HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartan

4,940 karma · joined July 5, 2015

submissionscomments
kartan··on City of Barcelona moving away from proprietary software
Thanks for the link.

"Those supporting the move to Microsoft Office say staff using LibreOffice find it difficult to swap documents with external organizations, due to incompatibilities with Microsoft Office"

This happens all around the industry. Once you are locked in there is no easy way to change. This renders the capitalist concept of competition obsolete. Everything becomes a monopoly. Intel, Nvidia, Facebook, Microsoft, Google... they amount of 90% of the market on their products.

What was 20 years ago a dynamic fast changing industry, that feared anti-monopoly actions from the goverment, has become a short list of big companies with tight ties with politicians.

Such lack of diversity opens the risk that a vulnerability is going to send all our IT into chaos, as Intel issues have showed up. It also hampers innovation and contributes to a world with less opportunities for new entrepreneurs, that are more focused in created something to sell to a big company than a long term viable business.

So Munich decision is part of the problem, but just an small one. I hope that it works better for Barcelona.

kartan··on What It Felt Like in Hawaii When Warning of an In-Bound Missile Arrived
> The only thing we know is that we won’t ever receive the truth.

How do you know? If you never get the true.

> Can you imagine how much worse it would be if the story were “US anti-missile defense destroys weapon headed for Hawaii”?

For the Trump administration? It will have been a blessing. Forget about porn stars, Russia, tax reform for the rich, ... just talk about war.

kartan··on The Future of JavaScript Will Be Less JavaScript
> Libraries, too. Are we going to find ourselves writing our own custom dropdowns and datepickers in C++?

You are talking about C++. If a library exists, already exists an implementation for it in C++. Comparing Elm with C++ doesn't makes so much sense.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_platform-independent_G...

kartan··on The Future of JavaScript Will Be Less JavaScript
For me the main point is WebAssembly. Javascript was the only option for the web (As the article notices you can compile/transpile to Javascript but this was adding more complexity for less gain). With more options developers will use languages that better adapt their taste and needs. C++ can be highly optimized when creating WebAssembly code, C# and Java offer flexibility, Python and Groovy are easier to star to use, etc.

Javascript was used beyond it's own merits as a language. It was the only feasible door to pluguinless development in the web. WebAssembly will allow people to choose. And even that a lot of developer will still have Javascript as a first option, others will not, and the web development environment is going to deeply change.

kartan··on Student Loan Debt Is Now as Big as the U.S. Junk Bond Market
> People who are properly motivated and who have what it takes should be able to go to college, but it needs to cost something... just not as much as it does now.

In Spain there is a limited number of open position in different studies. You get an test and people is sorted by their grades. The people with higher grades get to the college they choose. It is not perfect as people in better neighborhoods get better education and can get more easily to college. But at least, it is closer to a meritocracy and costs less money.

> as an excuse to take a 4-year vacation

If you don't pass a minimum of credits the first year, you get kicked out. A lot of people doesn't pass this phase.

There is ways of solving the problems, but you need a government with willingness to do it.

kartan··on Write tests. Not too many. Mostly integration
So much people in this thread is talking about different domains and are not able to see that they need different rules.

It is not the same creating a library that is going to be used to launch a multi-billion rocket to Mars than developing a mostly graphical mobile app where requirements are changing daily as you A/B test your way into better business value.

The article has really good points and the reasons why they work. Apply them wisely. Take the right decision for your project. Don't be dogmatic.

kartan··on Write tests. Not too many. Mostly integration
> What in the. serious. fuck. Of course tests test implementation details. Because _implementation details_ are where the goddamn bugs are.

Testing is about testing inputs and outputs, not implementations details. Bad testing checks if you called this function or if you accessed this data. Good test checks that for a given input you get the expected output.

> Please don't follow the advice of this. It's total crap.

The general tone of your comment is non-constructive, lacks accuracy and appeals more to your status as "working in V8" than to real reasoning. It is a shame that it is so high in this thread. :(

You may have some good points, but just by reading your comment I can't get them.

kartan··on Paw – macOS HTTP client for testing and describing APIs
Maybe I'm too old school. But JMeter is just amazing at this job: http://jmeter.apache.org/

But I guess that it is as useful and complete, as it is ugly. If you don't care for the eye candy, this is the tool to use.

kartan··on How Los Angeles Banned Some of Its Most Popular Building Types
> The article also touched on the various housing ordinances that were racially charged, and were precisely implemented so that only PoC could not afford to move out of their designated neighborhoods.

This is something that is very interesting for me. When I post in USA forums how good are housing ordinances, that keep public spaces, protect beaches and make life a lot better for Spanish citizens. And how bad is that it took so long to implement, as a big chunk of the Spanish coast was destroyed anyway. I get a lot of answers vilifying housing ordinances. Nowadays, I understand why. It is a completely different history depending on where you live.

Regulations and market self-regulation can be good and bad. This article does an amazing job giving background to the current situation of LA and by extension some other USA's big cities.

kartan··on Tech workers worry about age discrimination at age 40: Study
For an informed answer you can see: "Uncle" Bob Martin - "The Future of Programming" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ecIWPzGEbFc

Please, see the video. It is an awesome informative and it will give you a lot of insight on our current situation. It is not about startups, but about the maturity of the industry itself.

kartan··on New law bans California employers from asking applicants their prior salary
> First, because you might think the feedback is not justified.

That is a clear signal that there is a misalignment between my expectations and company expectations. It is important to clarify the point. And to see how it can be resolved so I can offer to the company what it's expected from me.

> Your manager will tell you that other person is better than you according to some metric and you are very likely to disagree.

Maybe it is because "Sweden". But I have had really interesting discussions with my direct reports about this topic when I was a manager. And it was my job to explain what they could improve and to do it in a way that they will understand. You are right that I didn't always manage at the first attempt. But, usually, I was at fault for not giving clear enough metrics.

That's why transparency can improve a company so much. It forces management to be more data-driven and to have better metrics. When a company doesn't know how to set salaries they need to improve.

> But assuming the feedback is warranted and you are mature enough to take it as a positive criticism that you're going to work on.

Do you hire people knowing that they are not able to react positively to feedback? That's a mistake. A non-blaming feedback culture will help the company and employees to improve drastically their skills and output.

> You will then probably expect to get that raise that evens out your salary with that other person, but what if you never do? Again anguish, resentment, etc...

Of course, I will expect to get the same salary if I improve to the point that I'm seen as someone as good as my colleague. Isn't that fair? Isn't that the correct point where the company pays for what it gets, and I get paid for my productivity? What is the reason to not get a salary accordingly to my seniority, expertise and work output?

> There's really hardly any chance anything positive comes out of this kind of transparency.

If the company wants to underpay people and lie to get away with it. It may be seen bad by the company. But it will still be a good thing, because it will force it to improve.

kartan··on New law bans California employers from asking applicants their prior salary
> As someone running a large organization, this is also a logistical nightmare since I usually have very good reasons to compensate X more than Y even if Y might think they should be paid the same amount.

That's the key. I want to know what reasons. It is the best possible feedback for me. If you want to earn X more, you need to do this and that like this colleague does.

It will force management to have better salary policies. I have seen people getting offered almost doubling their salaries when they say that they are leaving. Just because they were badly underpaid to begin with.

Openness forces for better justifications of your actions.

> Besides, even as a hiring manager, I really think it's none of my business how much that previous employer valued this person. What matters is here and now. I just ask people how much they want then I counter with what we're comfortable paying, and then we negotiate.

That's a really good approach. And looks like you are someone that will easily be able to justify the salaries of your hires. But there is a lot of managers that will not, and they will need to get better at their jobs if salaries where open.

kartan··on The Cavendish banana is under threat from a fungus
A world without diversity is fragile. This is true for vegetables, cattle and even us. Genetic diversity is a barrier to the spread of virus, bacteria and other parasites that cause diseases.

'"Another danger of a more homogeneous global food basket is that it makes agriculture more vulnerable to major threats like drought, insect pests and diseases, which are likely to become worse in many parts of the world as a result of climate change." As the global population rises and the pressure increases on our global food system, so does our dependence on the global crops and production system that feeds us.'

* "Crop diversity decline 'threatens food security'. BBC news" http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-26382067

* "REPORT on plant breeding: what options to increase quality and yields? Committee on Agriculture and Rural Development. EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT" http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?pubRef=-//EP//...

* "Increasing homogeneity in global food supplies and the implications for food security" http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2014/02/26/1313490111

kartan··on Google admits citing 4chan to spread fake Vegas shooter news
> that's your responsibility as a reader

I live in Sweden. How do I fact check what happens in a neighborhood in the USA? How do I know that a result of a clinical test is reliable?

Do I check it on another on-line source? Do I spend millions on R&D and do my own analysis? Or just few thousands going to Las Vegas and gathering my own data? Or do I need to wait for a Newspaper that actually has fact-checking?

> Even more reputable sites like Snopes tend to draw absolutist conclusions about things which I find are certainly not absolute.

Billions of citizens fact-checking every single news is not cost effective. It will be good to have a minimum of quality, and then you can apply any correction to the inherent bias of that medium. There is a difference between someway biased information and bullshit.

kartan··on Sitting down too much is doing more harm to your body than you can imagine
The more you sit and the less exercise you do, the less energy do you have to improve.

At least make sure that weekends you have hobby that requires to go outside. If you find yourself walking all the weekend is going to be easier to stand at the office.

I also have tried playing VR games with "room scaling". It forces you to play standing.

The more exercise and time you spend standing, the easier it becomes. But the reverse is also true. If you feel tired all the time, it is hard to start exercising and you need to trick yourself into bootstrapping the habit.

kartan··on 3D crosswalk in Iceland helps slow down speeding motorists
> A year or two after a new, more intrusive format became ubiquitous, its performance would fall back to the old format's

When Sweden changed driving side, that is exactly what happened.

"The relatively smooth changeover saw a reduction in the number of accidents. On the day of the change, only 157 minor accidents were reported, of which only 32 involved personal injuries, with only a handful serious. On the Monday following Dagen H, there were 125 reported traffic accidents, compared to a range of 130 to 198 for previous Mondays, none of them fatal. Experts suggested that changing to driving on the right reduced accidents while overtaking, as people already drove left-hand drive vehicles, thereby having a better view of the road ahead; additionally, the change made a marked surge in perceived risk that exceeded the target level and thus was followed by very cautious behavior that caused a major decrease in road fatalities. Indeed, fatal car-to-car and car-to-pedestrian accidents dropped sharply as a result, and the number of motor insurance claims went down by 40%.

These initial improvements did not last, however. The number of motor insurance claims returned to 'normal' over the next six weeks and, by 1969, the accident rates were back to the levels seen before the change." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dagen_H

kartan··on Three Paths in the Tech Industry: Founder, Executive, or Employee
> The same just isn't true of product development, sales and marketing. Any one of those three teams, staffed well, will account for well more than the value of the entire engineering organization.

Why is it not true for them? Sales are not magic, it is a profession that can be learned. I have seen a lot of companies stating how important is sales, and how unique they are. It can't be true for all companies. It is like everyone thinking that they are above average, it is just not possible.

If your product is software, literally it is impossible that sales add more value than the engineering organization that builds the product. Without engineering organization, you don't have anything to sell. Without sales and marketing, you will also have a hard time. It is collaboration what brings success.

> There's too much focus by developers on shallow things, like fad-following the latest frameworks, on pseudo-intellectualism or technology-purism

This is usually a problem with recruiting. You get what you pay for. If your interviews are about technical expertise and you ignore basic persona-values evaluation and fit to build valuable features, you get that. And it jeopardizes the viability of a company. You need some really good experts, but you don't need everyone to be one.

kartan··on Stop Calling it ‘Identity Theft’
> it is more efficient to optimise for conversion rate than to deny valid but incompetent or "unable to provide all the details" consumers.

And that's not a big problem even that it is not nice. The problem is when your company lends money to someone that says it's me. And it becomes my problem. Why?

The company wants a lot of conversions, so it has a low entrance cost. Then that company should pay for that problem, not unrelated third parties.

> Low trust versus high trust society is the thing you need to understand here.

For me, that's just one of the reasons.

Sweden, for example, is a high trust society. But companies are trying to play fair because they are going to be punished otherwise. Isn't that fair?

But, of course, in a society with a lot of corruption, and cheating, and low trust. Companies are going to defend themselves more. As they risk will get more fraudulent transactions that real ones.

kartan··on Facebook’s Ad Scandal Isn’t a Fail, It’s a Feature
The main problem with Facebook is "too much tailored advertisements".

You can even use this advertisements to deanonymize data. And that's extremely-dangerous. If you want a list of people from an ideology, or minority, or whatever. You can send an ad targeted to that people, in the city that you are interested in. But the ad is for getting some free, unrelated to your motives, sample product. People will send you their name and address without even knowing that they saw your ad only because they are part of that minority/ideology/...

You can also, and it has already been done, target undecided people in an election. This is nothing new, but the precision and scope has increased drastically. And usually you only need a few percentage points in one state to swing an election. The money that could buy you half a percentage point, now is going to buy you a lot more.

Facebook offers a great feature for ad companies to be able to specifically target people, but it is dangerous for society as a whole. I think that the GDPR (http://www.eugdpr.org/key-changes.html) is a good step in the right direction. But probably it is not enough.

The article misses completely the point. Moving the subject from "privacy" to "antisemitism".

kartan··on Spanish police raid .Cat domain name registry offices
The internet is not isolated from the physical world. Some times "the cloud" seems like an ethereal place, but in the end there are servers somewhere with hardware that can break, that needs maintenance and that can be confiscated by the government. Technology doesn't solves political problems, it just makes governments more efficient.
kartan··on Renault-Nissan lays out plans for electric and autonomous vehicles
> You are short-sighted.

1. I'm for automating driving, as it will save lives and it is a job that usually requires people to be away from their families for long periods of time (long distance trucks).

2. The industrial revolution, for example, was not more of the same. It changed the world. This kind of change is probably at the same scale. But it has the same risks.

My message is: Bring automation, but bring political change with it or it is going to cause a lot of pain and suffering.

And yes, I'm short-sighted and that's why I wear glasses. :P

"Employers could pay a child less than an adult even though their productivity was comparable; there was no need for strength to operate an industrial machine, and since the industrial system was completely new, there were no experienced adult labourers. This made child labour the labour of choice for manufacturing in the early phases of the Industrial Revolution between the 18th and 19th centuries. In England and Scotland in 1788, two-thirds of the workers in 143 water-powered cotton mills were described as children." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Industrial_Revolution#Standard...

kartan··on Renault-Nissan lays out plans for electric and autonomous vehicles
If they and other companies succed the number of jobs disappearing is going to be massive. Technologically we are almost there, but socially just a few see this coming, and we are not prepared.
kartan··on The Realities of Being a FOSS Maintainer
> It's the assholes who think I'm gonna put up with their crap for free that most chap my hide, and I suspect OSS is unique in just how entitled people can be for something they got for free.

Some people is entitled. Period. They have the same attitude when they pay, when they get something for free, when they are right and when they are wrong. And these people are the ones that ruin it for everyone.

kartan··on The Equifax Breach Exposes America's Identity Crisis
An Example: https://www.aclu.org/other/5-problems-national-id-cards

And some arguments are laughable.

> What happens when an ID card is stolen? What proof is used to decide who gets a card?

Mine has a picture on it. If this argument is true, then why does any country issue passports, drive licenses, etc...? Why do security enforce agencies have identifications? They are not perfect, but they work.

> An ID card system will lead to a slippery slope of surveillance and monitoring of citizens.

The "slippery slope" theory is just the straw-man fallacy on disguise.

> A national ID would require a governmental database of every person in the U.S. containing continually updated identifying information. It would likely contain many errors, any one of which could render someone unemployable and possibly much worse until they get their ""file"" straightened out.

This is the definition of what Equifax is. But it gets worse as people gets into no flight lists because they share the same name than a person of interest. The lack of an ID card just magnifies the problem, it doesn't makes it disappear. (http://www.nbcsandiego.com/news/local/Same-Name-Mistaken-Ide...)

> How long before office buildings, doctors' offices, gas stations, highway tolls, subways and buses incorporate the ID card into their security or payment systems for greater efficiency?

This information is already available for credit card companies. Is that better? And in Europe we have ID cards, and they are not used for any of that things. Except maybe the doctor office, as your life depends on having reliable data and it is part of your health care rights provided by the government.

> A national ID card would have the same effect on a massive scale, as Latinos, Asians, Caribbeans and other minorities became subject to ceaseless status and identity checks from police, banks, merchants and others.

This says more about USA culture than about id cards. Also, it already happens (e.g. the POTUS pardon).

kartan··on Equifax Lobbied to Kill Rule Protecting Victims of Data Breaches
I will like to know what's the ethical standards of the people that are trying to push for this legislations. Do they realize that they can be victims themselves of this kind of abuse? I guess that it's the tragedy of the commons. They can suffer the consequences, but they are ripping all the benefits.

When I say the Ferengi* in Star Trek, I found it hilariously unrealistic. Nowadays the possibility of corporations with rights but without responsibility is a scary possible future. Reality can surpass fiction.

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ferengi

kartan··on AssemblyScript: A Subset of TypeScript That Compiles to WebAssembly
> Forgive my ignorance but what purpose does WebAssembly have in this context?

Suppose a future web that is language agnostic. Your browser doesn't understand ECMAScript 2015, nor 2016, nor VBScript. It has an extremely optimized and fast virtual machine that works with WebAssembly.

This reduces complexity. It brings diversity to the web ecosystem, you can use any language that compiles to WebAssembly. There are no second class languages on the web.

But to build that future we need to create the tools. You can already use clang to compile many languages to WebAssembly, but ECMAScript nor Typescript are on that list.

WebAssembly should be able to interact with the DOM. But also to more low level APIS like access to USB devices. (https://developers.google.com/web/updates/2016/03/access-usb...)

Many things can go wrong, or can be moved in other directions. But the big success of the Java Virtual Machine shows the power of compile once run everywhere approach.

> Say for example a C++ game which then can run in the browser or stuff like that.

That's already possible using EmScriptem (http://kripken.github.io/emscripten-site/). Game companies like King already use the same C++ code base for their mobile games and browser games. The problem is performance. With WebAssembly it will get more simple and faster.

kartan··on European court rules companies must tell employees of email checks
> Why should an employee have the right to store sensitive personal data on my computer.

Because your employees are human beings and not machines. They have a life, they have needs, etc.

> Are you suggesting a framework where I could be prosecuted for running "cat /var/log/mail" on my own computer?

Yes. That's exactly it. The court ruled that employees have an expectation of privacy, even that can be limited by the company when there are reasons to do so. When you give an employee a computer, it is the company property but it's the employee's computer.

People have rights, even while working for an employer. They are employees, they are not slaves.

kartan··on European court rules companies must tell employees of email checks
No. It is not how law works: An employer “cannot reduce private social life in the workplace to zero. Respect for private life and for the privacy of correspondence continues to exist, even if these may be restricted in so far as necessary,” the ECHR grand chamber judgment said.*

"as necessary" is the important part. In fact, it is bad for a company to have a clause that says "we own all your email". Such a clause is invalid and it will be invalidated in court. A more reasonable and justified clause in the contract will hold in court.

* https://www.theguardian.com/law/2017/sep/05/romanian-chat-me...

kartan··on It’s time to balance the power between workers and employers
There was this year that my friend sold her apartment... It was a lot more money than she originally paid for it. She got an awesome income that year.

For the article: > Using data from the Internal Revenue Service, Mr. Carroll showed that between 1999 and 2007, half of those who earned over $1 million a year did so just once during this period...

Yep. I will recommend reading https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Lie_with_Statistics

kartan··on Iowa's handout to Apple illustrates the folly of corporate welfare deals
> If Apple didn’t build a data center in Iowa they would also collect $0 in taxes from them.

Iowa can't do that. But the USA can. If another state (instead of Iowa because of the tax break) has gotten the revenue of that taxes and the federal government gets it from that state. The USA can give that money to the Iowa residents.

← PreviousPage 15 of 25Next →