's possible to give feedback without burning bridges.

Unless you are a coach, and your job is to give feedback. I would advice a) Don't give a feedback ever. b) If you are in a situation and had to give feedback, always say something positive.

Very few people are genuinely interested in improving and largely use feedback as a mechanism to see how people judge their work, and here a negative feedback is simply used to mark up people as enemies.

There are people who are exceptions to this, but this really is the rule.

kamaal··on Avoiding the Global Lobotomy
Nah, almost all the times a thing can be said straight without having to resort to metaphors, similes, adjective, adverbs etc.

You don't have to exaggerate the description of anything to send a message, thats the literary equivalent of screaming.

kamaal··on Accumulation of cognitive debt when using an AI assistant for essay writing task
Most of math is just that. Try to predict the next change and see if it sticks.
kamaal··on Brain activity much lower when using AI chatbots, MIT boffins find
>>It makes me wonder if people today (especially younger people) would be able to watch a movie like the Godfather? I have doubts.

Last time I watched the movie 'The Irishman' with family, they all seem pretty tuned out by 15 mins.

It does feel like like addiction to reels/tiktok does have its toll. For that matter, due to Twitter exposure, I do have problems reading books.

When I probed ChatGPT a little, it tells me writing with a real pen and paper is now a super power as it lets you move slowly, pause, think etc.

kamaal··on A receipt printer cured my procrastination
A recipe has a great chance of success, there are few such recipes.

If you think you will try out a new recipe from scratch everyday it shouldn't be surprising if most of your days don't add up to much, or even add up to a negative.

kamaal··on Air India flight to London crashes in Ahmedabad with more than 240 onboard
Eventually it all folds into one management org, that is the whole issue.

I wouldn't expect two parallel cultures in a org, one for safety, one for entertainment systems.

kamaal··on A receipt printer cured my procrastination
It would do people a whole lot of good, if they start looking at a great day as executing well tested 'checklist' rather than a 'todo list' built from scratch every day.

No wonder some of the most productive people like Knuth, or people like presidents many times have fixed schedules, clothes they wear, food they eat etc etc.

If something is working, do it more often, you want to do more of what works, at some point things that don't work wont be on your check list.

kamaal··on A receipt printer cured my procrastination
This stops working after a while. The real deal is you begin the realise the 'points' you accumulate playing this game can't be redeemed to do something fun or satisfying. This game begins to appear totally pointless as you age(Points are less useful as you age, and dying with lots of points means time and effort was spent to acquire a thing that can't be spent now). Which causes even more procrastination.

I think humans crave freedom and free time, with good health more than anything else. This frees you up to care about doing things which we feel more rewarding and fun.

Several times you are better off skipping the drills and rituals and just focus on making lots of money as quickly as possible. And of course competing to accumulate more money just for the heck of it is equally demotivating as well. Focus what you want from the money and that is likely to move you along better use of your time and effort.

kamaal··on Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts
>>I witnessed this up close in India where parties openly exist to benefit certain constituencies based on caste, language, religion and so on.

+1

As an Indian, classic definition of corruption here is something that other people do. When our own do it, its not really called corruption, its more intelligent work done to make our people win.

Similar term is appeasement. It kind of means if people I hate are winning, they must be doing bad things or cheating. It is impossible that people I hate should do well in life.

kamaal··on A maths proof that is only true in Japan
>>In theory maths should be able to be broken down to its basic components and be proven to be all true, or if something is false, then the whole thing collapses.

>>But in practice things like this become so complex that it becomes a matter of conviction, influenced by things like ego.

Isn't this like doing a bunch of AND , OR operations?

How does ego become a factor here? Either an expression evaluates to true or false. There are only two outcomes, why is there a confusion here.

kamaal··on I think I'm done thinking about GenAI for now
>>will retard the skill development

I worked at a Indian IT services firm which even until mid-2010's didn't give internet access to people at work. Their argument was that use of internet would make the developers dumb.

The argument always was assume you had internet outage for days and had to code , you would value your skills then. Well guess what its been decades now, and I don't think that situation has ever come to pass, heck not even something close to that has come to pass.

Sometimes how you do things changes. During the peak of Perl craze, my team lead often told me people who didn't use C++ weren't as smart and eventually people who used Perl would have their thinking skills atrophy when Perl wouldn't be around. That doomsday scenarios hasn't happened either. People have similar things about Java, IDEs, package managers, docker etc etc.

Businesses don't even care about these things. A real estate developer wants to sell homes, their job is not to build web sites. So as long as working site is available, they don't care who builds it, you or AI. Make whatever of this you will.

kamaal··on I do not remember my life and it's fine
Im always confused about this. I think my brain has rewritten memories to a large extent.

While its ok to have fictional memories for fun, I think this is disastrous for legal reasons.

Plus I do think memory recall is strong for a lot of people. Wanting retribution for harm done long back, or even life long trauma for bad things that happen to people early life is real.

kamaal··on A manager is not your best friend
>>I've never seen or heard about anything similar.

Yeah, I mean, they don't exactly go around announcing how the whole thing is done. You often don't know who won at your cost.

kamaal··on A manager is not your best friend
Im not sure you get the mathematics of this here. You can hire anybody, anybody, any saint for that matter.

The more area a section occupies on a pie chart, the less area other sections get.

>>Apologies, but I don’t like when people outright talk nonsense about my friends, lowering them down to numbers.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiana_pi_bill

kamaal··on A manager is not your best friend
We are talking about colleagues, not friends.

Not sure if you know this, due to cost centers, companies have per team budgets. Quite literally, X gets bonuses at the expense of Y.

Im not saying people act out of malice. But the game is designed such that somebody needs to lose for the other to win. Its like a pie chart, more area a section occupies, less there is for others.

kamaal··on A manager is not your best friend
>>Counter data point, worked in a company 10 years ago, our team was so close that we would vacation together overseas.

Worst thing ever, nothing is more harmful than a enemy who appears as a friend. This is even more true at workplace, as you are competing with your colleagues for promotions, bonuses, RSUs, travel opportunities etc. Whether one likes to acknowledge this are not, you are actually competing with them.

Another big issue with this sort of this is, it creates all kinds of untold social contracts which eventually nobody abides by. You wouldn't expect your friend to scheme behind your back to have you stack ranked in the bottom 10%, get your fired. Save his own job and have himself promoted. But in nearly every layoff cycle, this is exactly what happens.

kamaal··on A manager is not your best friend
>>The best friends I’ve made at work have usually been in non-competitive departments.

Best friendships I've made at work especially with my managers, in my own teams, have happened when I have openly announced I'm not competing for their position/job. Merely making this clear has made me more friends.

People just don't like to see other people do well, even more so when people are working to take their own position.

That few shitty years I had at work early career often were due to seniors finding books at my desk, or watching me work like mad on side projects, or delivering and speaking a lot during meetings. That's akin to announcing to them they must screw you to save their own jobs. Nothing good happens from there as groups of powerful people mark you up as your enemy and have to get rid of you for their collective good.

The people who got promoted are often those who pretend to be harmlessly inert but are scheming and working behind people's back to get promoted and take top positions. Only last year, a junior I know got a manager fired and took his job, much to the shock of the manager, he eventually learned the junior had been working over an year and bypassing him, talking to managers above, convincing them he could do the job et al. The manager who got fired is struggling from months to find a new job.

Long story short, speak as little as you can, avoid showing off your skills at work, don't appear aggressive, threatening or intimidating. Act totally harmless and inert, but work with people above for your progress. Career growth rarely comes from good performance, its almost always because of interpersonal relationships.

kamaal··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
>>I’ve always worked that way. In school (or in seminars), I ask questions that may have the whole room in stitches, but I always learn the lesson.

In my experience, if a question is understood well enough, it basically directly translates into a solution. In most cases parts of questions are not well understood, or require going into detail/simplification/has a definition we don't know etc etc.

This is where being able to ask questions and getting clear answers helps. AI basically helps your do understand the problem as you probe deeper and deeper into the question itself.

Most human users would give up after answering you after a while, several would send you through a humiliating ritual and leaving you with a life long fear of asking questions. This prevents learning, as a good way of developing imagination is asking questions. There is only that much you can derive from a vanilla definition.

AI will be revolutionary for just this reason alone.

kamaal··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
>>It also ends up undermining faith in true content, which may be outlandish.

In all honesty, art in some form or the other has always been simulated to some extent. Heck, the whole idea of a story, even if in a book is something you know hasn't happened in real life, but you are willing to suspend belief for a while to be entertained. This is the essence of all entertainment. It is not real, but it makes you feel good.

Like action movies have had cgi, cartoon shows, magic shows and even actors putting on make up itself can be considered deviation from truth.

I guess your idea is that news can be manufactured and one could rig public opinion to all sorts of bad things. But again, once you are here, a good amount of public already knows this to be false enough to be wary of it. Come to think of it, a lot of news is already heavily edited to a point it doesn't represent the original story. This is just a continuation of the same.

kamaal··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
>>I'm not afraid to ask "stupid" questions -That is critical.

AI won't judge and shame you in front of the whole world, for asking stupid questions, or not RTFM'ing well enought, like Stackoverflow users do. Nor will it tell you, your questions are irrelevant.

I think this is the most killer AI feature ever.

kamaal··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
At some point trust will break down to a point, you will actually only believe things from a real human with a badge(talking to them in person).

For that matter, My email has been /dev/null for a while now, and unless I have spoken to a person over phone and expect their email, I don't even check my inbox. Facebook/Instagram account is largely used as a photo back up service, plus online directory. And Twitter is for news.

I mostly don't trust anything that comes online, unless I already have verified the other party is somebody Im familiar with and even then only through the established means of communication we both have agreed to.

I do believe reddit, quora, leet code et al, will largely be reduced /dev/null spaces very soon.

kamaal··on They used Xenon to climb Everest in days – is it the future of mountaineering?
>>Not sure if meritocracy has been on a decline, or that we're now just more aware of it due to the internet.

As an Indian, let me tell you, to accept something is wrong, and then just being fine about it, and just adjust your life to bad situations is how the fall of societies starts.

Eventually everything becomes fine and acceptable, and you learn over time to adjust yourself to everything, like every bad thing ever.

kamaal··on As a developer, my most important tools are a pen and a notebook
>>Some of the most intelligent people I've ever met in math, physics, and computer science don't even use a notebook. They use printer paper and pen. When they're done, they throw the paper away.

Donald Knuth works that way. In fact, most such people tend to do most of their thinking on paper, making small changes to the problem state, verifying if it sticks, and is going where they want it going. Rollback, make a different change to the same thing, or same change to different things. This goes on over hundreds of pages.

One of the advanced user level performers don't tend to view stationary(especially paper) as something that must be rationed or spent with limits.

kamaal··on Power Failure: The downfall of General Electric
>>I think that Welch spawned a whole bunch of "Mini-Jacks," that worked to be what they thought he wanted.

>>The management, however, was terrible, especially at the higher levels. Lots of nice suits and cufflinks, but very little smarts.

People being people, eventually corruption takes over all processes. This whole idea that one had to stack rank the bottom 20%, promote the top 20% and let the former eventually fire the middle performers depended on honesty from people running the processes.

>>The management, however, was terrible, especially at the higher levels. Lots of nice suits and cufflinks, but very little smarts.

All the best depending on mediocre people to promote smart people above them, heck even the smart people wouldn't promote people smarter people above them. What this means is the process in most companies that practiced this was fixed. Most managers promoted their lackeys, fired who ever was good(perceived as a threat to their own position), remainder was tolerated as long as they stayed inert. This now achieved the very opposite what the process was to achieve.

This should kill the company, and it often does, but most large companies have products and customers that take a while(years, to even decades) to go away. To that end, this could go on for ages until things reached their natural end.

kamaal··on Power Failure: The downfall of General Electric
People who don't come from a hardcore engineering background, often fail to understand what goes behind making good engineering deliverables.

This problem has complicated since MBA types people have taken over. Everything is a cost center, and goes into some model in a spreadsheet. The 'What If' feature gives you all kinds of fairly tale cost savings and optimisation options, as you turn the dials and knobs.

There is also a failure to understand that some amount of extra investments in people, quality and training is needed to keep the profits going. It might appear like they are not contributing to profits directly, but as it often happens eliminating them causes loss.

You are basically trying to modify a highly complicated and delicate process, optimised over years of lessons, changes and far sightedness. Trying to optimising entirely from a cost perspective leads to all kinds of counter intuitive results.

kamaal··on Trying to teach in the age of the AI homework machine
>>You’re exactly right that it’s practice.

Thinking is a incremental process, you make small changes to things, verify if they are logically consistent and work from there.

What is to practice here? If you know something is true, practicing the mechanical aspects of it is text book definition of rote learning.

This whole thing reads like the academic system thinks making new science(Math, Physics etc) is for special geniuses and the remainder has to be happy watching the whole thing like some one demonstrating a 'sleight of hand' of hand trick.

Teach people how to discover new truths. Thats the point of thinking.

kamaal··on At Amazon, some coders say their jobs have begun to resemble warehouse work
>>That just strikes me as an odd thing to say.

This is along the same lines as why I don't doubt the syntactical features to break. I assume they work. You have to accept some abstraction work, and build on top of it.

We will reach some point where we will have to assume AI is generating the correct code.

kamaal··on Watching AI drive Microsoft employees insane
Again I don't know what people mean when they say it will get more expensive. This is a wrong way of looking at the issue.

Pretty sure cars are more expensive than horse carriage, or that iPhones are/were more expensive than button phones. You can cite so many such examples. Like photocopying machines, or cameras, or wrist watches, or even things like radio, television etc.

More importantly, sometimes how you do things change. And that changes how you go about your life in a very fundamental way.

That is what internet was about when it first came out, thats what internet search, online maps, or search etc etc were.

AI will change how you go about living your life, in a very fundamental way.

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →