HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartan

4,940 karma · joined July 5, 2015

submissionscomments
kartan··on Saving Lydia
> Do I have to Ph.D in every medical science to make sure my kids get a treatment what they deserve?

When you live in a society you have duties and rights. We count on each other. Some people gets an education with help and resources of society and then there is an expectation for them to take responsibility and do their part. That is expected from everybody whatever your role, studies or background.

You are right that this social contract seems broken. That we are told that everyone is on their own and if you don't profit as much as possible from the system you are a sucker. That cheaters are right. This doesn't work on the long run. Too much cheaters in a society and it is doomed to fail.

We should take care of ourselves and others. We have rights and we should be willing to fulfill our duties. And have expectations on others to do the same.

kartan··on The Tech Industry Is Building a Vast Digital Underclass
I guess that we both agree that you need resources to create wealth. Without resources, wealth cannot be created. I guess, that we both agree that you need education, knowledge and science to use that resources in an efficient way. That technology+resources create wealth.

My argument, for which I provide some links, is that you need to redistribute that wealth so everybody profits form it for that wealth to be sustainable:

"Economic growth provides the basis for overcoming poverty and lifting living standards. But for growth to be sustained and inclusive, its benefits must reach all people."

* https://blogs.imf.org/2017/09/20/growth-that-reaches-everyon... * https://www.oecd.org/newsroom/inequality-hurts-economic-grow...

But, maybe we have different values and that is the root cause of our disagreement. I think that giving everybody enough to cover their needs is the goal of society. To remove poverty is a goal to achieve. Higher economic output is not a goal, but a means to achieve the goal of humans well being. Improving the economy is a means for humans to live better.

kartan··on The Tech Industry Is Building a Vast Digital Underclass
> Is mung beans, rice, and a shared room in a house "living" enough or does everyone need their full maximized-carbon-footprint atomized solo lifestyle in order to "live"?

That is the straw man fallacy. You moved the post from a discussion about fair salaries to one about everybody sharing the same house and eating only beans and rice.

The question is if delivery drivers should have a fair salary that allows them to have a decent life.

Do you agree that "delivery drivers" should get a fair salary that allows them to have a decent life?

> Another variety of "fair" that seems to be gaining mindshare is the idea that you deserve a "living wage" for literally any full-time job, which is a new idea unsubstantiated by economic reality.

I mean this one, that is why I said: " that allows them to have a decent life.".

> unsubstantiated by economic reality

The opposite is true. More equal societies have higher economic output. Reducing poverty reduces crime, reduces health care costs, etc. Even better makes people's lives better. So, it is a positive feedback loop.

kartan··on What If Consciousness Comes First?
If the spirit interacts with the brain, then a spirit is a phisical thing that can be measured and is in the realm of science. If the spirit does not interact with the brain, then its existence does not have any effect and it is irrelevant to understand consciousness.
kartan··on Facebook revenue beats estimates; discloses antitrust probe
> I guess all that growth must come from countries that recently got into Facebook.

I have worked for companies with big, really big, user bases. As time passes companies get way better at getting more value from each user. They have more data. They have better software to offer promotions, advertisements, etc. You may be better off with half the users but getting more money from each one of them than with more users but giving low value. Depending on where the lines in the graph cross less users and more money is possible.

kartan··on The Tech Industry Is Building a Vast Digital Underclass
> That’s a fallacy.

I agree. Not my comment. I was just quoting.

kartan··on The Tech Industry Is Building a Vast Digital Underclass
> Fresh paint on old tale.

There is a lot of true in what you say. But, part of the problem is the level of efficiency. Where you needed before a chain of managers doing the dirty job and creating inefficiencies. An algorithm does not sleep, does not care that you have kids or you are sick, does not have compassion or gets angry.

The root cause is the owner. Algorithms help, thou.

kartan··on The Tech Industry Is Building a Vast Digital Underclass
> we'll never be able to make it so that the delivery driver and the corporate executive have the same standard of living, unless that standard is consuming gruel in a formless concrete cube somewhere.

You moved the post from "delivery drivers" should get a fair salary to "everybody should have the same salary". The question is if delivery drivers should have a fair salary that allows them to have a decent life.

Do you agree that "delivery drivers" should get a fair salary?

kartan··on The Tech Industry Is Building a Vast Digital Underclass
You are describing an authentic dystopia. Technology promise was to work for humans. Now we are working for algorithms that push us to our human limits. It needs to change as it is nos sustainable in the long term. It just produces big profits in the short term. And, that is why is so difficult to stop.
kartan··on Toilets of the World
> People don't realize how much maintenance sewers need.

What can do about it? I think that education is at fault. Most people in big cities does not realize how costly and important are jobs like sewer maintenance, garbage collectors, signal maintenance, gardeners, etc.

Without all this work cities will paralyze, the population will get sick or die, transport will stop working. etc. Without that work civilization instead of flourishing with economic growth and technology it literally will crumble into ruin.

Cities work because there is an absurdly large amount of people taking care of them. If it was a private endeavor there will be advertisements about their work everywhere. But, as a public service it is almost invisible. That is a shame.

kartan··on French Minerve submarine is found after disappearing in 1968
There is a little more info in https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/a284720...

The ship used is the Seabed Constructor: https://www.swireseabed.com/assets/vessels/seabed-constructo...

And there is commercial info in Ocean Infinity official website: https://oceaninfinity.com/

kartan··on In the Defense of Spaghetti Code (2013)
Yes. Over-engineering is a thing. Also, there are problems that cannot be simplified (e.g. Implementing a Calendar class http://yourcalendricalfallacyis.com/ )

I agree with other comments that Spaghetti Code is not the right term for this. But, the original point is valid.

The other part of the point is also true. To hide implementation inside functions makes sense if the function is part of the real world domain. To do a cut/paste to extract lines of codes of a big function to make it look nicer may increased complexity as now jumping around the code is needed to read it.

kartan··on Bulgaria tax hacking: An entire nation was hit
> How could tax evasion not be correlated to the rate?

To make such a statement you need data. I can argue for the opposite to be true and an inverse relationship exists. Look for countries with very low taxes (like South Africa) and the to ones with high taxes (like Sweden). You will see that lower taxes correlate with higher evasion.

My data is not very rigorous. That is why I think that i requires further work to get to a conclusion. Can you present data that justifies your point?

kartan··on Bulgaria tax hacking: An entire nation was hit
Bulgaria underground economy was the highest of the EU27. Is it possible that low/high taxes has no correlation with tax evasion?

A good tax office, effective laws and public awareness seems more important than how high or low are taxes.

I only found data from 2012: http://jalac.kyxar.fr/ANG/ECONOIR11.html

kartan··on Many Americans who live paycheck to paycheck blame debt
> then you should not buy a car

How then they go to work? I understand that in the USA public transportation is quite lacking except for a few big cities.

kartan··on Many Americans who live paycheck to paycheck blame debt
> Some 40% of Americans would struggle to come up with $400 for an unexpected expense.

Would you say that they are in that 40%? Or is it a different case?

kartan··on A personal story about 10× development
> For instance, dev teams of 20+ where one person is the absolute backbone of the team and churning out features faster than the rest of the team put together.

I also have seen that. And, when that person leaves is another one from the group that took the role. Because you can have so many roosters in a flock.

It is so important to be able to lead as to let other lead you. Too many people, especially managers, does not understands potential. They see the result without taking into account any context.

Can be even bad. In one team, there was this guy that was more productive than the rest. He was an asshole. Everything has to be done his way, so, it was clear why he was the fastest one. Without him the team will have been faster and the product delivered earlier. But, the manager only was comparing outputs and the asshole that did not let the rest of the team work had higher output.

So, yes, there is people that are 10x. But, they are the ones that share knowledge, that put the team needs above her owns. It is that person that everybody wants to work with. And usually has little to do with personal output and more with improvements in the overall team performance.

Too many times I have worked with self-proclaimed 10x that are just making other people lives miserable and are surrounded with people that is new because his previous colleagues have left the company.

So, you are right. I just wanted to make clear what, at least for me, it means to be a 10x developer.

kartan··on Amazon Accidentally Sold $13k Camera Gear for $100 on Prime Day
> It’s kind of interesting- the asymmetry of moral expectations and entitlement.

First, there is an asymmetry in power too. Amazon can afford to double check or triple check everything if it makes economic sense.

Secondly, companies does not have morals. If you allow big corporations to change prices as they see fit because there is a "mistake". Companies will exploit that to their advantage with psychopathic precision.

You will get your package at home and then you will be informed that the price "was a mistake" and was 10% more expensive. They will print prices in adverts and then say that it was a mistake when people gets to the shop.

Companies are not human beings, as other comments already have said, to involve morality in this issue makes no sense whatsoever.

The real question is: is this an efficient way of improving the consumers well being? If this rules avoid companies of abusing price changes and labeling anything as being a "mistake" and at the same time it encourages better quality on price setting and the "punishment" is not big enough to send all companies to foreclosure. Then it seems a very good deal.

It makes economic sense.

kartan··on Why Nadal is unbeatable on clay
> where every sentence is a new paragraph?

Probably because of blog software. Word Press does this by default.

https://wordpress.org/support/article/wordpress-editor/

kartan··on Surveillance cameras debunk the bystander effect
> people "these days" don't care about each other, society is falling apart etc.

Interesting point.It was 1964. The same people that complain about the current generation.

I think that it's great that this myth of debunked. People wants to be good. Give people education and means and they will run a society smoothly.

kartan··on The Tyranny of Trendy Ideas in Academia
extremism /ɪkˈstriːmɪz(ə)m,ɛkˈstriːmɪz(ə)m/ noun the holding of extreme political or religious views; fanaticism.

Update: My point is that you are redefining what "extremism" means. e.g. The far-right is extremism. To think that you can create colonies in Mars in the next 10 years is "unorthodox".

If you redefine extremism to something that is acceptable, and most people defines far-right as extremism, you are defining the far-right as something that is acceptable. That is the danger of redefining words.

kartan··on We Need Insects More Than They Need Us
> Four billion years from now, the increase in the Earth's surface temperature will cause a runaway greenhouse effect, heating the surface enough to melt it. By that point, all life on the Earth will be extinct.

4 billion years from now they are going to need our planet colonizing technology to get out. ;)

But, until then, they will be doing even better without us.

kartan··on 81% of 'suspects' flagged by Met's police facial recognition technology innocent
> "what maximum level of crime can we accept?"

I agree with you.

Said that way seems that you are given up. I think that it can be better to say "do you prefer to catch 0.5% more criminals or to reduce 0.4% deaths by cancer". Or something like that.

People usually want 100% safety, that is not possible to achieve, and to try to get it they will give away thousands of lives that could have been saved with the time and effort invested in that impossible goal.

kartan··on Run Your Own Website
> since 1999

That is really impressive. I purchased my first domain around that year. But, I failed to keep it up to date. I have moved 4 times to different domains. And, it has been the last one that I have updated for the past 5 years or so. The rest are lost.

I really like your "Slashdotted" section. It brings back a lot of memories.

kartan··on In Japan, a growing number of car-sharing users don’t rent cars for driving
This is a problem with big cities. There are no public spaces. Even less private spaces for free.

Recently, I was in Barcelona and was surprised to see a bunch of teenagers cramped together sitting on the pavement in a shopping mall. At first, as an old person that I am, I thought that they were up to something. But, they were having fun, laughing and having a good time. The only park had no trees and few banks anyway. So, it was better to sit on the floor somewhere in the shadow that to sit on the floor under the sun.

Even more interesting was the fact that the place had a lot of empty chairs. But, those ones were for paying customers.

If it is so hard to find a place to sit with friends much more difficult is to find a place where to sit alone. Some libraries are ditching the focus on books to just offer a space to study together or alone.

If I have criticised USA cities for being designed for cars European (and Japanese also) cities are designed for businesses.

Stockholm is one of the few cities where I have seen a focus on parks and outdoor pastimes. Ironically, it is only available two or three months a year as usually is too cold to be confortably sitting outsite.

kartan··on Will Bitcoin Make a Good Investment?
> we agree cryptocurrency can be an amazing idea

Do we?

We all agree that currency can be just a pyramidal scheme.

kartan··on Will Bitcoin Make a Good Investment?
> Except for a small window around the peak

Most people bought during the peak, that's why it was a peak.

As any other pyramidal Scheme the only way to win is to be there first. Later on you are just trying to put other people into the scheme to regain some losses.

kartan··on YouTube bans content “showing users how to bypass secure computer systems”
> and there is no way in hell I'm risking that.

Yes. You need to keep a good balance in your social credit.

kartan··on American Suburbs Swell Again as a New Generation Escapes the City
> Also extremely intrusive urban planning

I agree partly.

In most European cities there is a lot of planning and regulations to follow. Barcelona Example (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eixample) is an example of 19th-century planning.

In most Europe, you can't build a tall building in a rural town, a skyscraper without the proper open space around it or a factory in a residential neighbourhood. But, those rules have been more sensible to the city needs and have had less pressure from car makers. Old towns are usually compact and easy to walk because they predate cars. Cities have very good public transportation systems as cars were too expensive for most of the population. Living in the city centre has been seen as a luxury. At least for me, "suburvio" (a suburb in Spanish) has always had a negative connotation. Nobody wanted to live in the outskirts of a city.

So, I agree that American cities are, in general, poorly designed. And public transportation is almost nonexistent. The problem is not urban planning but that the cities are designed for cars, not for humans. Carmakers had too much power for too long. Urban planning worked really well to achieve its goal: to sell more cars.

kartan··on American Suburbs Swell Again as a New Generation Escapes the City
> My old house was 900sf, perfect for 1 to 2 people

That is 80m2. I grew up in a 75m2 apartment (810sf) with my parents and two brothers.

I guess that "cramped" is a matter of perspective. :)

> Not sure about other large cities, but mine (Portland, OR) has a pretty big homeless and crime issues as of lately.

It makes me sad to hear about that. We are in the XXI century and we have good ways of helping homeless people and reduce crime. I understand that you leave to a better place, but that does not solve the problem.

> confronted in our driveway by a homeless individual, who said that he was considering suicide.

I hope that you have find a good place for you and your family but do not forget the people that you left behind. Their lives are a tragedy that can be averted.

← PreviousPage 2 of 25Next →