HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartan

4,940 karma · joined July 5, 2015

submissionscomments
kartan··on Amazon hired employees to tweet nice things about it
"While Jeff Bezos' wealth has increased $260 million every single day this year, he continues to pay many Amazon employees wages so low that they're forced to depend on taxpayer-funded programs such as food stamps, Medicaid and public housing to survive"

Privatice profits, socialize loses. Amazon has a PR problem with its employees, but the rest of the citizens should be also worried because they are paying for it.

kartan··on Age of Invisible Disasters (2017)
> The lesson of the Therac-25 is not writing perfect software

I will guess that the author will agree with you. The goal is a safe solution and that implies better software, better hardware, better procedures, ... anything that you can learn from mistakes to make this not happen again. If you look at plane crashes reports they will highlight software and hardware malfunction but also pilot mistakes (one plane crash happened when the pilots were distracted talking during landing about another plane crash that happened because those pilots were distracted talking during landing).

> The problem with the Therac-25 was NOT the race condition. Complex devices will always have bugs,

That is the point of the article. " ... The reason? A race condition. An unplanned-for coincidence, made deadly by the conscious design decision to remove an old-fashioned safety interlock."

The problem was the race condition. But if you solve that one, another one will pop-up. So what was deadly was the "decision to remove a safety interlock".

We need to identify which one can be solved, and do it. If we can not write perfect software we should add hardware safety. If hardware safety is not enough we need to improve the procedures to handle it. If that is not good enough, we can add more software to help were humans are failing... it is a refining process that you learn studying past failures.

kartan··on There's No 'Safe' Level of Alcohol Consumption, Global Study Finds
Yes, you are completely right. Going Friday night back home in Stockholms tunnelbana can fully confirm this. :)
kartan··on There's No 'Safe' Level of Alcohol Consumption, Global Study Finds
I would like that people saw this as a reality check to another promoted narrative.

"Sometimes, beer loves us back too: Studies have suggested that, when consumed in moderation, beer has many health benefits." - http://www.foxnews.com/story/2010/01/15/healthy-beer-drinkin...

"Despite the health benefits of moderate drinking, Holahan emphasizes the need for common sense. One or two drinks a day may be beneficial for some, but drinking a lot more can be dangerous, he said." - https://news.utexas.edu/2010/08/27/psychology_drinking

One in Five Americans Say Moderate Drinking Is Healthy - https://news.gallup.com/poll/184382/one-five-americans-say-m...

So there is still people believing that alcohol may be healthy. It is good to understand that it is not. And that to decide to drink will have consequences.

I have seen an increase of availability of alcohol-free drinks for the past decade that allow you to hang out with your friends, keeping that very needed human contact, but allowing you to not suffer the adverse effects of alcohol and to drive safe home.

kartan··on Future elections may be swayed by chatbots
Countries and big corporations already have a huge presence on social media. From Russia meddling with the elections to viral videos for beans we live in a world were no body knows that you are a dog on the internet, or a paid poster for some interest group.
kartan··on Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’
> Sorry, are you saying you’d like App Store software taxed enough that sales are low and it’s not viable for Apple to make money, forcing them to allow an unregulated open market if they want a meaningful number of apps on their phones?

No. :)

kartan··on Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’
> This suggests that a high revenue share of a software sale is viable in a way that a high revenue share of a truck load is not.

This is a good point. But I would rather see this apps more highly taxed than to allow monopolistic empires to grow.

kartan··on Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’
> but Apple's certainly adding value.

Do roads add value? Should trucks pay a 30% of their cargo retail price in road tolls?

I agree with your point that Apple adds value. I just do not see that as a justification to take a 30% share of all apps that run on their devices.

kartan··on Ice confirmed at the Moon’s poles
From the article: "M3, aboard the Chandrayaan-1 spacecraft, launched in 2008 by the Indian Space Research Organization, was uniquely equipped to confirm the presence of solid ice on the Moon. It collected data that not only picked up the reflective properties we'd expect from ice, but was able to directly measure the distinctive way its molecules absorb infrared light, so it can differentiate between liquid water or vapor and solid ice."

Another source: "near the south pole of the Moon on 9 October 2009 showed the spectral signature of hydroxyl, a key indicator that water ice is present in the floor of the crater (1). Analysis of the results indicates concentrations of roughly 6% water in the impact area, including nearly pure ice crystals in some spots. "

https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/ice/ice_moon.html

kartan··on National prison strike launches over underpaid labor and prison conditions
> --why shouldn't they be forced to take on some of their own upkeep?

If keeping people in prison is an economic gain for society, you are going to send people to prison whatever they deserve it or not. And that is the case in the USA.

"He was found guilty in February of racketeering for taking a $1 million kickback from the builder of for-profit prisons for juveniles. Ciavarella who left the bench over two years ago after he and another judge, Michael Conahan, were accused of sentencing youngsters to prisons they had a hand in building." https://www.forbes.com/sites/walterpavlo/2011/08/12/pennsylv...

So over-incarceration cannot be set apart from economical profit for jailing citizens.

> Nobody is arguing you should have to pay kids minimum wage for doing chores...

Children labour is forbidden. And when they actually work, e.g. movie actors, they get paid.

Make society pay for sending people to prison and they are going to be more eager to rehabilitate than to punish. It is not the only factor, but it helps.

kartan··on Someone Is Waging a Secret War to Undermine the Pentagon’s Huge Cloud Contract
> at least lobbyists are supposed to register

I read this with a tone of defeat. :(

The lobbying situation is very bad, it is just corruption with extra steps. And its effects are the same one that corruption. Money gets diverted from public utility towards private hands. Cut lobbying and this "Navigation and honing" is also going to be reduced. When a behaviour is normalized it replicates at all levels.

kartan··on Tiny Plastic Is Everywhere
> Usually the municipality sweeps the beach every morning.

This. People don't realize how costly can be to maintain a beach in a good state.

I remember getting early to the beach seeing one of this https://gfycat.com/gifs/detail/BronzeOldfashionedKarakul

Even more expensive is beach nourishment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beach_nourishment

Cleaning work is ungrateful because people only notice it when you do a bad job.

kartan··on Amazon's electricity rate discounts have pushed up utility costs
> and the politicians buy it even though it's very unlikely to be true.

For who are this measures passed? Interesting explanation:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs

kartan··on Netflix Has Deleted Every User Review Ever Posted to Its Website
> That doesn’t make any sense, getting rid of user reviews makes Netflix streaming less social. Netflix is not social media.

Yes. You are right. If they are just looking for more engagement removing the reviews will go against that policy.

kartan··on HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook
> If you had a building in an area that catered to people speaking a minority language (5%) of the population; can you target speakers of that language or do you have to spend 20x?

If I understand correctly, your argument is that optimizing cost goes against making fairness for all its citizens. So, it is a matter of priority. What is more important "fairness and justice" or "cost reduction"?

kartan··on Netflix Has Deleted Every User Review Ever Posted to Its Website
> Why do they go through so much effort to have me binge watch Netflix.

"Focus Area #1: Engagement Engagement is, hands down, the #1 area that you should be concerned with on social media. It is the catalyst for improvement in all of the other social media KPIs we'll discuss." https://www.impactbnd.com/blog/social-media-kpis

This is just an example. Everybody wants to become Facebook for some reason.

kartan··on The Secret to Ant Efficiency Is Idleness
When I was in Japan it was strange to see how slow some trains are. You will see that sometimes they stay more time in a station and will accelerate way faster than usual.

But when one train arrives it is common that there is another one arriving at the same time. People exchange lines from one train into another in a few seconds and then both of them depart.

My feeling is that the optimization is not for the speed of the trains. Japanese trains do not go as fast as they can. But all the train system is optimized to reduce waiting time. Each individual train is slightly slower. But the mean time that Japanese travellers spend is reduced.

I would love to see some study about this, as it was just my travel experience. It would be cool to compare that on how ants behave. It will not be the first time that ants have resolved an optimization problem way before even humans existed.

kartan··on Tech's most egregious violations of user privacy
> "this advertiser has done this kind of (horror) stuff using that kind of google collected data"

Data collected by Facebook was used to radicalize USA population looking into their political preferences and organizing groups in the extreme of the spectrum.

Political ads were used to show lies like "Europe, is negotiating to open borders with Turkey" to people depending on their political orientation during the "Brexit" vote by also Russia.

Targetted ads by hostile countries without any electoral supervision are running amok in social networks as ads are private and personalized.

kartan··on New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers
1. It is banning non-residents. You can be a national from any other country and still buy a house if you live there.

2. Watered down by interest groups: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-newzealand-economy-housin...

kartan··on Companies Shouldn’t Be Accountable Only to Shareholders
> We in the US fund our defense and Germany's defense (and cover the rest of the free world too)

I agree that the USA has used its military to keep a kind of pax americana. But that is not the complete story. The super expensive wars on Afghanistan and Irak didn't had anything to do with "the free world" and a lot with oil.

BTW That may have changed nowadays, but it was a very good idea that Germany had a low military budged.

kartan··on Americans Own Less Stuff, and That’s Reason to Be Nervous
> Because to me, it just looks like the (mostly potential/future) downsides are massively outweighed by the (mostly actual/current) upsides.

Yes. That is true for most things. Eat fatty and sugar-rich food, have pleasure now pay it later. Drink a lot of alcohol, have fun now pay the consequences later. Burn fossil fuels have cheap energy now have catastrophic consequences later. Spend all money now, not have savings in the future.

You are prioritizing current convenience against future consequences. That is a very human thing to do.

kartan··on Americans Own Less Stuff, and That’s Reason to Be Nervous
> Almost everyone, including myself, thought the guy meant well but had really lost his mind.

Yep. I know a guy that hang with him for a while and Stallman behaviour was already off. That was years ago.

But the original idea it is still relevant today. It is important to detach the message from the messenger.

> Thinking back, it's like we forgot our rights aren't guaranteed and didn't need to be protected or even considered at those levels.

Yes. I think that the success of the open source movement makes it commercially important and the message got diluted. There was a lot of pushback against LGPL and GPL licenses at that time.

Nowadays people contribute to projects that any company can take on and convert to a closed product. Just put some effort in some improvements - a nicer interface and some documentation - and the freemium version will overtake the free version. GPL was designed to make that move impossible unless the original company owned all the code, as then it can change the license whenever they want.

kartan··on Americans Own Less Stuff, and That’s Reason to Be Nervous
> “you ought to own the stuff you possess.”

That is the base that Richard Stallman created for the open source movement. You should own your own hardware, and the only way of fulfilling that is to own the software that makes it run. And I also thought that this is common sense at least for the past generation of developers. I am not so sure how much the message has been lost, but it is not so strong as it used to be.

kartan··on US elections remain 'dangerously vulnerable' to cyber-attacks
> A paper ballot system is just as terribly ineffective as electronic voting. Look at Russia. They have a paper voting system as well.

If corruption is widespread at all levels of society no system will work.

> I know in other poorer nations thugs just straight stuff the ballots with votes, some even steal the box, some set it on fire, and it can be in general a complete shit show.

And you know that this happens because you need a shit show to mess election at that level. With electronic voting, you will not even notice.

Paper voting is inefficient and is what it makes it hard to break. You need a lot of manpower to alter an election. If you can alter the election result with manpower, the system that you use does not matter anymore.

kartan··on Would You Let the I.R.S. Prepare Your Taxes? (2015)
> I would not trust IRS to do my taxes but I am happy if they send me a draft and I have to just sign or make corrections

That is how it works in Spain and Sweden. But, in the end, the tax office will randomly select people and check their tax applications. If you did something wrong they will send a correction so you pay the difference plus an interest rate. But even then you can send allegations to justify your original tax application. Only if they reject the allegations you need to pay the difference.

kartan··on Would You Let the I.R.S. Prepare Your Taxes? (2015)
I have paid taxes in Sweden and Spain. In both countries, I get a preliminary tax form with all my data. If I don't want to change anything I just need to go online. Click Accept. And pay with my credit card the difference between what my employer pays to the government monthly and the total, around 100$. It is very efficient.

I have the feeling that apart from lobbying USA loves to hate taxes. To make paying taxes overly-complicated adds to that feeling. When you only need to pay 100$ at the end of the year after one or two clicks (or you can get a paper copy mailed to your home and pay at the bank) makes it less painful.

kartan··on Investors Seek Refuge in Bitcoin as Turkish Lira Plunge 45% \
How can be Bitcoin a refuge for investors when it went from almost 20,000 to 6,000 in less than a year? That is more than the 45% drop of the Lira.

Bitcoin makes sense as a way of evading taxes when moving from Turkish Liras to some other currency. If you want a refuge you go to traditional assets like housing or take it out as dollars and pay the corresponding taxes.

kartan··on On Apple's Love Affair with Swift
> If a bug is allowed, someone will perpetrate it sooner or later. Sacrificing correctness and safety for the speed and complicity of C is not a valid tradeoff for the industry in my opinion.

It depends on what you are building. For an app it is not a big deal to be slower. But you will not write a kernel in Swift as you will lose performance all over the place.

Python/Javascript/Lua are used as scripting languages to create video games. But the 3D engines are written in C or C++.

Each tool has its use.

kartan··on Advocates say paper ballots are safest
In Spain is the same. But political parties send you also a copy and an envelope. So you can bring your ballot from home.

If the envelope contains more than one vote, but all are the same, it counts as one. If the envelop contains more than one vote but they are different it does not count.

In the voting school there are randomly chosen citizens and party representatives that identify the voters, all adults must have a national ID, and count the votes.

It works, and it will need a massive amount of people to change a significant amount of votes.

kartan··on Understanding Simpson’s Paradox (2013) [pdf]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox

Wikipedia got the joke: "Suppose two people, Lisa and Bart, ..."

← PreviousPage 10 of 25Next →