HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kaydub

638 karma · joined April 7, 2020

submissionscomments
kaydub··on Cleaning up after AI rockstar developers
Just look at the author's accolades. They are very light.

I've never heard of this guy. He's "self employed"

The article lacks any real detail and it just a guy patting himself on the back.

kaydub··on Cleaning up after AI rockstar developers
There's always oversight, that's just something you wrongly assumed.
kaydub··on Cleaning up after AI rockstar developers
I accept that for every prompt of building I'm going to have 1-5 prompts of refinement.

Once the LLM tells me "Okay, it's done, everything works" I always as it to do a thorough review, I tell it to split up the work among sub-agents with each one taking on a specific responsibility (look for code smells, look for bad architecture, review the data access model, DUPLICATE CODE, testability and unit testing, etc.)

After a certain number of revisions and reviews you'll come to accept the shortcomings it comes back. Usually there will be specific design decisions you made that the LLM keeps bringing up, once the review only brings that up and maybe some other minor issues it's time to move on.

I don't overly rely on markdown files and directions. I don't rely on tooling around it either. I just don't trust the LLM when it says "all done", tests pass, and deployment works. I make it to multiple reviews and iterations even when it thinks it's done.

kaydub··on Cleaning up after AI rockstar developers
Yeah, v1 is sloppy, then I tell the LLM to clean it up. Every 1 prompt of building tends to require 1-5 prompts of clean up. Simple, fast, clean good code.

The chasm between "Software Developer" and "Software Engineer" is getting wider. Articles like this and the comments under it give away who is an Engineer and who is just a coder.

kaydub··on Cleaning up after AI rockstar developers
This is such a low value article lol

I'm not even sure what it's trying to say. It's just someone patting themselves on the back.

kaydub··on Made my first plugin – How I orchestrated 3 LLMs to ship a plugin in 2 hours
I've been in software for about 15 years now, so long before LLMs. But now, I won't write code without them.

When I go out to eat, I'd love to know what people's favorite dishes are so that I know what to try. This plugin I made is specifically for that. This is just a small hobby project, but I thought I'd share some details and how I built it in this modern LLM age of building software.

And although I may not write code without LLMs these days, I do (currently) write all the blog posts and create all the content myself.

kaydub··on Anthropic surpasses OpenAI to become most valuable AI startup
My anecdotal experience isn't a benchmark. Just because I feel like something is better or different doesn't mean it actually is.
kaydub··on Anthropic surpasses OpenAI to become most valuable AI startup
I just don't believe non-deterministic tools can actually be benchmarked. It's all hoopla to me.

I flip between models all the time. Makes little difference. Sometimes one model is faster or better than another but there's no rhyme or reason why.

kaydub··on Anthropic surpasses OpenAI to become most valuable AI startup
I've always interchangeably used the models.

I don't look at benchmarks.

It's a non-deterministic tool. A lot of the shit going on with LLMs just doesn't make sense to me. All the tooling around like MCPs, they're all just putting stuff into context. So to me the tools aren't really robust and they make little difference.

Lots of AI psychosis going on these days. And I say that as somebody that hasn't written a line of code since Sept 2025

kaydub··on Every AI Subscription Is a Ticking Time Bomb for Enterprise
I'm surprised at how many businesses are using subscriptions instead of paying per token.
kaydub··on I returned to AWS and was reminded why I left
So you think your bespoke solution is less complex?

Custom scalers? Running prometheus, grafana, etc?

kaydub··on I returned to AWS and was reminded why I left
Lambda IS super simple.

These people are professional amateurs. They don't know what they don't know so they post stupid posts like this and all the other know-nothings upvote it and comment likewise.

Seriously, there's nowhere online for good software engineering discussion.

kaydub··on I returned to AWS and was reminded why I left
Yup!

I've been holding Hacker News in too high of esteem for too long I think. Most people on here are amateurs at best. The complaints about AWS/Cloud and LLMs are getting too loud. Did the industry pull in too many inexperienced during covid and now we're witnessing the backlash or something?

I've been doing this a long time. Running hardware, running VPS in the cloud, and running on AWS. I'll never go back to hardware/on-prem.

kaydub··on I returned to AWS and was reminded why I left
I honestly can't believe most of the people posting aren't engineers or they work at small companies or something. They show their lack of experience when talking about how cheap Hetzner and DO are.
kaydub··on I returned to AWS and was reminded why I left
Alright, so where are the good engineers these days?

Reddit died quite a while ago and I was holding on to Hacker News, but with all the anti-LLM posts and the anti-cloud fud I see on here it's obviously not here either any more.

What is going on that all the "engineering" users are anti-engineering, against change and advancement?

You guys posting this shit have to realize you're working on podunk garbage coding projects right? If you're finding AWS overly complex this is sounding more like a YOU problem.

Those of you saying on-prem is better, you're saying a lot more about yourself, your experience (lack of) and the project you're working on than you're saying about cloud.

Like holy fuck, how can you hate lambda? It's STUPID simple wtf???

kaydub··on Claude Opus 4.7
At my job and for personal projects I pay per token with claude and I've had no problems at all with it. No slowdowns, no "throttling", nothing.

I'm honestly surprised how many people have subscriptions and are expecting anthropic to eat the cost lol

kaydub··on I went to America's worst national parks so you don't have to
Have you been to Orcas Island or the San Juan islands in Washington?

I think Acadia is a great National Park, especially for the East coast. But I moved to Seattle a few years back and only more recently got out to Orgas Island. It's insane how similar it is to Acadia.

kaydub··on I went to America's worst national parks so you don't have to
Interesting perspective, thank you.
kaydub··on I went to America's worst national parks so you don't have to
Acadia is a beautiful park and it definitely reaches National Park level for the East coast. I don't really agree with your assessment there, especially since it doesn't sound like you saw much of Acadia if you think it's only Cadillac mountain and a single hike.

The East coast just doesn't have as many untouched lands as the West. West coast parks, pretty much all the parks West of the Mississippi, are next level. If you're accustomed to that then none of the East coast parks are going to wow you.

kaydub··on When does MCP make sense vs CLI?
Yeah, I've gotta use skills more. I didn't quite get it until this last week when I used a skill that I made. I didn't know the skill got pulled into context ONLY for the single command being ran with the skill, I thought the skill got pulled into context and stayed there once it was called.

That does seem very powerful now that I've had some time to think about it.

kaydub··on When does MCP make sense vs CLI?
I avoid most MCPs. They tend to take more context than getting the LLM to script and ingest ouputs. Trying to use JIRA MCP was a mess, way better to have the LLM hit the API, figure out our custom schemas, then write a couple scripts to do exactly what I need to do. Now those scripts are reusable, way less context used.

I don't know, to me it seems like the LLM cli tools are the current pinnacle. All the LLM companies are throwing a ton of shit at the wall to see what else they can get to stick.

kaydub··on How I use Claude Code: Separation of planning and execution
Why would you use Grok at all? The one LLM that they're purposely trying to get specific output from (trying to make it "conservative"). I wouldn't want to use a project that I outright know is tainted by the owners trying to introduce bias.
kaydub··on How I use Claude Code: Separation of planning and execution
Do you think this is a gotcha?

You just prompt the llm to change the plan.

kaydub··on How I use Claude Code: Separation of planning and execution
Yes to all of these.

Here's the rub, I can spin up multiple agents in separate shells. One is prompted to build out <feature>, following the pattern the author/OP described. Another is prompted to review the plan/changes and keep an eye out for specific things (code smells, non-scalable architecture, duplicated code, etc. etc.). And then another agent is going to get fed that review and do their own analysis. Pass that back to the original agent once it finishes.

Less time, cleaner code, and the REALLY awesome thing is that I can do this across multiple features at the same time, even across different codebases or applications.

kaydub··on How I use Claude Code: Separation of planning and execution
There's comments like this because devs/"engineers" in tech are elitists that think they're special. They can't accept that a machine can do a part of their job that they thought made them special.
kaydub··on OpenClaw is changing my life
You just have another agent/session/context refactor as you go.

I built a skribbl.io clone to use at work. We like to play eod on Friday as a happy hour and when we would play skribbl.io we would try to get screencaps of the stupid images we were drawing but sometimes we would forget. So I said I'd use claude to build our own skribbl.io that would save the images.

I was definitely surprised that claude threaded the needle on the task pretty easily, pretty much single shot. Then I continued adding features until I had near parity. Then I added the replay feature. After all that I looked at the codebase... pretty much a single big file. It worked though, so we played it for the time being.

I wanted to fix some bugs and add more features, so I checked out a branch and had an agent refactor first. I'd have a couple context/sessions open and I'd one just review, the other refactored, and sometimes I'd throw a third context/session in there that would just write and run tests.

The LLM will build things poorly if you let it, but it's easy to prompt it another way and even if you fail that and back yourself into a corner, it's easy to get the agents to refactor.

It's just like writing tests, the llms are great at writing shitty useless tests, but you can be specific with your prompt and in addition use another agent/context/session to review and find shitty tests and tell you why they're shitty or look for missing tests, basically keep doing a review, then feed the review into the agent writing the tests.

kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
I don't see how...
kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
Yeah, definitely a stupid take from OP. LLMs are very strong at using the frameworks, it makes it easier to hire people to work on your codebase, it makes it easier for future uses of LLMs since they'll have a lot of framework details in their training data, etc.
kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
The arrogance to think this isn't possible using llm tools and that the opposite didn't already exist at plenty of software shops pre-llm tools...
kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
You haven't worked somewhere where you're working on multiple different microservices each written by different teams in different languages?
← PreviousPage 4 of 10Next →