HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartan

4,940 karma · joined July 5, 2015

submissionscomments
kartan··on Billionaires, Not Voters, Are Deciding Elections
This is one of the problems of allowing the accumulation of power. As an individual, I have little money to spend and the gains are distributed to all citizens. Billionaires have a lot of money to spend and they are rewarded quite directly from the policies that they affect.

The best option would have been to not get here in the first place. To have stopped it when it was easier. But now that power has accumulated so much there is more reason to work for wealth re-distribution.

I also interested to know how much relationship there is between the accumulation of wealth in a few and war. I see that the rise of the far right and the economic inequality are happening at the same time. But I do not know what is the relationship between them. Anyone has data on this?

kartan··on George RR Martin: ‘When I began GoT I thought it might be a short story’
> When I began, I didn’t know what the hell I had. I thought it might be a short story; it was just this chapter, where they find these direwolf pups. Then I started exploring these families and the world started coming alive

Talking about the difficulties of estimation. At least he managed to publish a few books. Imagine that he waited to publish anything until the complete work is finished. Sounds familiar?

kartan··on Urban Area Cost-Of-Living as Big Tech Moats and Employee Golden Handcuffs
> As absurdly high as their salaries become, the cost of living drains it away,

This is how it works. The more money people have the more business will charge you. Real state is the one getting the biggest part as you cannot get more land that the one that already is.

Now stop a moment and think about all that people that is NOT part of Tech. That people that has normal salaries but live, or used to live, in that area.

Social democracy, where the well-being of citizens is as important as the business needs is the way forward. Better public transportation allows people to live farther away but do not wast more time on commuting. Social housing helps the people that cannot afford to pay the rent but is needed to run services, local business, etc.

Citizens should be plan for the citizens not just for Big Tech or the next Big Whatever.

kartan··on Sweden's cashless society is no longer a utopia
> Swedish legislation makes it possible for retailers, restaurants and other companies to refuse to accept cash, for instance by putting up a sign at the entrance or by the till.

Yes. It started as a curiosity and now this signs are everywhere.

> By connecting a bank account in any bank with a mobile phone number, Swish has become a popular way to share a restaurant bill

Yes. And to gather money for a friend's birthday or anything else.

> Why Sweden's cashless society is no longer a utopia

I see the potential risks of this situation. But the article does not bother to bring an analysis of them.

One thing is already happening. The oldest part of the population have a hard time adapting to this situation. It's easier to take a bus and pay in cash than to have to buy an e-ticket in your phone.

I would prefer to see such analysis than this e-krona nonsense.

kartan··on The Irresistible Urge to Build Cities from Scratch
Yes. And they also underestimate the cost and time to build such a thing.

From the article, "The project is closely identified with President Xi Jinping, which means it’s unlikely to join a long list of Chinese “ghost cities” financed by local governments."

A lot of initiatives are started by people with an idea but without resources or knowledge to execute it.

I think that city planning is an awesome idea. I grew up in Barcelona and the results are very good (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eixample). But creating a new city from scratch is more difficult. And it is harder to get the experience to do it right as the execution of the project will take decades.

kartan··on Out of all major energy sources, nuclear is the safest (2017)
"a project to control flooding and provide electrical power generation."

Damns are build to control flooding like the Banqiao Dam, to have reserves of water and to generate energy.

If you are going to build a dam anyway, why do not use it to produce energy?

kartan··on Engineers Shouldn’t Write ETL
Thank you. I think that is good practice to introduce abbreviations correctly. Even that it is easy to forget when you work with them all the time.

"How do I introduce an abbreviation in the text? The first time you use an abbreviation in the text, present both the spelled-out version and the short form." https://blog.apastyle.org/apastyle/abbreviations/

kartan··on Quick Thoughts on the Google Walkout
> Historically, a problem with movements of utopian ideals, is that they tend to be disconnected with reality while their adherents keep doubling down. Eventually, everyone is accused, and most everyone outside of the most fanatical true believers are frightened someone else will find out what it is they really think.

This kind of unions already exists, like for example the Screen Actors Guild‐American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (and actors have way more than 10x difference between them).

Bun in your opinion unions - like https://arkiv.sverigesingenjorer.se/About-us/ that work in other countries - will cause disconnection with reality the raise of fanatical believes and utterly chaos.

> Examples of this can be found cutting across different root cultures, different continents, and different eras. Many of the examples are concentrated in the 20th century, however.

Maybe we mean something different when talking about unions. Can you give me an example so I can see what do you refer to?

kartan··on Quick Thoughts on the Google Walkout
> If you're a 10X coder it doesn't really behoove you to pull up ranks with all of the 1X coders.

I do not get the point. If someone is a 10x coder should that developer accept sexual harassment?

kartan··on Travel and the algorithmic trap
> The world is becoming optimized for the dominant aesthetic of the internet.

Nope. The world is becoming ever more communicated. Ideas travel faster. Good ideas - and sometime bad ones - are copied around the globe.

Why should I be able to eat sushi just in Japan?

> I swear: every trendy, optimized-for-algorithms place has the same lights, the same chairs, and the same damn avocado toast.

It is difficult to be unique in a 8 billion people world. If your design is good, I will copy it. That forces people to look harder for new things. There is more originality and novelty than ever before in human history. That so much people has access to it, that it can be produced cheap and enjoyed by millions is not a bad thing.

> The issue is this: hotel visitors know they’re getting something generic. That’s the point. Mid-tier hotels advertise safety and reliability. They sell risk minimization, not experience maximization. Algorithms, though, advertise authenticity while selling commodities.

McDonalds (1955) predates Intel (1968) and the rise of the algorithm. Algorithms has nothing to do with your travel experience. You may get the recommendation from an algorithm that you should visit the Eiffel Tower. 50 years ago was a travel agent doing that job.

> At first, authentic travel experiences such as tours and cooking classes are too expensive to buy. As they gain popularity, they become standardized and mass-produced.

Should travel be only allowed for the rich?

> In fact, the best parts of travel are precisely the things that technology cannot touch.

In my travels in Japan I use technology to move around. I use technology to read signs and museum notes (I do not speak Japanese). I get lost in a city knowing that I just need to look at my phone to get back to the hotel.

> One caveat: Avoiding algorithms doesn’t apply to traveling in beautiful places. I depend on algorithms in expansive natural parks. When I’m in Patagonia, I want to do the best hike.

Yep. Algorithms looks like a solution, not a problem.

> City travel works best when we put down our phones, seek serendipity, and lean into another culture.

If you really want to know a culture forget about traveling. You need to live there for a few years. Some people may thing that traveling with the locals is being part of their culture. It is not. Working there, getting the same salary, getting the same laws, looking for a job, looking for an apartment... it is very different that hanging out with interesting people. I love to do the later, but it is not being part of the culture, you are still a tourist.(tourism: the commercial organization and operation of holidays and visits to places of interest.)

> I see travel as a method of learning. It’s an investment. I rarely travel for leisure, recreation or relaxation. I understand why people do it, but at this time in my life, that’s not where my priorities lie.

I feel the same. But I still thing that the people that looks for leisure are traveling. The people that want to relax are traveling. I would have liked the article if it has been less judgemental, eliminated or explained what it means by algorithm - because it makes no sense in some context - and kept things as an opinion not as a truism.

kartan··on U.S. Freelance Workforce, Now 56.7M People, Grew 3.7M Since 2014
False self-employment is a situation in which somebody registered as self-employed, a freelancer, or a temp is de facto an employee carrying out a professional activity under the authority and subordination of another company. Such false self-employment is often a way to circumvent social welfare and employment legislation, for example by avoiding employer's social security and income tax contributions.While a modern "gig economy" encourages more casual employment practices in the interests of labour flexibility, the extent to which this disguises precarious employment and denial of rights is of growing concern to authorities. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_self-employment
kartan··on TikTok surpassed Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, YouTube in downloads last month
> TikTok surpassed Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat & YouTube in downloads last month

This is not very relevant. The comparison will make sense in 5 years from now. If after months and years TikTok still gets more downloads then it's a game changer. Otherwise to compare them makes no much sense without a lot of interpretation.

People do not install Facebook each day. They install it when they get a new phone. But a new app will be installed in all preexisting phones.

This happens all the time. One app goes up in the charts as it becomes a new thing. Then it goes out of fashion. And in the end, the number of uninstalls is greater than the number of installs. Then the app disappears from the charts. But Facebook, Instagram, Candy Crush, Clash of Clans, etc. are still there the next month.

kartan··on Facebook promised to fix political ads on its platform. It hasn't
> I wouldn't expect them to fix anything. When you have the ethics of a company like Facebook it's much easier to claim you're going to fix something and then keep doing it.

For companies, if there is no punishment there is no solution. Even when there is a punishment. If the punishment is cheaper than to not break the law companies chose the later.

Harsh on companies, keen with people. That is the way. But the system works in the opposite direction. Human beings go to prison for light misbehavior while companies get a way just with a warning when they put the entire country at risk.

kartan··on WebAssembly Threads ready to try in Chrome 70
C++ is already used in production by big companies. It currently is deployed as asm.js. But you can use an equivalent toolchain to create WebAssembly.

This way you can create production-ready code and be ready to move to WebAssembly as soon as it gets feature ready.

The fine control that C++ offers will help you to understand the underlying architecture and put its performance to test.

kartan··on The backlash against overtourism
I am from Barcelona, even that I have not lived there for the past 5 years.

Governments have been caring to maximize business profit. And in that pursuit, they have created cities where one cannot live anymore.

Unregulated tourism has make things worse. The rise of Airbnb and similar schemes are punishing buildings in popular neighbourhoods that instead of a place to live with your family they become a business without rules. And any regulation is sold as "any business" and "communism" by the usual internet trolls. Problems are so bad in some neighbourhoods that even that push-back from online discussions and the business themselves is overridden by voters.

Tourism is a very good thing. And that thought has not changed in the city. Abuses should not be tolerated, thou. That you bring money to the economy is not an excuse to be above the rules. Citizens first.

kartan··on IBM acquires Red Hat
> Open Source, as adopted currently, is a flawed model that valors corporate protection more than end-user freedom.

I see your point, and I mostly agree.

I would like to differentiate between Open Source organizations - like Linux Foundation, Apache Foundation or Mozilla Foundation - and mixed organizations like Oracle (owns MySQL), RedHat (owns too many to list), etc.

The first ones represent the pure Open Source approach. Were the software and how it better serves humanity is their main concerns. The second ones are just business that see in Open Source and gratis (free as in beer) software a way to get a bigger user base and to kill any possibility of competitors from the bottom as new entries cannot compete as easily with products that you do not need to pay for.

Real Open Source foundations are fundamental for a functional global software industry. The other ones bring value, but they use Open Source projects as a weapon against competitors, not as something for the good of its users. And that ones are the ones that value corporate protection more than end-user freedom.

kartan··on IBM acquires Red Hat
IBM has been historically a Linux contributor. Eclipse, their open source IDE, opened the other to Java and other programming languages in the OS. And Power processors supported Linux early on. From that perspective to purchase Red Hat makes sense. It makes even more sense as the announcement states that they are trying to create a bigger cloud provider to compete with Amazon Web Services, Google Cloud, and Microsoft Azure.

My main concern is the reduction on variety. All big businesses are buying layer after layer of different markets reducing the number of options that one can choose.

* https://thenewstack.io/contributes-linux-kernel/

* https://www.redhat.com/en/about/press-releases/ibm-acquire-r...

kartan··on A Dark Consensus About Screens and Kids Begins to Emerge in Silicon Valley
> As a result, modern slots pay out on approximately 45 percent of all spins, instead of the 3 percent of traditional slots.

I do not get this. slots pay out (RTP Return To Player) is around 90%. The article mixes volatility with RTP.

> Lower-volatility games often have greater appeal in 'locals markets' than in destination resort markets like Las Vegas or Atlantic City

This looks correct.

> During "flow," time speeds up (hours feel like minutes) or slows down (reactions can be made instantly) and the mind reaches a state of almost euphoric equilibrium.

Most sensible regulations force you to send reminders to the players that interrupt this flow. On-line betting usually has harder regulations, as to play in a casino you need to physically get there but on-line is always available.

Usually in high regulated markets each spin should last at least 3 seconds. This is so you cannot get a fast continuous flow, but the pace is forcefully slowed down.

Physical casino slots and on-line slots are slightly different as products and regulation wise.

> "People only have so much leisure time and there’s a lot of activity on iPhones"

Slot machines are competing against Candy Crush (and Royal Charm Slots from the same company), Netflix, YouTube, etc.

> Eyal criticized slot machines for what he said was a business model dependent on addicted players — "that industry, I have a problem with," he said.

And the solution is to regulated it in a way that the most addictive aspects are not possible to implement. Or to prohibit it completely, not just to move it underground. If anyone expects that the industry is going to regulate itself they are for a hard ride. No industry does that for real.

kartan··on A Dark Consensus About Screens and Kids Begins to Emerge in Silicon Valley
> You have no issue working in that industry because those games are 'boring'?

Not because they are boring, but because they are less addictive than they can be. So they are "boring" in comparison. If we were allowed to use all tricks that mobile and on-line games do it will be really bad for society as it will create more addiction.

It is like Coca-Cola. Even that so much sugar makes it problematic, I find it better that at least does not include cocaine like it did in 1891. Does that make Coca-Cola good? No, it does not. But I find that makes it a lesser evil. Even that cocaine-less Coke is more "boring" nowadays, it is the right thing to do.

kartan··on A Dark Consensus About Screens and Kids Begins to Emerge in Silicon Valley
> Can you recommend any literature on the topic of these "tricks"?

I am talking about basic stuff like:

* Push notifications reminding you that you should play the game.

* Let you win some money but then lose it unless you make a payment.

* A bar that fills faster at the beginning and then starts to fill slower. So it looks like you are closer to a goal that you actually are.

* Show a deck of cards that instead of the 52 standard cards, expected by the players, has another configuration that makes you lose more often.

etc.

Any mobile games video - like https://www.gdcvault.com/play/1014450/Behavioral-Economics-a... - has a lot of forbidden techniques for on-line gambling.

kartan··on A Dark Consensus About Screens and Kids Begins to Emerge in Silicon Valley
> Why AREN'T certain games subject to the same regulations as slot machines?

The regulations were designed for casinos before video games became so popular and way before mobile games and micro-transactions even existed.

Example of gambling regulation for New Jersey: https://www.nj.gov/oag/ge/docs/Regulations/MergedRegulations...

> Is that a state-by-state regulation?

Yes. Delaware, Nevada, New Jersey and Pennsylvania allow gambling. But I guess that at any moment local or federal regulations could be created.

> And does the regulating code specifically mention physical machines?

There is specific regulations for casinos, for on-line gambling, for jackpots, sports betting, etc. e.g. CHAPTER 69O INTERNET AND MOBILE GAMING from the linked PDF

Example of definitions:

* "Authorized Internet or mobile game" means any game authorized by the Division for use with an Internet or mobile gaming system.

* "Client terminal" means any device that is used to interact with a gaming system for the purpose of conducting server-based gaming activity.

* "Data warehouse" means a system of one or more servers located in New Jersey for the purpose of storing transactions received from the primary gaming equipment.

* "Dormant account" means an Internet gaming account, which has had no patron initiated activity for a period of one year.

kartan··on A Dark Consensus About Screens and Kids Begins to Emerge in Silicon Valley
> They are specifically designed to function like a slot machine.

I work in the gambling industry, making literally slot machines.

Slot machines are heavily regulated and there is a lot of "engagement" tricks that can not be used in the gambling industry. The kind of trick that Candy Crush will use.

The dangerous side of gambling is for people that think that they can "win money". But the games themselves are kind of boring by design. Regulations force us to make them boring. (And that is a good thing, I will not work on this industry otherwise).

The future of on-line games and mobile games is regulation. Micro-payments, push-notifications, etc. cannot be used without limits. People have right to their mental health more than companies have to higher profits.

kartan··on Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks
> Fake news is how free speech is supposed to work.

I can't agree with your statement. Game news is the contrary of what free speach stands for. Free speach is about being able to express your opinions. Fake news are intentionally misleading and hurt other people's well-being.

> Fake news" isnt a problem the problem is a lazy populace that take any word for granted as long as the production value is good enough.

Blame the victim. If you cheat me, it is my fault to not see thru your lie, if you rob me it's my fault for not being more vigilant.

If I lie about my products, or about other things for economical gain. Shouldn't the state make sure that I'm punished for that? Should not be the same case that for breaking a contract?

kartan··on The CumEx-Files – How Europe's taxpayers have been swindled of €55B
> They didn't even check that the people owned the shares they claimed to own

Yes. But people hates bureaucracy.

A common answer is'why do I need to present another document in the tax office?'

At least now Danish citizens have an answer. 'to avoid losing 1.7B'

bureaucracy is a remedy to a problem. It can be done right or wrong, but it's not bad by itself.

kartan··on Anti-Tax Fervor Closed Their Libraries. Now Residents Are Trying to Go It Alone
> “There is no worse tyranny than to force a man to pay for what he does not want merely because you think it would be good for him.” —Heinlein

'No Man is an Island' - John Donne

kartan··on Money Can Buy Happiness [pdf]
For me is hard to see what meaning of "value" is used in the article, for example this sentence:

> Spending money is a means of acquiring other goods and services that are one’s values or that will enhance one’s ability to realize one’s values.

Which one is it?

- "value" as principles or standards of behaviour; one's judgement of what is important in life. "they internalize their parents' rules and values"

- "value" as estimate the monetary worth of. "his estate was valued at £45,000"

kartan··on First analysis of how Uber and Lyft have affected roadway congestion in SF
> Publishing reports like these without controlling for the economy/jobs/popularity of these cities seems to me to be an unfair attack on Uber/Lyft, where the real culprit might just be a strong economy.

I agree. That is why this report is so good. The section "How Do We Determine the Causes of Changes in Congestion?" covers this question.

" this time to systematically estimate the individual contributions to changes in roadway congestion of the factors of transportation network supply change, population change, employment change, and TNCs."

I agree that they have done a good job and that the conclusion that Uber/Lyft contributes to congestion increase is very valid and should be considered to take actions in the city.

kartan··on We can no longer leave online security to the market
> In my experience, the threat/worry of bad publicity is actually the best motivator in a company getting their security up to par.

If that were just true Facebook will not exist.

> I work in the banking industry where security IS regulated. We have auditors come and review our technology once a year. These guys don't know what the hell they are doing.

Regulations do not make problems disappear but make the situation better. If you vote for politicians that want to improve it, instead of politicians that are paid by lobbyists to free companies of their responsibilities.

kartan··on The Bermuda Triangle of Wealth
I very interesting article. This kind of numbers should be on the news all the time (like global warming) so people focus more on them instead of what is the last Twitt from the president.

> "Get rich or die trying"

I have always seen this as USA's major flaws. You are not supposed to have a good life but to risk everything for riches. This was working when the rest of the world was under-developed. USA citizens had so much more than the rest. As the world catches up and surpases USA its problems are getting bigger and bigger. If ever the dollar stops being the defacto world currency I can't even imagine what will happen.

How many TV shows I have seen that people laugh at the janitor looking down to him? There is no pride in a job well done, there is no self-fulfilment on doing what is correct. Money and fame are the only thing that matter. You even have religious groups that see economic wealth as a sign of God blessing!

Other countries have different and even bigger problems, but meanwhile the american dream is about economic aboundance and not about having a good life you are doom to a rat race.

> The taxman. I’d like 30% please. 40% if you got a bonus this year. Good job. > Medical conditions! Your income means you have to pay out of pocket

The fact that your taxes are disconnected from a public health care system is scary. I am very proud of paying taxes that helps people to survive cancer, to get an education or to live with a disability. Your problem is not that you have to pay taxes but that the taxes are not used to give you back services as it was designed to be done (and that rich people does not pay their fair share, and that is something that it is also true in Europe).

kartan··on Madrid announces new rules of the road in bid to banish traffic from center
> Maintaining our mass transit is (stupidly) a state responsibility, to be fair.

I guess that this is circumstantial. That is USA's political system that is not working.

Because the headline is about a local government taking responsible actions to improve peoples lives while empowering public transportation as an efficient way of transport.

How different is "Metropolitan Transportation Authority" to "Consorcio Regional de Transportes de Madrid" [0]?

[0] https://www.crtm.es/conocenos.aspx?lang=en

← PreviousPage 8 of 25Next →