HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartan

4,940 karma · joined July 5, 2015

submissionscomments
kartan··on High Speed Trains Are Killing the European Railway Network (2013)
> Privatised rail makes no sense anywhere in the world.

It makes sense in Japan. It is a small country with a high amount of population that is very concentrated.

In any other part of the world governments are the ones paying the bill for the rail networks meanwhile "private" companies are just adding their profit to the cost. There is no competition, there is no long term investments (until the government pays), customers are captive, ... It just doesn't work.

kartan··on Americans Are Delaying Health Care Until Tax Refunds Arrive
> Out-of-pocket medical spending jumps once the money hits people’s bank accounts.

It is a bad thing that tax withholding is one of the few ways Americans can have savings. When you live check to check this can be your only option.

kartan··on Italy’s austerity-fueled crisis is a warning to the Eurozone
> What's the point of investing the money into education if the people study in poor countries and then move to the rich countries?

The point is to make people happy. That people that emigrates has an opportunity that would have never had. Some of them will come back bringing other countries knowledge.

That doesn't mean that you are wrong. "Brain draining" is a real problem.

I like the logic of "What if we train our employees and they leave? What if we don't and they stay?"

kartan··on Italy’s austerity-fueled crisis is a warning to the Eurozone
While one hand was trying to balance the budget cutting in investment (education that makes people happier and more productive, healthcare that keeps people healthy, ...) the other hand has been increasing the expenses and decreasing revenue (giving bailouts to bankers, allowing tax havens).

How was austerity supposed to balance the economy when money was given away to the rich and taxes reduced? For each euro that was removed from schools, more than that was given to banks. Each time public health benefits were reduced there was a new company moving to Ireland, Malta, etc.

So, now we have the same or more unbalanced budgets but citizens are poorer, less educated and do not see a future for themselves.

> Continued stagnation will feed the resentment and anti-establishment, anti-euro forces in Italy.

The Eurozone countries need to increase revenues and start investing that money into education to prepare its citizens for the new economy. The alternative is disenfranchised citizens stuck in poverty that will fall in the hands of populism.

You have to spend money to make money. Austerity misses the point.

kartan··on California now has more than 1,300 charter schools – Alt.Ed gone bad
> The check on charter schools is that if they provide a bad education, the students will leave.

It sound estrange for me. But, I think that you are right that this is the intention.

Are the kids responsibility to evaluate the validity of the education system? Aren't they just kids that are in school to learn the most basic stuff?

There is a reason why kids are not legally adults. And it is their lack of maturity and experience to take decisions.

> If they create a bad working environment for teachers, the teachers will leave. The latter actually seems to have checked the subject of the article effectively: teacher turnover was high, and the teachers profiled here both ultimately did leave.

It is interesting that the adults where the ones actually leaving.

kartan··on Goldman Sachs will open-source some of its trading software
https://www.businessinsider.com/goldman-sachs-is-making-its-...

"Aug. 12, 2015, 12:33 Goldman Sachs is going the way of Google and Facebook. The investment bank is giving away some of its trading technology to clients through open-source software, according to The Wall Street Journal...."

Am I missing something?

kartan··on Sweden Wants to Revive Europe’s Overnight Trains
I traveled from Stockholm to Malmö almost 5 years ago. I had a sit instead of a sleeping coach. It was a good experience. I got really early to Malmö without the stress of flying.
kartan··on The Cult of Homework
> ...my siblings and I...

Thank you. English is not my mother tongue and I easily fail that kind of constructs.

kartan··on On Being a Free Software Maintainer
> You'll be criticized irregardless.

For me this is one of our flaws as society. When we like something we just continue with our lives. When there is something that we do not like we stop to say so.

One of the best learnings I got as a manager is to give positive feedback. So, employees know how much we appreciate their job, and that we see their value. And just that one time that it does not work out, I will give them feedback to improve.

But, I realize how little I have applied this with OSS and on-line in general. I rarely stop to say thank your for your comment, it was informative. Even, that I may donate some money I never stop to say thank you to the maintainers of OSS.

So, that's probably why you mainly hear complains and comments from seemly entitled people.

Thank you for sharing your experience it gave me a perspective to think about.

kartan··on The Cult of Homework
My mother did not work while me and my siblings were growing. The time that we spend doing homework was not the funniest one, but it showed how important is school work to us. She will help us with our school work in the same way that she will help to prepare us for tests.

How can parents do that when work just burn them out? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19530479

And I am not in favor of forcing parents to stay at home. One of my mother more liberating moments was when she went back to work and got a salary for herself.

So, I do not know how good or bad is homework for children. But, I think that is an extra-burden for their parents that can have a negative effect in the children family.

kartan··on Burnout caused by chronic stress is widespread
> Burnout caused by chronic stress is widespread

We are making employees lives miserable to reduce the need of planning for companies. Quite often management lacks the emotional maturity needed in their positions that hides normal mistakes that are part of the job, push for unrealistic schedules and sometimes even get into bulling as a way of getting what they want.

8 hours plus commute time, that has increased as cities have grown, does not allow people to have time to attend their families, their own finances and have time to relax.

When it comes to human management in companies we are closer to the middle ages than to the current knowledge about human nature.

kartan··on A 119-Word Local Crime Brief Became Facebook’s Most-Shared Story of 2019
"By clicking “Agree,” you consent to Slate’s Terms of Service and Privacy Policy and the use of technologies such as cookies by Slate and our partners to deliver relevant advertising on our site, in emails and across the Internet, to personalize content and perform site analytics. Please see our Privacy Policy for more information about our use of data, your rights, and how to withdraw consent."

No thank you.

kartan··on Dehumanization of cyclists predicts self-reported aggressive behaviour to them
> As vehicles, they have to stop at stop signs and lights, but feel like quite an appreciable percentage do not.

I guess that this is a problem of how energy conservation works. When a cyclists stops they lose all their gained energy, like any other vehicle. But then, the cyclist needs to put a lot of effort to get again to their original speed. If that stop is in front of a slop the cyclist only option is to get off the bike and walk.

So, maybe it is more a fault on the design of the roads than on the cyclists.

kartan··on Tech workers in China’s Silicon Valley face burnout before they reach 30
> Easier said than done when you're only other option is toiling in a field.

Yes. There is times that developer do not have a real option to say no. But, it is good for junior developers to understand what they are agreeing to and what are the consequences.

In the end businesses are going to ask for so much as legally is possible. If 15 hours/day where legalized, it is what people would get.

kartan··on Inbox is about to die, and Google still hasn't brought its best feature to Gmail
> Still, nothing beats the old convenience of Inbox's automatically sorted emails, especially when it comes to travel.

I love this feature. Now I use the Google Trips app, that is not available for Desktop, and it feels dull in comparison.

Inbox team did a great job creating a better Gmail.

kartan··on Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targeted Ads
copy/past from another comment:

42 U.S. Code § 3604. ...it shall be unlawful—

(c) To make, print, or publish, or cause to be made, printed, or published any notice, statement, or advertisement, with respect to the sale or rental of a dwelling that indicates any preference, limitation, or discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, handicap,familial status, or national origin, or an intention to make any such preference, limitation, or discrimination.

The law is clear. The only difference is that the publisher of the advertisement is Facebook instead of the New York Times web or newspaper.

kartan··on Tech workers in China’s Silicon Valley face burnout before they reach 30
> Maybe this is an excessively callous view, but isn't all of this voluntary and self-imposed? Is the expectation for the reader to pity their condition?

I guess that you are down voted because you are supporting a fallacy. Your comment supports the idea that you cannot change the system, and that the system is never at fault but individual people is.

If this people wants to improve their situation there is no individual action that they can take that will make a big impact. Only if they unionize, or make changes in government they can achieve improvements in their lives.

> When you start with nothing, and you want a lot, you end up getting exploited by a system that has major leverage over you.

Yes. This is exactly what I mean. But, the rest of your comment seems to contradict this fact.

kartan··on Tech workers in China’s Silicon Valley face burnout before they reach 30
> Anyone who asks you to be "dedicated" to their business or cause is looking to exploit you. When things get tough, they will not repay your dedication in-kind.

If you give your time for free to a company. The company will assume that your time is worth nothing. And once the expectation is created, there is no gratefulness for doing it. The only thing that you will get is a bad looks if you stop giving your time for free because now it is expected.

kartan··on Working for a startup makes less sense, unless you are into the mission
> Get rich quick in case of success.

This is just betting. The probability of success is extremely low. Would be as wise as betting part of your salary each week in the lottery.

kartan··on Wall Street’s Latest Love Affair with Risky Repackaged Debt
> ...are something akin to black hat hackers.

There is an important difference. The people working in financial markets have lobby power to change laws and create more weaknesses.

So, it will be more like if black hat hackers paid part of the salary of the IT-Ops that have to patch the software. Half of the server will run on unpatched Windows 95 and there will be long discussions on why updating is not a good idea because of made-up-reasons.

kartan··on Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing
> Is there such thing as "tech" that makes unionizing easier?

e-Mail, instant messaging, etc. Any form of communication makes unionizing easier.

kartan··on How to Make $80k per Month on the Apple App Store (2017)
> They’re taking advantage of the fact that there’s no filtering or approval process for ads, and that ads look almost indistinguishable from real results, and some ads take up the entire search result’s first page.

How is not Apple legally responsible for this? Apple tricks its own users to click on ads, but it doesn't take any responsability on its content. I guess that it is, but nobody is suing them and goverments have been historically soft with IT companies.

Automation and the rule of law are mutually exclusive. Or you have inmense scalable systems without human intervention or you have systems that follow local laws and ethics. And this will not change until AI has human-level understanding and intelligence.

kartan··on Japan’s elaborate, colorful manhole covers
> There are small towns, villages, (and certainly suburbs) much worse crime-wise in most western countries. So it's not just a village vs city thing.

My comment was about comparing past and present, and how some times people overstimates how good the past was. I agree with you that it is not only about big cities vs little towns.

kartan··on Japan’s elaborate, colorful manhole covers
> in Japan they still have a sense of civic responsibility

Tell me if I'm wrong. But, I see your "still" as if things were better in the past.

In litte towns, as everybody knows everybody, the rules are different. As more and more people moved to cities there was no family presure to behave. So, things were worst because family pressure desapeared and there was no substitution to get good behaviour. Big cities were a source of trouble.

But, I have seen an improvement everywhere I go. I saw this kind of transformation in Spain. As the country become less corrupt after the dictatorship, economics improved and a safety net was expanded Spaniards become more civic in the big cities.

Also, Japan takes care of its citizens. Japanese expect the goberment and the company they work for to take care of them. Societies that promote a every-man-for-himself approach have a harder time to ensure public civic behaviour.

kartan··on My Salary Progression in Tech
I have worked in Spain and Sweden. My salary as developer has been in the range of €32K-€45K in the past 15 years in Spain. It has been around €65K in Sweden (similar to what now friends make in Spain). And it is below €100K as an architect.

The cost of living in Sweden is higher than in Spain. And Spanish salaries in IT has soared. So, economically, it was not worth moving. But, the experience of living abroad is worth the money.

It is difficult to compare with USA salaries as here there is more taxes but you get better services. For me the deal breaker is the equality. I know that people around me makes a living wage. But, I will not discard to move to any other country in the future for the experience as every country has its own charm.

kartan··on Rudder issue that plagued the Boeing 737 throughout the 1990s
> I have a hard time believing that a cover-up in Boeing was orchestrated over several years by a group of people all who didn't care about loss of life.

No orchestration is needed. Managers only need to look with disdain to anyone that brings the issue.

If your company does not put a lot of resources to make it transparent it is going to be opaque by default. Transparency is hard to achieve when humans are so good reading a superior expression of disapproval. Most people does not need to be told to not bring that problem again, all that we need is a subtle clue.

So, to get a cover up you only need to do nothing.

“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!”

kartan··on Facebook, Instagram go down around the world in an apparent outage
"This usually means we're making an improvement to the database your account is stored on. While this process won't affect your account, you temporarily won't be able to access the site." https://www.facebook.com/help/134401680031995

I guess that this is all that I will get. Facebook is never down, it is just making improvements (like restarting the services to make them work again).

kartan··on US refuses to ground Boeing 737 Max
> It will cause a very big stink if one crashes in the US.

And people will die and families will suffer.

kartan··on CERN cuts ties with 'sexist' scientist Alessandro Strumia
> one would think Physicists could easily debunk them if they were bogus

Done: "Physicist Sabine Hossenfelder cited papers addressing some of Strumia's conclusions and provided an alternative analysis, arguing that after accounting for disproportionately higher rates of women leaving the field the sex differences Strumia claims to have found become negligible."

kartan··on US citizens will need a visa to visit Europe starting in 2021
Exactly that.

From https://www.eulisa.europa.eu/Activities/Large-Scale-It-Syste...

" ETIAS is a pre-travel authorisation system for visa exempt travellers."

Video explaining the system: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=11&v=orrBJiXAcSU

← PreviousPage 5 of 25Next →