HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartan

4,940 karma · joined July 5, 2015

submissionscomments
kartan··on The Troika Laundromat
> We constantly hear the Russian economy is in shambles, but at the same time the whole planet seems flush with shady Russian cash.

There are 144.5 million Russians. Even if individually they are poor the country can be very rich.

Also is the matter of illegal arms sales and break of international embargos. You can sell your gas or weapons to countries that you have signed treaties not to. That is a lot of money that is not part of your legal economy but can surface anywhere in the world.

High wealth inequality also makes this a more acute problem. A few people have a lot of money to spend in lobbying and luxury while most of the population lives in relative poverty.

kartan··on Google Wants $15M in Tax Breaks to Build a Data Center in Minnesota
> this unwillingness to play ball may just result in the companies fleeing to other countries rather than other states

If they could they will do it. But it is not possible as you need data locality. If your data center is in China, it cannot compete in speed with a local data center. And this is true in different ways for a lot of businesses. That is one of the many reasons why all business are not already in India even that everything is way cheaper there.

And how a small company can compete with this kind of deals? Google is already having a scale advantage add to that tax breaks and it's impossible to compete with them. These tax breaks have a very bad impact on any capitalist economy.

kartan··on Google Wants $15M in Tax Breaks to Build a Data Center in Minnesota
> Google is promising to bring 50 full-time positions to the area. The company also projects that it will create 2,300 jobs during the 18–24 month construction window.

Is this a joke?

> State Sen. Andrew Mathews (R–Milaca) and state Rep. Shane Mekeland (R–Clear Lake) recently introduced a bill to provide an additional $20.1 million in state bonds to give the Becker Business Park—where the data center would be built—a facelift.

So, invest 1 million in politicians get tens of millions from the public treasury.

> Such incentives are typically justified by politicians as a crucial way to stimulate the economy.

Probably their own personal economies.

There are reasons to give corporations tax breaks. Like for example to expand green energy or to give jobs to people in risk of exclusion, or another hundred reasons. But, it looks like now it is used for everything without any real justification beyond "the company will bring business to the town". That can be covered by any kind of business willing to pay for lobbying and that does not present any social benefit. And it is a zero-sum game where another town loses the possibility for you to gain it. It is hardly a justifiable situation.

kartan··on Florida prisons sued for erasing $11M worth of prisoner music purchases
> Demler’s complaint involves Florida’s digital music player program, which let inmates buy a specially designed media player for $99 or $119, then buy individual songs or audiobooks for $1.70 apiece.

I guess that the bigger is the inmate population the easier is to make more money.

> But in 2018, the FDOC switched to a new company called JPay, which didn’t honor the earlier purchases. The agency required inmates to trade in their music players for new multimedia tablets, or to pay $25 and have the players shipped to someone outside prison.

That is a perfect business. You have literally captivated customers.

I think that USA do not see inmates as human beings. That is the only way to explain what happens there. But, they are human and abusing them is as much as a crime as abusing anyone else.

kartan··on The MBA Myth and the Cult of the CEO
> To play devil's advocate: what if top CEO's (whether by school or by track record) look for harder challenges?

That literally means that CEO's do not know how to do their jobs. Even if they do it knowing it.

> Someone once said Dara Khosrowshahi took the CEO job of Uber not to make money, but because anyone willing to take that job is somehow who wants to play the CEO game on "hard mode".

And there is families that depend on that companies salary. Drivers around the world will be affected by Uber's CEO decisions. That is a job that will not be a game for most people. But, maybe it is for anyone that want that kind of job. They are just playing while others are the ones that are affected by it.

kartan··on France Plans 5% Digital Tax as Governments Chase Internet Giants
> You are assuming that somehow that tax revenue is theirs in the first place. The big corporations that evade taxes are using the economic power, infrastructure and legal systems of countries without contributing to any of them. That is money that the corporations owe to the citizens of those countries.

> What if that tax rate makes a business non-profitable in France but a money-making machine in Ireland? I see your point, they are centred about maximizing profit. But, there are other goals as well. The goal of improving the taxation system is related to broad social issues like wealth redistribution. It has nothing to do with the only goal is to maximize short term profits for companies.

> Also, too much focus is centered around taxes when spurious regulations are generally more damning for a lot of companies. For example some friends of mine have attempted to start escape rooms, they have all abandoned their pursuits because here in Spain the legal framework is unclear. All escape rooms in this country are in a legal greyish area.

This is one of the many reasons regulations take a long time to be in place for new kinds of business: https://www.news.com.au/world/europe/five-girls-locked-in-ho...

I hope that your friends find a good way to start escape rooms in the end. If it is their passion they will succeed. Regulations may be slow, but regulations get set and then people can do business safely for everyone involved.

kartan··on France Plans 5% Digital Tax as Governments Chase Internet Giants
Doing business with tax havens should be illegal. A tax Haven creates an agreement between companies and a country to steal another country tax reveneu.

Tax havens produce close to nothing, so they have very small exports. It's just a legal arrangement that has nothing to do with production.

kartan··on Parents who digitize their babies’ lives
> One of us is making incorrect assumptions about user behaviour and privacy wishes. I hope it’s me.

I heard a lot about people's privacy. Most non-tech people I talk with see Google as a faceless evil corporation that wants to control humanity.

But, they use Facebook, and browse the web while logged in in GMail, Facebook, etc. instead of opening a private tab.

That is the problem with lack of knowledge. People don't trust big corporations, sometimes to irrational extends. But, they do not understand how the technology really works.

If we want behaviour and concern to be one consequence of the other, we need better education and more government action.

kartan··on Facebook’s global lobbying against data privacy laws
> I don’t think it’s a surprise that the UK chancellor would meet the chief operating officer of one of the world’s largest companies …

It is. Politicians need to be transparent and serve the public. Private meetings without public record with big influent corporations is concerning.

Politicians should keep public records of this kind of encounters. That a public officer talks about his right to keep secret talks to remove privacy from his citizens is wrong at many levels.

kartan··on Facebook’s global lobbying against data privacy laws
> Some people, particularly on the left, are unconcerned about political censorship by Facebook, Google, Twitter, etc, figuring that they will only censor people the left don't like.

The article does not talk about censorship but privacy. That a corporation uses data to sell advertisements has nothing to do with personal expression and censorship.

We can have a discussion about censorship when it's relevant. What has to do your comment with the post?

kartan··on A report on attacks on land and environment defenders in 2017
> Companies have a responsibility to their customers, who should have confidence that the products they buy are not fuelling human rights abuses, cultural destruction or environmental devastation.

We need better agreements between countries that force politicians to support humanitarian actions. Right now rich countries expect to get goods without looking at the atrocities committed to produce them. And then, there is an increasing willingness to protect frontiers to shield that some countries from the consequences of their actions.

We need to improve the world together. We need to support environmental protection all over the globe. It is very difficult for small economies to eradicate violence and corruption when rich countries pour money that makes the problem worst. It is not an easy task. Patronizing developing countries is not going to work.

The article also links to that: https://www.globalwitness.org/en/campaigns/environmental-act...

kartan··on Facebook admits 18% of Research spyware users were teens, not 5%
> My take is that in tech it's no longer acceptable to separate the work an employee does from the morals of their employer.

Does this apply to employees of tabacco companies, alcohol companies, sugar companies, supermarkets that give plastic bags, shops that sell clothes made by children or quasy slave labor, car manufacturers, ... Should everyone stop working?

There is a solution for all that. The solution is democracy and good government. It helps to improve our lives without drastic measures, and without reading the people that instead of walking of stays in companies doing bad stuff.

> the devil is worth the extra money

A lot of people works for awful companies for minimum wage. It is the people at the top taking decisions the ones that take the share of the lion.

kartan··on Facebook admits 18% of Research spyware users were teens, not 5%
> The trouble is their employees don't seem particularly bothered by the evil they do every day. if they did, they'd leave.

What does this have to do with employees? This is the leadership of the company that is morally corrupt. Most people at the ground level is going to see just a small piece of the picture without realising how everything adds together.

Concerned employees leaving a company makes it worse, not better.

Employees are paid at market value. Employees do not profit directly from these tactics. Ask Activision-Blizzard employees fired a year of increasing profits and morally dubious micro-transactions in their games.

Better regulations and enforcing them is what the industry needs. You need to remove bad incentives for the people at the top. Corporations should be held accountable for the pains that they inflict.

kartan··on Citizens allowed to sue on behalf of Lake Erie when it’s being polluted
This is the only way to make companies and governments to pay for externalities. It is the only way to make capitalism work.

If people can get profit by making other pay the cost, then there is a perverse incentive for destruction.

kartan··on How Much a Dementia Patient Needs to Know
> Is it surprising that people are happier and better able to deal with their illness when they believe they are doing meaningful work and are useful to the people that surround them?

This is one of the many reasons that thinking that "poor people" are just lazy. To feel useful is a very basic human need. To the extend that even very rich people that does not need to work still does it.

> The sisters who ran the home, though perceiving his confusion and delusion, respected and even reinforced the identity of this somewhat demented resident, who, they felt, might fall apart if it were taken away.

Maybe a definition of sanity is the ability to deal with the lack of purpose. Most people is going to feel stressed and try to find a way to be useful again. Only when you are sick - whenever is dementia or depression - you stop being able to find your place in the world by yourself.

kartan··on Widespread and sometimes drastic marine oxygen declines
Long term viability and neoliberalism are at odds. Why do you want to invest in a company long term when you can squish it and buy another two more functional ones with the profits?

We are ripping planet resources for short term gain. I hope that out there are some good planets on sale, because in the current course of action we will need one.

> "As oxygen-rich regions become scarcer, current fish habitats will also shrink and force economically important species—such as tuna, which globally generate an estimated $42 billion annually—into new ranges."

Most of the articles seem to cater to that line of though. Think about the economy! Will we let the planet die if it was good for the economy?

kartan··on Programming Languages: Survivors and Wannabes (1996)
You are right. C++ does some of the opposite trade-off that C does.

C++ is good for speed, good mapping with hardware features and fine tuned memory management. There is a replacement for C. But, it chooses to add complexity to the language to facilitate memory management, expressiveness and other perks. So, in that regard is the opposite that C.

kartan··on Programming Languages: Survivors and Wannabes (1996)
> BASIC, the Beginners All-purpose Symbolic Instruction Code

I think that BASIC has been replaced by JavaScript. The lack of typing and the immediate feedback match the same uses.

> PASCAL was invented in the late 1960's by Prof. Niklaus Wirth of Zurich as a tool to teach students proper programming structure before their brains became hopelessly warped by Basic.

Java fits this niche. It introduces typing and object oriented programming in a very structured way making it good for teaching. And it has not the hardness of C++.

> C is a terse, elegant, deceptively simple language that allows programmers almost unlimited flexibility.

C is being replaced by C++. But, without an ABI, C++ is not a complete replacement. So, C still goes strong for interfacing with the OS.

kartan··on Workism Is Making Americans Miserable
> Is wealth inequality inherently bad?

Lack of agency is. When people are not allowed to take decisions on their own they are unhappy.

Once money covers your basic needs. Money becomes power. High wealth inequality is directly linked to high power inequality.

http://america.aljazeera.com/opinions/2016/2/how-the-rich-co...

- Of the policies listed on the chart, the only one that was passed within four years was the North American Free Trade Agreement, which was opposed by the lowest-income voters and the median voter. On the other hand, the three policies supported by the bottom and middle deciles but opposed by the richest decile — ranging from tax increases to workplace protections — never passed. Across the board, the richest are most skeptical of redistributive policies.

From: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/06/the-bir...

- Rising immobility and rising inequality aren’t like two pieces of driftwood that happen to have shown up on the beach at the same time, he noted. They wash up together on every shore.

So, yes. Lack of wealth inequality is bad.

kartan··on Workism Is Making Americans Miserable
> That sounds like a case against wealth inequality, since there’s no increase in happiness for the very rich.

Not necessarily. Inequality seems to bring unhappiness independently of wealth.

You may have more than others. But if you get way less for your work than others, most people will be unhappy. That is why millionaires want more when they see the billionaires.

This video helps to illustrate my point: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=meiU6TxysCg

kartan··on America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Miserable
> but can still serve as a mental shortcut for whatever society agrees morality is ~currently~.

Can that be philosophy and humanist approaches? That is a way to look for higher meaning without rewarding fanaticism or dogma.

kartan··on America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Miserable
> Religion instills this virtue and gives framework of how our actions on earth and our ability to reason and create is an imitation of "god" aka creation of existence.

Isn't USA more religious than other more happy countries? Is not possible that actually religion and other external expectations are making Americans miserable?

If any, there is a correlation between religious countries and unhappiness.

Can you elaborate more on why do you think that religion is the solution and not the real problem?

kartan··on Toxic Workers Are More Productive, But the Price Is High
> Toxic Workers Are More Productive,

Not my personal experience. I have seen that they are perceived as better as they have less self-doubt and sound more authoritative. But, the ones I have work with were bad.

Usually toxic workers seen as more productive and bad/inexperienced management go hand with hand.

kartan··on The men fighting Florida’s python epidemic
Thanks for noticing. I'm sorry that you got downvoted for it.

My comment was a test, I wanted to see how it played out. Even with such common knowledge topic, I see that there is not enough "tone" in my comment for people to be able to read its intention.

This is a similar case to Poe's law.

Next time I will try with ";)". I guess that it will clarify the intent of the comment.

So, no fault in the people that did not notice. Next time I will do better.

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe%27s_law

kartan··on The men fighting Florida’s python epidemic
The solution is really easy. You just need to pay people for each dead python that they bring in.

And problem solved.

kartan··on Forget the 401(k) – Let's Invent a New Retirement Plan
> Why should I have to pay for someone elese’s retirement?

To have a functional society. Everybody has the mandatory duty to take care of the society they live in.

You have right, as you should. But is as fair to have duties. A society where everybody is entitled to rights but nobody wants to perform their duties is a sick society.

This benefits you in the end if a selfish reward is what you look for, by creating a better society your odds to have a good life are increased.

kartan··on Forget the 401(k) – Let's Invent a New Retirement Plan
> Workers would still be free to opt out of saving entirely

This is never going to work. With so much people living check to check, who has the money to save? This approach supposes that we are hommo economicus able to take the best long-term decisions. We are not.

For me, the easy solution is tax people now to pay the retirement of older people. Then, do that forever. It works in Europe.

But, will this work with a diminish population? Is not this a pyramidal scheme?

The reality is that productivity has gone up way faster than population is going down. The main problem is how to distribute that enormous wealth, not if there is enough for everybody.

kartan··on Is it creepy when brands pester you on social media?
I do not see this so much creepy as scary. Big companies have the resources to stalk everyone with an open opinion, and the technology is just getting cheaper.

I want to be able to comment on-line without having tens, hundreds or thousands of companies creating profiles of my personality.

People need to get back their position in politics, economics and the public space. If every conversation is exploited to sell more products, how can we as a society have honest open conversations in the public space?

Sadly, even in the private space (WhatsApp, Facebook, etc.) there is also data collection and commercialization of people private lives.

Yes, it is public. But, no, it is not acceptable to transform everything public in a product.

kartan··on Facebook's security team tracks posts, location for 'BOLO' threat list
> The company's information security team is capable of tracking these individuals' whereabouts using the location data they provide through Facebook's apps and websites. > But Facebook is unique because it can use its own products to identify these threats and track the location of people on the list.

This is so scary. That the company feels entitled to use that user data in any way they please is horrifying.

I would not be surprised if they are also using internal data to get to spy on spouses or ex, to stalk people, etc. Once the ethics of a company like this are zero, the possibilities are infinite.

This is why more regulation like the GDPR is needed. And also a closer supervision of the big tech companies.

kartan··on Google and Facebook should be regulated for news content, UK government report
> Introducing censorship won't help fix these issues

Regulation does not equate censorship. There are other things that can be done. What do you think about this one "The report also said social media companies should agree to "code of conduct" to govern their commercial agreements with publishers."?

It looks like a good idea that the tech giants should be held accountable for how they run their advertisement business that affects the behaviour of all the population.

"Should these companies be allowed to run what accounts as psychological experiments on big portions of the population without any supervision?" is a valid question. It is not censorship. What do you think about it?

← PreviousPage 6 of 25Next →