HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartan

4,940 karma · joined July 5, 2015

submissionscomments
kartan··on EU’s attempt at internet copyright reform is a ridiculous own goal
Actually, LA Times will be happy to collect money from anyone linking to them.

The GDPR is a law to protect user data.

Article 13 is there to automate the creation and execution of copyright claims taking over freedom of speech and self-expression.

Article 11 is there to help newspapers to monetize their digital distribution as most of them have not found a sustainable way of doing so by themselves at the cost of other companies with a digital presence.

GDPR and this new law are at two opposite sides of the spectrum.

kartan··on “It’s Easier To Ask Forgiveness Than To Get Permission”
> Ah, the developer who's 10x because their work slows down everyone else 10 times.

You are right. People that think of themselves as 10x developers are the ones that do that and will slow down everybody else.

Really productive developers help others and speed up all the company.

I have worked with some people that one can call "10x developers", even that I don't agree with the term. They were good, they were friendly and willing to help the business and their fellow developers.

And they ask for permission and share their ideas with everybody. Their product owner was also amazing and they had a great synergy. Back then I was a manager. And my job was to make sure that things did not change.

kartan··on “It’s Easier To Ask Forgiveness Than To Get Permission”
> Could it be you have some unconscious bias against the person who took that action, leading you to see them as a rogue cowboy instead of a wise leader?

The rest of the team was pissed off. A leader is followed, a rogue cowboy leaves everybody else behind and without the information that they need to do their jobs.

But I agree that it is difficult to say if it is one or the other from the outside. That is why it is so important for management to be present and to have direct communication with all the development team. "Lazy" management tends to trust whoever screams the loudest instead of expending the time to fully understand the situation and listening to everyone involved.

You are right. With just my description, it is not possible for anyone to know if it was one or the other. And in fact, it was more grey that I have described. Taking into account all the information I gathered, I still believe that it occurred as I described.

kartan··on “It’s Easier To Ask Forgiveness Than To Get Permission”
> a) Arguments don’t work because team doesn’t listen and/or doesn’t want to change because they wish to stay in their comfort zone.

It is a problem if there is no communication. To bypass all formality only hides the real problem is not solving it. It is not easy to know who is right. That is part of my job when one person is in a fight with the rest of the team my job is to listen to everybody and help to get a decision thru. I have seen all combinations, the team is right the lone ranger wrong, the lone ranger is right and the team is wrong, all are right and one path needs to be decided, all are wrong and I help them to find a different solution.

> c) Those who see a bigger picture do not care to or cannot explain it and/or keep it a secret.

Again this happens and it is a big problem that needs to be addressed. To hide it doing things rogue stile only perpetuates the problem. Sometimes is better to get everything to a halt until information is shared than to tag along for years of painful fights.

> e) Software architects

Yes. I am one. And my main problem is the arrogance of other architects, not the managers, product owners or developers in the teams. :P

kartan··on “It’s Easier To Ask Forgiveness Than To Get Permission”
I have seen this abused. A team member does whatever she thinks is best, and the rest now have to tag along because to communicate to all stakeholders that it was not a team decision and needs to be revisited is too costly.

That can be seen by some management as "getting things done". And quite often that person feels vindicated when her solution works.

But that person is not able to realize the cost of the mistrust of the team and detachment of the job nor to think about the possibility that the other solution not only have worked, but it will have been way better.

At my job, I have to arbitrate between team members and teams. I will flag anyone that decides to "ask for forgiveness instead of permission" and notify their manager. I don't like to work with people that think that they are so good that don't need to present their arguments like the rest.

So when going for forgiveness instead of permission, it is wise to think:

a) If your way is so good, you should be able to get what you want with arguments.

b) If you force everyone else to follow your way without their consent, you are not a leader you are just abusing the system.

c) That it works does not mean that was the best option.

d) That other people can also have done the same does not mean that they are worse than you, it may be that they see a bigger picture that you can't see.

It is still possible to go for it. But you need to be accountable for the consequences.

kartan··on The Koch brothers are campaigning against tax rises for public transit projects
> It seems like a bit of class warfare on the part of the Koch's.

You can get richer by increasing your wealth or by decreasing everybody else's wealth. People that think that life is a zero-sum game think that both are the same thing.

People with a growth mindset care more about wellbeing over relative richness. Sometimes the best way for me to have more is for everybody else to also have more. And others happiness and wellbeing is part of my own.

The Koch's fall in the first category.

kartan··on YouTube’s Piracy Filter Blocks MIT Courses, Blender Videos, and More
> The Article stipulates that platforms should “prevent the availability” of protected works, suggesting these ISSPs will need to adopt technology that can recognise and filter work created by someone other than the person uploading it.

But there is no requirement that at the same time protects fair use. To remove content just in case has no negative consequences.

> Article 13 is “incompatible with the guarantee of fundamental rights and freedoms and the obligation to strike a fair balance between all rights and freedoms involved”

This looks like a one-sided law. It takes into account "authors rights", you can read it as big media conglomerates financial interests, over any other consideration.

This is an example of a law that puts some companies profit over any social consideration and will impact EU socially and economically in a negative way.

kartan··on Theranos Didn't Just Harm Investors
> Unskilled investors losing a lot of money is, in fact, a very good thing for the Silicon Valley ecosystem.

This is blaming the victims. The article says that Theranos lied to investors. How can you invest in anything if lying is allowed without consequences?

> It's how bad influencers are flushed out of the system.

Justice punishing wrong behaviour is what flushes out the system. People walking away with money collected from lies and fraud does not.

kartan··on Square obtains NY State cryptocurrency license
> the need for a system of sound, programmable money remains

I understand that the original goal was to have the value of the currency to be not controlled by a central bank.

Is there any other benefit to it? What does it mean that the currency needs to be "programmable" in this context?

kartan··on The “Doorway Effect” – forgetting why you entered a room
I lived in a one-room (plus bathroom) apartment for half a year. It was an awful experience. The apartment was very well designed with nice furniture and very very centric. But it felt claustrophobic.

I have lived since then in similar apartments, equally small, but with at least 2 rooms (living room and bedroom). It feels so much better.

At first, one-room looks like is going to be better. There is more space as you don't have inner walls. But when you play games, watch tv, cook and sleep all in the same room it feels that there is something wrong.

Getting up in the morning, leaving the bedroom and going to the living room makes a big difference. The context-switching is welcome. It is also easier when going to sleep.

kartan··on Lemming Suicide Myth: Disney Film Faked Bogus Behavior
This is not my personal experience.

Lemmings are fearless creatures that will scream to any animal, including humans, that cross their path.

I have seen a Lemmings confronting a crow. The crow sends the lemmings flying on three different occasions until it took the lemming dead body and left flying. The lemmings never tried to run or hide, it just was screaming at the crow until its very last moments.

So I can see that "mass suicide" is a myth. But it has some true on it looking at the lemmings' behaviour.

kartan··on N.Y. Set to Criminalize Much “Verbal” “Abuse” of Under-18-Year-Olds Online
> "knowingly engage[] in a repeated course of cyberbullying of a minor."

How does it work for normal bullying? Why do we need a special law for "when things happen online"?

It seems that the online world needs separate laws from the non-digital one. This is nonsense.

Cyberbullying is just bullying on the internet. Do we have laws for phone-bullying, letter-bullying...?

Discriminations, bullying and other forms of abuse are a social problem. We need to solve the problem, not just try to hide it out of the public view that is the Internet.

kartan··on I’m Nat Friedman, Future CEO of GitHub. AMA
Nat is being really smart here. It should not backfire unless he acts pedantic or insults Redditors intelligence. I think that both are unlikely.

Maybe Nat is trying to counteract any PR damage to GitHub, or maybe he just wants to see how much can skyrocket his account's karma. If I was in his situation I will be happy doing it for both reasons.

kartan··on Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in wealth (2016)
> If not, I don't see what use that number could be.

There is still value in the comparison. Products like mobile phones are going to have similar prices around the globe. Also, it affects the capability to travel.

With my European salary, I can travel anywhere in the world. Norway is more expensive than Turkey, but I can travel to both.

We had a team member for a secondment that came from a country with lower salaries. Our company had a policy where you pay first and then you get refunded. He needed to get all expenses pre-paid because of his full salary not being enough to pay for the expenses.

If you can buy a house in your country for 2,000 dollars. I can also buy a house in your country at that price. Probably I can buy a few of them once I have my basic needs covered in my own country.

So, there are more interesting data points than purchasing power in dollars. But it is relevant when we talk about wealth distribution.

kartan··on Google quits selling tablets
> I think a more plausible reason for sales numbers falling is that people don't need or want tablets as much as they thought they did

That probably is part of the explanation. For me, I bought a "New iPad" on 2012. Some months ago I bought a new model, as iOS is not updated anymore. That is the main reason to upgrade and this is another topic for discussion. It has been six years between tablets. And the need for an upgrade is slightly artificial.

A 6-year-old tablet will still be able to run the latest version of Chrome and I can play casual 2D games without a problem. If Apple has not stopped supporting it I will continue using it.

When I was a teenager, I was changing computers every two years and a half. If you were a gamer it was a must do. For office applications, browsing the internet and playing casual games the live of computers is getting longer. Even my gaming computing is getting old, it supports VR and an extra wide 4K screen without a problem.

kartan··on The birthrate in the U.S. is the lowest it’s been in 30 years
> You could structure social security as a tax on capital, but that isn't how it currently works.

Yes. 100% true. I just mean that it can be changed. It is not an economic constraint, but it is the current situation.

kartan··on The birthrate in the U.S. is the lowest it’s been in 30 years
> One man owning 10 robots will pay less SS than 10 workers.

That can be changed. The difficulty is more related to corruption and lobbying than any economical constrain.

But, you are right. If nothing changes on how taxes are collected, or if it continues changing against social wellfare then it is a problem.

kartan··on The birthrate in the U.S. is the lowest it’s been in 30 years
> There is a theory that the root cause of these problems is the continued dismantling of traditional gender roles.

Except that Japan has kept traditional gender roles, where the woman leaves her job when marries, and they have one of the lower fertility rates in the world.

At the same time, Sweden with very strong gender equality has a higher fertility rate than other European countries. Even that it is still low compared with historical hights.

kartan··on The birthrate in the U.S. is the lowest it’s been in 30 years
But nowadays people can choose if they want to have children. In the past, that was not so easy, at least if you wanted to have sex.

Once people can choose to not children, factors like the economy affect population growth.

kartan··on The birthrate in the U.S. is the lowest it’s been in 30 years
> (Not saying Social Security is bad in concept, but it only works in times of sharp population growth, and even then, banking on the youth to carry you just because seems squicky to many ).

Social Security works with economic growth. It doesn't matter if you get 10 babies or 10 robots. Automation makes possible to keep proper living standards without exponential population growth.

Social Security, as other services like education, stops working because it is not shared.

Actually, with enough automation, it is easier to satisfy a smaller population.

There are 3.5 million professional truck drivers in the United States. Self-driving trucks mean that you need 3.5 million fewer babies to carry out that task. Just 3 million if you actually need 500,000 people to maintain the software.

So, I agree with you that in the past Social Security was depending on population growth. That has been changing fast for the past 50 years. There is no economical reason to not have Social Security in the future.

kartan··on Nebulet: A microkernel that runs WebAssembly in Ring 0
Java virtual machine could have had better integration into OSs and browsers, but it's licensing model made it impossible. I worked with Applets on the browser and had a lot of potential, but probably it was too soon for them as computers where slower and Java was not so will optimized back then.

WebAssembly doesn't has this history and it can be used in ways that Java has been discarded for historical reasons.

kartan··on Nebulet: A microkernel that runs WebAssembly in Ring 0
JavaScript was running in the browser until Ryan Dahl decided to create Node.js. Nowadays it is a big platform, and it can run also WebAssembly.

This is just another step in that direction where is the OS the one running that code.

Does it have problems? Yes. Adding more complexity to the kernel will open new attack vectors for breaking its security. But that is true for any added layer, even in the hardware which complexity has brought Meltdown and Spectre. Running JavaScript in your kernel is a lot riskier than running it in your app.

The good news is that WebAssembly is created with sandboxing in mind. I hope they have learned some lessons (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Java_security).

kartan··on Nebulet: A microkernel that runs WebAssembly in Ring 0
This is what the Java Virtual Machine could have been but never was. Most applications are so lightweight for today's computer capabilities that running them over a virtualization layer is not a problem at all. As a developer I want my applications to run everywhere without having to take into account different OSs, architectures, etc.

You still will have native applications for a lot of different situations where performance is more critical and paying the higher cost of creating, testing and distributing for different OSs. That is a skill that should never die, like creating the hardware itself.

HTML5 is a good attempt to this, but it has problems with not-well-defined behaviours and the fact that not all applications, e.g. games, fit the hypertext approach.

kartan··on Facebook Tools Are Used to Screen Out Older Job Seekers, Lawsuit Claims
> So Facebook's ad algorithm's are going to target younger people because it's more cost effective

Because there is a technical explanation doesn't means that it is not discrimination. Actually discrimination had a lot to do about getting an individual differently because he/she is part of a group. We didn't baked a law, the machine did. It is not a good defense in a trial, or at least I hope it is not.

A good read on this topic http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/05/qa-should-artificial-...

kartan··on How Britain came within hours of the 'breakdown of law and order' in 2008
Banks needed to be bailed out, bankers didn't.

I don't know how it was in the UK, but in Spain bankers where bailed out. Citizens paid the excess of bankers. Taxes where redirected from health care, education, and other services toward banking. 10 years later bankers got everything back. Banks were bailed out and their owners where not accountable of anything. Just one learning for them, there is no risk when taxpayers have your back. Next time is going to be even worse.

In my opinion bankers should have to head lost their money. Banks should have been bailed out to continue offer services and to keep safe accounts.

How was done in other countries?

kartan··on Toshiba’s loss of star engineer tells tale of company's decline
> [...] come up with all kinds of BS to patent [...]

I guess that that is the point. I worked for a similar company. They were not interested in groundbreaking one-of-a-kind patent. They were looking for something to use as a countermeasure if another company in the same sector sues them.

A new chemical process, a new antibiotic, or something of that scale can be used to create a new successful product, save lives, etc. Patents were designed to make sure that companies could profit from them, but that the knowledge was not lost just because they keep it secret.

In software development, I have seen a lot of "method to send content to a remote storage using gesture-based commands" (this one is made up). When they just mean that a developer implemented a drag & drop touch functionality for the phone that sends a file to a server. A necessary implementation, but hardly an invention as any developer will come with a similar solution in minutes if presented with the problem.

kartan··on Apple rejects Valve’s Steam Link game streaming app over ‘business conflicts’
Antitrust laws may affect monopolies and oligopolies. oligopoly: a state of limited competition, in which a market is shared by a small number of producers or sellers.
kartan··on GDPR: US news sites unavailable to EU users over data protection rules
Business don't comply with regulations because it is easy, but because it's needed to do business.

If a service didn't had a big user base in Europe, most countries don't speak English, it may be cheaper to remove the service.

The New York Times or The New Yorker that even have physical copies available in Europe work as usual.

I work in a gambling company and this is our day to day business. To enter a new market means to follow a new set of regulations. To do the adaptation or not is an strategic decision based in complexity, expected revenue and other factors. GDPR is just another regulation to add to the long list related to tax evasion, responsible gambling, fair play, etc.

kartan··on Microsoft’s commitment to GDPR, privacy and customers’ control of their own data
Yes. I got my configuration reset and needed to set up some features again.

This is an example of what you get on startup, and cannot be skipped: https://twitter.com/baekdal/status/996391978957987845

kartan··on Barcelona is leading the fightback against smart city surveillance
http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/stats/Crime/Violent...

Position ... Murder rate per million

74 Romania 19.6 2009

102 Spain 8.69 2009

Your numbers are not in contradiction with my reasoning. More pretty thief is more crime, but it is less violent crime.

← PreviousPage 12 of 25Next →