HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartan

4,940 karma · joined July 5, 2015

submissionscomments
kartan··on Barcelona is leading the fightback against smart city surveillance
> they simply don't get punished, except with a small fine, so they keep doing it. It's disgraceful.

Violent thieves (robbers) get punished. Non-violent theft is treated more lightly unless is done on a big scale. This gives criminals a high incentive to not be violent.

I have heard that the theory is that if you hard punish any thief, then thieves are going to be more violent to not get caught. If you focus the police force on violent crime, then violent crime goes down.

Most criminals know that if they give themselves in when caught, they will get a more favourable sentence that if they resist.

The goal is to keep people safe first, then property. To punish criminals is a means to that goal, but just that. I think that in the USA there is a moral component where punishing criminals is a moral imperative, even if this causes worse crime or if people get wrongly punished. Or, at least, that is what I interpret from the news.

kartan··on GDPR: Don't Panic
> and also to be curious about why they were not hired. A GDPR button lets them indulge their curiousity and start digging in to interview notes etc.

If your company can not show the candidates why they were not hired, you are doing a very bad job.

Are you discriminating against protected classes?

Are you rude or offensive in your comments?

Then, stop doing it. That will be a very good side-effect of this situation. Public scrutiny works. If a company needs to make public their interview notes, that notes are going to improve quality and abide to law.

> how strong any company will experience their firehose of GDPR requests to be

If you are big enough to have a big influx of GDPR, you need to automate it.

> how easy it is for them to make requests

It needs to be easy. The goal is not to let your company shield behind "sorry it is too complicated to give you the information". You need to give people easy access to their own data.

> wildcard factors

How is this difference of a Denial of service attack on the technical side? On the legal part, there are lawsuits that are going to be more effective than GDPR that starts with recommendations for improvement.

> The candidate gets back a formatted dump by email of all sorts of recruitment data, including interview notes, etc. There are obvious ways to monetise a service like this, hence incentive for someone to do it.

You only get the data about YOUR own interview. You can not hoard data this way. It works the other way around. The data protection is protecting you from the company monetizing this information without your consent. Companies are the ones hoarding YOUR personal data and creating a business around it without YOUR consent.

Your concerns are the main reason GDPR was created.

kartan··on What if JavaScript wins?
> manually reviewing WASM

You should not write code in WASM.

You should not review WASM.

In the same way that most Java developers don't have a clue how bytecode works in the JVM.

kartan··on What if JavaScript wins?
The missing point is that other languages have bigger/more specialized ecosystems.

For the networking effect to exist, your network doesn't needs to be just big. But it needs to be bigger than the rest. That's why people don't leave Facebook.

Java, C#, C++, Python have big ecosystems with specialized libraries for enterprise applications, performance, data analytics, etc.

If any, Javascript is already decreasing its influence in the web. Unity3D works with C# and it is removing support for its own version of Javascript. Or your choice may be Unreal Engine and C++. Or you can use Emscripten with C++ to build your own solution.

JavaScript is a language with a lot of problems. The final blow is going to be WebAssembly, as it will open direct web development to all other languages.

JavaScript will stay with us for long. But I don't think that is reaching its peak right now.

kartan··on Disney, please sell the rights to Monkey Island back to its creator Ron Gilbert
> that Disney is increasingly having in the children entertainment business.

This is one of the evils of Copyright as it actually exists. Companies own culture. They own every story and character you grew up until after the day you will be dead.

Add to that the lax anti-monopoly rules and you end with empires like Disney.

Facebook or Disney are cultural trends that are impossible to ignore for an individual that wants to be a normal part of society.

I am happy that Alice in Wonderland, Jack and the Beanstalk, Roman culture, Egyptian culture, ... are free to use.

kartan··on On Cumulative Advantage and How to Think About Luck
> Yes, that's the problem with Monopoly

It is the problem of it "as a game", but it was the original goal design. It is a lesson on how capital can accumulate and leave people without options.

Monopoly is derived from The Landlord's Game, which was created by Elizabeth Magie in the United States in 1903 as a way to demonstrate that an economy which rewards wealth creation is better than one in which monopolists work under few constraints[1] and to promote the economic theories of Henry George and in particular his ideas about taxation. (From Wikipedia)

kartan··on FizzBuzz Enterprise Edition
> What if we need to scale this to infinite numbers for millions of clients?

I worked for a company where an internal tool for, at the moment, a dozen users was designed to be more scalable than the actual product. The product was used, without major problems, by hundreds of millions of users. So we had a team of 14 people to build something that previously was done by one guy in an already maintainable way.

The server was also divided into several components to mimic a micro-service architecture. Even that no one else was using any of the services and it made deployment cumbersome.

To cut a long story short, the company has a-lot-of-money to throw at problems. So waste is not a big deal. I moved on, as it was boring to work that way.

Many backend developers feel proud of their complex architecture. Simplicity is seen as "not being professional".

For the client side of that app, there was just one guy. He was also acting as scrum master because he had spare time.

kartan··on Google show signs of reconsidering auto mute after developer critique
The Issue report is not very well done.

> Autoplay restrictions on the web have long been inconsistent and served only to impede legitimate use cases.

This is judgmental, and it is not backed up with any data. Has it really "served only" to impede the legitimate uses?

> I've described this in detail in the following blog

Blog promotion.

> What is the expected behavior? Allow audio playback on page load without any user interaction.

Definitively this is not the expected behavior. Chromium team has defined that no audio will be allowed until there is user interaction.

> Abusive content will just blare out audio at the first opportunity.

Yes. This is a red queen race. But doesn't means that it is not worth pursuing.

I think that the point is valid. But the premise of the report, it is not. With the goal of minimizing sound SPAM in the web, Chromium has imposed some drastic measures that require changes in the interfaces of a large unknown amount of Javascript code.

> "These restrictions require special coding to handle them. Instead, the browser could simply allow all playback attempts to succeed, but mute the master audio output. Then the browser can automatically unmute the master audio output the first time the user touches the screen (or whenever else it deems the user is OK with audio)."

The proposed solution is quite good. Let the browser show a button to enable sound like they did with pop-ups. So all the affected companies and individuals don't need to repeat the checks all over the internet, to create a unified experience and to keep legacy games and applications that have no chance of being updated.

But as another post says, there is a lot of corner cases. I can imagine a blind user wanting to have sound without having to read some text.

The company I work for was affected by this change. And there was a lot of problems in production. To fix it, people had to work the weekend. I know that should not be like that, that we need to improve beta browser testing, and such. But sometimes the realities of companies make this kind of behavioral changes difficult.

I hope that Chromium finds a good way of keeping ads muted, while not breaking the Internet.

kartan··on Buffett bashes Bitcoin as nonproductive, thriving on mystique
> "They are the fuel that powers a new form of technology infrastructure that is being built on top of the foundational internet protocols."

I can't get my head around this sentence.

> Bitcoin and Zcash are stores of value that allow users to participate in this decentralized application space without the need for fiat currencies.

That is exactly what collectibles are. Art has been used in this way for a long time.

https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/jonathanjonesblog/2...

> Crypto-assets produce decentralized infrastructure.

There is pro and cons on decentralized currencies. (https://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21721354-contemporar...) But is nothing new, nor nothing that needs cryptocurrencies.

Cryptocurrencies are an interesting experiment. Its intrinsic value is zero. It can be used, like other collectibles to transfer wealth. How it works when people lose confidence in them is to be seen. It is usually ugly, even for currencies backed by countries (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperinflation).

Tulips where at least beautiful.

kartan··on Amazon Launches Own Pet Product Brand, Wag
> Also, why is Amazon launching this for just dogs? My cats are offended that they were left out!

They have the data of what is what people buys. They have that info for all kind of products. If it for dogs, it makes sense that it may be the best option.

kartan··on Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China
> I used to manage plenty diverse global team of engineers

To have Chinese engineers in China, Brazilian in Brazil and Mexicans in Mexico is NOT diversity. That is the contrary of diversity. That is to have homogeneous teams.

I have worked for companies in Stockholm that have people from India, Canada, Australia, Sweden, Spain, Ukraine, Poland, ... working together in the same office. That is diversity. All of them were had the same range of salaries and expectations. Of course, it was not fairytale perfect. But it was quite good.

Externalizing costs to a low-cost country has nothing to do with diversity, as I understand it.

kartan··on The life cycle of HIV in 3D [video]
When I see the animations I can't stop thinking about a Turing machine. How it works in a similar fashion, copying symbols to keep track of the program while generating the result in the process.

It will be nice to know if you can build a Turing complete machine using DNA and the cellular mechanisms. https://www.quora.com/Is-DNA-a-Turing-machine

kartan··on Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China
> sure they can work the young guys harder,

If you are NOT a good manager, that is all that you care about.

Did you fail to plan the rest release? Developers will do extra hours.

Did you miss understood the requirements? Developers will fix it with extra hours.

Did you decide to use the wrong technology for the project? Developers will work extra hours.

A company that hires only people that does what is told and stays longer hours have incompetent management.

> I wonder if it’s a good for efficiency.

Companies that value diversity (age, gender, nationality, etc.) are the ones looking for that high-quality output that makes products work in the long term.

Sweden is as successful as China when it comes to software, even that there are orders of magnitude of the difference of population. The main reason is the respect for family and employees. Even that Sweden also is far from perfect.

kartan··on StreetLend.com shuts down, citing GDPR regulations
> Small tech owners can't fight such litigations.

Yes. This I think is a downside of the law. Some small owners are going to have a more difficult time.

But this is true for any regulation like food safety regulations, construction regulations, etc. They hurt more a small restaurant than a big chain. But in the end, these regulations are there to protect the customers. Small restaurants have closed and will continue closing for not following food safety regulations. But what is the alternative? Is business creation the final goal of our society? Or there are things more important?

In summary, small businesses are going to have to extend their insurances to also cover risks related to GDPR. But it's the price to pay for having safer data.

kartan··on StreetLend.com shuts down, citing GDPR regulations
If you are a bank and a client asks you to delete their data. The bank will still keep it for the tax agencies.

If a tribunal gets asked to delete the personal data of the accused, they will keep the data.

There is a principle of public interest and public obligations to keep data.

What part do you think that is a disaster?

kartan··on Joseph Stiglitz Says American Inequality Didn’t Just Happen
You didn't took into account that rich people can use more of their income for investments, to leverage and to spend more time to use marked fluctuations in their favor.

Your example looks correct. But I don't see how is the common case. Middle class investors usually don't have more percentage in the market that the 0.1%. Most middle class main investment is the home they live in.

kartan··on PrivacyGuide: Towards an Implementation of EU GDPR on Privacy Policy Evaluation
Internet exists in the physical world. You can use extradition to put CEOs in jail. You can use commerce treates to enforce USA to make them comply. You can ban their IPs. You can make Apple, Google, or whatever the platform that allows this to pay.

Internet is part of the real work, and the rule of law still applies there. Even when there is a lot of tech start ups that think the contrary.

Google pulled out of the Chinese market, while Apple complies with Chinese law.

kartan··on Theology majors marry each other a lot, but business majors don’t
> Theology majors may represent a greater proportion of believers in pre-marital sexual abstinance than do business majors

Or maybe Theology majors have a higher pregnancy rate and "need" to marry more often. ;)

Any theory is as good as any other without more data or a way to test it.

kartan··on Facebook to change user terms, limiting effect of EU privacy law
> I wonder if I could live with myself if this was my job.

You are in the company, you have a job to do, everybody else is doing it. Other people share your concerns, but in the end, you have a feature to deliver and you don't want to fail your team. Some people is really concerned, they try to change things, they quit, they are tired of the pressure of going against the managers and making it more difficult for their own teams. Peer pressure, management pressure, etc. is an important factor. I don't think that the people that do this things get paid better than anyone else.

I have been in too many situations where your team is in the "hamster wheel" and is just doing without thinking. Fast-growing companies have the incentive to run forward, quite often without so much direction.

It is easier to not join a job that you don't want, that to not do it once you are already in. So, think before joining if that is what you want to do. Once in, you will see that they are not evil people, that they are trying the best to do their jobs. And that to change things is hard, even when is in the company best interest, so much harder when the company will lose revenue.

kartan··on What Data Does Facebook Collect When I’m Not Using Facebook, and Why?
> The simple (and inevitable) solution is to break up Facebook.

There was a time when anti monopoly laws were taken seriously. That you are the number one social network should not be used to also become a big player on advertising, selling items, casual games, etc.

Letting companies leverage on a monopoly to gain other markets is dangerous for the economy.

kartan··on What Data Does Facebook Collect When I’m Not Using Facebook, and Why?
> at least not until now.

They have it to finish before the GDPR enforcement date (25 May 2018) - at which time those organizations in non-compliance may face heavy fines.

So, all companies big and small need to have a good data governance that allows to delete data on demand. And, better than that, stop collecting any data that they don’t have been authorized to get.

https://www.eugdpr.org

kartan··on Thinning in brain regions important for memory linked to sedentary habits
"The researchers next hope to follow a group of people for a longer duration to determine if sitting causes the thinning and what role gender, race, and weight might play in brain health related to sitting."

This is just a preliminary study. It´s too soon to get any conclusions. But, it´s a good starting point for a hypothesis. I will like to see the results of the final study, even that is going to take a long time.

I have seen many times links between sedentary life and illness. But this one looks promising as tries to find a mechanism on why this happens at the brain level that may affect cognition.

And yes, before doing a more expensive study, they asked 35 people for a preliminary study. You don´t spend a lot of money to try to prove something without first trying to disprove it on the cheap. Translation for developers: before spending a lot of time to test something you first do a smoke test. If it passes you invest the time to test it fully. Otherwise, you go back to writing code.

kartan··on A $76,000 Monthly Pension: Why States and Cities Are Short on Cash
> Without actually showing some statistics on the pension payments and how the overall budget breaks down, I can't help but feel manipulated.

The article links the lack of public services to high pensions. It´s painted as if there were no other options but to cut on pensions.

"In the meantime, mounting pension costs mean that a generation of schoolchildren is growing up in the area with no theater program, no orchestra, no wood shop and minimal sports, chorus and art."

Because pensions are the only reason. Maybe increased inequality, the lack of taxing of the top 1%, money wasted on lobbying, are also causes. But we are not offered any data.

kartan··on Duolingo Suddenly Has Over Twice as Much Language Learning Material
> I heard Portuguese from South America and from Portugal are different - maybe that could be a reason?

I came here to say the same thing. Spanish from one country is "wrong" in another one. A lot of people doesn´t understand that it´s just not your flavor of the language. It´s almost the same that If I, that speak Spanish, commented how wrong is Portuguese because is similar to Spanish but not the same.

Maybe the mistake is to announce the course as Portuguese instead of, for example, "Brazilian Portuguese".

kartan··on Sex workers fear violence as US cracks down on online ads: 'Girls will die'
> "my body, my choice" "consenting adults" -- all that goes out the window when it's sex for cash? it makes no sense.

This is true, only if individuals have a good education, job opportunities, a broad enough safety net, etc.

Otherwise, you are just pushing abused women or women with no resources to submit to sexual servitude.

When you have a high correlation between prostitution and poverty, you are just realizing that that choice was never there.

A good approach is to punish clients instead of prostitutes. This way you help to shift power balance and protect prostitutes that denounce abuse.

There is no freedom without a possibility of choice.

kartan··on Microplastics found in 93% of bottled water tested in global study
> Don't buy plastic disposable water bottles if you live in a developed nation

I´m playing with semantics here. But some parts of USA hardly count as developed states. As a country, the USA is overachieving in a lot of measures, but individual states found themselves at the same level than developing nations.

It´s difficult to apply the same rule to 10,000,000km2 of territory and 325 Million people.

kartan··on America should borrow from Europe’s data-privacy law
> Given the expense and difficulties of complying with these rules and enforcing them

To know what data do you have and to able to manage it is not difficult nor expensive. It is a short-term cost for long-term benefits. The fact that most companies don´t have this in place shows how bad data architecture and governance is around.

> but if surveillance is cheap enough, how do you make sure that no one is amassing reams of private information?

Laws don´t suffice, but there are mechanisms to enforce laws. Whistleblowers protection, in-premise inspections, public claims, etc.

That is hard to assure food safety, doesn´t means that you give up. Time to time you find really bad transgressions, but it was worst before this laws.

> This information wouldn't be available only to the powerful or well-connected, it should be available to everyone.

The problem is the asymmetry of usefulness. For me, to know that you went two days ago to the supermarket and that you have a post about privacy is useless. For a marketing company may provide high value.

There is the risk that the powerful will become more powerful having data that they can use to increase their riches. While the poor will continue as poor as they can´t use the data for anything useful.

> but we do need to prioritize what aspects of our lives should remain the most private.

This is true, thou. To have public salaries, for example, may help employees to have as much information as companies already have. To give access to everyone to some data, can help to improve society. The difference is that I will prefer it the other way around. We protect our data and decide what to show, instead to make everything public and fix what breaks. So, I´m not so far away from your view. But I see it from another perspective.

kartan··on Hubble finds first galaxy in the local universe without dark matter
> a bunch of off-the-shelf Canon telephoto lenses stuck together on a metal frame

That's an interesting remark. It's hard to beat mass production. As number produced skyrocket to the millions, it's difficult that a custom device has the resources that a mass marketed device has.

That's why millionaires have the same phone that you, the military use Xbox 360 controllers in their submarine's periscopes and COTS supercomputers are common.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beowulf_cluster

https://www.quora.com/What-smartphone-do-tech-billionaires-u...

"US Navy submarines are getting Xbox 360 controllers to control their periscopes" https://www.theverge.com/2017/9/19/16333376/us-navy-military...

kartan··on Is the social media bubble about to burst?
> Cynically, or conspiratorially, I think everyone is making a huge deal about this because it's manipulation that's not happening through the officially-controlled and sanctioned channels.

Cynically, it is cynism to devaluate all democratic values because democracies are not perfect. You say, and I agree, that democracies are not perfect because there are groups of interest that manipulate the results. Your conclusion is that we should stop caring and we should accept any level of manipulation, as it is impossible to reach zero manipulation. With that same logic, we should allow any crime as it is proven that we cannot stop all of them.

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/tools/lp/Bo/LogicalFalla...

kartan··on Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secret, emails reveal
> but a little top-down pressure can go a long way

"The legal and philosophic aspects of obedience are of enormous importance, but they say very little about how most people behave in concrete situations. I set up a simple experiment at Yale University to test how much pain an ordinary citizen would inflict on another person simply because he was ordered to by an experimental scientist. Stark authority was pitted against the subjects' [participants'] strongest moral imperatives against hurting others, and, with the subjects' [participants'] ears ringing with the screams of the victims, authority won more often than not. The extreme willingness of adults to go to almost any lengths on the command of an authority constitutes the chief finding of the study and the fact most urgently demanding explanation."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment

← PreviousPage 13 of 25Next →